╌>

Court Rules That Subsidies in Obamacare's Federal Exchange are Illegal, Dealing Huge Legal Blow to Health Law

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  12 years ago  •  35 comments

Court Rules That Subsidies in Obamacare's Federal Exchange are Illegal, Dealing Huge Legal Blow to Health Law

Link

3899_discussions.jpg

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit delivered a huge blow to Obamacare this morning, ruling that the insurance subsidies granted through the federally run health exchange, which covered 36 states for the first open enrollment period, are not allowed by the law.

The highly anticipated opinion in the case of J acqueline Halbig v. Sylvia Mathews Burwell reversed a lower court ruling finding that federally run exchanges did have the authority to disburse subsidies.

Today's ruling vacates the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) regulation allowing the federal exchanges to give subsidies. The large majority of individuals, about 86 percent, in the federal exchange system received subsidies, and in those cases the subsidies covered about 76 percent of the premium on average.

The essence of the court's ruling is that, according to the law, those subsidies are illegal. They were always illegal, and the administration never had the authority to offer them. ( According to an administration official, however, the subsidies will continue to flow throughout the appeals process.)

The court's ruling agreed with challengers who argued that the plain language of the law, which in multiple instances limits subsidies and credits to any "Exchange established by the State," does not allow subsidies to be disbursed in exchanges where a state declined to establish its own exchange and is instead run by the federal government. Basically, the federal government cannot step in and create and run an exchange that is somehow still an exchange established by a state.

"We conclude that appellants have the better of the argument: a federal Exchange is not an 'Exchange established by the State,' and [the relevant section of the law] does not authorize the IRS to provide tax credits for insurance purchased on federal Exchanges," the decision says.

The law "plainly makes subsidies available only on Exchanges established by states," the ruling says. "And in the absence of any contrary indications, that text is conclusive evidence of Congresss intent. To hold otherwise would be to say that enacted legislation, on its own, does not command our respectan utterly untenable proposition."

It's a major blow to the way the administration has chosen to implement the health law, and a victory for plain language legal interpretation as well.

Update: On a conference call this morning, Case Western University Law Professor Jonathan Adler, who was instrumental in laying the legal groundwork for the case, made the point that this is not the court changing the law. It is the court interpreting the law and its clear language. Which means that any of the ruling's effects, including the loss of subsidies, were built into the law when it was passed.

"If people lose those subsidies, its because the courts rule that those subsidies are and always have been unlawful," he said. The administration "never had the authority" to dish them out. " Halbig did not cause those effects. Those are the effects of the Affordable Care Act."

"I f that causes dislocation, if that causes disruption, I think the responsibility lies with the IRS and the administration," Adler also said.

Update 2: A different circuit court ruled today that subsidies offered through federally run exchanges are authorized on the law. This creates a circuit court split, which increases, but does not guarantee, the chances of an eventual hearing by the Supreme Court. It is also possible, and arguably even more likely, that the circuit split will be dealt with via en banc review.

Read the complete decision here . More background on the case here and here . I'll have more to say after sorting through the full details of the ruling. This post will be updated.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

NPR's morning edition on this.

...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

There are numerous explicit and implicit parts of the ACA that make it clear the subsidies are intended across the board, exchanges and otherwise.

The SCOTUS in my opinion will not take appeals and the Federal Court that ruled against subsidies had only 3 judges rule -- not the full court.

But hey, let the Congressional Republicans run with the decision and tell people they're going to take away their health insurance.

Then watch voter turnout.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Should have been "single payer" from the start.

For once, we agree completely.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

If and until this decision is affirmed by the SCOTUS, calling this a severe blow to the PPACA is nothing but political hyperbole in an election year.

Two federal courts decided the same issue and ended up with opposite conclusions about the law, so if the decisions stand after an en banc review it will be off to the SCOTUS.

Until then, this is no blow to the PPACA at all as it is business as usual (everyone gets the tax breaks) pending the result of the government appeal of the decision.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Sloppy, carelessly written laws show up in the courts a lot. Democrats need to hire someone who has read the constitution. That would save a lot of problems.

I agree; the language used to bring the challenge was sloppily written. But the issue in this decision had nothing to do with the Constitution -- it was about the language (which BTW, is, contradicted by a number of explicit and implicit pieces of language in the ACA to the contrary).

The court doesn't care about the vote -- but that's not an issue; the Republicans who will do a victory dance over the D.C court decision will not likely have the balls to use it to take health insurance from millions who now have it thanks to the ACA. But those who celebrate too loud will frighten voters, who, will likely vote against them.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

RIO, how do you think this Ruling would affect the health Insurance for Congress Members as well as the Judges?? Federal Employees had to sign up for Obamacare in November 2013...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

No, at least a I understand it a panel of three judges from the DC District made this decision (perhaps I am incorrect) and it will automatically have an en banc review by the entire court and if they reverse this decision then it is settled.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I am sure there is a federal exchange in the district, but if they signed up through a state exchange then it could theoretically affect them

This will not pass scrutiny by the SCOTUS.

The tax credits will stand as "intended" by the writers of the legislation, common sense will rule in this case

Imagine that

That is hardly an important consideration at this point

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Agreed

And a decision of the DC District Court would be appealed to the SCOTUS - you are correct I misspoke

Sorry about that

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Democrats need to hire someone who can read and comprehend - sad mixture severely lacking in the Democratic forums.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Not quite so Robert - any ruling of a court, no matter what level its on, is binding in law - until and if overturned by a higher court.

Noticed that the "Administration" stated they would continue the subsidies - even though they've been ruled illegal.

Typical for this administration.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

CM - no, federal employees did not have to sign up. Only those who were uninsured. The Congressional staffers and Congress-people had to sign up - if they weren't exempted.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago
Democrats need to hire someone who can read and comprehend - sad mixture severely lacking in the Democratic forums.

So true.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

"You can keep your doctor." .... Obama quote .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

But the issue in this decision had nothing to do with the Constitution

There you go again.

The SCOTUS upheld the Constitutionality of the PPACA particularly the funding aspect.

This is about a poorly written paragraph in the ACA. Whether or not that can cause the end of the law is doubtful. Imagine the SCOTUS being faced with hearing an appeal by which THEY IN ESSENCE HAVE TO ADMIT -- "Ooops, we missed that paragraph."

No way they'll hear appeals.

Supreme Court: Affordable Care Act Is Constitutional

FYI:

This morning the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that the Affordable Care Act is constitutional . The health insurance mandate, also known as "Obamacare" was found to be "permissible under Congress's taxing authority."

The full ruling (PDF) is now available, and the court's opinion begins on page 7. Amy Howe from SCOTUS blog summarized the ruling thus :

"The Affordable Care Act, including its individual mandate that virtually all Americans buy health insurance, is constitutional. There were not five votes to uphold it on the ground that Congress could use its power to regulate commerce between the states to require everyone to buy health insurance.

However, five Justices agreed that the penalty that someone must pay if he refuses to buy insurance is a kind of tax that Congress can impose using its taxing power.

That is all that matters. Because the mandate survives, the Court did not need to decide what other parts of the statute were constitutional, except for a provision that required states to comply with new eligibility requirements for Medicaid or risk losing their funding. On that question, the Court held that the provision is constitutional as long as states would only lose new funds if they didn't comply with the new requirements, rather than all of their funding."

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Socialized medicine, which along with the other entitlements (we keep adding more) will lead to hyperinflation and national bankruptcy.

You have seen the future in Greece.

Margaret Thatcher said, "The trouble with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money."

The early participants in Ponzi schemes are delighted with the process.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

True the decision can be appealed to SCOTUS however if a review by the full DC District overrules the 3 judge panels decision and ends up agreeing with the 4th Districts ruling then why would SCOTUS want to take up a case where the lower courts agree?

Of course this current version of SCOUTS has shown it doesnt mind too much about appearing political so they might very well accept rather than deny a review of this case even if there is no disagrement in the lower courts decision.

So, Watch this Space, as they say.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Because as Robert G points out (more eloquently than I) if the court upholds the law then the plaintiffs have the right to appeal to the SCOTUS and likely will. Likewise, if the entire DC District was to overturn this portion of the PPACA then the government would also likely turn to the SCOTUS for resolution.

The way the legal ball bounces in the U.S.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

Except guys there is no constitutional questions involved in this particular case. This case hinges on the ambiguity of one section of a large, complicated bill.

Both courts agreed that the language of one section was poorly written then one court went with decades of precedence and ruled that they would not ignore Congress obvious intent for the law, which was that everyone that qualifies for subsidies get them whether through a State run exchange or a Federal run one while the DC panel ended in a different place.

Of course SCOTUS would be more inclined to review the case if the full DC court sticks with the 3 judge panels ruling because then you would then have a split decision on a major piece of legislation but if both courts come down on the same side I don't think SCOTUS will get involved, well at least not for legitimate legal reasons.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

It does not have to be a constitutional issue, the SCOTUS can also hear a case to resolve a conflict in law (e.g. ambiguity in the statute or disagreement among lower courts in interpretation of the law)

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

1st, since the other court said it was proper, how does the ''administration'' follow through. One said illegal, the other legal...Seems that the courts have a problem, not the administration.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Actually the question to be decided here is whether the intent of legislators who wrote the statute was in fact to allow the subsidies regardless of whether the insurance was purchased in a state or federal exchange.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago
Robert G,The court that decided the funding only applied to the Exchanges had only three of its judges make the ruling; should the full court rule, the outcome will likely go the other way.The Virginia court ruled in favor of the law as it stands; beyond that, as I commented earlier, there are numerous explicit and implicit pieces of language in the law regarding the subsidies.
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

The higher court rules and "kind of" negates the ruling of the lower court. That's why they're listed as "superior" courts in the Constitution. The "kind of" is based on the appeals process - if one is filed - which hasn't happened here - yet. Until the next level rules, the ruling of this court is substantive.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

Exactly the point I was trying to make, the question to be decided on is the intent of the legislators in crafting the law despite their inelegant choice of language.

Regardless of which way the whole court rules this is likely to be appealed to the SCOTUS for final scrutiny

I agree with you that a liberal leaning d.c. district court will likely reverse the ruling of the three judges and then it is on to the none wise ones

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

"We don't worry about the Constitution around here, we make it up as we go along." Democrat Quote.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

However, Amac, there have been instances where the Supreme Court did not see things the way you did. Odd as that may seem.

Robert G, what's odd is that I bother to try and educate you, knowing all the while that when you have no viable comebacks, you resort to comments like the one quoted above.

I don't believe the DC court ruling will get to the SCOTUS; the full DC court will reverse the decision of the two of its judges (of three) that made the ruling.

And even if it should get to the SCOTUS THIRD TIME it already ruled on the constitutionality of the ACA and specifically on the subsidization. The intent and scope of the ACA subsidies, DESPITE THE RAGGED ASS BADLY WRITTEN PARAGRAPH, is clear throughout the rest of its pages.

$25.00 for the American Cancer Society that the ACA subsidies will stand? Do we have a wager, Robert G?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"We don't worry about the Constitution around here, we make it up as we go along." Democrat Quote.

Another example of how the right-wing makes pronouncements of all kinds without any validation.

But I'll bite; who made that declaration, when and under what circumstances?

In the interim

Constitutional violations WITH EXTENSIVE, SPECIFIC DOCUMENTATION.

Article I
Creating a Secret Propaganda Campaign to Manufacture a False Case for War Against Iraq .

Article II
Falsely, Systematically, and with Criminal Intent Conflating the Attacks of September 11, 2001, With Misrepresentation of Iraq as a Security Threat as Part of Fraudulent Justification for a War of Aggression .

Article III
Misleading the American People and Members of Congress to Believe Iraq Possessed Weapons of Mass Destruction, to Manufacture a False Case for War .

Article IV
Misleading the American People and Members of Congress to Believe Iraq Posed an Imminent Threat to the United States .

Article V
Illegally Misspending Funds to Secretly Begin a War of Aggression .

Article VI
Invading Iraq in Violation of the Requirements of HJRes114 .

Article VII
Invading Iraq Absent a Declaration of War .

Article VIII
Invading Iraq, A Sovereign Nation, in Violation of the UN Charter .

Article IX
Failing to Provide Troops With Body Armor and Vehicle Armor .

Article X
Falsifying Accounts of US Troop Deaths and Injuries for Political Purposes .

Article XI
Establishment of Permanent U.S. Military Bases in Iraq .

Article XII
Initiating a War Against Iraq for Control of That Nation's Natural Resources .

Article XIIII
Creating a Secret Task Force to Develop Energy and Military Policies With Respect to Iraq and Other Countries .

Article XIV
Misprision of a Felony, Misuse and Exposure of Classified Information And Obstruction of Justice in the Matter of Valerie Plame Wilson, Clandestine Agent of the Central Intelligence Agency .

Article XV
Providing Immunity from Prosecution for Criminal Contractors in Iraq .

Article XVI
Reckless Misspending and Waste of U.S. Tax Dollars in Connection With Iraq and US Contractors .

Article XVII
Illegal Detention: Detaining Indefinitely And Without Charge Persons Both U.S. Citizens and Foreign Captives .

Article XVIII
Torture: Secretly Authorizing, and Encouraging the Use of Torture Against Captives in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Other Places, as a Matter of Official Policy .

Article XIX
Rendition: Kidnapping People and Taking Them Against Their Will to "Black Sites" Located in Other Nations, Including Nations Known to Practice Torture .

Article XX
Imprisoning Children .

Article XXI
Misleading Congress and the American People About Threats from Iran, and Supporting Terrorist Organizations Within Iran, With the Goal of Overthrowing the Iranian Government .

Article XXII
Creating Secret Laws .

Article XXIII
Violation of the Posse Comitatus Act .

Article XXIV
Spying on American Citizens, Without a Court-Ordered Warrant, in Violation of the Law and the Fourth Amendment .

Article XXV
Directing Telecommunications Companies to Create an Illegal and Unconstitutional Database of the Private Telephone Numbers and Emails of American Citizens .

Article XXVI
Announcing the Intent to Violate Laws with Signing Statements .

Article XXVII
Failing to Comply with Congressional Subpoenas and Instructing Former Employees Not to Comply .

Article XXVIII
Tampering with Free and Fair Elections, Corruption of the Administration of Justice .

Article XXIX
Conspiracy to Violate the Voting Rights Act of 1965 .

Article XXX
Misleading Congress and the American People in an Attempt to Destroy Medicare .

Article XXXI
Katrina: Failure to Plan for the Predicted Disaster of Hurricane Katrina, Failure to Respond to a Civil Emergency .

Article XXXII
Misleading Congress and the American People, Systematically Undermining Efforts to Address Global Climate Change .

Article XXXIII
Repeatedly Ignored and Failed to Respond to High Level Intelligence Warnings of Planned Terrorist Attacks in the US, Prior to 911 .

Article XXXIV
Obstruction of the Investigation into the Attacks of September 11, 2001 .

Article XXXV
Endangering the Health of 911 First Responders .

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Bush did it - it's all Bushes fault - Cheny is nuts - Cheny's a nutcase.

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

However, Bush didn't have the courts rule against him in 20 cases - did he???? Oops - 21.Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

My dog is sleeping, otherwise I'd have him argue about this with you.

More likely it's your DUCK as you again duck the specifics and come back with a cheap shot.

No wager, Robert G?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

When a lower court's ruling against a plaintiff or defendant is overturned, it can't be counted as a ruling "against" any longer.

But I'll consider your number if you can post the rulings.

And when I post THE EXACT LAW THAT OBTAINS REGARDING THE CENTRAL AMERICAN CHILDREN REFUGEES, AND IT IS A LAW PUT INTO PLACE BY BUSH, WHEN YOU MOCK ME, YOU DISCREDIT YOURSELF.

The other items came in direct response to a Sixpick comment.

Never mentioned Cheney -- tossing that in to pad your already off-target comment only weakens an already weak response.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

However, Bush didn't have the courts rule against him in 20 cases - did he???? Oops - 21.Smile.gif

1stwarrior where did that 21 cases come from?

Since I only recalled Bush getting push back from the court in cases centering around what he tried to do with the prisoners in Gitmo I took a few minutes to google around looking for how Pres. Bush fared in the courts.

Just my quick search turned up;

The New Yor Times, June 15,2008

War Powers
Why This Court Keeps Rebuking This President

The court has ruled against a president in a time of armed conflict no more than a handful of times, ....

So it is extraordinary that during the Bush administrations seven years, nearly all of them a time of war that began on Sept. 11, 2001, the court has been prompted to push back four times. Last weeks decision in Boumediene v. Bush, in which the court ruled that prisoners at Guantnamo Bay have a right to challenge their detentions in the federal courts, marks only the most recent rebuke.

As well as;

PolitiFact.com

Goodlatte said, the "9-0 decision last week was the 13th time the Supreme Court has voted 9-0 that the president has exceeded his constitutional authority." A thorough review of the 13 cases found many instances where presidential authority was not at issue. Further, most of the cases originated under and were first litigated by the Bush administration.

We rate Goodlattes statement False.

So again I ask which 21 cases are you referring to 1stwarrior?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

Not disputing the points you cite but isn't this the definitive straw man argument deflecting from the point of the seed?

No reasonable person disputes that Bush II was a poor president, but citing examples of Bush did it too or Bush did it first is hardly justification or defense for the actions or inactions of any other administration.

Wouldn't you agree?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

but citing examples of Bush did it too or Bush did it first is hardly justification or defense for the actions or inactions of any other administration.

Wouldn't you agree?

I was responding specifically to a comment made by Sixpick, specifically

"We don't worry about the Constitution around here, we make it up as we go along." Democrat Quote.

If he hadn't made that comment, there'd have been no need to provide balance.

Otherwise, I agree, RIO.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

We need to lighten the mood a little on this subject

Political Cartoons by Chip Bok

I thought this was quite an amusing update in the "we must pass the bill to see what's in it" story - not really interested in debating whether she said it, whether she meant it or whether it is all a plot by the right wing nuts to undermine the credibility of Ms. Pelosi.

I simply thought it was funny - you can agree or not

 
 

Who is online





47 visitors