Freedom is relatively a new concept in the scheme of time.
Not entirely true . One of the 1st points Friedman brings up is about the ancient Athenians and how they had a period of great prosperity . Their prosperity was due in part to freedom but also due to their devotion to pursuing international trade . And trade is about supplying desired demand ...
Petey, I'm certainly not debating he said that and Friedman is known for his "Supply and Demand" economics, but the theme of the video really had nothing to do with that. He also said they went from a Golden Age to Tyranny and it wasn't because of supply and demand.
I think you know what the theme of the video was Dean.
Freedom vs. Tyranny & Misery Somewhat of a transcript.
Milton Friedman
F- You and I, who have been lucky to have been born in a free society take freedom for granted as if it is a natural phenomena, but let me ask you? What fraction of the human race today lives in a free society?
I- Tiny, tiny, ting percentage
F- Over history in any moment of time have every lived in a free society?
I - Even tinier
F- Even tinier
I- Im leading you down the garden path
F- No youre not, no youre not. It is true that the normal condition of mankind is tyranny and misery. Weve escaped. Weve been extraordinarily fortunate to escape into an island of freedom and prosperity. If we do not maintain that island of freedom and properity. If we do not maintain that essential features of the society which made that freedom and prosperity possible, there isnt a wide range of alternatives. We go to tyranny and misery, which is the normal state of mankind. Why am I optimistic? Because were all so ignorant. If we could really predict the future, we couldnt be optimistic. But weve seen historically time and again that people who try to make long range predictions have not been pretty good at it. The human race is a funny thing, its always turning up surprises on you. People are capable of doing things you wouldnt have expected to as to rising to the circumstances, when I suppose I maintain my optimism partly because my inmate character is optimistic, but party because of consequences of not recognizing our state of affairs in time, of not acting in time could check it seem to me to be so horrendous that I can not but believe that well less people realize the alternative before they wont take measures to make sure it doesnt happen.
I- Well what took us into this little island of time in which we are so different or have enjoyed I dont what youre inclined.?
F- Thats a very interesting question and its one that can be spread more dept and I been very much interested in. From time to time in mans history there have been golden ages, 5th century BC in Greece, renaissance in Italy, socialism in decent period in England, 19 th century, and we in the midst of what I regard as the golden age in the United States the 19 th and early 20 th century. Rather the interesting question is how is it we can take it out of our own context. There were the same people there in the 6 th century, 5th century. The same people there in the 4 th century as the 5th century, 3 rd and 2 nd century. Why is it they had this sudden flowering, enormous late productive and brilliant period, disappears in the 4 th , 3 rd and 2 nd century BC. Same people but I think in many ways a fundamental explanation and now Im simplifying and conjecturing and misuse and a solid where sustained have passed since has its own lack something comes along which wipes the slate clean of restraints that have been holding the people back. When our own goal made it very clear what that was. It was a new continent, a new people coming with a new form of government, with a constitution of Declaration of Independence. There was an opportunity in which people were unrestrained in which the natural instinct of people to improve their lot by given freedom of control or command.. Now what happens and the reasons these just tend to be brief is the reason they last 100 years or 150 years at most was as time passes the slates fill up. Its very much easier to introduce restrictions and restraints than it is to remove them. Easier to pass a law than to repeal a law. And so over the course of time we tend to impose these changing of restraints on yourself most of them for good reason. The initial objections are always good but that doesnt mean the outcome is. And finally the slate becomes so filled up, if I may continue to use that image theres no more room to write on and you need somehow something that will provide for another removal of restraints.
I- What do you think would provide now for a wiping clear the the slate?
F- Well I think the first the thing that is necessary to wipe clear the slate is to set a limit on government spending. The same that has been encroaching more and more upon that slate is before 1928 or 29 total Federal, State and Local spending never exceeded 10% of our income except the Civil War and the 1 st World War, but now has risen to over 40% of our income. If that continues 40% is a awful lot. The first necessary is a tactical matter, is to put an end to that. As a strategic the main necessary is to have a change in the intellectual climate of opinion which will substitute a belief in individual responsibility for the false belief in social responsibility. Well let me emphasize, the problems that have arisen to us have not come from evil people who were trying in a conspiracy or anything like that to enslave us. That hasnt been our problem. Our problem is there were some good people who were trying to do good, but trying to do good in a fundamentally flawed way. The welfare state is in many ways a noble construct a noble concept. Its a concept that we that we ought to help our family. Its one thing for you to help me out of your pocket, but its another thing for you to help me out of his pocket. And the fundamental flaw of the welfare state in my opinion is the idea we should do good with somebody else money. Now whats wrong with that? Two things, first place, nobody spends somebody else money as carefully as he spends his money. We talk about NYC. About 7 or 8 years ago Ive forgotten exactly when it was Dennis Galbrath said there were no problems in NYC that couldnt be solved by NYC spending enough if my memory serves me well he said by doubling New Yorks budget. And in the mean time NYC budget has quadrupled and the problems have gotten worse not better and thats cause and effect, because when they spend more money, whose money? The city in NYC spend more money, but where did they get it? From its citizens. Theres no more money in total to be spent. But nobody spends somebodys money as carefully as he spends his on so you have more money being spent carelessly and less money being spent carefully. And second place, equally important. You can not spend somebody else money unless you first get it. How do you get? Ultimately and fundamentally by sending a policeman to take it away from you. So the concept of doing good with somebody else money has flaws or coercion built into it as an essential feature. And those flaws and waste which allows us to spend somebody else money and the coercion which is unavoidable distrust the good and the idea of doing good and convert it into the idea of doing bad.
So I say what is the ratio of United States National Debt to GDP today? 101.5% not the 40% it was when Milton Friedman warned us.
WORKING for the dole will become compulsory for almost every jobseeker and the unemployed will be forced to look for a job almost daily under a hardline welfare crackdown.
The government has given out nearly 1 billion dollars in grants right from the government website during the last 2.5 years importing poverty and increasing that National Debt. I guess 101.5% isn't enough. So when you hear that first cry these days when a baby is born, you know why, because he already owes a bunch of money from our representatives lack of vision for the future of this nation. Of course most of them will be gone soon and filthy rich while selling you on the idea they are trying to help you. Wonder if Obama will ever have enough money? I bet not. But he will still be telling those who continue to fall for his lies he is one of them.
Yes, like back in 1977 by him.
Supply & demand are simple concepts but they have fallen out of favor .
This video has a lot more to it than that Petey. In fact it doesn't have anything to do with supply and demand at all.
For the biggest part of mankind's history it has been tyranny. Freedom is relatively a new concept in the scheme of time.
We failed to protect our freedom now we are faced with tyranny. He was a visionary. The welfare state is driving us into the ground.
Not entirely true . One of the 1st points Friedman brings up is about the ancient Athenians and how they had a period of great prosperity . Their prosperity was due in part to freedom but also due to their devotion to pursuing international trade . And trade is about supplying desired demand ...
Petey, I'm certainly not debating he said that and Friedman is known for his "Supply and Demand" economics, but the theme of the video really had nothing to do with that. He also said they went from a Golden Age to Tyranny and it wasn't because of supply and demand.
I think you know what the theme of the video was Dean.
Freedom vs. Tyranny & Misery Somewhat of a transcript.
Milton Friedman
F- You and I, who have been lucky to have been born in a free society take freedom for granted as if it is a natural phenomena, but let me ask you? What fraction of the human race today lives in a free society?
I- Tiny, tiny, ting percentage
F- Over history in any moment of time have every lived in a free society?
I - Even tinier
F- Even tinier
I- Im leading you down the garden path
F- No youre not, no youre not. It is true that the normal condition of mankind is tyranny and misery. Weve escaped. Weve been extraordinarily fortunate to escape into an island of freedom and prosperity. If we do not maintain that island of freedom and properity. If we do not maintain that essential features of the society which made that freedom and prosperity possible, there isnt a wide range of alternatives. We go to tyranny and misery, which is the normal state of mankind. Why am I optimistic? Because were all so ignorant. If we could really predict the future, we couldnt be optimistic. But weve seen historically time and again that people who try to make long range predictions have not been pretty good at it. The human race is a funny thing, its always turning up surprises on you. People are capable of doing things you wouldnt have expected to as to rising to the circumstances, when I suppose I maintain my optimism partly because my inmate character is optimistic, but party because of consequences of not recognizing our state of affairs in time, of not acting in time could check it seem to me to be so horrendous that I can not but believe that well less people realize the alternative before they wont take measures to make sure it doesnt happen.
I- Well what took us into this little island of time in which we are so different or have enjoyed I dont what youre inclined.?
F- Thats a very interesting question and its one that can be spread more dept and I been very much interested in. From time to time in mans history there have been golden ages, 5th century BC in Greece, renaissance in Italy, socialism in decent period in England, 19 th century, and we in the midst of what I regard as the golden age in the United States the 19 th and early 20 th century. Rather the interesting question is how is it we can take it out of our own context. There were the same people there in the 6 th century, 5th century. The same people there in the 4 th century as the 5th century, 3 rd and 2 nd century. Why is it they had this sudden flowering, enormous late productive and brilliant period, disappears in the 4 th , 3 rd and 2 nd century BC. Same people but I think in many ways a fundamental explanation and now Im simplifying and conjecturing and misuse and a solid where sustained have passed since has its own lack something comes along which wipes the slate clean of restraints that have been holding the people back. When our own goal made it very clear what that was. It was a new continent, a new people coming with a new form of government, with a constitution of Declaration of Independence. There was an opportunity in which people were unrestrained in which the natural instinct of people to improve their lot by given freedom of control or command.. Now what happens and the reasons these just tend to be brief is the reason they last 100 years or 150 years at most was as time passes the slates fill up. Its very much easier to introduce restrictions and restraints than it is to remove them. Easier to pass a law than to repeal a law. And so over the course of time we tend to impose these changing of restraints on yourself most of them for good reason. The initial objections are always good but that doesnt mean the outcome is. And finally the slate becomes so filled up, if I may continue to use that image theres no more room to write on and you need somehow something that will provide for another removal of restraints.
I- What do you think would provide now for a wiping clear the the slate?
F- Well I think the first the thing that is necessary to wipe clear the slate is to set a limit on government spending. The same that has been encroaching more and more upon that slate is before 1928 or 29 total Federal, State and Local spending never exceeded 10% of our income except the Civil War and the 1 st World War, but now has risen to over 40% of our income. If that continues 40% is a awful lot. The first necessary is a tactical matter, is to put an end to that. As a strategic the main necessary is to have a change in the intellectual climate of opinion which will substitute a belief in individual responsibility for the false belief in social responsibility. Well let me emphasize, the problems that have arisen to us have not come from evil people who were trying in a conspiracy or anything like that to enslave us. That hasnt been our problem. Our problem is there were some good people who were trying to do good, but trying to do good in a fundamentally flawed way. The welfare state is in many ways a noble construct a noble concept. Its a concept that we that we ought to help our family. Its one thing for you to help me out of your pocket, but its another thing for you to help me out of his pocket. And the fundamental flaw of the welfare state in my opinion is the idea we should do good with somebody else money. Now whats wrong with that? Two things, first place, nobody spends somebody else money as carefully as he spends his money. We talk about NYC. About 7 or 8 years ago Ive forgotten exactly when it was Dennis Galbrath said there were no problems in NYC that couldnt be solved by NYC spending enough if my memory serves me well he said by doubling New Yorks budget. And in the mean time NYC budget has quadrupled and the problems have gotten worse not better and thats cause and effect, because when they spend more money, whose money? The city in NYC spend more money, but where did they get it? From its citizens. Theres no more money in total to be spent. But nobody spends somebodys money as carefully as he spends his on so you have more money being spent carelessly and less money being spent carefully. And second place, equally important. You can not spend somebody else money unless you first get it. How do you get? Ultimately and fundamentally by sending a policeman to take it away from you. So the concept of doing good with somebody else money has flaws or coercion built into it as an essential feature. And those flaws and waste which allows us to spend somebody else money and the coercion which is unavoidable distrust the good and the idea of doing good and convert it into the idea of doing bad.
So I say what is the ratio of United States National Debt to GDP today? 101.5% not the 40% it was when Milton Friedman warned us.
Australia Instituting "Work For the Dole" Program
WORKING for the dole will become compulsory for almost every jobseeker and the unemployed will be forced to look for a job almost daily under a hardline welfare crackdown.
No, not us. We want to import more welfare.
The government has given out nearly 1 billion dollars in grants right from the government website during the last 2.5 years importing poverty and increasing that National Debt. I guess 101.5% isn't enough. So when you hear that first cry these days when a baby is born, you know why, because he already owes a bunch of money from our representatives lack of vision for the future of this nation. Of course most of them will be gone soon and filthy rich while selling you on the idea they are trying to help you. Wonder if Obama will ever have enough money? I bet not. But he will still be telling those who continue to fall for his lies he is one of them.