Maybe The Robots Will Steal All Our Jobs And Maybe The Robots Won't Steal All Our Jobs
Theres a new report out from Pew and Elon University looking at the question of whether the robots and AIs are going to come and steal all our jobs in the near future. Roughly half of the respondents to the canvassing (its not a balanced sample and thus not a survey) say that while robots are going to be important in the economy by 2025 the new technologies will, as new technologies in the past have done, create more jobs than disappear. And the other half seem to think the opposite, that there will be fewer things around for humans to do once the robots take over. The truth is that while the transition might not be either easy or pretty the actual end result that we all desire is that the robots do take all our jobs. For that would be the prelude to what Marx so desired, the arrival of true communism.
The report is here and as you can see respondents are fairly evenly divided :
Half of these experts (48%) envision a future in which robots and digital agents have displaced significant numbers of both blue and white-collar workerswith many expressing concern that this will lead to vast increases in income inequality, masses of people who are effectively unemployable, and breakdowns in the social order.
The other half of the experts who responded to this survey (52%) expect that technology will not displace more jobs than it creates by 2025. To be sure, this group anticipates that many jobs currently performed by humans will be substantially taken over by robots or digital agents by 2025. But they have faith that human ingenuity will create new jobs, industries, and ways to make a living, just as it has been doing since the dawn of the Industrial Revolution.
Theres a couple of different ways of approaching the larger question, of whether we actually want the robots to come and do all the work.
One is the standard economic assumption that human desires are infinite and yet resources to meet those desires are limited. Thus there will always be something for a human being to do as a job. So while we might not know what those new jobs are going to be as robots and AIs push us human beings out of the sort of jobs we currently do theres a never-ending universe of other ways for us to spend our time.
Or we might look to the end of the process: robots and AIs become so fabulous that they can do everything that humans can do and more. They also dont want feeding nor paying so theres just no point in a human having a job at all. Anything and everything can be better provided by those mechanical and digital contraptions. At this point some worry that humans will die off as well have no method of earning an income.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2014/08/08/new-pew-report-maybe-the-robots-will-steal-all-our-jobs-and-maybe-the-robots-wont-steal-all-our-jobs/

A very formal way of saying that we have bigger problems facing us and shouldn't worry about this too much
John
I think that is one of the things, the folks at Elon and Pew are telling us not to worry about for the moment
Appreciate your perspective but we do not really know what the future climate will be now do we, unless of course you have a working crystal ball
John
In a word "NO"
The author's point which seems to be escaping you is that no one can really say exactly how automation is going to play out in the coming years and that here is a lot of misplaced anxiety on an issue that no one can really do anything about at this point.
Your response to that point
seems very much like an "either or fallacy"
We can always count on someone to take the conversation to a lower level rather than discuss a real issue
Must have been your turn
I need a personal robot, to develop the address list and send out all my Wellhead Protection Notices... Let them go out in the hot sun and cold rain to interview 267 businesses... Fine by me!
In other words, they can have my job-- and would probably be more efficient at it than I. However, they do lack that divine spark of creativity, that "hunch", and that "human touch", that helps you do your job...
No machine will ever have the "Dowser" touch that is for sure
Good points and thanks for the perspective
Some important points to look at :
1] People spend money . Robots don't . If the govt supports displaced workers will that create resentment in the remaining workers .
2] Some jobs are very hard to automate ... notably ones which require the "worker" to get wet . Also automating cops might prove to be an even worse disaster than current human police tactics .
Some counter points to consider
1. People who own robots and build robots and program robots and dream up things for robots to do make and spend money. A societal transformation could render the population with the opportunity to exist and thrive without the current manual labor phenomena we see today.
2. Some jobs are hard to automate now, but they make not be so hard to automate in the future and I do not think the author means that "every" function (job) in society will be automated.
As always thanks for the feedback and perspective
Southpark - They Took Our Job!
Thanks, Robert, that is very kind!