The measure makes providing support to or fighting for a terrorist group targeting the U.S. an affirmative renunciation of American citizenship, Mr. Cruz said on the Senate floor Thursday. He pointed out that former Sens. Joe Lieberman, Connecticut independent, and Scott Brown, Massachusetts Republican, introduced a similar measure several years ago related to al Qaeda.
If we do not pass this legislation, the consequence will be that Americans fighting alongside ISIS today may come home tomorrow with a U.S. passport, may come home to New York or Los Angeles or Houston or Chicago and innocent Americans may be murdered if the Senate does not act today, Mr. Cruz said.
Sen. Mazie Hirono, Hawaii Democrat, objected, saying the bill has not been brought before the Senate Judiciary Committee and it affects fundamental constitutional rights, which should be given the full deliberation of the Senate .
Legislation that grants the government the ability to strip citizenship from Americans is a serious matter, raising significant constitutional issues, she said.
Mr. Cruz said in response that there is an urgency and an exigency to the situation.
It is unfortunate that Democratic senators chose to object to this to prevent this common-sense change in law, and I would note when it comes to the constitutional concerns, I dont know if anyone in this Senate has been more vigorous or more consistent in terms of defending the constitutional rights of Americans that I have endeavored to be during my short tenure here, he said. I will yield to no one in passion for defending constitutional liberties it is current law right now that if you go and join a foreign nation and take up arms against America, that act has long been recognized as constituting a constructive renunciation of United States citizenship.
He said existing law provides due process for individuals and the measure is a recognition of changing circumstances in the world.
The question is very simple: would any reasonable person want an American who is right now in Iraq, who is right now training with ISIS, who is right now taking up arms, who is right now participating in crucifying Christians, who is right now beheading children, who [has] right now participated in beheading two American journalists, who is right now standing arm-in-arm with virulent terrorists who have pledged to take jihad to America would anyone of good conscience in either party want that person to be able to come back and land in LaGuardia airport with a U.S. passport and walk unmolested onto our streets? he said.
The obvious answer is no, and it saddens me that we could not see Republicans and Democrats come together, he continued. It saddens me that in an election year the Democratic senators up for election chose to block this common-sense legislation, rather than to work together to protect the American citizens. I hope in time we see less election-year politics and more service to the men and women who all of us are obliged to protect.
So now we have this and the edit the Fed bill that will not get a vote. Guess the Republicans don't have a monopoly on obstructionism, they seem to be getting plenty of help from the Democrats.
Well since we are now "at war" with ISIS (or ISIL), these "citizens" would be committing treason, aiding and abetting he enemy in a time of war.
Seems like the death penalty would be appropriate
That's what I was thinking... If they're not citizens, you can't accuse them of treason, but if they are, you can.
Nidal Hasan committed treason even if this panty-waist administration calls it workplace violence to prevent the families of the murdered soldiers from receiving benefits. Let's see if he is given the death penalty as required by military law.
Any bets on him being given "life" so that he can bombard the media with demands for his "religious rights" during his remaining lifetime as our honored Islamic guest, thereby constantly shoving his name and face into the consciousness of America and bereaved family and friends of the victims of the Ft. Hood massacre?
Well many problems would be nipped in the bud, if we kill them while they are still over in Iraq and Syria. Then again, that would be an infringement of an American citizen's rights.
The Left and Right better get onboard with who the real enemies of our country truly are, and stop swiping at each other. Obama can kill as many islamists as he wants, and that would be just fine by me.
So now the guys that want strict constructionism when it suits them politically, want to get around the the Constitution when it
suits the politically.
Selective indignation is the Tea Party/Right Wing way
A.K.A "HYPOCRISY."
So which is it the Constitution when you can use it to castigate Obama and, not the Constitution when you can
castigate Obama?
When he or any President acts questionably, by all means express justified indignation; but you're a selective hypocrite.
Already explained it.
When it suits your politics, you insist on strict constructionist interpretation of the Constitution (like in your CU articles); and other times, like now, you advocate against strict constructivist interpretation.
I cited the Constitutional aspects in a previous comment.
If American Citizens choose to become part of ISIS and thus put themselves out-of-reach from prosecution for treason, if they die by drone strike because they've embedded themselves with the enemy, that's their doing and not Obama selectively choosing to kill without them without a trial.
If the bastards are embedded with the enemy in a foreign country... if they are found here in America and proudly announce they are members of a terrorist group that has been named an enemy of our country... strip them of their citizenship.
If they are illegal aliens, or immigrants waiting for citizenship, or immigrants visiting here... load them on a plane and send them back to where they came from. If their home country refuses to accept them, load them on a military plane, strap on a parachute, throw them out over their home country and forget about it.
Put them on a boat with a life vest, point them toward the shore of their home country, and wave goodbye, and forget about it.
There are several options that don't include all the angst of trials, medical care, food and housing.
No, I did not. I posted this earlier.
As for
Third time
You and a number of others want strict interpretation/no interpretation of the Constitution on issues like the CU decision, the 2nd Amendment, and (I'm guessing) the 10th Amendment.
I have clearly qualified why the following scenario is different from the one you reference.
"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in
adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of
Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on
Confession in open Court.
The Congress shall have power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no Attainder of
Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the
Person attained."
Means nothing to you? Perversion?
the Constitution can be perverted at will to adapt to their ideology and to pander to their base.
The 14th Amendment was a good example.
Care to explain?? How do the Repubs do more than the Dems and ignore what the Constitution lays out. Does Obama ring a bell to you? How 'bout immigration, taxes, Obamacare and the many other "changes" Congress (includes Dems and Repubs) have made??
So, stripping that same person of their citizenship is bad why?
That's what the article and the Bill are about.
Marine24,
Passport revocation-our wonderful neighbors to the north have started doing thta exact same thing. Much smarter than we are at times.
Kind of hard to explain why one wouldn't push this through isn't it?
When you commit treason, such as aiding and abetting the enemy (of which we have way too damn many), as the Contitution states - you can be shot, put in prison and/or, on rare occasions, lose your citizenship. That is standard legal procedure.
You can lose your citizenship for treason. In all U.S. history fewer than 40 people have been charged with treason. You can lose US citizenship for serving in a foreign army, but only if theyre engaged in hostilities against the USA. This is unusual, too. You could lose your citizenship if you apply for citizenship to another country, on purpose and by your own free will, and with the idea that you're giving up your US citizenship. If you really want to, you can give up your US citizenship. To do this you have to go to another country, go to the US embassy there, sign an oath of renunciation, and not come back to the USA. The people in the embassy will try to make you think twice, but if you go through with it you can't undo it.
So, you're good with Citizens United then-because it has been ruled legal by SCOTUS. Good to know you are good with all those decisions.
And if passed, it will go through the same legal system and it will be decided if the law is in accordance withthe constitution.
?????
Glad you agree with me.
I thought it was ISIS - and they have very opening declared war on us - 'member??? "We'll kill you at home in your sleep."
But, Cruz is from Canada.
Don't know 'bout you, but where I work, you can't be "convicted" of anything 'til you've been charged. You can't receive penalties for what you're charged with until you've been convicted, usually, by a jury of your peers. Don't know where you would get the idea that the conviction part would be skipped.
The Bushe's and Obama have made the ME terrorist "groups" countries in their "War Against Terror".The legal definition of treason is - "Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason and shall suffer death, or shall be imprisoned not less than five years and fined under this title but not less than $10,000; and shall be incapable of holding any office under the United States. "
Please note - "ADHERES TO THEIR ENEMIES" - don't see state or country mentioned, do you?
Passport revocation is a good start!
Actually, no. I didn't think you needed any remedial courses in beginning to end during a discussion. If you do, from now on, I'll put on my 5th grade writing procedures and nuance you to death.
The bar is a little high? Nope, not for me. Needs to be higher and we also need to start shooting traitors by firing squad as we used to. The dude in Ft. Hood would be a good start. Leslie Chelsey Manning would be a great second one. Lemme think of some more for you.