St. Louis cops release incriminating video of fatal police shooting, think they look good
I have to applaud the police of St Louis. They are pretty powerful. Somehow, they managed to take a video which captures a fatal, unjustified and unnecessary police shooting, and turn it into a video which, they claim, is exculpatory and proves that they were in the right.
In order to understand how they were able to transform the footage to suit their needs, lets review what everyone agrees happened.
On Tuesday, in St Louis, fewer than four miles away from where the unarmed teenager Michael Brown was killed by police, aconvenience store owner called 911 to report that a man later identified as Kajieme Powell had stolen pastries energy drinks . Another woman called the police and said that Powell had a knife in his pocket and was behaving erratically. Two white officers arrived in an SUV. 23 seconds later, Powell, who was black, was dead on the ground, having been shot by the two officers.
On Wednesday, The St. Louis Police Department released footage recorded on a cell phone by a bystander. According to a police union representative, the footage released was exculpatory . In other words, the police decided to release the footage, along with the 911 calls, to show they had nothing to hide.
But lets compare the footage of what happened and what the police claimed happened.

Unbelievable.
Personally, I wouldn't try to disarm a man with a knife and I'm going to assume that he has one if that's what was reported. I have practiced knife disarm techniques many many times and I usually get cut. Knife cuts are nasty and blades can be dirty. So I agree with the police on avoiding hand to hand combat. Having said that, the police have guns. They're not trying to drop a charging elephant. All they have to do is stop shooting when he either falls or stops advancing. Fire one shot at a time rather than a hail of bullets from two cops in an obvious attempt to kill him. These cops, to the shock of onlookers, also handcuffed the man after riddling him with bullets. I think the entire incident, from the time the police arrived, to the man's death took less than 30 seconds. So his life wasn't even worth a full minute of thought. How do they ever expect to gain any trust in the community if they treat people like rabid animals?
The fact that death is possible should dissuade a person wielding a knife from advancing on someone with a gun. The length of the baton is not determinative because fighting ranges change during combat. Specifically, a person with a knife may not be stupid enough to stay at the end of a baton where the knife is useless. He will try and move inside your swing. If he gets inside your swing, and he may be willing to take a hit to do it, then you get stabbed. It can happen very quickly. Two officers are better than one but the risk remains.
I'm not sure whether you think the goal is to disarm an assailant or club him into submission. I've trained with police officers and, in my opinion, they do not have anywhere near the skill to disarm a knife fighter with a baton. And as I explained, even clubbing someone into submission cannot be done safely.
I would use a baton only against an unarmed assailant. If he has a knife, I'll assume he knows how to use it and I'll pull my gun. I would say freeze and give him the chance to stop. If he continues forward, I'll only allow him to get within no less than two body lengths from me (depending on his age, size and physical condition) to minimize lunging. Any closer and I'll shoot. When he stops advancing, I stop shooting. I won't back up because I could trip. I'd like to avoid killing him if I can but, if it's him or me, then I pick him. I'm a big opponent of police brutality but, on the other hand, police officers should not have to put their lives at risk unnecessarily.