╌>

Justice Ginsburg Sings Another Verse of Kill the Poor

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  3 comments

Justice Ginsburg Sings Another Verse of Kill the Poor

R uth Bader Ginsburg, having decided for some inexplicable reason to do a long interview with a fashion magazine (maybe it is her celebrated collection of lace collars), reaffirmed the most important things we know about her: her partisanship, her elevation of politics over law, and her desire to see as many poor children killed as is feasibly possible.

Speaking about such modest restrictions on abortion as have been enacted over the past several years, Justice Ginsburg lamented that the impact of all these restrictions is on poor women. Then she added: It makes no sense as a national policy to promote birth only among poor people.

This is not her first time weighing in on the question of what by any intellectually honest standard must be described as eugenics. In an earlier interview, she described the Roe v. Wade decision as being intended to control population growth, particularly growth in populations that we dont want to have too many of. She was correct in her assessment of Roe ; the co-counsel in that case, Ron Weddington, would later advise President Bill Clinton: You can start immediately to eliminate the barely educated, unhealthy, and poor segment of our country, by making abortifacients cheap and universally available. Its what we all know is true, but we only whisper it.

In 1980, the punk band the Dead Kennedys released a song called Kill the Poor . In it, singer Jello Biafra considers the many benefits to be had from the policy he is singing about: the elimination of unsightly slums, the lowering of welfare taxes, reduction of overcrowding, reduction in crime, etc. The sun beams down on a brand new day, he declares, Jane Fonda on the screen today convinced the liberals its okay. To be sure, Mr. Biafra wasnt singing about abortion; his tongue-in-cheek proposal was for the relatively antiseptic measure of striking poor neighborhoods and housing projects with neutron bombs, eliminating the populations but preserving property values. A ghastly and satirical proposal, to be sure, but not really so different from the case that Justice Ginsburg and others of her ilk make for eliminating those populations that we dont want to have too many of.

We only whisper it.

The economist Steven Levitt, for example, has argued that abortion helped to bring down crime rates; that probably isnt true , but it has not stopped abortion enthusiasts from incorporating crime-reduction into their case for killing the poor. Abortion as a tool of population control remains very much in vogue, particularly with international organizations: To avoid a world with deteriorating social, economic, and political stability, with the concomitant loss of personal and national security, we must ensure that safe abortion is made available, writes the American population-control activist and academic Steven Mumford , who also advocates mass sterilizations.

There are two ways to account for humans beings: as assets, or as liabilities. For those who see the world the way Justice Ginsburg does which is also the way Barack Obama does, along with most of his party human beings are a liability. That is why they fundamentally misunderstand challenges such as employment; if you see people as a liability, then you see labor in terms of creating jobs, i.e. neutralizing that liability with a check every two weeks. It does not matter whether that labor produces anything valuable; if the liability is being met with a sufficient paycheck, problem solved. It should go without saying that Barack Obama et al. do not see themselves as liabilities. They see themselves as assets, which is how left-wing activists and Democratic functionaries justify their own enormous paychecks .

And they dont see their own children as liabilities, either just your kids, loser.

The alternative is to view human beings as having inherent value. In economics, that means thinking of every worker as having something potentially valuable to contribute. In broader terms, that means thinking of every person as a full member of the human family, no matter if they are healthy or sick, running marathons or profoundly disabled, Bill Gates rich or Bangladesh poor.

Kill the Poor was a satire, not a political platform. And it sure as hell wasnt guidance for the Supreme Court, which would be much improved by the absence of Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/388757/we-only-whisper-it-kevin-d-williamson


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

First, Ginsburgs view that we dont want more poor babies is perfectly consistent with a century-old progressive tradition as I explain at some length here . It is simply a restatement of Margaret Sangers religion of birth control which would ease the financial load of caring for with public funds . . . children destined to become a burden to themselves, to their family, and ultimately to the nation.

Second,the reaction, or I should say non-reaction, to her comments offers an interesting contrast with the deliberately dishonest attacks on Bill Bennett who, in 2005, offered a hypothetical in which crime might be reduced if blacks had more abortions. Relying on the Freakonomics thesis, he said, That would be an impossible, ridiculous, and morally reprehensible thing to do, but your crime rate would go down. Bennetts critics willfully ignored the part about such a policy being impossible, ridiculous and morally reprehensible and immediately proclaimed, in the words of Ed Schultz that Bennett was out there advocating the murder of all black babies.

To this day, the hypocrisy and stupidity of the reaction is difficult to capture in its staggering totality. As I noted at the time , Bennetts pro-choice critics suddenly accepted that fetuses are in fact babies and that killing them is murder. In an instant they defenestrated the entire moral apparatus for abortion fetuses are just uterine contents and eliminating them is merely of a piece with womens health just so they could score a few cheap partisan points against Bennett and preen about their racial enlightenment.

Some of Bennetts critics might split hairs by arguing that Bennett was talking about crime and Bader is talking about poverty. But this ground is awfully weak when you factor in the fact that virtually all liberal explanations about the causes of crime hinge on some variations of root causes arguments.

It also misses the core philosophical and moral point of Bennetts remarks, which werent about race at all. They were about the moral illegitimacy of justifying abortion as a tool of social engineering (his comments were in response to a caller who said that abortion was having a deleterious effect on social security).

Now here is Ruth Bader Ginsburgtalking about controlling the population of certain undesirables. It is doubtful that she is unaware that the poor are disproportionately African-American. So when she says we dont want to promote growth of poor people, it doesnt take any of the bad faith Bennetts detractors deployed to conclude, Oh, we know who she means.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

It's a lot easier to love minorities when there aren't so many of them .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Solomon couldn't have said it better. Great artilce.

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot
shona1


55 visitors