Article claims cure for Ebola is being unfairly denied to black Africans
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 28 commentsThe ongoing West African Ebola outbreak has, after five months, finally captured global attention, in large part because in late July, three Americans contracted the virus. One, Liberian-American Patrick Sawyer, died in Lagos after flying from Togo. The other two U.S. citizens are health workers at a clinic in Liberias capital, Monrovia, who have since been transported for advanced care at Emory Hospital in Atlanta.
Monday brought news that to many seemed miraculous: the Americans being treated at Emory seemed to have been revived and possibly saved from Ebola thanks to an experimental serum, ZMapp, that was secretly transported to their bedsides in Monrovia. Dr. Kent Brantly, who had sensed that he was in the end stages of Ebola and about to die when he ingested the serum, was so much improved that he was able to walk from his ambulance into Emory with only minimal assistance. cs symptoms also improved, although it took two doses of ZMapp for her to experience improvement, whereas Brantly only required one.
The news of a possible cure for Ebola is heartening, but it left many observers with mixed reactions. Why were Brantly and Writebol the only Ebola patients to receive ZMapp?
The optics of the situation were already bad enough: at great expense, two white Americans were whisked away to safety and a level of health care that simply cannot be provided on the fly in a Liberian hospital. The black Liberians they had been treating were left to see whether fate would save or kill them under the same substandard health care system they have always lived under.

I work in the regulated field. Therapy manufacturers are not allowed to give experimental drugs to populations without a hospital ethics committee review and subject informed consent. Further, they cannot publish their findings without rigid testing procedures. They cannot submit their findings to the FDA, EU, JP or any other regulatory body if the findings cannot be clinically verified by the rigid testing procedures.
So as sad as it is, the manufacturers do not want to try medications (and are legally barred from doing so in most first world countries and frowned at if side stepping in 3rd world ones by the WHO and UN) in the unregulated environment in Africa because they cannot use any benefits seen in order to get the actual medication available on the open market. It might cure people (or kill them) and they cannot use the data to support selling the drug (or even giving it away).
Additionally, drug manufactures cannot target populations based on their cultural understanding, income level, setting or coerce the government of such people into taking experimental drugs. If you ever want an understanding of this regulatory no-no, look up syphilis trials in slave populations or experimental drugs used on orphanages, or really any population of people at mercy of government/owners/organizations.
The rules carry a double edge, but were put into place to cause the least harm to people.
Hopefully the results from the patients treated will give the manufacturers a pass on some of the more rigid rules and allow them latitude in using it, but the short story is that the cure is untested, unproven and cannot be mass distributed (even for free) in good conscience (or good science for that matter).
The US brought the two American doctors back to the States to give them the drug so it would remain within the control of the lab that discovered it and the US military. They are not going to give this drug away for free.
Bringing the two Americans back home started a dangerous trend. Other countries with citizens in Africa who have Ebola are bringing them, thus raising the possibility of a global outbreak one step closer.
I understand what you are saying, Rescue, and on the face of it, agree with you.
The thing is, when this drug was first mentioned in the media it was stated that it had been under development by this lab in conjunction with the US military.
Not even G_d can get the US military to release anything they deem as priority product. Africa has asked for military help on a number of issues, specifically Boco Harem. There are a number of diseases specific to Africa and its jungle environment that our military have never before encountered that would render it helpless without a vaccine to counter them.
Now we have the African Summit wherein Coca Cola, General Electric, and other top tier companies want to invest billions, but will need heavy fire power to protect assets during the building phases and to protect employees after.
Leprosy is curable... but as it didn't affect enough people to make the vaccine profitable to make, no drug company bothered with it for decades . I think the last couple of decades one was developed and turned over to the WHO who treats any person with it for free. But for a long time, no one bothered with it because it wouldn't produce profits. Global travel and awareness of other countries changed things.
The same is true of Ebola. No one has bothered with trying to discover a cure in the past because it didn't affect first world countries. Now, those countries are interested in the wealth of Africa so they are looking into curing African diseases.
But right now, that lab is not going to give up this potential golden egg and they are going to hold on to it under the guise of "proving the science." Anyone dying of an incurable disease would willingly offer themselves up as guinea pig.
Anyway, as I said, the US military is partners with the lab, and you don't mess with the military. Not even Obama.
There is no golden egg here. This serum has limited uses and Ebola hasnt been on the radar for a couple decades. When a disease isnt prevalent, it isn't marketable to work on it in any capacity except for those government grants that people complain about paying.
No big business is going to fund billions of dollars in research and clinical testing for a product that applies to exactly 1100 people. They definitely arent going to do it for 1100 people that "might" be infected 5 years from now if an outbreak happens.
People that are dying are not permitted to give themselves up for untested research drugs that do not even have tox studies (that is animal study) completed. It is unethical and can result in a lot of fines and even being barred from selling any products produced by the same company. No company, research lab or any other laboratory will consider dosing people who do not have the ability to giveinformed consent.
Doctors can give informed consent because it can be legally substantiated that they understand theramificationsof being given a medical treatment that has little to no data supportingefficacy. I can guarantee that the amount of paperwork that doctor and nurse had to agree to is probably bigger than the stack of paper you signed for your mortgage.
But you cannot pull a random person off the street, ask them if they want to be dosed and then give them mystery medication. That is not how it works.
As for the military, they are somewhat at fault for all these structured rules now. They used to dose infantry men with everything in the kitchen sink just to test it out. That is an abuse of authority and does not substantiate informed consent.
How do you account for the fact that this lab "in conjunction with the military" already had this drug available for testing?
This outbreak of Ebola only became a crisis in March, and was only considered a crisis in one of the African countries before it jumped to another, then another. Why would our military be working in conjunction with the lab way before this outbreak of Ebola took its jet flight?
Kudos and a tip of the Swami's turban to both our contestants!! It's worth noting that the stuff had to be smuggled in to the dying doctor, and it's a cinch that whoever supplied and/or brought in the ZMapp could be in for prosecution if identified.
I agree w/ you all the way around, Miss C, but this seems like a case where the road to hell was paved with good intentions...My personal feelingis that the words "You have contracted Ebola"would move me to volunteer for just about any experiment short of Bruce Banner gamma-radiation therapy.
(PS: Who the hell decided to name it 'ZMapp'? Sound like it should be marketed by the Umbrella Corporation...)
Most people feel this way Swamii... it's always a huge topic in the Biomedical Regulatory Affairs Masters degree class on ethics every year. It typically covers half a quarter. The regulation it deals with is compassionate use CFR.21.V.E.306bbb.
Most people say if they were dying they would take anything in the universe for a chance at life. The problem is that drug testers can take advantage of these people (easily) just by naming a percentage at life, even if unsubstantiated.
What the FDA insists on is some kind of data that is verifiable that actually proves something of the claims prior to people just being injected/treated. You have to submit your IND which outlines what the therapy is made of, how it is made, how pure your product is, and your preliminary studies including some idea of efficacy, toxicity and a plan for how you will go about testing those levels in humans to the FDA for approval first.
This plan also has to be approved by the population ethics committee in the population it would be distributed. That ethics committee has to have (at minimum) a local doctor, a local religious head, and a local "every day human being" from the community where the drug will be distributed. All of those people have to think that the plan to distribute the drug is better than not distributing it.
As for the name... I think it has something to do with how the serum was found. A GenMAPP is a statistical tool that generates what-ifs using DNA microarray analytics. I'm guessing that the code for the serum was found in MAPP Z that someone per-mutating theoretically and then duplicated in the lab physically using a lot of interesting reagents.
It may be a vaccination, but both the Americans flown into Atlanta already had the disease and were either in or nearing end stages when they took the drug.
The people bringing the male doctor back were astonished that he was able to walk without assistance from the ambulance to the hospital, and the female was so bad they had to give her two doses of it... but now even she is recovering quite well.
Is there a reason you need to be so snippy here Rescue?
I repeat, it was given to both the Americans now in Atlanta AFTER they both had contracted the disease.
Both were well advanced in the disease so if it is only in vaccination form it would not have helped. The male doctor got one dose, the female doctor got two doses.
There's no need to stop making comments. It's how we learn.
The news reports on this disease are now coming in faster than I, for one, can keep up, whereas a couple of weeks ago there was barely a mention of it in media headlines.
It's now a fireball. And to be fair, the government says one thing and a couple of hours later, it's something else. First it seemed as though an American company in CA had the drug, now it's that Canadian company. My head is spinning.
Pardon me for being confused, R, but but the article as posted clearly states
which obviously isn't a 'vaccination' process.All I meant to suggest is that in a situation such as is currently being faced in Africa, an 'experimental procedure'certainly poses less risk thant standing around watching Ebola take it's course. I grant you that one or two cases like Dr.Brantly don't yield much data, but allowing a fair number of willinginfected patients to participate in trials might provide some valuable info one way or another. Worst case scenario: the volunteer dies anyway. 'Informed consent' in such a situation is almost a bad joke... the patient's already been informed he/she is already a death statistic.
Not true. There is a lot involved in drug/vaccine development that many people know nothing about. And there is something called "compassionate use". When a physician thinks a drug under development could be a life saving option for a patient, he/she contacts the pharmaceutical company with a rationale for the compassionate use.This is reviewed internally and submitted to the regulatory agencies as well as an IRB. In the end, the dug will be given under the compassionate use based on these assessments and approvals. Pharmaceuticals gain nothing with this as the data cannot be used for registration purposes. From the medical point of view I can assure you there is a gret sense of accomplishments knowing an unmet medical need was achieved
And the decision is based on facts gathered from the drug development and it is no unsubstantiated
There's a global initiative that makes AIDS drugs available to most countries in Africa, there are treatments for malaria but new drugs that were developed failed during the development process as did drugs for TB.
There's so much happening in the world of drug development that people aren't aware of
What people also forget is the extremely corrupt governments in African countries plus the militias especially in East Africa who steal medicines and vaccines intended for health clinics to sell them at extremely high prices
multi-resistant TB is a worldwide problem and drugs are being developed but unfortunately they are failing
3?
Make it 10. At least
There are 4 phases of development; Phase 1 through 4. Between development, enrollment and results there's at least 3 years for each. And for approval you need 2 pivotal studies (under Phase 3)
For vaccines, add to these surveillance studies which are also long