For two weeks, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and forces loyal to Bashar al-Assad have been battling for control of the Shaar gas field, one of Syria's largest, near the landmark city of Palmyra . On July 19, it was reported that the Sunni militant group had killed 270 regime fighters, taking control of the field in what was reportedly one of the conflict's deadliest 48-hour periods to date.
As ISIS steams further into Syria, analysts say a significant portion of its financial resources come from the crude oil it sells on the black market; accordingly, oil fields have become prime targets in the fight. So do gas fields like Shaar, where disruption of lines lead to electricity shortages and power cuts in regime-controlled areas as far as Damascus.
We asked Robin Mills, a Dubai-based energy analyst and author of "The Myth of the Oil Crisis," and Theodore Karasik, research director at Dubai-based think tank INEGMA, to weigh in on why oil fields have become so important to ISIS and how turning them into battlefields could disrupt energy production as well as the jihadi group's cash flow.
Syria Deeply: What has been happening over the past two weeks?
Robin Mills: The latest fighting is around Shaar, which is a gas field near Palmyra, further west. Reports are that the government has recaptured it, but ISIS says it has withdrawn or destroyed the field. It was a gas field, and there was nothing that ISIS could do with the gas itself unless it continues to sell to the government [throughout the conflict], they have reportedly had deals with the Assad government, to sell them oil and gas.
Theodore Karasik: It should have been obvious to the Syrian government that energy fields were going to become a source of contention because of their value. These fields were probably under guard, but not in a robust nature that could take overwhelming force from groups like ISIS. They are trying to establish a state, and these types of revenues are important for the state's formation because it makes up a significant chunk of their revenue. They can take over eastern Syria without oil revenue, but seizing these types of fields [like Shaar] are part of an ongoing plan to develop their own economic system.
Syria Deeply: How much does ISIS make from oil?
Karasik: Officials from the Iraqi oil industry have said that ISIS reaps $1 million per day in Iraq in oil profits and that if they get the Syrian fields in [areas where they're advancing], the total would be $100 million per month for both Iraq and Syria combined. They sell it for $30 a barrel because it's a black market. It's not pegged to international standards for oil prices , which are over $100 a barrel. The oil is bought through Turkey from Syria, and it's sold to black market traders who function throughout the Levant.
Mills: The $1 million a day figure is coming out of the Iraqi fields of which they have control. Iraq and Syria together could reach up to $3 million a day, so they're still getting more oil out of Syria [than Iraq]. Production is at 10 percent of pre-war levels they're old, mature fields that need a lot of special technological work, and they're not getting it, so production is falling very sharply. We've seen from reports that ISIS controls most of the oil fields in eastern Syria and Deir Ezzor, right up to the northeast, where some are under Kurdish control.
Syria Deeply: Why are old fields such an important target now for ISIS?
Mills: It's a very important priority because it generates income. ISIS's strategy seems to have evolved around generating income. ISIS raises money in several ways, but oil is certainly a part of that. For a long time, they avoided having much direct confrontation with the regime. They generally tended to turn their fire against other rebel groups. They had been selling to the regime, or basically anyone who'd pay for it. But recently it seems like they are taking a more aggressive approach, like with the attack on Shaar. Were they just attacking it to destroy it [to hit the regime], or to take it over and continue selling gas? It's not clear what their intention was.
If ISIS truly has destroyed fields there, it means the [regime's] gas supply will be cut off. It's already down to half of pre-war levels, and this will cause more power cuts and electricity cuts in Damascus. It means the regime will have to use more expensive fuel from Iran . It means more suffering for [civilians], and this perhaps will undercut support there for the regime. And it makes it very hard to have any prospect of the economy recovering.
Karasik: Even before all of this activity began, Syria's oil exports were not a large part of their economy. But having said that, what these nonstate actors can grab provides them with a source of income. We've seen that already with ISIS, which has an illegal oil export scheme that derives revenue. It seems now that [oil in Syria] is up for grabs and ISIS started this trend [of fighting for it]. It is likely that other groups such as Nusra will try to follow.
As the Islamic State is established, it's clear that ISIS wants to have all parts of their government and revenue sources well organized, and that energy exports are part of this scheme. The scheme includes the collection of taxes, but also other black market activities like trade in other illegal goods the group plunders from the land it captures. Given the call by [ISIS leader Abu Bakr] Baghdadi on the first day of Ramadan asking for consolidation of the state and the recruitment of individuals to help run that state you have to figure that the energy sector figures into his planning.
This article originally appeared on Syria Deeply .
ISIL has been claiming to be more "moral" than those they attack . But Sharia law declares the penalty for theft to be cutting off the hands of the thief . If this report is accurate al-Baghdadi should have that happen to him in a public ceremony .
OTOH Islam is the religion born of theft . Mohammed used to raid caravans for their spoils . He was never punished for that . Apparently this hypocrisy is built into the religion .
I noticed this connection between ISIL and the pursuit of oil properties back on July 14 :
I would have thought that this would be a subject that would attract more attention . Why is there no discussion from the PC crowd about respecting middle eastern "culture" ? I'm guessing that even they see the hypocrisy in "stealing for god" .
I don't think the average person realizes all the little details involved in this ISIL group and just how far they are going to be able to go with their little <sarc> war. Talk about nation building! This is a very important article we will see and feel the effects in the future.
Unless anyone has a counterpoint to make , I am led to the conclusion that ISIL's claim of "moral superiority" is just empty rhetoric .
Here is another potentially dangerous development :
Can ISIS Really Pose a Threat to Jordan?
I don't think so.
For starters, ISIS still has more ambitions in Iraq.
Also, several western countries (especially Britain & the U.S.) as well as in the Middle East (especially Israel, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the Kuwait & the UAE) would never permit it.
I had no idea that Jordan had that much support from the Arab world let alone from the west .
What do you think of the premise of the seeded article ? Is ISIL as energy seeking as reported ?
I'm surprised there is so little interest in this subject . Is it too early to talk about this topic ... not enough political "digestion" of the subject matter ?
If nothing else this does provide insight into the current price of oil and gasoline . Oil prices have continued to drop throughout this ISIL incursion which is the opposite of what most would expect ...
''Oil prices have continued to drop throughout this ISIL incursion which is the opposite of what most would expect ...''
My thoughts exactly. The exact opposite of what you would think the oil prices would do. Why so?
See that ... I thought I explained myself on this but apparently I was not sufficiently clear .
ISIL rather than impeding the flow of oil is actually capturing wells and selling the oil at a substantial discount . According to the seeded article they are selling to the black market at 30 cents on the $ . It seems that Turkey is involved in this black market trade although it is not clear to what extent .
ISIL has no interest in taking oil out of circulation . Instead they are acting as a black market discounter .
The article talked about Syrian oil but they have also shown an interest in Iraqi oil :
You were clear Petey, but. Now here comes the ''but''. Selling it on the black market at $30 barrel is attractive to some. Now, who is the ''some'' that are buying it? Can and will they purchase enough to hold the prices low. (If you can call $3.00 plus a gallon low).
Will ISIL keep it at $30 gallon? IMO, no they won't, their greed will overtake them and the prices will go up. How will that affect the world market. It remains to be seen. Also I don't see the big oil producing countries sitting back and watching their profits drop, because of ISIL.
Will we see an ''oil war''?
Inquiring minds want to know.
I'm pretty sure you mean $30 per barrel . I was not trying to precisely & quantitatively define the math for world oil prices . I had a far more limited goal ... to explain why petroleum prices have not been rising in spite of what appears to be a disruption in supply . But it is NOT a disruption . As to predicting future price effects , I will leave that to the experts .
That depends on what you mean by "'oil war" .
Interesting comments in a video featuring Michael Knights of the Washington Institute :
He points out that ISIS had been getting money from running protection rackets in Iraq for years . However , that combined with the money from selling stolen oil on the black market still does not amount to enough to run a country of 4 million people .
Recent events :
...
'Massacre' in Iraq as strikes hit near key dam
My summary to the video :
ISIL which captured a major dam near Mosul has received a counter attack by air near the dam . The news said they do not know who launched the counter attack .
Clearly this is an operation which requires precision air strikes . Any errors would risk destroying the dam and the resultant major flooding .
Here are more details about the dam conflict :
Iraq crisis: US strikes aid Kurdish bid to retake dam
....
Reports on Saturday morning said US aircraft had launched strikes on IS positions near the strategic dam in Mosul.
I suppose this was inevitable ... training adherents of a peaceful religion to defend themselves :
Kurdish militants train hundreds of Yazidis to fight Islamic State
And we could fly over there and blow them to hell and back and put ourselves at very little risk doing it, but we've waited until they've infiltrated so many, it just makes you wonder why?
The main problem with just bombing it it does not discriminate between foe and innocent bystander . The latest attacks launched by the USAF were on isolated convoys of ISIL traveling on isolated roads .
BTW , please take a look at my latest piece comparing ISIL to the Ferguson rioters :
Cars Being Abandoned Left and Right in Qatar
The question is..... who is purchasing the oil?
It's hard to hide tankers, rail cars, and trucks.
I can see the big boys tolerating this for a bit, but if oil prices start to fall, or more to the point "their profits fall" then I can see them getting motivated to take action. It might be that's why we have seen Syria, and Iran say they want to take action of late.
More to come......
In Afghanistan they process and sell opium.
In the Arab states, they black market the only thing the rest of the world wants from them.
Imagine what how fast the world would have been asked to respond if they had been blowing up the wells? Hell Halliburton would have been on their hot-line to the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
According to the article :
The oil is bought through Turkey from Syria, and it's sold to black market traders who function throughout the Levant.
Syria is losing territory to ISIL so that is no surprise . As to Iran , they were involved early on due mostly to religious conflict . Iran is Shia while ISIL is Sunni .
It isn't the states . It is the invaders who are doing these black market ops . And they are only asking for 30 cents on the $ for their product . Imagine getting your gasoline for 30 cents on the $ !
Why the Islamic State Is Mostly a Network ofRoads
Jordan has always had an especially close relationship with Britain.
The government is quite "moderate" as the Arab world goes, (and they have made peace with Israel,the only Arab country besides Egypt to do so) so the U.S. wants to see the current government in power.
And they are Sunni, possibly being threatened by Assad some day-- so Saudi Arabia, and Egypt and UAE support Jordan. (Also because they are moderate-- Saudi Arabia now fears radical islamists).
Geographically they are a buffer between much of Syria and Saudi Arabia, and the Saudis fear that if ISIS gets strong in Jordan they will move next door to attack Saudi Arabia.
Israel wants the Jordanian government to stay in power, because what ever gov't would replace it would probably start a war with Israel. (Jordan is actually Palestine-- it was part of the original Mandate of Palestine, land that was originally promised to the Jews. The majority of its population are now Palestinians-- it really should be a new Palestinian state).
ISIS wants money anyway it can get it. I think the purpose of the article was mainly to show how ISIS gets so much money from oil. ISIS has lots of money, its the wealthiest terrorist group in the world.
Thanks for your perspective . Based on how quickly ISIL got through the defenses of Syria at that air base , I could really see Assad wishing he had more poison gas to use !
Nice analysis!
The thing about roads is they make fast transport of troops possible ... within limited distances . In other words the size of ISIL is limited by the speed of motorized road travel .
This development makes the first restrictive threat to oil supplies :
...
Jihadists burn three Iraq oil wells as Kurds launch attack
Kirkuk (Iraq) (AFP) - Retreating jihadists set three wells ablaze at a northern Iraq oil field Thursday as they battled Kurdish forces who launched a major attack nearby, officials said.
The Islamic State (IS) jihadists set the wells on fire before deserting the Ain Zalah field, which was seized by militants along in early August, an official from the North Oil Company said.
....
IS-led militants launched a sweeping offensive in June that overran large areas of Iraq, and turned their sights on Kurdish forces in the north earlier this month, driving them back toward Arbil, the capital of their three-province autonomous region.
That advance, during which the militants targeted minority groups and forced some 200,000 people to flee, sparked a campaign of US air strikes which, combined with international shipments of arms and ammunition, have helped the Kurds claw back some ground.
The militants reportedly rake in significant volumes of cash from the sale of oil from fields they control.
They have made repeated attempts to seize the Baiji oil refinery, which once filled some 50 percent of Iraq's demand for refined petroleum products, but have each time been driven back.
The militant offensive has wreaked havoc on northern production and exports, but Iraq's main southern fields and export terminals have not been affected by the violence.
Here are more details about the fund raising activities of ISIL . The underlining of portions is my emphasis and not part of the published news article :
Islamic State group's war chest is growing daily
Associated Press
By KEN DILANIAN
WASHINGTON (AP) Islamic State militants, who once relied on wealthy Persian Gulf donors for money, have become a self-sustaining financial juggernaut, earning more than $3 million a day from oil smuggling, human trafficking, theft and extortion , according to U.S. intelligence officials and private experts.
The extremist group's resources exceed that "of any other terrorist group in history," said a U.S. intelligence official who, like others interviewed, spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss classified assessments. Such riches are one reason that American officials are so concerned about the group even while acknowledging they have no evidence it is plotting attacks against the United States.
The Islamic State group has taken over large sections of Syria and Iraq, and controls as many as 11 oil fields in both countries, analysts say. It is selling oil and other goods through generations-old smuggling networks under the noses of some of the same governments it is fighting: Kurdish-controlled northern Iraq, Turkey and Jordan.
While U.S. intelligence does not assess that those governments are complicit in the smuggling, the Obama administration is pressing them do to more to crack down. The illicit oil is generally transported on tanker trucks, analysts said .
"There's a lot of money to be made," said Denise Natali, who worked in Kurdistan as an American aid official and is now a senior research fellow at National Defense University. "The Kurds say they have made an attempt to close it down, but you pay off a border guard you pay off somebody else and you get stuff through."
The price the Islamic State group fetches for its smuggled oil is discounted $25 to $60 for a barrel of oil that normally sells for more than $100 but its total profits from oil are exceeding $3 million a day, said Luay al-Khatteeb, a visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution's Doha Center in Qatar.
The group also has earned hundreds of millions of dollars from smuggling antiquities out of Iraq to be sold in Turkey, al-Khatteeb said, and millions more from human trafficking by selling women and children as sex slaves .
Other revenue comes from extortion payments, ransom from kidnapped hostages, and outright theft of all manner of materials from the towns the Islamic State group has seized, analysts say.
"It's cash-raising activities resemble those of a mafia-like organization," a second U.S. intelligence official said, reflecting the assessment of his agency. "They are well-organized, systematic and enforced through intimidation and violence."
Even prior to seizing Mosul in June, for example, the group began to impose "taxes" on nearly every facet of economic activity, threatening death for those unwilling to pay, U.S. intelligence officials say. An analysis by the Council on Foreign Relations estimated the group was reaping $8 million a month from extortion in Mosul alone.
Once the group took over Mosul, in northern Iraq, and other areas, it grabbed millions of dollars in cash from banks, though not the hundreds of millions initially reported, U.S. intelligence officials say .
This spring, four French and two Spanish journalists held hostage by Islamic State extremists were freed after their governments paid multimillion-dollar ransoms through intermediaries .
The Islamic State group "has managed to successfully translate territorial control in northern Syria and portions of Iraq into a means of revenue generation," said a third U.S. intelligence official.
Analysts say the group is relying on the fact that the area along the border between Iraq and Turkey has long been a smugglers haven, and was made more so by the fall of Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein in 2003. Generations of families have illicitly moved goods through the region.
The Islamic State is the successor to al-Qaida in Iraq, which was founded by Jordanian Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. For a time, the group was allied with the Nusra Front, the al-Qaida affiliate that is a key player among the rebels battling Syrian President Bashar Assad. The Islamic State group has since broken with the Nusra Front and al-Qaida.
In the early days of the Syrian civil war, the Islamic State group was funded in large part by donations from wealthy residents of Gulf States, including Kuwait and Qatar , American officials have said.
"A number of fundraisers operating in more permissive jurisdictions particularly in Kuwait and Qatar are soliciting donations to fund ... al-Qaida's Syrian affiliate, the Nusra Front, and the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL)," David Cohen, the Treasury department's top counterterrorism official, said in a speech in March. ISIL is an alternative acronym for the Islamic State group.
That stream of funding has diminished in recent months as the group's violent tactics have drawn worldwide attention, U.S. intelligence officials say .
The group's reliance on oil as its main source of revenue could easily be disrupted by American airstrikes, officials say. But so far, no decision has been made to target Iraqi or Syrian oil infrastructure, which is serviced by civilian workers who may have been conscripted .
There is a lot of disagreement about the air attacks on ISIL . The biggest issue from my POV is "will they actually stop ISIL ?" . Here is a new development which may go a long way towards answering that question :
US-led air strikes target IS oil refineries in Syria
To my way of thinking this would likely be the most effective single tactic which can be done . ISIL needs money to continue its operations . By disrupting the flow of black market oil at the source it may go a long way to starving ISIL of funds .