╌>

Will “Made in America” help or hurt America?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  1 comments

Will “Made in America” help or hurt America?

Tony pressed the remote and watched as the pulley on the Liftmaster garage door opener dutifully pulled the garage door back towards the ground. He had just returned from Lowes where he had purchased a brand new Frigidaire refrigerator. On the way back home he filled up the tank of his Toyota Camry at the 7-Eleven on the corner and picked up a burger at Burger King. He reached for his IBM Think pad and picked up the remote to his Sony Television. As the screen came to life he was greeted by the words Made in America. He had switched on to a feature story on the Made in America. campaign.

ABC news has launched a series called Made in America which promulgates the idea that if Americans spent 1% more on American-made items, it would instantly create 200,000 jobs. (ABC News' 'Made In America')

This follows the enactment of the Buy American Statute as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Subpart 25.6) which states:

None of the funds appropriated or otherwise made available by the Recovery Act may be used for a project for the construction, alteration, maintenance, or repair of a public building or public work unless the public building or public work is located in the United States and

(1) All of the iron, steel, and manufactured goods used as construction material in the project are produced or manufactured in the United States.

(i) All manufactured construction material must be manufactured in the United States.

(ii) Iron or steel components.

The idea that buying American will save or create more American jobs has led to calls and campaigns to shun foreign products. But what exactly are these campaigns calling for? Are they asking US consumers to:

  • Purchase more products that were made in the US
  • Purchase more products that were made in the US by US companies
  • Purchase only products that were made in the US
  • Purchase only products made in the US by US companies.
  • Purchase more products that were made by US Companies
  • Purchase only products made by US companies.

Is the goal to protect American products, American companies or American jobs?

Products made in the US

Several foreign owned companies produce goods in the US. When Tony purchased gas at 7-Eleven, he was supporting a Japanese-owned franchise that was providing an American product and creating American jobs. Although Toyota is Japanese company it also manufactures cars in the US creating 365,000 jobs in the US up to 2012. (Wells). The annual America-Made Index by Cars.com listed the Toyota Camry in the number 1 spot from 2009 2012 with four other Japanese brands making the list (Toyota Sienna, Tundra and Avalon, Honda Odyssey). GM had three models in the list. Vehicles making the list must have 75% North American content. Other factors in the formula include where the vehicle is built and U.S. sales -- since a low-selling vehicle may be mostly made here but creates fewer U.S. jobs. Models built exclusively outside the US are excluded from this list (Wells). Cars.com indicated that many American-built cars use parts from overseas and that cars built from mainly American-made parts are not easily sold. (Wells)

Purchasing more from companies operating in the US could potentially lead to a boost in the economy but it can be argued that companies producing goods overseas and selling in the US could also boost the economy. American jobs are created by retailers purchasing cheaper imports and selling them in the US. American companies operating overseas also boost the American economy when profits are sent back to the US. ABC news cited statistics from the U.S.-China Business Council, reporting that the Chinese spent $104 billion in U.S. exports in the last year -- up 542 percent from 10 years ago. (Muir, Noll and Francis).

A report released by the National Retail Federation cited by Manufacturing.net, May 2014 points out that some apparel products has over 70% US content while some foreign-brand cars has more than 95% US contents. It also reported that the Apple iPod has $162 worth of American parts and $4 worth of Chinese content although it is Made in China. (Wells)

Protectionism

While governments around the world seek to boost their economy and employment levels, companies seek to improve their bottom line. They do this either by increasing revenue or reducing costs or both. When a country imposes trade protection as the US did with the Buy American Act it could end up hurting the economy.

The fact that trade protection hurts the economy of the country that imposes it is one of the oldest but still most startling insights economics has to offer. The idea dates back to the origin of economic science itself (Bhagwati).

For a market economy that exists in a world that has become a global village, shielding businesses from international competition will not necessarily lead to job creation or job protection. It could potentially expose U.S. businesses to retaliatory restrictions by trading partners, thus reducing available markets.

High tax rates

A major factor affecting US corporations is the higher corporate tax rates coupled with the fact that they are taxed on worldwide income at the higher rate making it difficult to compete with foreign companies that have lower tax rates. This has led to US companies using creative schemes such as Tax Inversions and buyouts effectively moving the ownership of the company overseas. Burger Kings move to Canada is only the latest in the list of companies that have sought to protect their bottom line by finding creative ways to reduce the tax impact. While not necessarily a tax-related move, General Electric Co. (GE) is discussing the sale of its home appliance business to the Swedish company, Electrolux. (Welch and Clough). Other US companies that have migrated include AbbVie and Medtronic while more than twenty other large companies are possibly heading for the exit. Pfizer also sought to exit by making a bid for AstraZeneca in the UK. (AB, 09/2014: 8).

A reduction in tax rates eases the pressure on the bottom line for companies and makes the country more attractive for business. Canada seems to be benefiting from the benefits of lowering taxes by having US companies crossing the border to save money.

Migrant population

Tony is one of the 40 Million foreign born individuals living in the US. (US Census, 2012). He like many others may have left the country of their birth but retain a taste for some of the products that they enjoyed while in their native land. Having some of these products available in the US makes it easier for them to adapt to their new home in the US. The sale of these foreign products also helps to create US jobs and sometimes cheaper alternatives for consumers.

So will the Buy American law and the companion Made in America campaign help or hurt American workers?

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/article/20140917135055-42663322-will-made-in-america-help-or-hurt-america?trk=nus-cha-roll-art-title

Devon McCarthy ,Chartered Accountant, MBA student and Enrolled Agent, Enrolled to practice before the IRS


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I came across this article on LinkedIn and thought it was quite informative and thought provoking.

What do you think?

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
shona1


72 visitors