Question of the week - Why did the federal government institute a reservation system for Indian tribes/nations?
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Question of the week - Why did the federal government institute a reservation system for Indian tribes/nations?
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: 1stwarrior • 12 years ago • 3 comments
It was set up to keep Indians away from the white folks. It certainly had nothing to do with giving them their sovereignty, as every time a white man exercised his right to go wherever he wanted and poached on Indian land and found gold, silver, and later.. oil, the Indians were overnight rounded up and herded like cattle to another god-forsaken wasteland and dumped. This was also done when hordes of settlers needed to squat on land the Indians had cleared and cultivated thinking it was to be their home. Head 'em up... move 'em out!
Oh... excuse me! They were not "herded like cattle," because drovers and trail bosses took all possible care with cattle to see they made it to market in top condition to bring the best price. Indians were merely herded with no care at all of the dead who were left along the way.
Good point BF, but backwards. The "reserves" were set aside as Indian territory and with it also came all of their inherent rights - i.e. the right to govern their people, hunting, fishing, agriculture, etc. The stipulations in the treaties were for reserving "all of the inherent rights" and lands of the Indians for them to keep on governing themselves. The Feds got the rest but they never took away any of those rights until late in the 1800 and then it was the cultural stuff like the Ghost Dance, methods of elections, tribal laws (totally Indian controlled), etc.. Unfortunately, in a lot of cases, the reservations were further reduced due to white guy pressure for more land, but the lands were still "reserved" for the tribes and placed in trust by the Feds for protection (yeah - right).
The total land grab thing started in 1802 under Jefferson when he signed the Georgia Compact which stated that the Feds would "take" all the land in Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi, pay the Indians, "offer" them their own territory across the river, and allow the states to expand their territories. That "almost" got whipped out by the Georgia Nation v. Georgia where Chief Justice Marshall told Georgia that the Cherokee lands were, indeed, Cherokee lands and Georgia could do nothing about it. Wellllll . . . . . . . . .
Was the reservation system set up to segregate the tribes or to give them their autonomy/sovereignty?
It was set up to keep Indians away from the white folks. It certainly had nothing to do with giving them their sovereignty, as every time a white man exercised his right to go wherever he wanted and poached on Indian land and found gold, silver, and later.. oil, the Indians were overnight rounded up and herded like cattle to another god-forsaken wasteland and dumped. This was also done when hordes of settlers needed to squat on land the Indians had cleared and cultivated thinking it was to be their home. Head 'em up... move 'em out!
Oh... excuse me! They were not "herded like cattle," because drovers and trail bosses took all possible care with cattle to see they made it to market in top condition to bring the best price. Indians were merely herded with no care at all of the dead who were left along the way.
Good point BF, but backwards. The "reserves" were set aside as Indian territory and with it also came all of their inherent rights - i.e. the right to govern their people, hunting, fishing, agriculture, etc. The stipulations in the treaties were for reserving "all of the inherent rights" and lands of the Indians for them to keep on governing themselves. The Feds got the rest but they never took away any of those rights until late in the 1800 and then it was the cultural stuff like the Ghost Dance, methods of elections, tribal laws (totally Indian controlled), etc.. Unfortunately, in a lot of cases, the reservations were further reduced due to white guy pressure for more land, but the lands were still "reserved" for the tribes and placed in trust by the Feds for protection (yeah - right).
The total land grab thing started in 1802 under Jefferson when he signed the Georgia Compact which stated that the Feds would "take" all the land in Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi, pay the Indians, "offer" them their own territory across the river, and allow the states to expand their territories. That "almost" got whipped out by the Georgia Nation v. Georgia where Chief Justice Marshall told Georgia that the Cherokee lands were, indeed, Cherokee lands and Georgia could do nothing about it. Wellllll . . . . . . . . .