US job market's lingering weak spot: Stagnant pay
The U.S. job market has steadily improved by pretty much every gauge except the one Americans probably care about most: Pay.
The unemployment rate has sunk to a nearly normal 6.1 percent. Employers have added a robust 2.5 million jobs the past 12 months. Layoffs have tumbled.
Yet most people are still waiting for a decent raise. Friday's August jobs report confirmed that average hourly pay has crept up only about 2 percent a year since the recession ended five years ago -- barely above inflation and far below the gains in most recoveries.
Just why pay has been so weak and when it might strengthen are key issues for the Federal Reserve in deciding when to raise interest rates.
The trend has mystified analysts. "This is the primary economic and policy puzzle facing policymakers right now: Why have wages remained so low in the face of an improving economy?" said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at McGladrey, a tax and accounting firm.
Some economists expect pay to pick up eventually as the job market keeps improving. They think wages have lagged because millions of people are still out of work -- many of whom aren't counted in the unemployment rate because they're no longer looking for a job. But others say they fear that pay has stagnated because of trends that will persist even after the economy has moved closer to full health. They note that companies have been making more use of temporary and part-time workers, usually at lower pay, to replace full-time permanent jobs. And newer technologies have enabled businesses to produce more with fewer employees.
A survey of Harvard Business School graduates released Monday lends weight to that notion. Nearly half the respondents said they'd rather invest in technology than in workers. Just over 40 percent expect wages and benefits to decline over the next three years.
Economists are flummoxed by the way the historical relationship between pay and unemployment has eroded since the recession ended. Based on historical trends, the steady drop in unemployment should have raised inflation-adjusted wages by 3.6 percent by June, according to researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. That's because employers have had to fill jobs from a smaller pool of unemployed people -- a trend that normally forces them to pay more.
Instead, overall inflation-adjusted wages have essentially flattened since 2009.
That said, workers in some industries have fared better. For those in a category that includes data processing and analytics, as well as broadcasting, film and publishing, hourly wages have surged 4.6 percent in the past year. And pay is up at least 3 percent for financial services workers and wholesalers.
By contrast, wages are up just 1.3 percent for employees in education and health care.
So why has overall wage growth been so weak? Economists point to several factors.
The biggest is that there are still too many people desperate for work than is typical for a healthy economy. That makes it easier for employers to fill jobs without raising pay. There are 227,000 fewer people with jobs than in November 2007, just before the recession began. Yet the working-age population is up 15.3 million since then. That's kept the number of unemployed elevated: 9.6 million Americans, up from 7.6 million when the recession began.
But it's not just unemployment that's holding down wages. The many part-timers who would prefer full-time work are also competing with those who are out of work. There are 7.2 million involuntary part-timers, up from just 4.6 million in late 2007. Half the economists surveyed by The Associated Press last month cited the high number of people without full-time jobs as the main reason wage growth has been weak. The Chicago Fed estimates that if all measures of unemployment, including involuntary part-timers, had returned to pre-recession levels, paychecks after inflation would now be rising up to 1 percentage point faster.
Given these trends, people who do have jobs have less leverage to demand higher pay. Sixteen percent of working Americans say their pay hasn't budged in the past year, up from 11 percent before the recession, according to research by Bank of America Merrill Lynch. In a healthier economy, more people would seek higher pay elsewhere and quit their jobs once they found it. But the number who quit their jobs tumbled during the recession and has only partly recovered.
In addition, fewer startup companies are being created, holding back hiring. In the final quarter of 2013, new companies created just 1.3 million jobs, down from an average of 1.75 million in the 1990s, according to government data. Fewer startups and fewer quits have reduced what's called job-market "churn." Economists liken churn to musical chairs: When people quit or new jobs are created by startups, more positions open for the unemployed or for workers seeking higher pay. But churn has declined by up to one-third since the early 1990s, according to research by economists Steven Davis and John Haltiwanger.
Typically, wages also rise in line with increased productivity. Productivity measures output per hour of work, and higher productivity enables companies to pay more without sparking inflation. Yet productivity has been unusually sluggish the past three years.
Some economists are surprised that the recession didn't weaken Americans' pay even more than it did. So deep was the recession that many analysts assumed companies would reduce not only jobs but also wages. The lack of pay cuts during the recession may help explain meager raises now. Having paid more than they typically would during the downturn, companies may now try to make up for lost ground by holding off on raises longer than usual.
Tags
Who is online
57 visitors

Raise the minimum wage, revoke trade agreements, impose tariffs on imported products, penalize companies that have operations of shore, raise taxes on corporations, .....
All things that this or that expert tells us will improve he job situation, the middle class and thus the economy in the U.S.
If the solutionreally was as easy as doing this and that, then this and tat would probably already have been done.
The situation can and will be reversed but it will take measured, rationale steps that will take time to work correctly (tax code reform, trade agreement realignment and enforcement, government partnerships with the private sector, education reform, minimum wage reform and many other thing)
American baby boomers are retiring and taking their knowledge base with them at a rate far higher than they can be replaced by domestic talent. I can't even imagine where this is going to leave the US economy.
FLYNAVY
Absolutely correct
Corporate America must invest in and drive education reform and partnerships with educational institutions and their work forces to realign the current work force wit industry needs and to prepare the future work force for the challenges of the new global economy
Corporate America is not going to invest in any such thing Robert as that is someone elses responsibility. Their job is to make money any way shape or form by selling product to those that can buy them. When the market shrinks, they will take their products somewhere else.
The corporate locusts will be done feeding on American shores within the next 20 years. Take a good look at Detroit and much of the rust belt. This will be the shape of things to come across the United States in most every form of manufacturing you can think of. I have watched it and been part of it for decades now.
FLYNAVY
That is certainly one way to look at the situation and history seems to support your position, the approach I described was more about what must happen to turn the situation around in the future and I think that we will see corporations realizing (perhaps it will not happen quickly) that they must invest in and insure the viability of their work force as consumers as well as a means of generating wealth for the corporations.
I grew up in and live in the rust belt and am seeing a slow rebirth and transformation of the businesses that employ people around here. It is too little and too slow, but it is a beginning.
We are seeing local business partnerships withand support for local vocational high schools, post-secondary technical school and colleges to focus graduates into fields that have current and future job openings. It is only a small effort in a couple of mostly rural counties in NE Ohio, but it is working and could work better. Perhaps that type of thinking can become more pervasive around the country.
I tend to see glasses as half full rather than half empty, but that's just me....
It is easy to focus on how we got the economy to the current situation, to blame others or ourselves and to insist that "they" must change (the owners or the workers) in order for change to occur.
But keeping our focus on the past, means that we are not looking ahead and will run into obstacles rather than working around those obstacles.
The days of 30, 40 or 50 years with a single company and then retirement are indeed a thing of the past and not likely to return, but some level of loyalty and responsibility must exist - employers must be loyal to and accountable for the success of workers (whether new hires or long term employees) and employees must reciprocate with loyalty and sincere effort to their employers whether they plan to stay an employee of the company a week, a year or for a career.
I 100% agree with you on what has to happen Robert and I for one would love to see it happen.
We have talked about the baby boomers and their retirement. I find it more than a bit ironic that the baby boomers (us) are the the ones that implemented "profit is all that matters". It was the "greatest generation" before us that believed in and practiced corporate civic responsibility. I'm still trying to figure out what motivates generation-X and the millennials as all they have ever known is what they have seen from the baby boomers. You can see why I'm not optimistic on the return of corporate responsibility any time soon.
FLYNAVY
We have indeed discussed this paradox before and I totally understand your position and your pessimism
It is important that pessimists remain vocal so that optimists do not become complacent waiting for things to happen
Greed is one of the strongest motivators of human behavior. You have to change the human animal before there is any hope of changing the corporate climate. We have to start caring about each other in a real way for that change to happen.
Just look at the hot topics here on NT and tell me there is a hope in hell of changing human nature anytime soon.
FLYNAVY1
Absolutely on point!
No one is disputing that history is unimportant or that we do not need to know, understand and accept the reasons that the economy is where it is at.
The point is that more time, effort and energy should be focused on changing things than on reiterating who is to blame and why things are so hopeless.
Admitting there is a problem is indeed the first step in solving the problem, but taking the view that nothing can change unless one side is eliminated or totally changes is neither realistic or likely to occur.
Pessimism in the viewing and investigation of proposed solutions is indeed very important and those that have contributed to the problems (corporations, politicians, etc) be viewed with skepticism until they prove that they are indeed turning over a new leaf.
In the evolution of the private sector that is needed to revive and bolster the working class and in fact the entire U.S. economy, does not mean that corporations should not be profitable or even that they will be less profitable than they are now.
If the capabilities of the work force are improved through corporate investment and focus and employee rewards for their efforts (pay and benefits) are increased, the corporation will see more consumers for better, more efficiently produced products.
Things could get better with no losers,and even though itwill take time and effortit is something that we must begin sooner rather than later for the betterment of all.