╌>

Obama Flip-Flops on Export-Import Bank

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  12 years ago  •  4 comments

Obama Flip-Flops on Export-Import Bank

August 1, 2014 3:51 pm

Once again, President Obama has flip-flopped on another issue.

In 2008, then Sen. Obama (D., Ill.) opposed the Export-Import Bank calling it little more than a fund for corporate welfare.

A complete position reversal was exposed during a Friday news conference when Obama strongly defended the institution:

But for some reason, right now the House Republicans have decided that we shouldnt do this, which means that when American companies go overseas and theyre trying to close a sale on selling Boeing planes, for example, or a GE turbine or some other American product that has all kinds of subcontractors behind it and is creating all kinds of jobs and all of sorts of small businesses depend on that sale, and that American companys going up against a German company or a Chinese company, and the Chinese and the American the German company are providing financing and the American company isnt, we may lose that sale, Obama argued.

Why when did that become something that Republicans opposed? Itd be like me having a car dealership for Ford, and the Toyota dealership offers somebody financing and I dont. We will lose business, and well lose jobs if we dont pass it, Obama continued.

Earlier this week, Rep. Paul Ryan (R., Wis.) argued the Ex-Im bank is representative of crony capitalism.

Reuters reports :

I do believe that the Ex-Im bank is representative of some of the crony capitalism we have in Washington. Big government and big business joining in a common cause to hand out preferences, Ryan said. I believe that we as Republicans should be pro-market, not necessarily pro-business.

A core of conservative Republicans have been pressing to kill off the bank, despite its reliance mainly on fees, interest and other non-tax revenues.

Ryan echoed their argument that the bank puts government in the way of free-market decisions and that the United States should not subsidize key industries such as aircraft production even if other countries do so.

~~Link~~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

Larry Summers' Really Quite Extraordinary Argument About The Export-ImportBank

I find myself very surprised indeed that an economist would make this argument about the Export-Import Bank and the discussion about whether to renew its mandate or not. To find a politician using this argument, or a businessman, that wouldnt surprise me, but to find an economist does. For its straight out wrong when we consider the true economics of subsidising exports :

DV: I want to turn to your op-ed in the Financial Times on July 6 on the U.S. global stance on economic issues. In particular, you expressed support for the Export-Import bank and said that eliminating it would be an act of unilateral disarmament. Can you explain that?

LS: Probably at this moment, the greatest threat to open market capitalism comes from state-driven mercantilism capitalism, often carried on by authoritarian governments. They do not seek a level playing field. They seek a playing field that is tilted in their favor through the use of a variety of kinds of subsidized credits. The best and most credible way of deterring and limiting that behavior is to have a capacity to respond so that it does not produce commercial advantages. Thats what the Ex-Im bank enables us to do.

There are some who believe that it is good for everybody globally to subsidize exports. Im not among them. Im in favor of negotiations that would move towards a system where you didnt have every country racing to compete with subsidies. But unilaterally renouncing our subsidies would be a source of great satisfaction in important parts of the world with which we compete and I do not think would be a productive way to bring about a more rules-based system.

Its entirely true that state directed mercantilism is a threat and also that that Ex-Im Bank is a part of such state directed mercantilism. But its not a threat because those playing by mercantilist rules will somehow beat us who play fair and by those free market rules. Its because mercantilism, in and of itself, just doesnt work.

At heart mercantilism is stating that the more we export, the more of other peoples money we get by doing so, the richer we are. But this is a perversion of reality: it is the imports part of trade that makes us richer. We get to enjoy all those lovely things made by Johnny Foreigner, those things that J. Foreigner can make cheaper or better than we can. Thats what makes us richer, the increase in our consumption possibilities. And of course our exports are what make J. Foreigner richer too: because our exports expand their consumption possibilities.

When you look at this way around, the correct way around, then the idea of subsidising exports becomes crazy: because we are subsidising J. Foreigner by subsidising our exports. If they want to be mercantilist then let them be so: they will after all be subsidising us. And we rather like it if other people send us their subsidies.

So Summers argument is simply extraordinary. We all agree that mercantilism doesnt work but the reason it doesnt work is because it makes those people doing the subsidising poorer. So, if Johnny Foreigner wants to make himself poorer by subsidising us we should thank him and tell him to carry on. But it would be absurd for us to respond by announcing that we were then going to make ourselves poorer by then subsidising our own exports.

Close the Ex-Im bank down, of course, simply because doing so will make us richer.

~Link~

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

How the Export-Import Bank Creates Problems for the Market

Many who defend the Export-Import Bank say that the bank must be addressing a market failure. But if that kind of failure existed, the bank would face a high rate of default and cost taxpayers even more. Instead of fixing any identifiable market failure, the bank is creating problems for the market.

To their credit, many editorial writers and reporters gravitate toward economic justifications for supporting Ex-Im. The standard reasoning is that Ex-Im provides trade finance that the private sector would not provide, expanding economic activity in the U.S. This argument has the virtue of specifying that it is only a (presumed) deficiency in private marketsa market failure, in econ jargonthat necessitates government involvement.

But proponents, including some economists , fail to show that a market failure exists. Why is the private sector not involved if there is money to be made in trade credit? Wall Street often takes flakbut never for an unwillingness to make money. And Ex-Im is not involved in the vast majority of export credits, including small-business exports.

The most likely market failure in exports is that the buyer might fail to pay as promised . The exporter might not have legal recourse if the buyer defaults, meaning a large loss for the exporter. (Economists call this form of market failure limited commitment . )

Suppose this failurewere a major feature of the export market. Enter Ex-Im with direct loans to buyers and guarantees of private loans. What would happen? Nothing in Ex-Ims business model prevents the defaults in this hypothetical scenario. And because Ex-Im is sopping up all the risk, it engenders riskier loans and even more defaults. In theory, that could be an improvement over the original scenario, but it would come at a high cost: a rate of default on Ex-Im loans far higher than what the private sector would accept.

But Ex-Im advertises that it has a default rate of 0.237% . Compare that to the 1.04% global corporate bond default rate estimated by Standard & Poors. Ex-Im is not financing transactions with a high default rate, so it does not appear to be providing financing that the private sector would ... because of default risk.

Meanwhile, Ex-Im creates four market failures: First, it introduces moral hazard by offering taxpayer-backed loan guarantees to favored corporations, encouraging risky lending. Second, the subsidies at the core of Ex-Ims business model benefit certain corporations at the expense of others to the detriment of overall efficiency. Third, Ex-Im is heavily tilted toward corporations that have oligopoly or monopoly power, entrenching incumbents and hurting competition. Fourth, Ex-Im encourages rent-seeking through lobbying and corruption .

In short, Ex-Im is failing to fix a phantom problem of limited commitment and at the same time creating moral hazard, subsidies and other issues. The good news is that we know how to fix these problems: End Ex-Im.

~Link~

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Seems that as soon as he became president he became a proponent for corporate welfare doesn't it?

 
 

Who is online




evilone


64 visitors