╌>

Study: Forced Unionization Harms Economy

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  12 years ago  •  6 comments

Study: Forced Unionization Harms Economy

July 18, 2014

Right to work laws boost income, competitiveness

Forced unionization cost the economy nearly $650 billion in 2012, according to a new study.

A state-by-state comparison of growth and employment rates found that right to work laws, which free workers from coercive unionization, boost competitiveness for local economies, as well as wages. Per capita income increases more than $13,000 per year for a family of four, according to the Competitive Enterprise Institute , a libertarian think tank.

The reason for the disparate growth rates, according to CEI Vice President Aloysius Hogan, is that investment capital generally migrates to business climates that are amenable to growth. Entrepreneurs and other small businessesthe primary drivers of employmenthave a higher chance of profitability and survival when they are free to control costs and negotiate with workers directly. Their success increases employment opportunities in the region.

Right to work laws attract businesses and create more jobs and ultimately create more prosperity and wealth for individuals, Hogan said in a phone interview with the Washington Free Beacon .

About half of states currently have right-to-work laws on the books. Even traditional union strongholds are beginning to embrace such policies to drive growth. Indiana and Michigan became the 23rd and 24th right to work states in 2012, despite strenuous union opposition.

However, the business community has celebrated the new policies. Michigan jumped 21 places in the American Economic Development Institutes annual ranking of business-friendly states , making it the most-improved state of 2014. Nine out of the top 10 states are right to work.

A handful of states have shown exemplary leadership in growing their economies and employment base while countering these trends by improving their business environment, adding new companies and growing existing companies, corporate relocation expert Dr. Ron Pollina said in a release. These states have broken the bonds that hold others back and positioned themselves for success today, tomorrow and the remainder of the decade, which is a remarkable achievement in the aftermath of the Great Recession.

Workers, as well as businesses, prosper under friendly business climates, according to Hogan. While labor groups contend that higher union presence can create higher wages, the CEI study found that it also limits job creation, ultimately undermining competitiveness and job opportunities.

The shortsighted view says unionization will raise wages, but the consequences of those increased costs means businesses are less drawn to that state and that state will have less growth, Hogan said. Increases in productivity encourage capital resource investment and creates long-term positive effects.

A prime example of the ill effects of unionization has been the migration of automobile manufacturing away from traditionally union-friendly states to southern right-to-work states such as Tennessee, despite the increased costs of building new infrastructure. Right to work states effectively lured carmakers to build new factories in the states, leading to a proliferation of union-free workplaces and job growth in the south, while Detroit experienced a population exodus.

Over the 31-year period, nationwide total employment grew by 71 percent. RTW states significantly outpaced this average, with employment growing by 105.3 percent. Non-RTW states lagged behind both, with an employment growth of only 50.0 percent, the study says. More jobs were created in the RTW states, despite their having much smaller initial populations and labor force.

Right to work advocates said that worker rights are also crucial to economic advances.
While right to work is about employee freedom in the workplace, this analysis also shows that rolling back coercive union power has undeniable economic benefits as well, National Right to Work Foundation spokesman Anthony Riedel said.

Workers have followed job opportunities. States without right to work laws saw their populations decrease by about five percent in the first decade of the 21st century, while right to work states have grown by about five percent. Hogan predicts that this disparity will only grow over time as employers continue to expand in right to work states, but policymakers are capable of reversing the trend.

Theres a distinct labor migration to right to work states because theres more opportunity. People are voting with their feet, Hogan said. The south and right to work states writ large have been the beneficiaries of unionization in the north, but you will see a different trajectory in Michigan and Indiana going forward.

~~Link~~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

I see you haven't been keeping up with the statistics John.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Sixpick

CEI is hardly an unbiased or non-partisan organization.

Total unionizationis not the answer to out economic woes and challenges, but neither is the elimination of unions. No reasonable person is going to dispute that unions have played a vital role in the transformation of the middle class and the establishment of safety, wage and hour, environmental protection and other guidelines whose importance is obvious. That same reasonable person is also aware that unions and union practices over the years (no matter how well intentioned initially) have led to unanticipated and averse consequences for the economy and the middle class.

As it usually is the answer to "How much unionization is enough?" is in the middle of "None" and "Total"

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

That may well be true and I agree in many areas in the above comments, but if you don't have a job because you have priced yourself out of the competition then it doesn't really matter how much you would have made if the company was still in business or still in the USA.

Robert, do you think "Talking Union" is any less biased? LOL

I would say the states that are the best for business are the most likely places to find a job which may not pay as well as the union job you would have if the company was still open for business or not located in China now. Sure everyone wants more pay, but you have to have a company that is still here or open to have that job.

The Best States for Business and Careers

Funny, I almost thought that out of the 50 states Illinois wasn't even on it until I realized it was number 38 out of 50. I notice the top states are "Right to Work States". So we don't make as much money, but we have a job at least and the opportunity to succeed is evidently better than quite a few of the "Union" states.

Why do you think the Unions now want all these illegals in this country? It is so they can legalize low wages. These people are illegal now, so they can't do it. The Chamber of Commerce is owned by the Corporations, so they want all these illegal aliens given amnesty as well. Funny how all these anti government types are now cheerleaders for their own demise today.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Robert, do you think "Talking Union" is any less biased? LOL

I do not, but that fact does not add credibility or impartiality to CEO either!

Both sources obviously have agendas and their interpretation and manipulation of data is to be viewed skeptically by all reasonable people.

A RTW state doe snot prohibit unions, in fact many unions are present in RTW states, there is simply a prohibition against union shops or forcing employees to join a union in order to get a job in a business where a union is present.

Businesses and communities in RTW states have flourished because even though wages are lower than in a union shop in another state, the wages are much higher than what was present in the area before hand (South Carolina and Boeing come to mind, as well as southern states with auto manufacturers located within their borders.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

You can be anti union and still realize that they are not the consummate evil any more than they are the redemption of the economy

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

John, I know you're accustomed to having the government as your leader and savior, but the cost of living around an area that has a lot of union workers or a "Union" state is higher, so understand it is not the same in a "Right to Work" state, so making a little less, being more competitive, working for a company which isn't on strike half the time, actually having a company that hiring instead of closing its doors or moving its operations overseas can be a good thing.

There are many companies here other than the Boeing which is in SC for a long time, but North Carolina really hasn't done that well until lately, like after the last election.

You see John, North Carolina has been under Democrat rule for over 100 years in the legislature and it has only been since the last election the Republicans have super majority. All the bad things about this state have been caused by the Democrats, but there was no protesting until the Republicans took control. You would think the world is coming to an end now with the commie groups flying back and forth to Washington every day to make their next plan.

I expect we will have a lot of "community organizers" opening up offices before the election like we did last time. They describe themselves as community helpers, but they all closed down right after the election.

I'll keep you informed, but you probably already have the memo.

 
 

Who is online





47 visitors