Don’t BS the American People About Iraq, Syria, and ISIL
The apparent beheading of American journalist James Foley by the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) is a stark reminder of the groups terrible brutality and the seriousness required to counter them. Unfortunately, much of the political discourse about the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) is counterproductive to good policy. Many of the basic facts are wrong and the argumentswhatever the merits of the policies they prescribetend to be political, overly personal, and hyperbolized. President Obamas policies in the Middle East have failed in numerous ways, but he is right that the paucity of our political debate is the greatest threat to our global standing.
One cannot credibly argue that the U.S. withdrawal from Iraq in 2010 contributed to the rise of ISIL without also acknowledging that the U.S. invasion in 2003 did the same. The former without the latter is a political argument, not a policy position. The same goes for airstrikes in Syria and arming the Syrian rebels. Its a reasonable hypothesis that supporting the Free Syrian Army earlier might have blunted ISIL, but thats a pretty hollow position if one also gives Syrian rebel factions a pass for tolerating and even embracing ISIL and Jabhat al-Nusrah through late 2012. As a long-time analyst of jihadism in the Middle East, it was clear to me in the summer of 2011 that the Islamic State of Iraq was well-positioned to capitalize on what was then a largely peaceful Syrian protest movement. And it was just as obvious that the groupwhose brutality, extremism, and grandiose political aspirations were well-documented long before the Syrian uprisingwould later turn on the Syrian rebels whose cause they claimed to champion. The same should have been obvious to the Syrian rebels, their external supporters, and pretty much anyone interested in the Syrian uprising and the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad.
Retired U.S. Army Col. Pete Mansoor is a serious man, but his assessment that the mission against ISIL will require 10,000-15,000 troops does not match up with the policy the President has chosen. Mansoors troop numbers are based on a policy to roll back ISIL, when the President has carefully limited his policy to stopping the current advance and aiding refugees. Reading most of the media coverage over the last few weeks, youd be forgiven for thinking President Obama was seeking to defeat ISIL in detail, but had chosen ineffectual means. But that is not his goal, even considering the coordinated U.S., Iraqi, and Kurdish effort to retake the Mosul Dam from ISIL. It is fair to criticize the Presidents policy as too limited or vague (I think it is both), but it is not to roll ISIL back and should not be measured on that basis. That distinction makes a difference, because as Doug Ollivant and Ken Pollack have both pointed out, airpower is much more effective against an army massing for an offensive than on troops settling in to govern in urban areas.
The larger problem with Mansoors vision is that rolling back ISIL is an unstable and untenable policy at this time. The Islamic State is a threat to U.S. interests because of the safe haven it creates and the instability it fosters; the exact location of its borders is not the most important factor. And so a policy of pushing them into a smaller box does not solve the problem; it is a temporary fix, an open-ended commitment, an invitation for mission creep, or all of the above. If destroying ISIL becomes the near-term policy goalwhich seems the likely outcome of saying you are going to roll back the groupthen 10,000-15,000 troops vastly understates the true commitment, which will actually require years, direct military action on both sides of the Iraq/Syria border, tens (if not hundreds) of billions of dollars, and many more than 15,000 troops. ISIL is an inherently resilient organizationlook how far they have come since getting rolled back during the Surge in 2007 when 150,000 American troops were occupying the country.

(From the article):
Be in it to win, not just to make a show of concern, or because it is politically expedient.
We have not fought to win a war since WWII. I must add, that many of the wars we engaged in, were for lack of a better word, bullshit. (Vietnam anyone).
If it is determined that the US should enter a war, and not determined by lobbyist, and those standing to make millions, then we should enter to win. PERIOD.
Very true. Putting them in a box will only enrage the tiger more.
Absolutely correct Kavika!!!!!!!!!
Well saidKavika.I don't know if we have the political will to go, a large nod from the public sphere is soimportant to get it right. However, to acknowledge all the truth about such a mission would require understanding what that truth is. It will be nasty, long, and we might end up in Syria too. This will challenge us, as it should. You put Iran just around the corner, Russia invading The Ukraine, parts of Africa boiling on the other side of the Mediterranean...
One huge problem that I see, is that the American people have been lied to so many times by both sides of the aisle, that they really don't trust/believe anything that politicians/government say any longer.
Too many sons, daughters, fathers, mothers, friends have been lost to these useless wars. War's that we started with no frickin idea of what wasreally involved.
How many times is the American Public going to salute, and send their sons and daughters off to die for some BS from the politicians?
...
Exactly. Who's to trust in DC? There has got to be some sorta encompassing strategy, and it needs to be clear and precise. Right now it's not only a matter of trusting politicians not to lie, but to make good choices based on what's best for the country. We need a leader. One that will not equivocate, but will instead instill trust.
I pretty much agree w/ all the author's points, but I'm skeptical if the US (or the rest of the West) can currently be "in it to win". 'Winning', IMO, means a decisive victory over an identified enemy, with elimination of the enemy's threat-capability-- as the Allies won WWII, destroying the Third Reich & Japanese Empire's ability to carry on (as Kavika noted above).
As we've learned (or should have learned) in about every conflict since then, 'winning' in some scenarios literally isn't an achievable goal. The Korean 'war' demonstrated that there isn't a 'win' situation when a significant portion of the population views the conflict as a civil war... a lesson we didn't learn, so we repeated the same scenario in VietNam. An additional complication involves 'guerilla' fighters, non-uniformed combatants who can't be separated out of the population we think we're fighting 'for'...
The US (and others) have been dicking around in the Middle East since at least 1990, and we've essentially achieved fuck-nothing in 24 years and uncountable billions of dollars (and lives). Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, you name 'em, nothing has been 'won', consolidated, 'stabilized' or improved. There are so many mutually antagonistic factions that nobody can be seriously counted on as an 'ally', and once again, once the uniforms are off, we can't tell our 'friends' from the 'enemy' (assuming there's a difference). ISIS in NOT an identifiable 'state' to begin with, so knocking out the infrastructure of territory they occupy isn't going to 'win' anything... only make more enemies. It appears that the Kurds are the closest to being folks we could 'trust' (to be on 'our' side), but then again, they have an agenda that isn't necessarily aligned with the goals of the US--- (assuming we even know what our goals are).
There's a reason nobody (US, UN or any other Western power) is picking 'sides' in the ME--- there are too many 'sides' in mutual conflict, and the odds are extremely good that none of the combatants are remotely reliable, let alone 'friends'. IF and as ISIS does become an identifiable 'state' with command center(s), military installation targets & vulnerable infrastructure, 'winning' (by total destruction, with concommitant civilian casualties) will become feasible. Until then, getting seriously embroiled in the ME will simply be the the desert version of VietNam--- 10 years of battles, more hundreds of billions of dollars, thousands of dead American soldiers, without consolidating & securing a patch of ground the size of Kansas City.
Let the assorted Muslim fanaticsfight it out until there's a clear 'winner'--- then we'll know who to bribe or bomb...