╌>

Egyptian & Israeli joint "blockade" of Gaza, & the rockets

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  12 years ago  •  20 comments

Egyptian & Israeli joint   "blockade" of Gaza, & the rockets

It's time to bust the Israeli blockade led to Hamas rockets myth

fallacy

NOUN(pluralfallacies)

A mistaken belief, especially one based on unsound arguments. (Oxford Dictionary)

Here is the widely believed fallacy: the Israeli blockade of Gaza led to the firing of Hamas rockets from Gaza.

And here is the little known truth: it was the firing of Hamas rockets from Gaza that led to the Israeli blockade of Gaza.

The fallacy distorts our understanding of why these escalations keep happening and what will make a durable peace possible. The fallacy frames the Israeli blockade of Gaza as motiveless and cruel at best, demonic at worst, while it presents the firing of Hamas rockets on Israeli civilians as acts of resistance. The fallacy makes us think that if only Israel "lifted the blockade" then peace would break out.

The fallacy spreads because of ignorance.

People do not know that when Israel left Gaza in 2005, the Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon who, like Rabin and Barak before him, and like Olmert after him, had crossed his Rubicon, finally accepting the need to divide the land said: We desire a life living side-by-side, in understanding and peace. Our goal [in disengaging] is that the Palestinians will be able to live in dignity and freedom in an independent state, and, together with us, enjoy good neighbourly relations.

They do not know that the reply from the Hamas bomb-making chief Mohammed Deif was instant. On the website of the Izz-al Din Qassam Brigades he declared: I thank Allah the exalted for his support in the Jihad of our people. I ask for your assistance to our jihad We shall not rest until our entire holy land is liberated To the Zionists we promise that tomorrow all of Palestine will become hell for you

They do not know that in spite of the Hamas threats, after leaving Gaza Israel signed an Agreement on Movement and Access with the Palestinian Authority which gave the Palestinians control over their own borders for the first time in history, allowed for imports and exports, and even approved construction of a seaport and discussions on an airport.

Unfortunately, Hamas does not respect deals made between the PA and Israel.

LINK


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

They do not know that Hamas launched a coup in 2007, took over the Strip, drove out its Palestinian political rival Fatah, threw their fellow Palestinians from rooftops, and declared as the new rulers of Gaza that they would now use the Strip as a base to destroy Israel.

They do not know that as a direct result, not only Israel but also Egypt put restrictions on the borders with Gaza, and Israel instituted a legal maritime blockade around Gaza to keep rockets and other weapons out of the hands of Hamas, while letting food and other humanitarian aid in.

They do not know that a UN inquiry (the 2011 Palmer Report) determined that Israels policy was legal given the threat it faced.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Important and timely information. Seems that facts aren't getting as much play as they deserve, when it comes to the this latest heating-up of the I/P situation.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

They know all this Krishna. The people here on NT are not fools and possess a fair amount of intelligence and the ability to research. What they lack is any concern for the truth or for the realm of reality.

Israel will not allow the blockade to be lifted. The Israelis cannot allow it. They cannot, for the sake of their own citizens, play a futile game of "one more chance" or "wait and see" knowing what the end result will be.

Neither will Israel open any borders that will allow freedom of movement for Palestinians into Israel for the same reason.

No sane person would expect them to.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Israel will not allow the blockade to be lifted. The Israeliscannotallow it. They cannot, for the sake of their own citizens, play a futile game of "one more chance" or "wait and see" knowing what the end result will be.

Neither will Israel open any borders that will allow freedom of movement for Palestinians into Israel for the same reason.

No sane person would expect them to.

All true.

And BTW, that also applies to Egypt as well.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Important and timely information. Seems that facts aren't getting as much play as they deserve, when it comes to the this latest heating-up of the I/P situation.

A lot of those who pretend to be "Pro-Palestinian" are in reality mere haters of Jews-- masquerading as "anti-Zionist".

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

A lot of those who pretend to be "Pro-Palestinian" are in reality mere haters of Jews-- masquerading as "anti-Zionist".

~related seed~

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

You're right. The pro-Palestinians on this site can't possibly be so ignorant and gullible to believe that the blockade is the fault of Israel,

And Egypt too, of course.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

We started out with Buzz haphazardly accusing people of being anti-semitic, when they criticize Israel, now it is spread to Krishna, apparently Larry, and even Perrie.

OMG! Its as bad as Ebola!

Heck-- its worse than Ebola!!

Oh-- the horror!

15.gif

All this McCarthy-ite tactic is going to do is make things worse on NT.

Naw-- there's no way they can get any worse than they already are. So-- why not sit back and enjoy the ride, lol.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I would call John Russell an anti-semite but I know better . He is actually too intellectually challenged to distinguish between that and an anti-Zionist ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

So tell me O wise one do you have any Jewish friends like this guy :

HAMAS SPOKESMAN: 'I Have Jewish Friends'

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Currently, Krishna is posting anti-semitic passages from the notorious racist David Duke and specifically implying that people on this site are in accord with Duke. It is outrageous.

And there's not a damn thing you can do about it. It must be frustrating to feel so powerless, eh?Grin.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Back to the topic of the article:

To expect Israel to modify or lift the blockade is juvenile thinking in the extreme given the number of rockets they were able get into Gaza with the full blockade on. Even the building materials for restoring homes that were destroyed need to be supervised since Hamas was able to construct so many elaborate tunnels with what was allowed before.

And who is to supervise? UN personnel has proved to be untrustworthy.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Israel helped create Hamas as a counterbalance to Arafat's PLO with the aim of creating confusion and delaying a Palestinian state. Hamas ended up being democratically elected in Gaza and displaced the PLO. Not exactly what Israel had in mind. Although Israel claims to have withdrawn from Gaza, it still has complete control over access to Gaza by land, sea, and air. That makes it an occupying power. It has been using its control to try and break the back of Hamas by collectively punishing the entire population of Gaza with a blockade and turning it into an open air prison. Gaza id cut off from the West Bank and the rest of the world. The blockade has been in place since at least 2007.

Although Hamas has made lifting the blockade a condition for an end to fighting, the blockade was not the trigger for the recent rocket attack. Hamas claims it was responding to a violent Israeli crackdown on the West Bank following the murder of three Israeli teens. When Israelis captured and burned a Palestinian teen alive, things got worse. Although there can be a temporary end to the fighting, there will never be peace because the root cause of the problem is Israeli colonialism.

The only way to end this is the same way that it ended in South Africa . . . an international boycott of Israel until they either let the Palestinians return or allow them to have a viable Palestinian state. Israel has fueled the boycott movement by destroying schools, hospitals, water plants, electric facilities, and displacing over 50,000 people who have no where to go. If the boycott grows, then maybe some good will come from all this destruction.

 
 

Who is online




evilone


64 visitors