Somerset, KY Has an Unique Solution to High Gas Prices
Eddie Girdler, the mayor of Somerset, KY, (a small town located in Eastern Kentucky), has come up with a novel idea to battle the price-gouging ways of the local gas stations. The city built a basic, no-frills, gas station, and now buys its gasoline directly from the supplier, selling it at lower profits to the population.
Prices in Somerset have always been 20 to 30 cents higher than the surrounding cities, and complaints have been made, to no avail. The solution is working, too!
The city's gas station serves around 300 customers per day, which is pretty good for a smaller city like Somerset. Profits go to the city, which will enable the city to provide more services.
The only losers in this game are the owners of the gas stations-- who have price-gouged for years. They are, of course, screaming the word "Socialism", but no one feels very sorry for them...
Louisville has the same problem, and perhaps we should take a look at Somerset's plan!
Thanks for coming by!

Our gas is typically 30 to 40 cents more expensive than the surrounding counties, as well. Our own mayor should take a look at this solution! Not only would this channel more money into the city budget, (which the mayor needs to do, somehow without raising taxes), but it would enable all of us to live better!!!
Frankly, it is a pain to drive 18 miles to get to the next county for gas.
It sounds like Girder has a great idea!! I hope it works out.
I don't totally agree with the solution. There are stations who have been charged for price-gouging, but citations were issued and fines paid for doing so. I know of several in North Carolina. Seems someone has a friend downtown to me Dowser.
If everyone of the stations in this town are really overpricing gas then I can see this as a viable solution, but I think it should have been put to all the stations in a meeting or something before the city punishes all stations.
I know in West Virgina living down in valley may mean 20 miles before you can find another station. I still think a meeting of all the station owners should have been held before the city took over providing gas for the people.
Do you know how many stations there are in this town? If it is isolated and only a couple of stations it shouldn't have been much of a problem to have a meeting with them. They do have to provide information as to their cost of fuel.
Reminds me of Maxine Waters telling the Regulators that the government would socialize their business and take over them.
Not all stations may be price-gouging. I don't know. I don't think the government should be in the gas business.
No offense but one small step ......
We already have enough of that as per my opinion.
Then some would like nothing better to have the government control every aspect of their lives, but not me.
Not here. There are laws against price-gouging, but they are NOT enforced, and only apply in 'times of emergency'. In addition, there is ONE oil supplier to the state. Which would be a monopoly, right? Unfortunately, there are no laws against a monopoly in selling wholesale gasoline in the state. In fact, there is a law against passing a law against a monopoly for gasoline sales. That was done years ago, to protect Ashland Oil...
So, everyone pays the same price to buy the gas, but everyone also tacks on what they feel the market can bear, price-wise. Therefore, Louisville is always at least 30-40 cents higher than out and about in the state. It appears that the Somerset stations were doing the same thing.
I have NO sympathy for them, at all.
Oh, and that meeting? That's against the law in KY. That's called price fixing. THAT, you can go to jail for.
Oh, and the gas stations had plenty of time to get their act together... This passed the City Council, and all ordinances/laws/rules, have to be advertised and subject to public comment before it is put into effect. So the people have spoken. The only ones 'losing out' are the gas station owners, who charged a whole lot more for gas in the weeks prior to this going into effect.
Ain't life just grand here in the Bluegrass State?
Me too!!!
Exactly what I think! In fact, I surely hope that our own Mayor pays attention to Somerset's achievement.
Terrific idea, hope it catches on in a lot more places...
I also live in a small town in NE Ohio, where all 5 gas stations 'coincidently' charge the exact same (inflated) price. You can drive 10-12 miles to even smaller towns (with smaller stations) and usually find gas 10 to 20 cents/gallon cheaper.
"I'm so old I can remember when people used to rob gas stations--- now it's the other way around..."
I live in very small town. 2500 people, and we have a number of stations. I've found that our fuel here is the same as in the larger cities north of us. Springfield, about 40 miles north of us, with a population of over 200,000 is selling gas within a couple of cents of down here. At times our fuel is a couple of cents cheaper.
I do like the idea, that when it's obvious price gouging, that step are taken to combat it.
I remember when, thanks to the gas wars, you could get gas for 21 cents a gallon. Yeah, and they cheerfully washed your windshield, too!
Me, too, Kavika. It won't work unless there is actual gouging going on, though. I mean, the city has to make a profit as well, yet the fact that they can, and still be so much cheaper, tells us just bad the problem has been!
I wonder if the gas is so high in your area because it is more like a vacation area?
Dowser, our gas is the same price as the larger cities, and in some cases a few pennies lower. So it isn't a problem here. Well, except that gas everywhere is overpriced.
Ahhh... I misunderstood.
I always get just enough gas to get to Owensboro, and fill up there, because I almost always save 30-40 cents there per gallon. Owensboro is a good sized city, (for KY), 55,000 souls. Makes you wonder, doesn't it?
Boat gas is about $4 per gallon, and guess what, it is the exact same gas as what is down the corner at Speedway...
Well based on the prices I found here your gas is about 20 cents cheaper than it is in Charlotte, NC. And it is cheaper than the national average located on left of the screen. I can go down the road into South Carolina and get it 20 cents cheaper than charlotte.
Here's Somerset's gas prices:
Here's Charlotte, NC gas prices:
Here's Rock Hill, SC gas prices: Rock Hill is just a few miles south of Charlotte. I go there all the time in my work and try to buy my gas there.
Louisville gas prices:
It does appear some station are charging more in Louisville, but it is the same way here. but
It's price fixing when all the stations are fixing the price. I can't see how having a meeting would be against the law. I'm talking about a meeting confronting the stations who are price gouging. I've never heard of that before being price fixing.
I've seen the problem solved by confronting the stations on several occasions and they promptly stopped it, especially if it was publicized. I don't think it is a brilliant idea at all unless you want the government to do everything for you. Believe me, if enough people come together, I can't see how that wouldn't be effective. But the people can come together and make it public as you see here and buy your gas from the cheapest stations.
Some stations are never going to be the cheapest in town. A lot of it depends on who owns the gas, the station or the oil company. Usually the oil company will be comply with the competition.
As you can see you don't have to buy your gas from the highest place in town.
Usually country stations are considerable higher. It isn't always the owner's fault most of the time, but the price he has to pay for it. Being close to a city is usually advantageous though.
But I've given you a number of stations here you should check out and as I said, the cost for a barrel of oil has varied quite a bit lately. Sometimes a station doesn't get the best price on their gas but still has quite a bit left before they sell it all, so they can take a big loss if they reduce their price.
Stations don't make too much on gas. The state and the Federal government make a lot more than the oil companies or the stations on gas by taxing it.
As I remember, North Carolina's tax is considerably higher than South Carolina's tax on gas, but some stations charge more than the difference in tax. I avoid them and I suggest you do the same.
By the way I always fill up and avoid North Carolina gas if I can. I do have an advantage. Mecklenburg County ends at the state line. Charlotte is in Mecklenburg County. I can drive 3 miles and save 20 to 25 cents per gallon and I've saved as much as 35 to 40 cents per gallon, so I guess some stations are gouging here too, but I don't shop there.
I've bought it for 18 cents for my lawn mower as a child. Do you know you can get a gallon of gas for 20 cents now if you have two 1964 dimes? Of course the station will not give it to you for that but two 1964 dimes are worth $1.59 a piece. I guess you would need one more and cut it in half since the price of silver evidently has come down some. LOL
Hey, a 20 ounce Diet Coke cost $1.49 in a convenience store and I don't drink bottled water, but I bet bottled water is more expensive than gas.
Before you buy bottled water, read the listing of the source on the bottle. If it is a municipal supply, then it has undergone very stringent testing. If not, don't buy it.
Dowser
Interesting article
Are you sure there is a single supplier of oil to the entire state of Kentucky? Seems incredible in this day and age.
I certainly sympathize as I live in a small rural village in NE Ohio and our prices are always higher $.10 to $.12 than it the cities 30 to 50 miles in various directions) but am a little concerned with could be looked at as a first step in the nationalization of part of the private sector.
We see significantly higher prices in our local supermarket in the village than at Giant Eagle or Marcs in the nearby cities, but I hardly think the village or county should go into the grocery business.
Just a few random thoughts.
Again interesting article
Yes, Robert, I am sure. It is Key Oil company. I've known this for years, ever since I researched what was in the gas at the boat docks in the wellhead protection area, and why that gas is $4-5 per gallon.
I agree that this can be looked upon as nationalization of a private sector. But this is Somerset, KY-- not a trend-setting place. And KY is a "red" state.
You both make really good points. However, I feel not one whit of sympathy for those that have gouged their customers for years. Finally, someone came up with a solution that was within KY state law. Their prices are finally becoming more in-line with the real costs. And remember, the city is making money, too!
Six, what the prices are today, are great, compared to last week, even. And they don't really compare to what they were two months ago, when this change took affect.
Louisville's gas is almost always more expensive. There have been one or two occasions in the past 5 years where it was close in price to those in Cave City, but Owensboro is always a LOT cheaper. Shelbyville is always a LOT cheaper. I don't always have the time to drive to Shelbyville to get gas, but, if I can, I do.
If this is what it takes to keep the stations honest, then I'm all for it. Everyone deserves a profit-- none of us are in business to lose money-- but this is ridiculous!
That's what I do too.
Dowser
Those points are true but irrelevant to the point of whether it is a good idea for the government to take over the private sector
I have no sympathy for the gas station owners that have gouged the public on pricing or for a company that has a monopoly over a critical supply item, but that notwithstanding and whether KY is blue, red or yellow government participation in the private sector is a not a good thing in my view.
No doubt and undoubtedly with advantages and cost avoidance realities that the private sector participants do not have.
This is a situation that the means are more dangerous than the end result.
As I mentioned above what's next, groceries, energy, building supplies....?
Unfortunately, I think we're going to see more of this, because KY does not have the laws in place to fix the problem. Every day price gouging is not against the law, only gouging in times of emergencies. There is actually a law against fighting the gasoline wholesale company as a monopoly. The law was passed to protect Ashland Oil, way back in the 1960s.
While I, too, do not approve of this, in general, I certainly approve of Somerset using the only tool at their disposal to combat the price gouging ways of these gas stations. It is, in a way, capitalism at its finest. Remember, too, that the city is making money, so they're not selling gas at a lower price than they are buying it. This is a "no frills" gas station. It only sells gas. Period. It does not sell oil, groceries, cigarettes, snacks, maps, etc.
It is only competing in the gasoline market. Perhaps, the KY legislature will finally take steps to actually combat the problem. But, in all honesty, I doubt it. Our legislative houses are in total gridlock. About all they could agree on is naming the state rock and state mineral. Which of course, they got wrong...
And SAFER.
If it is a municipal supply, believe me, it has undergone stringent tests!
Dowser
Thanks for the feedback
You are justifying the means with the end, which often leads that slippery slope we all hear so much about.
To use a medical metaphor, Somerset is treating the symptoms of a disease while making no effort to cure the patient of the disease
Unfortunately, the only cure that is available would be from the legislature, which is locked in an unending battle these days.
Nope, I'm not. Not really. I don't truly approve of this, either. But until our legislature can get the oil companies out of their pockets and vote for what's best for the people of the state, this is the only recourse available.
And, I'm NOT pointing fingers at any political party. KY politics is weird, by any definition. All sides contribute to the problem.
Dowser
I get your position and respect it but you prove my point when you say
I don't truly approve of this, either. But
You must admit that is the classic intro line for an "end justifies the means" argument
Really appreciate the back and forth - disagreement without being disagreeable - looks like it really can be accomplished on NT
Have a great evening
Fine, Robert.
The ends justified the means back in the 1960's when they passed the law that said Ashland Oil was the state gasoline supplier. Key Oil was a subsidiary of Ashland. Look where we are now.
Kentucky is an unusual state. We often do things that contradict each other. For example, we are the only producer of bourbon in the world, (by law-- to be called a true bourbon, it has to be made in the state), yet, out of 120 counties, 100 of them are dry, or mostly dry. The Kentucky Derby showcases or highlights horse racing and betting, yet we are definitely a part of the bible belt. Not a lot of what we do makes sense.
I seriously doubt that the city of Somerset will wish to open and operate groceries, shoe stores, etc. After all, they have their very own Walmart.
I can understand what they are doing and why. I think maybe you are carrying this a bit beyond the intent. If so, then come on down and vote for a legislator and governor that will take action. Because the oil companies and coal companies in this state run things, and no one is going to piss them off. That's just the way it is, here.
I'm proud of the Mayor, that he had the guts to stand up to all this. It will be his political death, but at least he did something.
Dowser
It was not my intent to make you angry
I just think this is a black and white issue - it is either appropriate or inappropriate for the government to be competing with the private sector
In my view, it is inappropriate.
I understand why it happened there and agree that something should be done about the underlying issue.
I just firmly believe that it is never the right course to treat a symptom rather than the underlying disease.
I enjoy your articles and comments as much as any on NT and attempted to vigorously make my point without belittling you or points because as I said it was not my intention to make you angry.
I will again thank you for all of the feedback and perspective and bid you a good evening and hope you have a great weekend.
Six, I haven't seen gas at $3.29/gallon in a looong time. It may be that the low prices you are showing are listed in gas stations across town-- which would not be unusual. It is an hour drive, in traffic, to get across town in traffic, especially with the road construction going on here.
I did all this when I replied to this, but heaven only knows what happened to my post. So, I researched today's prices. Please bear with me, as I took screen shots.
Today, these are the prices that are found near my house, which is where I usually buy gas. There is one station not listed, and you usually get a bit lower there.
Here are the prices near work, which is up in Prospect, KY:
I'm usually getting on I64 to go east or west, and often have to stop for gas on my way out of town. Here are the prices near I64:
In contrast, I can drive to the edge of Shelbyville, and see this:
I spend a great deal of time in Owensboro, whose gas prices are this:
And I also spend a lot of time in Cave City, where we park our camper.
You can see why I perceive Louisville as being a lot higher than the rest of the state. Here they are in Somerset, which is now more in line with the rest of the state:
I know you don't want to hear this, but the Somerset gas station worked to lower the price.
Dowser ,
If you're willing to go to the black market you can get your gas for a lot less :
Uh, nope! I'm not a "black market" kind of person...
Robert, sorry this slipped off the board and I didn't see your comment.
I was annoyed, not mad.
Not mad now, either.
You know I enjoy talking with you. Always. If you feel this isn't right, write the Somerset mayor:
Here is the city page! (Note the gas price index on the front page... Funny!)
Anyway you have the information and if you happen to be in that part of town fill it up. If you do that little driving, it really shouldn't make that much difference anyway. I drive 60 plus thousand miles a year, so I look for good prices and already know where they are. If someone just drives to the grocery store and back and maybe to the closest gas station that's so little driving I don't think it matters that much. What I've shown you is what I use to get my gas if I'm in an area I'm not familiar. I just look at the location on the map and if one of them is very close I fill it up. I always fill it up, because I may not be in a location that has those cheap gas prices.
Thank you for it, too! I've used that before, myself-- I do mind driving across town, just to get gas, but if I'm already there, I buy it.
Right now, Louisville is building a new I65 bridge across the Ohio, so traffic is messed up in ALL of downtown, they're fixing Spaghetti Junction, so it is messed up on the east side, not quite downtown, they're building a tunnel and bridge up at Prospect, I64 is torn up in both directions, just outside of town, I65 is messed up just outside of town, I71 is messed up just outside of town, and then, both the water company and the sewer company are laying new lines, IN town. There is no place to go that you're not in construction traffic.
Here is a map . All those little red dots is where there is road construction, sewer or water line modification, or some kind of construction that interrupts traffic. Not trying to be a pain, but after you see this, you may understand better why I am reluctant to drive very far just to get gas. Sometimes, I can get to the post office in 10 minutes, (just down from my house), and sometimes, it takes 30-45 minutes, depending on traffic and construction.
Thanks for your note! Please, I replied-- there is no need to apologize. I am sorry if I came off as being short with you, too. I've been working all week to fit band uniforms on kids. That will do anyone in...