╌>

Zero Tolerance for Violence Against Women and Children!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  4 comments

Zero Tolerance for Violence Against Women and Children!

Sounds reasonable to me and I am sure that many in the U.S. agree and that it is a position that transcends political affiliation, socio-economic positioning, race, gender, age and various other demographic divisions in the country.

Ray Rice, Ray MacDonald, Greg Hardy, Chris Brown, Charlie Sheen, Sean Penn Steven Seagall, Judge Mark Fuller, the list goes on and on. The famous people of sports, movies, music, television, politics, etc are center front page news in this and other situations.

Domestic abuse and child abuse are pervasive cancers in our society and zero tolerance is indeed the only acceptable standard.

Should Ray Rice, Greg Hardy, Ray MacDonald be banned for life from playing in the NFL?

Should employers in other private sector industries be able to fire and ban for life truck drivers, doctors, nurses, teachers, actors, singers, carpenters, accountants, politicians when they are convicted of domestic abuse?

Many will say to the first question and resounding no to the second.

What penalties should be imposed by employers when a person is arrested for and admits to domestic or child abuse and avoids punishment through pre-trial diversion programs? Should those abusers also be banned from their field of employment..for life.for a shorter period of time?

Should people who choose a profession that puts them in the public eye not be afforded the equal protection aspects of our laws and rules and be treated differently, more harshly than regular citizens?

Should an employer, the NFL in the Ray Rice case, have the absolute right to say who can and cannot work for them? How about the local store, factory or school? If an employer can exclude domestic abusers from employment, what other groups might be excluded those convicted of drug abuse offenses, DWI, sex crimes..?

Again, I support zero tolerance for domestic and child abusers and jail time for even first time offenders, but once a case is adjudicated (fairly or unfairly in each of our minds) and the court-assigned punishment served should employers be able to ban groups of people from certain career fields?

No answer here, just lots of questions.

For those that like lists

77 Celebrities Who Have Been Charged with Domestic Abuse

Men Whove Been Involved In Domestic Violence Situations

Federal Judge Accused Of Assaulting His Wife Strikes A Deal To Avoid Charges


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    12 years ago
I say yes to the fist and a qualified no to the second. No except in the case of NFL players, who a governed by a contract. In this contract they agree to the player's conduct policy. By agreeing to the policy they agree to the discipline. If they give the league a black eye, we'll an eye for an eye, if you will. So anyone who is under such a contractual agreement is subject to discipline.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

But a business/corporation could establish a personal conduct policy that excluded people who committed certain crimes or would enable them to fire an employee who committed such an indiscretion while employed.

Or perhaps a professional association like the AMA, ABA, the UAW or other professional organization would establish should a code of conduct for employees in those fields that would exclude certain felons from ever working in the field.

I agree that an employer (the team) should be able to fire an employee, but the NFL is not an employee but rather an association that is banning people from their area of expertise from attaining employment even if an employer (a team) wants to hire them. The players are not under contract to the NFL, but rather to individual teams.

Would you also support the NFL deciding that no one convicted of DUI, or a drug offense could never play in the league? Or any other crime?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    12 years ago
Employers have ways to check on their employees. Don't be naive to think they don't. Some employees convict themselves in social media.

However, now this 'what if' of yours has turned into infinite definitions of misconduct other than 'ZT to violence against women and children'. Sorry, I just don't think all bad behavior or illegal activity can be so broadly painted. Each is a separate issue. There is not a nuclear option in misconduct.

For the record, the NFL Players Association does have a binding agreement with the NFL and the teams. The NFL & the teams both have misconduct policies. Only with the team it's about misconduct that will void the promise to pay. So now, if you want to make too much money, be coddled and pampered, DON'T ABUSE YOUR CHILD OR SPOUSE!

Frankly, dealing with the NFL is like dealing with organized crime. Sometimes tax evasion works too.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I was in HR for many years and I am very familiar with background checks, criminal records checks and drug tests in the hiring process

My question is if the NFL can have a "policy" that players convicted of certain offenses can be banned for life, why cannot other industries and career fields do the same thing?

 
 

Who is online



evilone


68 visitors