Can There Be A Fair Inquiry for Michael Brown? - New York Times opinion
Justice is a process , and it wont necessarily result in the arrest of Darren Wilson, the officer who fired the fatal shots, as many of the demonstrators say they want. Witness accounts differ sharply on the events leading to the shooting, and its impossible to predict whether the grand jury that began hearing evidence on Wednesday will indict Mr. Wilson. But those in charge have an obligation to demonstrate fairness at every step, and that means there cannot be even a hint of bias in the process.
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that after a shooting in 2000, when two detectives shot two unarmed black men in the town next to Ferguson, Mr. McCulloch failed to bring any independent evidence to the grand jury. He claimed that every witness testified that the detectives were defending themselves, but secret grand jury tapes showed that several witnesses did not do so.
Grand jury proceedings are secret. McCulloch, in telling the public what the grand jury had found, repeatedly insisted that every witness had testified that the two detectives fired to defend themselves after the suspect tried to run them over with his car.
The Post-Dispatch reviewed the previously secret grand jury tapes and found that McCullochs public statements were untrue.
Only three of the 13 detectives who testified said the suspects car had moved forward, in the direction of the two officers who shot him and his passenger. Two of those were the shooters themselves . The third was a detective who McCulloch later said he considered charging with perjury because his account was so at odds with the facts.
Contrary to McCullochs public statements, the grand jury tapes showed that four other detectives testified that they never saw the suspects car travel toward the officers.
McCulloch never brought independent evidence before the grand jury to sort out who was right.
Nor did he request the testimony of a nationally noted collision expert who investigated the case for the Justice Department. He determined that the suspects car had always been in reverse added proof that it did not move toward the detectives .
