How Obamacare Encourages Some Millennials To Become Uninsured
If being uninsured were no big deal, presumably Obamacare never would have been enacted. The whole premise of the law is that being uninsured is a bad thing, so its well worth wielding a few carrots and sticks to get people into coverage. Unfortunately, Obamacare has had to break more than a few eggs along the way. One of the presumably unintended consequences of this misguided law is the fashion in which it encourages some young adults to become uninsured. These are the very young people that the Exchanges need to sign up for coverage if they are to avoid a death spiral.
It may seem puzzling that a law that both hands out subsidies to encourage coverage and imposes penalties on those who do not could possibly increase the incentive to become or remain uninsured. But actuary Greg Fann, of the Wakely Consulting Group, has cranked the numbers and heres what they show:
![]()
Very low income 24-year-olds with incomes close to poverty clearly have a strong incentive to secure coverage because subsidies on the Exchanges drive the net cost of coverage (inclusive of out-of-pocket spending) well below the expected costs of being uninsured or of the expected costs of a non-qualified plan outside the Exchanges. Note that for those who remain uninsured and those who purchase non-qualified coverage, the expected costs also include whatever penalty payments would be imposed on an individual at that income level if they fail to obtain qualified health coverage. As well,in states that expand Medicaid, such young adults would end up on Medicaid rather than have private coverage, but even if we considered a 24-year-old at 140% of poverty (just above the Medicaid eligibility threshold), the story would be quite similar: deep subsidies for qualified Exchange coverage, in conjunction with penalties associated with not having qualified coverage tip the scales heavily in favor of a decision to purchase health insurance.
For young adults at 225% of poverty, its much more of a toss-up. The expected annual costs (inclusive of the individual mandate penalty) is about the same whether such an individual remains uninsured, buys a non-qualified plan or obtains subsidized coverage. Ive shown elsewhere that the willingness-to-pay of uninsured people to get rid of the uncertainty in their out-of-pocket medical expenses (given that if they are too high, such expenses typically will get written off by providers) is less than $200 a year (actually closer to $15 a month). So taking that into account would slightly tip the scales in favor of subsidized coverage. But possibly not much once one considered the time cost of procuring Exchange coverage (I have a self-employed friend who estimates he lost about 12 hours due to all the time he spent enrolling through HealthCare.gov inclusive of time to hunt down and upload various documents), and the narrow networks typical of plans available there.
The third category, 24-year-olds at 275% of poverty, reveals precisely how and why Obamacare creates a perverse incentive to become or remain uninsured. Even though subsidies are nominally available to individuals at incomes as high as 400% of poverty, part of the point of Mr. Fanns analysis is to point out that actually, many 24-year-olds at 275% of poverty will qualify for no subsidy whatsoever because the premium for the second lowest cost Silver plan is below the maximum dollar amount considered affordable. In contrast, for a 64-year-old at the identical income level, the subsidy would be $462 per monthin excess of $5,500 a year!
Why Obamacare Makes Things Worse for 30% of 24-Year-Olds
About 30% of 24-year-olds have incomes at 275% or more of poverty. The chart demonstrates starkly how Obamacare makes life worse for such individuals. Prior to Obamacare, such individuals would have been slightly better off buying a non-qualified health plan with an actuarial value of 50%. But Obamacare gets rid of such plans, substituting plans with a higher actuarial value and more comprehensive benefits. So now the privilege of buying health insurance costs 44% more than the expected cost of remaining uninsuredand thats AFTER taking into account the individual mandate penalty (a penalty that can be avoided entirely by individuals smart enough to ensure that the IRS never owes them a refund check).
This obviously does not guarantee that every such individual will instead opt to become or remain uninsured, but it certainly greatly increases the incentive to do so relative to the pre-Obamacare status quo.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2014/07/31/how-obamacare-encourages-some-24-year-olds-to-become-uninsured/

The author of the article is an advocate of 'repeal and replace" the PPACA, but I am not as I think the PPACA was a step (small or large depending on one's viewpoint) in a long overdue reform of healthcare services, devices, medication and long term care in the U.S.
There is more to be done and there are bugs that need to be exterminated but as I said a step in the right direction
The look at why some of the "young people" so desperately needed in the PPACA pool would decide to not jump in was interesting.
I have three sons - the youngest is a liberal's liberal, lives in San Francisco and is a selfproclaimed tree-hugging progressive, the middle son is a staunch conservative living in Florida and the oldest is a center right or left (depends on the issue) moderate living in rural Missouri, but all three of them have voiced concerns about how the PPACA affects their generation.
The author's summary of the cause and effect on millennials are points that I have heard from each of them and from other young people in the area.
CM
Thanks as always for your perspective
The point is specifically about young millennials opting out and the primary reasons and Medicaid expansion is not one of those reasons.
I posted another article about the learning curve of the PPACA and IMHO your comment would be more applicable there based on the Medicaid issue
Understanding that hyper partisanism is automatic when the PPACA is discussed, I meant the article to highlight the point that there are still things to be changed for the better.
Again thanks for the perspective
Actually RIO, I didn't notice the graph, yea, it is an important subject to me with so many needing those services...did you insert the graph after you first posted the article??
Nope
Ok, I moved to your other article...
Thanks for that and for stopping by and sharing your perspectives
Always appreciated