I am not a lawyer, not do I play one on News Talkers, but a cursory ready of the RFRA reveals that there is an exception clause which would seem to preclude the applicability of the RFRA provisions to the repayment of student loans.
The law provided an exception if two conditions are both met. First, the burden must be necessary for the furtherance of a compelling government interest. [ 3 ]
Under strict scrutiny, a government interest is compelling when it is more than routine and does more than simply improve government efficiency. A compelling interest relates directly with core constitutional issues. [ 4 ]
The second condition is that the rule must be the least restrictive way in which to further the government interest.
Also since student loans are entered into voluntarily, rather than by mandate (e.g. the ACA) it would seem that the Hobby Lobby decision (relative to the RFA) would not be germane.
I assume amac is trolling. The contract clause of the constitution makes enforcing contracts the epitome of a compelling government interest. Governmental interests don't get more compelling than enforcing express constitutional mandates.
You assume somewhat correctly, Sean; I am breaking balls ... But not entirely. There are cases coming that will test the way the Scotus worded the HL decision.
All you laughin' boys don't seem to grasp that we're talking about part of a law that the SCOTUS narrowly overturned. Another case could arise and flip one of the Justice's votes.Do you think it can't happen?
I used the "student as a person" example as a prototype; when you think about it as compared with a corporation, you cannot help but at least wonder how the two can not be seen as either equivalent or self-contradicting.
Think also of the "personhood" legislation ... a big favorite of the right-wing base. If an embryo has rights under the 14th Amendment as personhood proponents want, does not a student claiming religious exemption to a legal obligation also have "personhood" rights?
It can't be both ways and somewhere along the way, the obvious contradictions will materialize in a case in a lower court.
Ultimately it may be in regard to CU or some other precedent ... or, maybe Congress will have to deal with it.
But a corporation, if it can have a "sincerely held religious belief," then on what Constitutional basis can i.e. a student, etc., be denied the same?This will go beyond Hobby Lobby -- it will come down to "a person," "the law" and whether or not a person's, as well as a corporations religious belief ALONE, can trump a law.
Looking at this myopically, one will not see the shit storm on the horizon; but it's coming.
I assure you, it is not over ... It's only the beginning.
Student loans however are not forgivable under US bankruptcy law.
Again, I used the "student" as a prototype. The interest rates on these loans can be reduced by Congressional action how low do they need to be lowered to be virtually "forgiven." But again, the graphic which is not mine -- was e-mailed to who knows how many people and
It is not, from my perspective, about student loans nor Hobby Lobby, it's about the legal definition of "a person," the right of "persons" to challenge laws on the basis of their "sincerely held religious beliefs," PARTICULARLY WHEN THE BELIEF(S) CITED IS DEMONSTRABLY FALSE!
The question of the legality of slavery in the U.S. is settled law via the 13th amendment
And the SCOTUS UPHELD THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF THE ACA! So it seems nothing is without a potentially viable challenge or Amendment or repeal or members of Congress getting frightened of a backlash and overriding SCOTUS decisions with new laws.
RFRA.
Freedom Not to Pay.
Got lots of biblical quotes that could be among one's "sincerely held religious beliefs."
And while I am no fan of organized religion, well-considered ideas no matter what their origin, work for me.
I am not a lawyer, not do I play one on News Talkers, but a cursory ready of the RFRA reveals that there is an exception clause which would seem to preclude the applicability of the RFRA provisions to the repayment of student loans.
Also since student loans are entered into voluntarily, rather than by mandate (e.g. the ACA) it would seem that the Hobby Lobby decision (relative to the RFA) would not be germane.
Let us know when you get to argue it in front of the Supreme Court. We'll all come and watch. I'll bring the popcorn.....
All of this could be straightened out if congress just passed improved legislation to replace RFRA .
Really that is how you think the issue will be addressed?
Seriously?
I think you are right about that, but repaying student loans will not be the issue
Reductio ad absurdum
The question of the legality of slavery in the U.S. is settled law via the 13th amendment
Reductio ad absurdum
I wonder how they came about the "every seven years", though...
Why not every year, or every other year? Maybe, something to do with the seventh day?
I used the "student as a person" example as a prototype; when you think about it as compared with a corporation, you cannot help but at least wonder how the two can not be seen as either equivalent or self-contradicting.
Think also of the "personhood" legislation ... a big favorite of the right-wing base. If an embryo has rights under the 14th Amendment as personhood proponents want, does not a student claiming religious exemption to a legal obligation also have "personhood" rights?
It can't be both ways and somewhere along the way, the obvious contradictions will materialize in a case in a lower court.
Ultimately it may be in regard to CU or some other precedent ... or, maybe Congress will have to deal with it.
But a corporation, if it can have a "sincerely held religious belief," then on what Constitutional basis can i.e. a student, etc., be denied the same? This will go beyond Hobby Lobby -- it will come down to "a person," "the law" and whether or not a person's, as well as a corporations religious belief ALONE, can trump a law.
Looking at this myopically, one will not see the shit storm on the horizon; but it's coming.
I assure you, it is not over ... It's only the beginning.
Petey is correct and it may in fact play out as he speculates.
Again, I used the "student" as a prototype. The interest rates on these loans can be reduced by Congressional action how low do they need to be lowered to be virtually "forgiven." But again, the graphic which is not mine -- was e-mailed to who knows how many people and
It is not, from my perspective, about student loans nor Hobby Lobby, it's about the legal definition of "a person," the right of "persons" to challenge laws on the basis of their "sincerely held religious beliefs," PARTICULARLY WHEN THE BELIEF(S) CITED IS DEMONSTRABLY FALSE!
And the SCOTUS UPHELD THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF THE ACA! So it seems nothing is without a potentially viable challenge or Amendment or repeal or members of Congress getting frightened of a backlash and overriding SCOTUS decisions with new laws.
Serious topics deserve serious and civil debate
And by the way, two half dollars equal $1 not $.50 but of course that is simply details right?
Actually, it's one half dollar, head and tail side.
But on this, I agree
Actually two coins are pictured but I will concede that it could be two pictures of the same coin