╌>

Neale's Weekly Gun Rant for 10-12-2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  neale-osborn  •  12 years ago  •  76 comments

Neale's Weekly Gun Rant for 10-12-2014

Anybody forget how I tend to start these off? I didn't think so. So here she comes, Mama Liberty! (in Burt Park's voice) Link . This week, she discusses guns (shocker), retention of same, and what to do if you ARE disarmed anyway.

The anti-gun people often tell us that a criminal would simply take a gun away from you and, probably, use it to kill you instead.

OK, it could certainly happen, and probably does sometimes. We read often enough about victims who manage to take the criminals gun and use it against him or her. Its a possibility either way. Is it the most likely outcome of using a gun in self defense? Does that make it pointless to have a gun in the first place? Of course not.

But lets just take it a little farther and think about what might happen in that situation. Are you all done defending yourself then? Should you just curl up and let the criminal attacker do whatever they please to you and any others around you?

Do I really need to tell you what to do next? I didn't think so. So go do it!

I e-mail the rant to a select group of people (you all know who you are) some of whom have taken exception to my writings about Islamic terrorists in several of my rants, culminating in last week's rant, where I pissed off quite a few of them, friends and enemies. Several took the time to let me know they weren't happy. I sent them all this response- (If you read TLE, you might get this response twice- it most likely will appear in either letters to the editor or as an article) In addition, it is published several places where comments on this specific part have not all been complimentary, and I feel I ought to extend to you, dear readers who aren't blessed by e-mails of this missive, the same response. So here it is.

I've been pissing off friends AND enemies with my stance on this subject, and so, I shallmake one last attempt to make myself clear to those whose opinions I value (the friends). Any enemies on this mailing list PLEASE inform me so that I may remove you from it.

I'm going to start at the very beginning, and work through to the end, so bear with me.

I lost my religion a loooong time ago, when it became clear to me that not only were ALL Christian religious leaders hypocrites (because none of them follow the tenets of their own faiths, in which I happen to be quite well educated), but because ALL of it stems from fairy tales told by Neolithic goatherds to explainlife, the universe, and everything. And ALL religions I have studied require one to suspend your intellect, ignore evidence, and take those fairy tales "on faith". As the late great Robert A. Heinlein said, "A religion is sometime a source of happiness, and I would not deprive anyone of happiness. But it is a comfort appropriate for the weak, not for the strong. The great trouble with religion any religion is that a religionist, having accepted certain propositions by faith, cannot thereafter judge those propositions by evidence. One may bask at the warm fire of faith or choose to live in the bleak uncertainty of reason but one cannot have both." I prefer reason. Now, to Islam.

As I have oft repeated, there is much to admire in any faith, Islam no less than any other. Islam's rules on hospitality and charity, for instance, are admirable. It's a shame their staunchest "supporters" do not practice either, but see my comment about why Christianity and I parted ways.......... ANY Muslim, as an individual, is most likely a nice enough person.As with all of us, they each have their flaws, and their strengths. When you get to flaws, however, is when I find a major problem with Islam as a whole. Read the Old Testament. It's full of vile shit- dashing babies brains out, angels slaughtering all male children in certain areas, God demanding his faithful to sacrifice their children to him, torturing a faithful man to see if he can beak his faith. But by and large, Christianity and Judaism have forsaken these things as no longer acceptable. Christian zealots who advocate ANY return to Old Testament treatment of non-believers are immediately and vociferously denied by their co-religionists, who loudly assert that "The Westboro Bible Baptist Church (to use one recent example) does not represent all Christians." And, in fact, the Baptist Conference has removed them from the rolls, from what I understand. What all this is leading to is that, generally speaking, the Judeo-Christian faiths have, by and large, grown up to the point they no longer support "Christian" ideas such as the Inquisition, the Auto da Fe, and conversion by the sword. Islam has not.

NO- I am not painting Islam with a broad brush. I am, reluctantly, pointing out a fact. When a fanatic Muslim decides it is time to behead an infidel for Allah, does most of Islam rise up and denounce his actions? Sadly, no. When 19 brave young Jihadi heroes fly airplanes into 3 buildings and a corn field, does most of Islam cry out in horror, and offer to help us in our hour if sorrow? No, sadly. Instead, they dance in the streets all over the world, celebrating the "victory" over the "Great Satan". When a Muslim "cleric" sentences a rape victim to being stoned to death for adultery (after all, she DID have sex with a man who was not her husband, who cares if she WANTED to or not), does the village refuse to allow the sentence to be carried out? Sadly, no. They pick up rocks and report to the field. And last, but certainly not least, when Muslim "clerics" proclaim fatwahs against infidels, or announce that they want to force all the world into Allah's tender care whether we wish to go there or not, does most of Islam deny this goal, and support our right to NOT believe as we so choose, to live our own faiths or lack thereof in peace and happiness? Again, sadly, they do not. Republicans insist that That jackass in the WhiteHouse is a closet Muslim. A lot of evidence supports that at one time he was, I cannot say what he is now, and I do not care. I don't want to bomb the shit out of Iraq and Syria to "stop" ISIS/ISIL/ Whatever the hell they call themselves now. And I'll be honest- as long as they are killing each other for not being the correct flavor of Islam, I don't really give a shit what they do to each other- it's a family fight among Muslim Hillbillies. WHEN, however, they come across the pond, and begin to try their crap here, I'm not going to be so mellow.

You may rest assured that I won't be leading mosque burnings, or so-called hate crimes against Muslims. You may ALSO rest assured that I will not tolerate ANY ATTEMPT WHATSOEVER to forcibly convert anyone around me. I will HAPPILY invite any religionist into my home to discuss their faith, and I will be respectful of them as long as THEY remain respectful of me. I will not tell them their faith is something that makes me laugh, I will not waste my time trying to show them how ridiculous I find their basic tenets. And I will not try to make them into atheists. I don't give a shit about their souls, and I do not choose to have mine saved. And, last but not least, I will fight to the death ANY attempt to force any conversions on me or mine, or to force me to become Dhimmi, and to pay jizyah. (look the terms up, they are interesting, to say the least) There is, currently, a very small, but very active, attempt going on to subvert the Constitution by using the Constitution to protect their activities. Fine, speech is actually free. Actions to enforce your version of right, however, is NOT. If this doesn't help you, there's not much left I can do.

A very good friend of mine, known colloquially as Tony From The Right, sent me this link . It is the FBI's unclassified report on all the active shooter (aka Mass Shooters) in the US from 2000 to 2013. It contains a lot of excellent information andstatistics, without any bias I can find in either direction. It's Just the facts, Ma'am. It is very hard to block quote from this report, so grab a cuppa joe, kick back, and start reading. It's fascinating. As Tony pointed out, it does NOT deal with the topic of gun free zones, where 24% of all active shooter events took place. Tony was concerned it might be deliberate. I don't- I feel that the FBI doesn't really care about that, so they just ignored it. All the report is dealing with is active shooters, and how the incidents went down. I'll have to read the whole thing a few times to truly absorb it all, so I might have overlooked something Tony saw. People- links like this are really important- send them to me if you can. (Thanks, Tony!)

I don't like the photo that accompanies this article, but the article itself is spot on. It's a shame more women do not do this. Link .

According to a local Fox affiliate, a woman who had been dealing with a stalker for months finally gained the upper hand recently when he forced his way into her apartment.

Reports indicate the unnamed woman had complained to authorities and in social media posts about the unwanted contact and increasingly invasive actions of 22-year-old Douglas Jackson, a man she had a short relationship with in the past.

Want to know where it goes from here? Read the linked article.

These two articles go hand in hand. Link . Link . Like it or not, a business owner has the right to refuse service to anyone. Laws to the contrary do not change this. As an operator of as gun shop for a few years, I was told by the government to discriminate against people- If a person tripped my suspicion meter, I was not only allowed to refuse them service, I was required to. EVEN if they passed the NICS check. so discrimination IS legal and a business owner's right. Of course, posting a sign "No Negroes Allowed" is not going to fly anywhere, it should be the owner's right to do so. And the townsfolk's right to bankrupt him by refusing to shop there. And, like it or not, a maker of wedding cakes has the right to refuse to make a wedding cake for a same sex marriage if they so desire.

Christian bakery owners Melissa and Aaron Klein just wanted to make a go out of their Oregon-based business. However, they werent willing to compromise their beliefs for the sake of making a buck. When a lesbian couple approached them in 2013 to ask for a wedding cake, they politely declined. Thats when the you-know-what hit the fan. Feeling discriminated against, the lesbian couple Rachel Cryer and Laurel Bowman filed an official complaint against Sweet Cakes by Melissa. Oregon officials naturally ruled in their favor.

As a result of the violation, the Kleins may have to pay exorbitant fines to the state. They have already lost their physical business location due to the furor created by gay right advocates. Now the Kleins operate their business out of their home.

Lets be clear. If the Kleins are experiencing a severe downturn in their business because customers are voluntarily boycotting the store, thats the nature of free speech and free market capitalism. You have the right to say what you want in this country, but customers can choose what they do with their spending dollar. If the Kleins want to complain about how theyve been treated by the community, thats a separate issue and one Im not particularly interested in.

What is much more interesting is whether anti-discrimination laws that force business owners to serve everyone equally are really Constitutional. Weve already seen from the Supreme Courts controversial Hobby Lobby decision that federal law cant force an owner to betray their own religion. Perhaps its time to draw the natural conclusion that this should also apply to couples unwilling to bake cakes for lesbian weddings.

As pointed out, the bakery closed because of a boycott- perfectly acceptable. But the fines they face are not. And this scene has been repeated several times across the country- where a person's religious views are forcibly violated by the government- the very government that is supposed to protect their right to those views. Views specifically protected by the 1st Amendment. The same Amendment that protects hate speech. YES, you have a right to spew racial epithets, to denounce a persons sexual or religious practices, to say nasty things about people. As long as you do not lie about them (libel) it is your right.

There was a time when to be a liberal, you had to believe in concepts like free speech. In fact, that was one of their primary platforms. Nowadays, it seems that the First Amendment, like the Second, has fallen afoul of the liberal plan for a totalitarian, socialist America. According to a new poll from YouGov, 51% of those respondents who identify as Democrat support creating laws making hate speech illegal.

This really takes the cake. For several years, conservatives have warned that loony left-wingers had hijacked the mainstream Democratic Party. Now, it appears that may not be the case; this kind of craziness extends to the rank-and-file voters as well. Perhaps it is an inevitable consequence of this social justice warrior phenomenon that is sweeping the Internet, turning formerly-apolitical sites into hotbeds for some of the nuttiest ideas youve ever seen in your life.

While no one wants to hear a rant full of racial slurs, it is the right of the ranter to spew forth. I care not for what you have to say, Sir, but I shall defend to the death your right to say it. (Don't bother to say it- I know Voltaire never said it- he should have, and I do say it)

One finds the logic of this article impeccable- so of COURSE the left despises it's message. Link . Of course, common sense NEVER trumps liberal ideology.

Some so called feminists on Twitter claimed that womens self defense enables rape culture. Rather than teaching women to defend themselves, they said we should simply teach men not to rape. We only need to tell predators Dont hurt others rather than teaching women to be aware, avoid trouble when they can, and to defend themselves when they must. Some so-called feminists went further and claimed that refusing to be a victim enables rape culture and so promotes sexual assault. I disagree. Preparation does not cause violence.

Locking your front door does not enable burglary culture

I understand the attraction of utopian fantasies. Claiming youre against rape by choosing to be vulnerable is a fantasy virtue with strong emotional rewards. It is a Tinkerbelle ideology of crime prevention, and a perfect meme for our age of hash-tag activism. The so called anti-rape culture clams to stop an attacker if we all think be nice real hard. The so called anti-rape culture claims our nice thoughts will somehow stop assault, rape and murder. That style of feel-good activism is enough for some people. The feel-good emotions of the anti-rape fantasy sell on campus and academia. Reality is not that pretty.

As Rob repeats throughout the article, common sense safety measures do NOT enable bad activities- seatbelts do no enable car crashes, earthquake straps do not enable earthquakes, and learning to shoot, and how to defend yourself does not enable rape. As anyone with even two braincells to rub together can figure out.

Apparently, the law prohibits you from preventing spying over your property EVEN if the spy isn't the government!!! Link . Yes, a man, flying a drone helicopter over his neighbor's property TO TAKE PICTURES OF SAID PROPERTY, called the police when said neighbor shot the drone down with a shotgun. For the gun-ignorant here, shotguns fired into the air do not pose a huge danger to the surrounding area- the falling shot will feel like a handful of sand or light gravel tossed into the air falling on you. But in NJ, defending your privacy is a no-no.

(BizPacReview) ANew Jerseyman was arrested on charges that he fired at his neighbors remote control drone with a shotgun.

The incident happened last week, when a resident called theLower Township Police Departmentclaiming that his remote-control helicopter had been shot down,CBS reported. After picking up the drone, he found holes in it.

Authorities said the resident was using his remote control helicopter to take pictures of his friends home. While taking the aerial shots, the resident said he heard multiple gunshots and instantly lost control of the drone, according to CBS.

Police later arrested Russell J. Percenti, 32, on charges of possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and criminal mischief and confiscated his gun.

I am SOOOO glad I escaped from New Jersey in a balloon during the Reagan presidency.........

Ahhh, the ever stupid "Zero Tolerance Policy" rears it's ugly head once again. Link . We have the asinine calling the Gestapo because a teacher wears a pirate costume on "Talk LikeA Pirate Day", complete with plastic sword. First, the asinine idiot calls a plastic pirate sword a gun. (Huh?) Then, the Gestapo lock down 4 damn schools because of the imaginary gun.

Four North Carolina schools were recently placed on lock-down by police, after a suspicious person was seen entering Richlands Elementary School on September 19th.

An initial investigation turned up empty handed, but two weeks later the police announced that they solved the mystery behind the suspicious person at the school.

The suspicious person that caused the lock down was not actually an intruder, but was one of the schools teachers, who had decided to celebrate talk like a pirate day, by dressing up for students.

A school representative explained to local reporters that the district has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to reports of suspicious people .

We have this new psy lock system, there was an immediate lockdown done of the school and check in with all the teachers to make sure to make sure everybody was safe and secure. Law enforcement of course came to the scene, Suzie Ulbrich, a spokesperson for Onslow Co. Schools said.

The staff member, whose name has not yet been revealed by police, was allegedly wearing a full pirate costume, complete with a pirate hat and a plastic sword. Another member of the staff who was not in on the joke was apparently threatened by the teachers costume, and notified the school office, who then called police.

According to multiple reports, the staff member was under the impression that the person was carrying a gun, not a plastic sword.

I'm still flabbergasted over the entire thing. Zero Tolerance Policy? No. Zero Brain Policy? You Betcha!

Don't cry, even though the rant is almost over, we still have the Quote of the Week to do!

"Since the criminals, being criminals, are NOT going to obey bans, the law-abiding citizen MUST have the ability to fight fire with firepower." Neale Osborn, January 27, 2011.

"I know not what course Y'all might take, but as for me, Give me Liberty or Die, Motherfucker DIE!!" Neale Osborn and A.X. Perez, November, 2010

" One loves to possess arms, though they hope never to have occasion for them." --- Thomas Jefferson to George Washington, 1796. The Writings of Thomas Jefferson,

" We established however some, although not all its [self-government] important principles . The constitutions of most of our States assert, that all power is inherent in the people; that they may exercise it by themselves, in all cases to which they think themselves competent, (as in electing their functionaries executive and legislative, and deciding by a jury of themselves, in all judiciary cases in which any fact is involved,) or they may act by representatives, freely and equally chosen; that it is their right and duty to be at all times armed;" ---Thomas Jefferson to John Cartwright, 1824. The Writings of Thomas Jefferson,

Bye, Y'all. Gotta ship this'un to th' editor!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

I went long on this one...... enjoy it!

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

I am SOOOO glad I escaped from New Jersey in a balloon during the Reagan presidency

Neale, you live in New York. I really don't think of that as a good example of upward mobility.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

But when I escaped, I moved to Colorado for a few years, which changed everything!Grin.gif

And someday, I'll finish the ark, and sail away from NY.......

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I agree with Gunny, Neale, another good article.

Has anyone yet mentioned the law that Brown signed saying that any family member can petition a judge to have a family member's firearms taken from him because they fear he will sometime in the future do them or himself harm with them?

If the judge signs it (and after all, this is California), a warrant is issued and the police/sheriff's department have the right to walk into the person's home and search for and confiscate all firearms there and hold them for six months to a year and you only get them back after you and your family members appear before a judge and they agree you are no longer a threat to them or yourself.

This could involve visits to doctors, competency hearings.... if all states go this route, it's a clever way to disarm citizens across the country.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

And it WILL lead to making criminals out of many of us- because I, for one,will NOT comply.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

I'm thinking Tennessee or Kentucky. Or North Carolina. Or ..............

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Neither will I, Neale. Already digging out a bunker to hide the valuables when the Gestapo comes.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Digging is so last week.............Grin.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I went long on this one

Yeah you went long, it took me forever to scroll to the end.

I have a couple of questions for you Mr. Osborne. I heard twice today that an American has a 22% higher chance of being killed by a gun than a citizen of any other modern, industrialized nation. Why is that?

I have also consistently heard or read that the United States has a death by gunfire rate 6 times higher than any other industrialized nation on earth, so I decided to look it up to look it up and see if there has been any recent improvement in that number, hoping it might have gone down. But nope, that number is now 6.6%

Look;

This chart was posted in an Humanosphere article in March 2014;

GunViolence-620x445.png?width=600

Katie Leach-Kemon, the articles' author points out;

" ..... findings from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010, illustrates the difference in firearm homicide rates between the US and other high-income countries. Adjusting for differences in population size, rates of homicides from guns were 6.6 times larger in the US than in Portugal, the country with one of the highest rates in Western Europe. "

Other question; It is said, " Guns don't kill people, people kill people ",..... I say nope, it's the bullet that does the killing. My question is how can a person make a bullet go fast enough to kill someone? I mean wouldn't they have to get their hands on a gun to make a bullet go that fast?

You're the "Gun Rant" expert Neale, help me out here.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Already digging out a bunker to hide the valuables when the Gestapo comes.

You reallybelievesomeone's coming for your guns don't you?!

Read this , from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy ; it should help you sleep better.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Frist, get your fucking act together. I have asked politely, nastily, and even demanded that people spell my fucking name correctly- it's right there in front of your face.

Second, to your question- if there are more cars in our country (as there are) more people will die by car. More guns- ditto. in addition, ALL of you people keep tacking suicides (which account for more than 50% of US gun related deaths) with murders. Since suicide is a right, not a crime, this is deliberately disingenuous. Just as people try to use Japan as an example of nearly murder free AND nearly gun free, yet they ignore Japanese law that lists as suicides ALL the deaths in a family murder/suicide. (Just an example)

Third, to your asinine assertion that guns kill people, not the person pulling the trigger. It's pretty simple- unless you load the gun, point the gun, and pull the trigger, no one dies. Therefore YOU are the murderer. With the exceptions of the gun being in a fire and going off from excess heat, or perhaps an earthquake or tornado hurling a loaded gun in exactly the right way to break the sears and fire the gun, A GUN CANNOT FIRE WITHOUT A HUMAN HAND MAKING IT SO.

So, as YOU YOURSELF POINTED OUT, guns do not fire without a human hand on the trigger. It's really that simple.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

I've been carrying for over 20 years. And not once has my gun (OR I) shot anyone. The two times it was drawn in defense, no shot was fired and the incident ended safely for all. And that is my continued hope for the future. I never want to have to kill (or even wound) another human being. But one thing is clear- MY family is more important, and MY property is more important, than the lives of criminals attempting to deprive me/us of them. And always will be, because unlike the criminals, I am not robbing from anyone.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Neale's

As usual enjoyed your article -

I received this picture from a friend and it made me think about the weekly column among other things - Ohio has a castle doctrine and out in the country where I live guns are pretty common for hunting and protection. We are introduced to guns and gun safety as children and there are very few accidental shootings in the area

3289_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Accidents have increased as children are taught less, in school AND the home, about safety. In addition (in my opinion) video games encourage shoddy gun safety. NO..... playing them doesn't make kids run out and shoot up a neighborhood, but it DOES reduce the visceral impact of parental safety lectures. And schools no longer even have shooting clubs, let alone teach firearm safety. When I grew up, half the boys and a quarter of the girls were members of the rifle club. Run, I might add, by police department volunteers.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I agree

We were taught that guns were dangerous and had to be handled correctly

When I was young, guns were for hunting - not target shooting or fooling around - and often put meat on the table when we live in the country.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

We were taught that guns were dangerous and had to be handled correctly

And now we're taught that guns are dangerous and that no one should have one. A silly idea, considering how many things in our homes are dangerous if handled carelessly.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Frist , get your fucking act together.

First , learn to proofread your post.

Secondly, I ask you why Americans are 22 times morelikelyto die by gunfire, andyourresponse is spell your name correctly?!

My deepestapologiesMr. Osborne Osborn, I didn't mean to rattle you so much as to cause you to completely misunderstand the primary aspects of my comment. Btw, the surname Osborn, Nordic in origin, has beenalternativelyspelled Osborne, or Osborn since the 13th century, I see you use the Osborn version, and I will be morevigilantin the future so as not toget you upset.

Now, let's discuss the issue at hand;

Of course the number of autofatalitiescorrelates tothe the number of vehicles on the road, just as the number of gun related fatalities correlates to the number of guns in the country,..... but that's the fucking point ! There are too goddamn many guns! We NEED the vehicles, we do not NEED so many guns!(especially when it'seasierto get a gun than it is to get a drivers license)

Next, " ALL you people ", does not include me because I do not compile the statistics, I just report them.

Actually you're wrong, suicides by gunfire make up considerably more than half of gun related deaths. A Feb. 2013 New York Times article reports;

" Nearly 20,000 of the 30,000 deaths from guns in the United States in 2010 were suicides, according to the most recent figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The national suicide rate has climbed by 12 percent since 2003, and suicide is the third-leading cause of death for teenagers ."

However, breaking down the various manner in which people are killed with guns is not important. The question is WHY are Americans 22 times more likely to be killed by gunfire than in any other developed nation?

Thank you for providing the answer for the readers on this thread (I already know the answer),..... " if there are more cars in our country (as there are) more people will die by car. More guns- ditto. "

Exactly! Too many fucking guns! And they are too easy to get your hands on. As I said above, it is easier to obtain a gun in the United States than it is to obtain a drivers license.

Third, to your asinine assertion that guns kill people, not the person pulling the trigger.

To your asinine assertion that I was "asserting' any such thing. (probably a result of your being thrown off because I misspelled your name, so I'll give you a pass on that one.)

guns_dont_kill_people_people_kill_people_design.gif?width=200
The " Guns don't kill people...... " quotation, Apparently you're not quite the 'expert' regarding the gun debate you hold yourself out to be. If you were, you would know that quote is supported and promoted by your precious NRA(I think it was originated by them), actuallyyou can buy a bumper sticker from them to help promote the notion.

I used the quote in an effort topreempt any of you guys from posting it, as it usually shows up in every gun control discussion, but you guys are far less astute regarding the issue than I gave you credit for.

Note;

www.theguardian.com Opinion US gun control
Dec 21, 2012 - That's why " guns don't kill people, people kill people " is still considered an actual argument. It's why the debates on gun control go in circles .
I thank you, 1st Warrior, Egilman and Royal Lancer for helping to debunk such a stupid notion.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We are introduced to guns and gun safety as children and there are very few accidental shootings in the area

In your area maybe, and that's a good thing. Too bad the rest of the country doesn't do that. Because it's a big countrywith330 million people and as many, if not more guns.

Would you care to speculate why 22 times more Americans die by gunfire, and why the US homicide by gunfire rate is 6.6% higher than any other developed nation? Do you think it's because there are too many guns, or not enough control, or a combination of both?

(Btw, accidental shootings account for about 6% of the gun deaths in the US)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

And now we're taught that guns are dangerous and that no one should have one.

THAT comment is exactly why we can't have areasonablediscussionregarding the death by gunfireproblem in America.

Almost no one thinks that way, andalthoughthere is the fringe Left that does think that way, I said reasonable discussion.

The main problem with the gun debate, is the fringe Right thinks any legislation aimed at getting some control over our firearms and the carnage they are causing, is going to lead the the confiscation of all our guns and theabolishmentof the 2nd Amendment, and on the other side, the fringe Left actually does advocate that.

However as in most debates, although the fringe elements make the most noise, they (both sides) are almost always talking through their asses. This makes it difficult to have anyreasonablediscussion,becauseno one wants to have to talk through all the bullshit,which results in nothing getting done, and America continuing to display it's immaturity andinabilityto do anything about it's ridicules high rateof death by gunfire.

So lets cut the bullshit anddiscussreasonablemeasures to save American lives whilepreserving the sanctity and purpose of the 2ndAmendment.

I would start with better, more comprhensive screening and background checks, coupled with better more comprhensive education and training for the use and storage of firearms.

We also need to discuss the need to improve ways to isloate mentally imbalanced and unstable people that may be likely to cause harm to the public. No one want to touch that one because know one (fewanyway) have any reasonable suggestions for just how we would do that.

There's a middle ground on this issue guys, let's see if we' can reasonable enough to find it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

One guy trying to be more sarcastic that the other when neither knows what their talking about. Classic!

Read :

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

MY family is more important, and MY property is more important, than the lives of criminals attempting to deprive me/us of them.

Which is pretty much the same way everyone thinks. Your point is .....?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Outstanding statement 1st.

Perhaps you would like to tell us shat you find so outstanding about it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Jerry, a little experiment, take a gun, and a bullet, and sit them on the table, see which one moves first.

You do the little experiment 1st. If I were you I would stop trying to be sacastic until you know what the fuck you're talking about.

Read :

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

There is NO middle ground- that's what you seem to be incapable of seeing. sapient beings have the right to protect themselves, their families, and their property. PERIOD. There is no compromise for my family's safety. I will NOT be disarmed so that criminal scum can harm me and mine at will- whether that scum is government or amateur. All the "reasonable compromises" proposed are NOT REASONABLE IN THE EYES OF GUN RIGHTS ADVOCATES. I will NOT ask for permission to defend myself. I will NOT ask for permission to possess the means to do so. AND IF the government decides to force things, I'll build new guns, ammo, and supplies and continue to possess those means.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

It is physically AND legally impossible to remove all firearms from the criminal community. That's the first part. Second, it is criminally asinine to trust ANY government to the point where you allow the government to be the sole possessor of arms- that relegates you to the role of subject/serf rather than citizen. So fools, idiots, dreamers, AND tyrants alike will be ignored in their demands for compromise on this issue. I'll only give up my guns when something even more efficient in protecting me and mine is invented AND has stood the test of time. And then, I'll probably STILL keep them, because they will always have historical and antique value.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

The main problem with the gun debate, is the fringe Right thinks any legislation aimed at getting some control over our firearms and the carnage they are causing, is going to lead the the confiscation of all our guns and the abolishment of the 2nd Amendment, and on the other side, the fringe Left actually does advocate that.

No Jerry, the main problem is that the Left allows the Fringe Left to run things and set the agenda. Every time that gun restrictions have been imposed, the violence problem has not improved and more restrictions are advocated. Has the Left never stopped to wonder why the restrictions have not fixed the problem? Of course they haven't, it's much easier to blame an inanimate object than it is to change the attitude of criminals toward violent behavior. If you regard it as a gun problem, then all that's needed is to cut down on the number of guns and the death rate will go down; except, of course, that it never does. That would lead one to the logical conclusion that, if you eliminate all the guns, the violence will disappear. Many people, mostly on the Left have bought into this fallacy. Their logic is perfect, but their basic assumption is wrong. It's not a gun problem, it's a violence problem. Guns did not create it and restricting guns will not solve it.

Want proof that it's not a gun problem? A bit farther down on the page you compared gun homicide rates between the US and other developed countries and found out that we lead the world by 6.6% in gun homicides. Of course we do, we have more guns, so they're the method of homicide in this country. You're looking at the wrong data. Instead of obsessing on guns, look at the comparison of overall homicide rates. You will find that, far from leading the developed world, we're not even in the top five. That's because homicide is a matter of intent, not a matter of the available tool.

I would start with better, more comprhensive screening and background checks,

Just exactly what do you want to screen for? Perhaps you would like to screen for rumors from the person's neighbors? We already check for felony convictions and those adjudicated as insane. If the States don't turn in the data on those, that's not a problem with the law. It's simply inefficiency on the part of the system. The, so called, "Gun Show Loophole" is total nonsense. The Federal government has never had and never will have the authority to regulate private sales of firearms or anything else between individuals within a particular State. The only reason they can do so with licensed dealers is because of the Interstate Commerce Clause. Any action on that must come from the particular State government (assuming that the legislators in those States have decided that their public careers have gone on long enough and should end immediately).

Your next paragraph is actually focused on the real problem. Unfortunately, as you pointed out, no one wants to go near it because there are no quick and easy solutions to present to the voters.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If 6% of the deaths are gun related, there are 94% that are not gun related.

Man! This is worse than dealing with kindergartners.

The comment says accidental shootings account for about 6% of the gun deaths in the US. I added that as a footnote, because Robert said something about accidental shootings in his area.

If this discussion is too complicated for you, you may want stay out of it.

However, if you have an intelligent response to the question of why is it Americans have a 22 times more likely chance of being killed by gunfire than the people of any other developed county, or have any other intelligent response to my comments, I would enjoy continueing a discussion with you.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

My guess is HuffPo, or Politico, or a similar exemplary source.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Provide a link. And read TTGA's post, above, then respond to it. I choose not to respond to liberal lies about guns. So give us the links, Jerry.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

In addition, the majority of people DYING by the gun are criminals killing each other, and suicides. Neither of which bother me.........

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

And I'd prefer the horror in my mind, and the trips to the shrink if needed, to my kids crying about daddy, or my wife crying about the kids, or.....

Yeah, I've thought about it. I'm an atheist, yet I have prayed it never becomes necessary for me to do it. And my heart goes out to you for having had to, and I'm very glad you were there to and able to. I think YOU are more valuable to society than the dead man was, no matter how much it can mess with your heart to have done it. May you never need to again, my friend.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Please cite a source.... (something like that WOULD be on the web, especially if it came from a liberal source)

I heard it on the TV, it was a news channel, I think it was CNN, but it could have been msnbc. But rest assured, I don't make shit up.

I look it all and get back to you. You want stats and links? I get you stats and links.

You guys are on the wrong side of this issue. There is no way you are able to equate the right to carry with the right to kill.

I, and most other gun control advocates, do not aim to eliminate guns in this country, I know damn sure I'm not giving up my guns. But I also know I don't want me or anyone I know to be killed by some crackpot that should not been able to possess a firearm, especially if some kind of more reasonable controls could have prevented it.

The problem we have here is any, ANY effort to improve our control of firearms is completely STONEWALLED!! Stopped dead in it's tracks, just like the 12,000 Americans that are killed every year with those guns are stopped dead in their tracks.

It is not a matter of MORE laws you guys have been told to object to, it's a matter of BETTER laws, because the laws in place are obviously not working. But, Oh No! No gun reform! They're out to get your guns!

Object to all gun reform, fuck those people being killed every year, let the rest of the world laugh at you, fuck them, we're allowed to own guns and we're going to own guns and we're going to kill people with them. Actually, many Americans are going to kill themselves with them! It's easy, just stick the barrel in your mouth and pull the trigger. You won't feel a thing. Try stabbing yourself to death, see how that works out. (It will be mighty painful, I'll garun-tee you that!)

But whatever you do, make damn sure it doesn't hurt the gun manufactures' profit margin. If you do that they won't be able to support the NRA, and what would you do without the NRA to tell you what to do?

Neale says this is a gun rant .... good, I'm on a rant, the eagle guy set me off. Which reminds me, I gotta go find some stats.

I'll be back.26.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

NO..... playing them doesn't make kids run out and shoot up a neighborhood, but it DOES reduce the visceral impact of parental safety lectures.

I do not believe you can support that theory with any credible references.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

The problem we have here is any, ANY effort to improve our control of firearms is completely STONEWALLED!! Stopped dead in it's tracks

Good. because you don't have the right to control guns.

Object to all gun reform, fuck those people being killed every year, let the rest of the world laugh at you, fuck them, we're allowed to own guns and we're going to own guns and we're going to kill people with them. Actually, many Americans are going to kill themselves with them!

Ignore the facts, Jerry. we don't mind. First to suicide- what's your problem with it? it's your right to choose to end your life. A gun is simply the quickest and easiest way ro exercise that right. NOT a problem. As to people being killed with guns every year, look up the WHO stats on murder worldwide- we're at 4.9 per 100,000. Right down near the bottom of the list. High was near 60. I'll leave it to YOU to find the stats- you won't believe it otherwise.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Very good article Neale. I read every word and followed every link.

This doesn't address why more people are killed by guns in the USA, but it does address the real objective of the anti-gun advocates such as the one in this video.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Oh so true. There is only one thing that will make ME a criminal- and that is banning guns. because I will not comply.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

There is NO middle ground- that's what you seem to be incapable of seeing.

There is ALWAYS middle ground, you are just incapable of going there and dealing with it.

sapient beings have the right to protect themselves, their families, and their property. PERIOD.

EXACTLY! Liberals understand that! Everybody want to protect their families. You don't seem to hear that we have guns also, and for the same reason!

There is no compromise for my family's safety.

Or for mine!

I will NOT be disarmed so that criminal scum can harm me and mine at will- whether that scum is government or amateur.

NO ONE IS ASKING ANYONE TO DISARM!

All the "reasonable compromises" proposed are NOT REASONABLE IN THE EYES OF GUN RIGHTS ADVOCATES.

Which is a totally unreasonable position to take. Keep in mind Neale, the discussion here about reducing the death toll we have every year from the guns in America. Your attitude is "fuck'em I don'give a shit, I'm all about me. PERIOD!

I will NOT ask for permission to defend myself. I will NOT ask for permission to possess the means to do so.

No one is fucking asking you to!!!! What the fuck do you mean by "asking permission"? You already have permission!!! It's been granted to you in the 2nd Amendment.

AND IF the government decides to force things, I'll build new guns, ammo, and supplies and continue to possess those means.

You do that.

Meanwhile I'll stop beating my head against the wall here and start a "Jerrys' Weekly Anti-Gun Rant" Maybe we can create some reasonable discussions and show you how to find that middle-ground.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If 1 thousand die each day 6% from weapons. 94% from other.

If 1 thousand die each day 6% FROMACCIDENTALSHOOTINGS94% from OTHERSHOOTINGS.

You're not really that stupid Gunny, you're just acting like a troll as usual.

Blind as a bat. and twice as old as Dracula.

Go fuck yourself.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

No Jerry, the main problem is that the Left allows the Fringe Left to run things and set the agenda.

Let's start right there. The fringe Left has no more effect on the liberal agenda than the fringe Right has on the Conservative agenda. The 'fringe' on both sides does have some impact on agendas, but neither side is run by their fringe elements. (Although some people within the GOP are starting to be concerned about how much control the radical Right is gaining )

Every time that gun restrictions have been imposed, the violence problem has not improved and more restrictions are advocated.

The present 'restrictions' and so called controls that are in place were watered down so much by the opposition that they are ineffective and/or unenforceable. The 'new' laws you are so concerned about are not really new, they are for the most part just reformations and improvements on the weak laws on the books.

Has the Left never stopped to wonder why the restrictions have not fixed the problem? Of course they haven't,

(?!)104.gif WHAT?!

We have said over and over, the laws on the books are not working, they are written so poorly that they are ineffective and/or unenforceable. All the gun control lobby is looking for are laws that will work! But every time anyone presents a proposal to fix the problem the NRA, and the politicians they support, makes you you guys go all bug-fuck and convinced big brother is coming for your guns.

Calm the fuck down! Cool out .... think.

We have a problem. Too many guns .... not enough controls, resulting in way too many dead Americans.

Something has to be done, and it seems to me the people that own most of the guns should feel the most responsible in seeing something IS done. But even after the terrible tragedy at Sandy Hook you guys refused to do absolutely anything.

it's much easier to blame an inanimate object than it is to change the attitude of criminals toward violent behavior.

No one is blaming an inanimate object because that 'object' becomes VERY animated once it is in someones hand. And the Left has been very active in attempting to change the attitude of criminals and preventing young people from becoming criminals, but it is VERY difficult to get the Right to provide funding for those endeavors.

Just exactly what do you want to screen for?

I'm not apsychiatrist, but I know there is a way to screen for violent tendencies, the problem we are dealing with is maintaining a balance between civil rights and public safety.

I'm also not a lawyer or a public safety expert, but I am a concerned American that knows we have to be screening for more than we are screening for now. Andthatthe Right needs to stop fightingaagainstevery efforttodo something to get a handle on the 300,000,000+ (300 million+) guns in the country, and the potential screwballs that should not be allowed to possess any of them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Provide a link.

Humanosphere article provide Oct 25, HERE . Read you're threads.

read TTGA's post then respond to it.

Done .

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I said here ; " I heard it on the TV, it was a news channel, I think it was CNN, but it could have been msnbc. But rest assured, I don't make shit up. "

This is what I found they must have been using the 22% figure from;

I njury Prevention

" Almost 22% (252 of 1162) of deaths among handgun purchasers were firearm related. "

That's a little vague, so lets go with this report from an ABC News article ;

U.S. Has More Guns And Gun Deaths Than Any Other Country, Study Finds

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I ain't telling you shit.

Good, because I don't need any shit from you.

(Silly of me to expect an intelligent response)

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Which is a totally unreasonable position to take. Keep in mind Neale, the discussion here about reducing the death toll we have every year from the guns in America.

Not true at all. The debate is over gun rights. YOU want it to be over compromising rights to provide imaginary safety. Ben Franklin would despise you.

I will NOT ask for permission to defend myself. I will NOT ask for permission to possess the means to do so.

No one is fucking asking you to!!!! What the fuck do you mean by "asking permission"? You already have permission!!! It's been granted to you in the 2nd Amendment.

no one is fucking asking me to ask for permission? REALLY??? What do you call licenses andpermits? I have to PAY FOR PERMSIION, and even if I pay, I can be denied it. try another lie. Oh, wait, it's right in the same quote- the 2nd GRANTS nothing. It ENUMERATES an existing right. In fact, Hamilton and Madison felt it was un-necessary BECAUSE IT WAS AN INHERENT PART OF BEING A CITIZEN, AND NO ONE WOULD EVER DREAM OF TRYING TO LIMIT OR REMOVE IT!!!!

Maybe we can create some reasonable discussions and show you how to find that middle-ground.

Not gonna happen. There is no "reasonable middle ground". ANY restriction upon the right of a human being to own and carry the means of self defense THEY determine is necessary to their existence. In this case, YOU are defining "reasonable, then getting pissed because I don't accept YOUR definition. MY definition of reasonable restrictions is "When on private property, obtain the owner's permission before carrying." That's it. ANYTHING ELSE is an infringement upon a basic human, civil AND Constitutional right.

Make your own rant- if I never see your posts it won't bother me at all.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

EVERY society that has removed guns from their society since the invention of guns, has see their incidence of violent crime triple or quadruple post gun removal.

Me thinks the President went to the wrong people to do his study. Who was on the commission? If they were politicians, keep in mind none of them wants to piss off the Conservatives over a bullshit thing like a report on gun violence.

Let's try this on for size;

The Atlantic

A Land Without Guns: How Japan Has Virtually Eliminated Shooting Deaths

"In part by forbidding almost all forms of firearm ownership, Japan has as few as two gun-related homicides a year."

" Crime in Japanis lower than in all other industrialized countries . "

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

One thousand a day die from guns? REALLY When did you lean to count, and why did you forget how? 32,000 deaths a year. YOUR number comes to 365,000 a year. You just multiple the daily "death toll" by more than 10. Then, you forgot to subtract the suicides (more than 55% of the so-called death toll, 17,000). In addition, you "forgot" that the lion's share of deliberate shootings are criminals shooting up criminals. Then you "forgot" to count the shootings by cop (5-600) that are deemed legitimate, and the shootings in self defense (3-500) that are deemed legitimate. And you totally (and deliberately) overlook the hundreds of thousands of defensive uses if guns that have nothing to do with a death, or even an injury (minimum of 195,000 by FBI stats, which ONLY count events where the police file a report). The troll is you. Fuck yourself, asshole.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Stalking I see. following my every comment here huh?

Don't flatter yourself. I can't imagine anyone ever having any reason to "stalk" you. Your little bird droppings are splattered all over this site, if you don't want anyone to respond to your birdshit ..... contain yourself.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I think you need a little rest in an asylum.

Yeah I do, I'm sure the crazies there will seem normal compared to some of the crackpots on this site.

Later Gunny, we're trying to have a discussion about something here. Apparently the math in this discussion is too complicated for you, so maybe you should just unplug your keyboard and go home.

Bye!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

One thousand a day die from guns? REALLY When did you lean to count, and why did you forget how? 32,000 deaths a year. YOUR number comes to 365,000 a year.

NO NOT 'REALLY'!

I made a comment that about 6% of all deaths by gunfire are accidental, and Gunny, in his normal practice of twisting comments to advance his trolling activities, changed it to;

" If 6% of the deaths are gun related, there are 94% that are not gun related. "

After I corrected that comment, he changed it again to;

" If 1 thousand die each day 6% from weapons. 94% from other. "

When I responded to that mis-quote, I just copied his comment and inserted the correction, not realizing he had said "If 1,000 each day ......". I apologize, my mistake.

Anytime I have looked up the stats on gun deaths in America, something I do during every discussion I get into re; gun violence, I come up with stats similar to the one posted in the graph on this thread .

Searches will show numbers are all over the place, depending on the source, for instance in this search for " Gun deaths in America ", usconservatives.about.com shows the toll at 32,000 per year, writing off about 19,000 of those as suicides (as if those people aren't dead), leaving around 12,00 gun murders.

You make reference elsewhere on this this thread about a WHO study that shows the the US much lower than I usually quote, however, I limit my comparisons to the industrialized developed nations, I think your reference includes all or most countries. You also discuss the suicide factor in that comment. I am in the process of getting back to you on that comment. But I got distracted by thisbullishofGunnys'.

This distraction is a classic example of how assholes and Trolls disrupt discussions, especially when authors and seeders allow their threads to be trolled by their friends.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Just one more Law will help while the other 2,000 plus laws didn't.

I don't care if there are 20 THOUSAND gun control laws on the books,theyare notWORKING!

We need to get some laws written that will WORK, and make a federal offense when LEOs take it into their own hands in deciding not to enforce gun laws.

Most gun regs on the books are poorly written and/or unenforcable resulting in the US looking like the assholes of all developed nations with a per capita gun death ratio over 6 times higher than anyone else.

IF you guyswantto have the 2ndamendmentrespected, then you must learn to have some respect toward the safety of your fellow Americans and do something about our terrible track record regarding gun safety.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

don't care if there are 20 THOUSAND gun control laws on the books, they are not WORKING!

Quite correct Jerry, gun control laws DON'T WORK. So, what makes you think more gun control laws WILL work? Insanity is continuing to try the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. Doesn't really matter now; after yesterday's election results, it will be a very long time before any politician proposes another one. They found out what happens to the ones who do.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

What's REALLY pathetic , Jerry, is that you refuse to keep your word. You ALWAYS bitch about my rants, you ALWAYS swear you're going to stop commenting, AND YOU LIE YOUR ASS OFF EVERY TIME YOU PROMISE IT!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Let me make this CRYSTAL CLEAR- Suicide is a right- I do not give a flying fuck what you use to commit suicide- gun, knife, rope, poison, OD, drowning, jumping, or a 100 mile an hour crash AS LONG AS YOU DO NOT TAKE ANYONE ELSE WITH YOU. Got it? (I doubt it)

We have one of the lowest murder rates overall in the world- developed OR undeveloped countries. Higher with guns, because we have a right to own guns, lower with everything else because we have far more ARMED potential victims who kill the killer. And that's fine with me. Humans, BEING human, are predators, and sometimes predators kill something they shouldn't. Punish the hell out of the bad guys, and I'll back you to the hilt. Try to limit, restrict, control, license, ban, reduce, or eliminate ANY part of our RTKBA, and I will oppose you.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

First to suicide- what's your problem with it?

It kills people.

it's your right to choose to end your life.

Not usually. Ask any grieving spouse, child, mother, father, brother or sister if they think their loved one had the right to kill themselves.

I know you won't agree with me onthat, because you're a conservative, and mostconservatives are very selfish people and only care about themselves and their own feelings.

A gun is simply the quickest and easiest way ro exercise that right. NOT a problem.

It IS a problem! It's because a gun is a quick and easy way to kill yourself that it's a problem. Fewer guns = fewer quick and easy ways to commit suicide.

" There always knives if they don't have a gun " Yeah, right,try stabbing yourself to death, see how that works out.

Poison and overdosing doesn't always work (has a 15% fail rate). Hanging also does not always work, not to mention, strangling sucks.

Other methods, like jumping off bridges and buildings requires an appropriate bridge or building, and not getting caught, or changing your mind before jumping.

All these methods give a potential suicide time to think about what they are about todo and they very often decide to opt out doing something so stupid.

A gun on the other hand often gives someone in a temporary high stress situation an opportunity to just stick the barrel of a gun in their mouth and pull the trigger. Which is something they may not have done if they had some time to think. Like the time it takes to drive to bridge or climb up to a roof.

As to people being killed with guns every year, look up the WHO stats on murder worldwide- we're at 4.9 per 100,000. Right down near the bottom of the list. High was near 60. I'll leave it to YOU to find the stats- you won't believe it otherwise.

I'm full aware of the overallpositiontheUS is in when compared to all the countriesused in the WHO charts.

However,thecomparison being made here is where we stand among economically developed nations;

graph.py?option=1&stat_id=410&group_id=4841867&entity_id=286&thumbnail=1&width=600

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I said GOOD BYE GUNNY!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

All that is too time consuming for me, you don't like the AMA report? Fine, explain this one;

graph.py?option=1&stat_id=410&group_id=4841867&entity_id=286&thumbnail=1&width=650

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

You ALWAYS bitch about my rants, you ALWAYS swear you're going to stop commenting, AND YOU LIE YOUR ASS OFF EVERY TIME YOU PROMISE IT!

I know, I feel guilty that I'm letting you get away with being happy in your own little bubble, with all your friends around agreeing with you.

I feel it's my obligation to come to your rants every once in a while and disagree with you, someone has to do it.

You see Neale, not everyone agrees with you, you're just going to have to learn to live with that.

Gotta go now, I'll see you the next time you come up on my "To Do" list.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Problem with this is a huge one. Federal law does not allow and specifically bans any sort of gun registry scheme that creates a list of gun owners.

How about the Feds set standard licensing requirements and havethe states process and issue state licensesthatare recognized inevery state, similar to the way driver licenses are issued?

The main problem with that idea is it smacks of compromise and Republican politicians are allergic to compromise.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Everyone knows my stand on compromise, and few of you get it. But I have offered this one before, and will again, even though I find it disgusting. I can accept this compromise, even though it is un-Constitutional, as long as BOTH PARTS are fully enforced. Pay close attention, Jerry.

When an American citizen turns the age of majority, (currently 18)s/he then goes to a local government building- maybe the county seat, town hall, police department- I am not picky- and presents their birth certificate or naturalization papers to prove said citizenship. They submit to fingerprinting,(or a retinal print scan ((more on that, later)) a passport-style set of photos, and as background check is run to make sure their rights as a citizen have not been revoked for any reason. If they choose to add firearms to their card, they must certify they have taken a safety and marksmanship class (better get them back in the public schools, but I have digressed). Once all comes back clean, they are issued their state-based ID that, like Driver's licenses, are MANDATORILY ACCEPTED ACROSS THE NATION.

This card MUST be presented in order to buy a gun OR to vote. It is ALSO a carry acknowledgement (NOT a license- you cannot license a right). When buying a gun, the card-holder presents the card, their retina is scanned (retinal scans are becoming cheaper to do, are safe and non-invasive, and unlike fingerprints, there is no way to gather retinal scans without the knowledge of the scannee) to verify they are not currently under indictment for a citizenship-stripping offense and that the card is not a forgery. NO RECORD OF THE GUN OR GUNS PURCHASED MAY BE ATTACHED TO THE CARD OR THE VERIFYING DATABANK- THE ONLY RECORDS ARE THE STORE'S, FOR WARRANTEE AND INVENTORY PURPOSES. This card allows for open or concealed carry. For voting purposes, this card is presented, the retina scanned to verify the card is valid, and you vote. The cost for this card may not exceed one hour of minimum wage pay (until this asinine concept is abolished, then it will be not more than1/2 the national average hourly pay) so that NO ONE can claim getting the card is a financial burden. Updating the card for address changes, and to update the photos, bears the same cost. Photo updates are not mandatory, but address changes that change what district you vote in are. Please do not overlook the fact that this card WILL eliminate partial citizenship penalties (18 to vote or die for the country, 21 to drink and own handguns) because I'm sick of the hypocrisy of partial citizenship

Now, if you cannot accept this, then I say "Oh well! That's ALL you're going to get from ME!!"

Again, I re-iterate- this is unacceptable, un- (indeed, ANTI-) Constitutional, but I will tolerate it despite my MASSIVE misgivings. I have compromised. What say YOU?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Jerry, we have a fundamental difference of moral philosophy here. And no, I'm not being an ass this time.

There is only one thing you own, and from that, grow all property rights. YOU, and YOU ALONE, own your life and body. Does suicide make the people in your life sad? Absolutely. Is it often the coward's way out? Absolutely. But the one absolute is that you CAN choose to end your life. It does not belong to the government, the community, the world, or even your family. It is the one thing YOU own. Now, I'm a nasty prick. If I had cancer, Id fight that bastard tooth and nail, and go down fighting. If I get depressed, I go for a hike, or a ride on my horse, or hug my kids, or do something to change it. I do not decide to leave this life. But it IS my right. Believe me, I get it- you want to make it harder for someone to do so. I don't care what method they choose- it's not MY business (or frankly, YOURS) how they exercise that sad final option. We have no right to make it harder on them, nor to use THEIR sad decision as an excuse for stripping rights from others.

So, to be blunt (as if I'm ever otherwise) suicide has NO BEARING AT ALL on the gun debate. Quite simply, (and coldly, I'd rather the suicides get on with their selfish business, and let US get on with life.

 
 
 
ARKY
Freshman Silent
link   ARKY    12 years ago

There are laws against cocaine and heroin too, have been for years. Don't work. Let's pass more laws. Maybe it will get better.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Jerry, we have a fundamental difference of moral philosophy here.

Yeah we do, but taking the 'moral high ground' is a habit of mine and often causes me to butt heads with those having a lower moral attitude.

And no, I'm not being an ass this time.

I take that as an admission you're being an ass with your other comments, thank you for that.

There is only one thing you own, and from that, grow all property rights. YOU, and YOU ALONE, own your life and body.

I was brought up in a Catholic tradition and taught to look at suicide as a "rejection of God's gift of physical life, a failure of stewardship, an act of despair, and a transgression of the sixth commandment, "You shall not kill" (Exodus 20:13)." [ 1 ]

Although I am agnostic regarding the existence of God, I do believe the 10 commandments should be used as a guide to establish our relationship with society and one another.

Does suicide make the people in your life sad? Absolutely. Is it often the coward's way out? Absolutely. But the one absolute is that you CAN choose to end your life.

We have the right to make any decision we choose in life. But that does mean every decision we make is a righteous decision. We can decide to drive 90 miles an hour on an interstate highway, but that is illegal as it could be very harmful to yourself and others, so we have taken means to prevent you from doing that. IMO, suicide is self-murder, and murder is also illegal and for the same reason. Therefore as society we have an obligation to prevent people from committing murder or self-murder.

It is the position of most gun control advocates that we need to any means available to prevent people from possessing firearms if they are sufferingfrom such mental anguish that they feelthe urge or need to commit murder. Grantedidentifying those suffering from mental problems is very difficult, but there are people working very hard on that part of the issue.

In the meantime, the other part of our high death by gunfire problem is theaccessibilityvs control of these deadly weapons. I know you cringe at the word 'control', but as a society there are certain things of which we have to apply some sort of controls. Dynamite and other high explosives is one example, firearms is another.

Give us a break Neale, we're not trying to 'disarm' the citizenry, we're just trying to get a better handle on the 350 million +- guns floating around the country, with a primary goal of isolating those with diminished or unbalanced mental capacities. I would think that that you, being a gun advocate, would be at the forefront of gun safety and an advocate for insuring those possessing firearms are mentally capable of using them in a manner that assures the safety of the public.

Now, I'm a nasty prick.

Really?! I never would have guessed.

I suppose that means we have one nasty prick debating with another here.

Believe me, I get it-

Believe me, if I thought you really 'get it', I would not have done all the above typing. This many come as a shock to you, but if you recall, you and I have shared friends list on NV since May of 2011. You are one of the few Right Wingers I had on that list, and I know you can be stubborn to the point of exasperation, but I also know you're sufficiently intelligent to eventually becomeconvinced to support some sort of reasonable and effective means to reduce the gun violence in this country, so I haven't quite given up on you.

I don't care what method they choose- it's not MY business (or frankly, YOURS) how they exercise that sad final option. We have no right to make it harder on them,...."

Sure it's our business, they are fellow humans suffering from mental anguish and they need help. It is not only our right to prevent or make it difficult for someone to harm or kill themselves, it is our responsibility to to take some sort of action.

So, to be blunt (as if I'm ever otherwise) suicide has NO BEARING AT ALL on the gun debate.

(?!) You're the one that introduces suicide to every discussion on the issue in an apparent attempt to prove Americas' level of gun violence is at anacceptable level, and, in so many words, claiming that blowing ones brains out is not a violent act.

Quite simply, (and coldly) I'd rather the suicides get on with their selfish business, and let US get on with life.

Actually I find that a little hard to believe. Are you saying that if you saw someone about to commit suicide you would just let them do it?

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

Fine, explain this one;

That's easy Jerry. The data is irrelevant. Show us one about where the US stands in overall murders (without the irrational obsession with firearms) and you then are showing important data. That would show you something about the attitudes of the citizens of various countries toward violence and killing. The problem is that you're focusing on instruments rather than intentions. Change the instrument and you still have just as many killings. Change the attitude and the murder rate drops off.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Last line first- yes and no. Grin.gif I have no right nor power to "let" them do it, or stop them from doing it. But I WOULD try to talk them out of it. I was 13 when my Cousin ran a hose from the exhaust pipe into the window of a car. I KNOW firsthand what suicide can do to a family. But I would not PHYSICALLY stop a person who was not inebriated in some way from committing suicide.

AS to being an ass- well, sometimes I do not give a damn whether you consider my words, so I do not...... modify my normal blunt, prickish behavior. in other words, I do not compromise. This time, I really wanted you to consider what I was saying untainted by attitude.

I DO understand your reasoning for considering suicide to be bad. I just disagree. I was raised Episcopalian (Catholic without confession, Hail Mary's, and the Pope isn't THE boss, just A boss), so I understand the Biblical side of the argument. I'm agnostic, leaning atheist, and I get the mental difficulties. And I'll have to finish this later- got farm chores to deal with- a horse just got out of the field..

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

And THAT shows your ignorance. you claim that without government I own nothing- I state that government only takes, it does not protect. Without the government CHARGING ME for a title, I would still own my car. Libertarians hold that ALL rights are property rights- stemming from the fact that you and ONLY you own your body and all the fruits that body provides. Of COURSE I need to protect my property, and I already do. Government does nothing for me but chargeme fees for owning what is already mine.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Horse caught, kids fed, youngest in bed, finally back on the computer......

Mental difficulties with suicide being a right, due to religious upbringing- Been there, worked it out. And for me, it was simple, once I accepted one simple fact- none of us know what comes next (if anything). So it is our right, if we so choose, to determine when we will find out. Me, I choose the long road- but if another chooses to jump the line, I won't tell them no.

So, to be blunt (as if I'm ever otherwise) suicide has NO BEARING AT ALL on the gun debate.

(?!) You're the one that introduces suicide to every discussion on the issue in an apparent attempt to prove Americas' level of gun violence is at anacceptable level, and, in so many words, claiming that blowing ones brains out is not a violent act.

I introduce suicide every time because suicide is NOT a violent act, for there is no victim- the suicide has made a choice, and acted on it. using suicide, exercising an inherent right of being sapient, to justify stripping or limiting the rights of another is disingenuous at best. Would I prefer to see violence in America lowered? Yup. at TYPE of violence is lowered? Nope. I do not differentiate between ANY type of initiation of force, whether it be with gun, knife, fire, car, fists, clubs, rocks, or rope. I do not support or condone ANY initiation of force. I only support and condone force in self defense. I have NO right to punch you, and if I try to, you have EVERY right to use whatever amount of force, using whatever force multiplier you deem necessary to enable that defense, and if I die as a result, it was suicide by stranger. If I were to succeed, you would have the right to sue my ass off if you didn't kill me for it.

And America is quite far down on overall violent crimes, and getting lower, even as we increase the number of guns in private hands.

According to an FBI report released on November 10: "violent crimes in 2013 decreased 4.4 percent when compared with 2012 figures, and the estimated number of property crimes decreased 4.1 percent [as well]."

Go to the link contained n the quote (I know you won't consider the article a good source, but he link is to the government's own figures.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

If true, you should advocate for gun ownership, since you hate gun owners, conservatives, and people with religion.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Now, if you cannot accept this, then I say "Oh well! That's ALL you're going to get from ME!!"

That's a helluva lot more than I ever expected to get from you! (I hope it doesn't give you a rash) 8^)}

Actually a state issued possession ID, or whatever you want to call it, accepted in all states, as I said above, is pretty much what I have in mind.

You obviously have given this much thought and the details you've worked out seem reasonable and practical. I would have no problem supporting your idea.

The constitutionality issue would have to be left up to 'the nine'. I'm sure sooner than later someone in the Dakotas or Alaska would bring it to them if such a proposal were to become law.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Oh FINE!!! Add me to your friends list. You realize this destroys my "Obstinate Ass Cred"! Remember- I snuck in a lowering of the drinking and smoking ages, and this card CANNOT be superseded by federal, state or local laws to prohibit carry on public property- Though I suppose some activist will try to get a few specific locales built in to the amendment that would be needed tocreate this card.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

There are laws against cocaine and heroin too, have been for years. Don't work. Let's pass more laws. Maybe it will get better.

.....and your point is.......?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

.....and your point is.......?

That laws don't work when thePUNISHMENT for breaking them is non-existent. For one tiny example- IF you are denied a firearm due to the NICS check determining that you lied on the Form 4473, you have committed a felony. So, when you are denied, the FIRST thing you need to do is protest/appeal the denial, to eliminate this felony. Over 15000 people in 2011 failed the NICS check and were denied the purchase. About 1200 of these denials were overturned upon this appeal, often due to mis-entry of info, expunged records or overturned convictions not being recorded, wrong address leading to wrong person being checked. Of the remaining approximately 14000 people, less than 100 were prosecuted for committing a firearms-related felony. So the appearance (at least) is that the DoJ doesn't want to prosecute people for violating gun laws. Hmmmmmm. So. let's NOT prosecute people for committing crimes, then claim the laws don't work, then demand MORE laws to NOT enforce. Doesn't make any sense at all............ (Not that the laws are actually Constitutional at all in the first place!)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Change the instrument and you still have just as many killings.

What makes you think that?

The contention that a person will commit a murder whether they have a gun or not is a flawed argument.

There are several factors that cause people to commit murder with a gun they may not have committed if they didn't have access to that gun. A gun is a unique weapon. It works much quicker, much easier, can be used from a distance and is more deadly than any other weapon.

Knives, the most common alternative, are not nearly as deadly, and require physical contact with victim. Try stabbing someone from across the street, or even across the room, see how that works out. Drive- byknifingshave never proven effective either.

Thenecessity forphysical one on one contact in itself is usually adeterrent to keep someone from committing murder.

Most other weaponsin many cases, give the victimthe opportunity to defend themselves. Actually a victim has an opportunity to defend themselves during almost any physical assault where a gun is not being used.

Just simply holding a gun gives a person an enormous feeling of empowerment. They know that all they have to do is point, pull that little lever and the bullet will take care of everything else.

A hammer (2nd most common) poison, explosives, fire, drowning andstrangulationare just not the same thing. They harder to use, don't always work and sometimes end up with the assailant being injured or killed.

No, a gun is definitely the way to go, especially when there are 350 million of them around.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Looks bad.

It looks bad because it is bad.

But Germany and the United Kingdom, on that list, have murder rates of about 1 per 100,000. Compared to the US, of around 5 per 100,000.

That looks bad too. But not as bad.

Not as bad as what?

Then again, the murder rate for whites in the US is closer to 2 per 100K.

Oh, excuse me Robert, I guess I'm doing it wrong. I'm only supposed to factor in the white population right? Although Blacks are also people, they don't count because they're Black. I forgot, I was thinking we were supposed to count all Americans.

It's probably even closer to Germany and UK if you just compared their stats to stats for German Americans and British Americans.

Wouldn't that be a better comparison?

Only if your a racist.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Oh FINE!!! Add me to your friends list.

What's the big deal? We've been "Frienamies" on the Vine since May 2011. (You should feel honored)

You realize this destroys my "Obstinate Ass Cred"!

Nothing will ever destroy your "obstinate ass" credibility. Anyway I have seniority intheObstinateAss Department around here.

Remember- I snuck in a lowering of the drinking and smoking ages

You should know better than to think you can sneak anything past me. I've always believed the drinking and smoking age should be equalto thedraft age. Yeah, smoking and drinking are bad for your health, like IEDs and RPGs are safer.

I had my first legal drink in June of 1957 at that time theminimumage inNY was 18, but I didn't start smoking until I was 28, and what I was smoking is still illegal in New York.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

Only if your a racist.

Very interesting Jerry. Since your avowed purpose is to remove firearms from those most likely to use them to kill, you would certainly want to start with those who are involved with drug smuggling and sales operations, since a large percentage of murders are committed by those involved in such operations (ie. drug gangs). Most of the people involved in drug gangs are either Mexican American or African American, and you would have to racially profile to identify those people. That means that you might not want to talk too loud about racism.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Government does nothing for me but chargeme fees for owning what is already mine.

Government charges you fees to help you prove what is yours is actually yours. If someone came along and claimed your farm belongs to him, you have a deed and other legalprotectionto prove he iswrong.

The deed contains the exact dimensions including latitude and longitude of your property stakes and an abstract of the chain of possession of that parcel going back to when it was first created.

That deed is then certified by the government and a legal copy is filed in a government building in order to protect you from any false orerroneousclaims that may be brought against you or your property.

That all cost money and that is what those fees are for.

Same with your car, the state charges you to register your car, YOUR car, at least you claim it to be your car, but then you have the legal documents to prove it's your car so you're ok. Like if someone stole your car, you would be able to prove to the cops you ownthe car, right? And you would be able to give them the plate number so they would know that they are looking for the right car, right?

I mean there were 10,876,551 vehicles registered in NYS in 2013, 10,876,351 in Steuben County alone. That's a lot of vehicles to keep track of, .... costs money.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Most of the people involved in drug gangs are either Mexican American or African American, and you would have to racially profile to identify those people. That means that you might not want to talk too loud about racism.

That's a pretty absurd and twisted rational T.

Yes I want to prevent guns from getting into the hands of the people most likely to use them to kill. If most of those people happen to to black orHispanic, that does not make me any more of a racistthan someone that advocates the deportation of illegal immigrants, most of which happen to beHispanic.

 
 

Who is online

Sean Treacy
devangelical
Gazoo
Right Down the Center


102 visitors