ESPN : New England Patriots Have Been Cheating For 15 Years, and the NFL Knew It
Arbitrary Incompetence All the Way Down: The Roger Goodell Story
Posted: Tue, 08 Sep 2015 16:08:18 GMTWell, well, well. All the pieces of the puzzle are now in place :
I want to hug and kiss this beautiful story from ESPNs Don Van Natta Jr. and Seth Wickersham and take it out to a fancy dinner. Splendidly reported and brutally damning of both the New England Patriots and Roger Goodell, it alleges that the Patriots Spygate scandal was worse than anyone imaginedand was actively swept under the rug by the commissioner and the NFL.
You should read the story immediately, but the thrust is thisciting interviews with 90 sources in and around football as well as primary documents, ESPN reports that Bill Belichick and the Patriots videotaped opposing teams signals from 40 different games from 2000 through 2007. And when the scandal broke, Goodell did everything in his power to protect Robert Kraft, who was one of his strongest supporters and without whom he would not have been named commissioner. The thesis statement in this story is that the cover-upand if this report is accurate, the leagues actions cant be called anything else but a cover-upso rankled other owners that Goodell came down extra-hard on New England and Tom Brady for Ballghazi as a makeup call.
[]
Ballghazi looks very different in this context. Not merely the NFLs usual clownish mishandling, its the culmination of 15 years of the Patriots bending and breaking the rules, and of pent-up acrimony accrued by Goodells chummy relationship with Kraft. The NFL, attempting to trump up the charges against Tom Brady, relied largely on his destruction of evidencea tactic, it turns out, with which the leagues investigators had firsthand familiarity.
And after all that, the NFL couldnt even get it to stick.
There was a lot of speculation about this, but Van Natta and Wickersham have confirmed it. We now know why the NFL inflated Ballghazi by leaking erroneous information to its media puke funnels, why they blundered forward with a punishment even after their investigation failed to turn up reliable evidence that the balls were deflated (not least because nobody cared about the issue ex ante), why the punishment imposed was massively disproportionate, why Kraft went along with round 1 of the massively disproportionate punishments, and why Goodell refused to make a deal with Brady even after Judge Berman did everything but rent the Goodyear Blimp and put I will vacate this punishment in neon within eyeshot of the NFLs offices.
The Patriots were guilty of actual, material cheating that was identified at the time by multiple teams. (Not just videotaping but doing stuff like stealing playsheets from the opposing locker room.) Goodell, acting on behalf of the owner to whom he owed his job, covered up the extent of the cheating by destroying evidence and putting pressure on the other teams to stay silent. Goodell did inflict a punishment on the Patriots that was arguably reasonable, but he went out of his way to cover up their reputations.
Its tempting to say and many have that Ballghazi was therefore rough justice. Tempting, but wrong. You dont make up for past wrongdoing by framing someone who may or may not be guilty of a trivial offense and imposing a massively disproportionate penalty on them. (Even the repeat offender charge doesnt work in re: Brady; he wasnt the one videotaping practices or stealing play scripts.) And while I can understand the frustration of the other owners with the special treatment the Patriots received, wanting them to be punished with a trumped-up faux scandal is shortsighted. What happens when another team has a vendetta against you and wants to run it through the cross between Ronald McDonald and Judge Dredd in the commissioners office? Ask Sean Payton.
I heard an interesting interview recently with Jay Feely, whos working for the NFLPA. Asked why the players he agreed to give so much arbitrary power in the hands of Goodell, he cited two things. First, the owners made it clear that the disciplinary process was non-negotiable the players could accept it or the lockout would last all year. And second, under Tagliabue, the system had worked tolerably well there wasnt the same pattern of compounding arbitrary punishments. The lesson to the player is that you shouldnt rely on arbitrary powers being applied fairly no matter whos in charge (although its not clear they have the leverage to do anything about it in any case.) But one lesson for the owners should be that a completely arbitrary disciplinary system isnt really in anyones interest in the long run, no matter who might benefit in the short term. Even if the owners find a less buffoonish replacement for Goodell, they should restore some independence to the process something that works perfectly well for other leagues.
http://rss.feedsportal.com/c/35353/f/661836/s/49abc5d6/sc/7/l/0L0Slawyersgunsmoneyblog0N0C20A150C0A90Carbitrary0Eincompetence0Eall0Ethe0Eway0Edown0Ethe0Eroger0Egoodell0Estory/story01.htm

I wonder how much longer Goodel will be the commish.
Every win in the books, including in the playoffs and Super Bowls that the Patriots have had in the last 15 years should have an asterisk by them denoting that there is a strong probability that the win came via cheating. And the losses should have one too, indicating that they just failed to cheat hard enough that day. They are no better the the baseball players who pumped up on steroids. Someday Brady will be inducted into the HOF and he'll actually think and say that he earned it. He didn't.
might wanna check out this stuff for how your team cheats ...
Mark, that site is an absolute joke....
LOL, even though my team, the Chiefs, have the lowest ''cheat points'', the site is, shall we say laughable.
Of course the site is laughable , but based in truth of record , but then again the whole deflate case as well as the posturing of late is laughable since this all has been going on since the league was formed ( really an NFL founder from the Bears cutting holes in visiting teams towels and putting itching powder in the soap, reminiscent of liquid heat in the jocks in the movie Nerds) was that REALLY a scandal? It was laughable that it even ended up in federal court .