Americans are down on America...What happened to our freedom?
Thats the bottom line in a new Gallup poll measuring the extent of freedom in 135 countries. Only 79% of Americans say theyre satisfied with their freedom to choose what to do with their lives, down from 87% in 2008. The top five nations where people feel most satisfied with their freedoms are New Zealand, Australia, Cambodia, Sweden and the United Arab Emirates. At No. 33, the United States is sandwiched between Bahrain and Cameroon.
Gallup doesnt define freedom in this poll, so citizens of different countries are likely to interpret the word differently. Thats why Cambodians enjoying peaceful elections as they recover from years of war rank among the top five. Still, changes over time show whether people in a given nation feel their freedoms are improving or deteriorating.
The United States is one of the few places where freedoms appear to be on the wane. Of the 100 countries where Gallup measured changes in freedom during the past five years, 75 of them registered an improvement, while 21 registered a decline. Four stayed the same. Of the decliners, only five nations report sharper drops than the United States. Two of them Syria and Afghanistan are dominated by armed uprisings. Two others Tajikistan and Thailand are racked with political turmoil. Luxembourg, the most prosperous of the decliners, has become a target of U.S. and European authorities going after tax evaders with foreign accounts.
A newfound humility
Such unruly company seems to have knocked some of the swagger out of the typical American. In a separate set of polls by Pew Research , the percentage of Americans who believe the United States stands above all other countries dropped from 38% in 2011 to 28% in 2014. Young Americans are least impressed with their home country, with only 15% of 18-29-year-olds saying the United States is the worlds No. 1 nation. Among seniors, 40% feel that way but still, that's down from 50% just three years ago.
That newfound humility corresponds with an economic comedown that is looking permanent for an uncomfortably large portion of Americans. The recession that ended in 2009 ravaged the economic fortunes of many American families, with median household wealth still about 40% lower than it was before the recession. Jobs have finally started to return, but for many workers, pay is lower than it used to be . People feel theyre falling behind, and the data show theyre not imagining things. Thats a loss of economic freedom, which impacts other choices.
Many Americans seem to question the basic premise that everybody can get ahead in the so-called land of the free. A recent analysis by USA Today found living the American Dream, loosely defined, costs a typical family of four roughly $130,000 per year. Thats in a country where the median household income is only about $53,000, or less than half of whats needed for a middle-class lifestyle.
One can quibble with USA Todays methodology, which includes nearly $5,000 for an annual one-week vacation, $3,700 for dining out every year and thousands more for college and retirement funds. Many people live comfortably without such extras. Yet part of the American Dream (which itself has never been clearly defined) is the financial stability that comes from knowing youve got enough money to continually improve your living standards and handle any surprises that may pop up.
Such tangible declines in middle-class living standards represent the most important economic trend in a generation. The recovery that followed the recession and began in 2009 has been the weakest since the 1930s. A gridlocked Washington may deserve some of the blame, yet digital technology and globalization have allowed companies to locate work wherever its cheapest and replace employees with computers, robots and other gizmos. Americans are rightly fed up with their government but there may not be all that much Washington can do to reinvigorate an economy that still has too much debt clogging its veins.
A fresh dose of humility, ironically, may help get America back on track. Americans love to chant Were No. 1! but, when asked their own opinions, they clearly believe were not anymore. As people complain about tough times, though, theyre also recalibrating their priorities and plotting comeback strategies. Developing an underdog mentality is a good start.
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/americans-are-down-on-america-190304928.html
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

I am not down on America; I am down on the politicians who are running it into the ground.
Well then you would be completely ignoring the NSA, Patriot act HR347 and many other laws and institutes that have come to being in the last decade. Ignoring these facts simply makes the problem worse...the less people complain, the less freedom we will have as new laws and institutions are invented. Denying a problem exists many times will enable it to continue.
I think a consumption tax would be most fair too. But somehow I have trouble believing the Democrats would be on board with it. It would be more difficult to redistribute wealth.
I think its a good idea. Also, a flat tax rate of say, 10%, across the board. Evens the playing field.
I agree with this statement about entitlements to a point-- exclude the elderly, who can't find a job, anyway. And, pay a decent wage so that one can live in a safe neighborhood while working a minimum wage job. Notice that I did not say lavish, I said safe. One shouldn't be able to get more $$ from the government than what one can earn in a 40 hour week at a minimum wage job.
I don't honestly know if people feel they are too good to work, or if the work doesn't pay enough to live on. I'm not talking lavish lifestyles, I'm talking a basic lifestyle. In this, since cable has replaced antennas, they need basic cable service. Everyone needs cheap entertainment, a way to relax, and if they have a TV, they are busy. A cell phone can be basic, and cheaper to use than a landline. Seriously! Or a pay as you go phone.
Anyone, give me one concrete example of something you were free to do as an American, that you are no longer free to do.
Specifics?
Visit Mexico or Canada without a passport.
I should say... return from a visit to Mexico or Canada without a passport.
Here's one: Freedom of privacy.
Send emails without someone collecting them. Talk on the phone in private. We have lost freedom of privacy.
Our children used to be able to sing songs about America during school programs without being told it would offend certain students in the school.
Our children used to be able to wear patriotic clothing to school without being told it would offend the illegal aliens attending the school.
We used to not fear gestapo tactics from law enforcement involving anything from a minor traffic incident to a no-knock blitzkrieg entry into our homes, even if they have the wrong address... and often kill innocent civilians.
We used to not have to compete with the millions and billions of dollars corporations can now use openly to buy candidates and influence legislation.
We used to be free to express extreme displeasure of the president and government without being called a racist, and without fearing someone from Homeland Security or the IRS would invoke the Patriot Act to comb through our personal lives looking for a way to sabotage us.
Case in point.....but WHY John? Rich people consume more and buy luxury items and therefore would pay more taxes....no loopholes. The poor, who spend less, will pay less. What's the problem?
Just because you don't know your privacy is being violated does not mean it isn't being violated. The amount of data they are collecting on average Americans is staggering. But, hey, what you don't know won't hurt you right?
USA Freedom Act
And that started when, by whom but it's continued under Obama and is just as objectionable although Democrats have, since Snowden blew the whistle, tried to do something about it. But Issa et others weakened the attempt (USA FREEDOM ACT).
But have you bitched about Google and FaceBook and all the sites log and sell your private, personal information? Have you told them to stop? Have you left them in protest?
Can you give me some specifics?
Three Felonies A Day
Our freedoms have been slowly slipping away for quite some time. The NSA has been around for quite a while, but only now does it have the ability to be in everyone's life 24 hours a day. We spent too many years thinking we were safe and happy because the government told us we were safe and happy.
Albertson's doesn't have courtesy cards, but I still get coupons for the dog food I just bought, or the V-8. Pretty amazing stuff isn't it?
I don't believe any of our rights have been absolutely removed, yet. There is the sense that they are becoming more restricted. This started at the very beginning. Just look at what happened in the with the Alien and Sedition Acts 1798.
People who believe it is the President that is the problem, don't really understand the problem nor the structure of their government.
Well the article is about loss of freedom, it doesn't really try to point blame although the fact that the median income is 40% lower than when the recession started doesn't look to good for Obama notw that you brought it up.
Bullshit. All that bill would have done is shifted who stored the data. The Amash sponsored bill would have done the most to stop this BS but Pelosi who pretends to protect our privacy rallied the troops to defeat the bill and succeeded.
...
...
Yes yes and yes
Then I commend you for being consistent and not hypocritical.
The NSA spying was known well before Snowden. The room with the Yellow Door at AT&T in San Francisco for example. That was under Bush and many conservatives who bitch now, uttered not a peep back then.
Again, you know I bitch about selective indignation.
...things have gotten worse on Obama's watch despite his promises to the contrary. We have already determined that when it comes to invading our privacy and infringing on the freedom of Americans there is wonderful bipartisanship. You can try to blame it all on the Republicans ...but that would make you FOS in the eyes of anyone paying attention.
Amac,
That does not change the fact that this bill was bullshit. All it did was change who holds the collected data and shifting this to the phone companies would actually exasperate the problem as even more data would be collected. Don't let the name fool you. (there is nothing patriotic about the patriot act either) This was a bullshit bill out forth to please those who are not paying attention. Read the Amash bill and this one and tell me which would have actually made a difference. (the fact you are touting this bill as something good tells me you either didn't read it or you don't understand it.)
Amac asked for an example that has affected me. This has affected me... so I gave it as an example.
It is a "right" in our constitution and it was a "right" to move internationally in history...
It is also a "right" by the International bill of rights
All of that said... I'm not disputing the reason for the restriction. I am however stating, for the record, that it is a right that I lost in 2005-ish and that affected me personally. Which is what the question was for.They used to have customer cards... now they just track you by your CC#.
They turn a blind eye in Colorado and Washington... maybe you need to energize your state.
I'm hoping MJ breaks the mold and allows scheduled drugs to move down in category... that has never happened.
It's not the president... it's the system of government...
Starting with Anarchy... there is an organization...
From that organization... there is a system...
From that system... there are flaws...
From those flaws... come more rules/laws...
From those rules/laws... come more restriction...
From that restriction... comes people who wish to return to anarchy
Maybe we are just ready to hit restart? I hate the thought of anarchy though.
You are so kind Fish. I do have a Fed ID now... so I'm good... but I will keep that in mind if I'm ever on the wrong side of the fence.
Do you think the direct line buses and trains will still be running for a while?
If you keep you head in the ground long enough, someone will come up behind you and kick you in the ass.
I'm not sure if he knows about that 96. Let's ask Nancy. She knows.
Patriot Act - 'nuff said.
And we need to get rid of the repressive Dems
The question was what happened to our freedom. Not where or when it started. What has happened to it, has been happening for about 20 years and it is gaining momentum. BTW where it is going is of utmost importance, don't you think?
This discussion is about restricting freedoms.
Yes I have the right, but that right has been restricted.
The restrictions are not much, but it is an increase over what I used to do prior.
It is an example to the question posed.
There are losses of freedom that comes with an organized society... it's the nature of the beast.
I think it is a pretty big loss of freedom when the Federal Government can make me pay a tax for not buying a product.
Kind of like how you get ticketed for not having auto insurance?
Amac,
I would like to encourage you again to read the USA freedom act and pay special attention that this act would only shift who is in charge of some data from the NSA to phone companies. The way it is written, they would have had access to even more private information. The Amash bill would have restricted the collection, which is what we need. The USA freedom act was nothing more than a measure to pacify people who aren't paying close enough attention while actually EXPANDING the invasion of privacy. Read them both again and I think you will understand my point.
96, see bottom paragraph.
NSA-Reforming USA Freedom Act Passes House Committee
More stringent protections against domestic surveillance spiked in interest of speed.
...
Amac,
You are still not getting it. This bill shifted the responsibility of holding records from the NSA to the phone company. The problem with this is that they would actually have MORE of our phone records to violate. It does nothing to stop this unconstitutional practice of collecting or accessing the data without a warrant. So to review, this bill would essentially force the phone companies to do what the NSA is currently doing with little to no other restrictions. How does that give us any privacy back? It doesn't. The Amash bill actually restricted this activity and is the only bill offered so far that would do so. The Amash bill, which is the only one offered so far to actually PROTECT our privacy, was killed by Pelosi and her posse.
So you are showing me that Republicans swatted a bill that would have made virtually no difference as far as our privacy is concerned and I am showing you that the Democrats swatted back a bill that actually WOULD have protected our privacy. I really don't care what party affiliation the assholes who are doing this claim. The fact that it was Pelosi who pretends to give a crap about your privacy should merely be an eye opener. As should the fact that they made the "US freedom act" bill to pacify people who are upset about privacy infringement, but who are not paying close enough attention..... this bill is a white lie made to make you (or at least those who are not watching closely) feel better. NOTHING ELSE.
I believe I do get it 96.
Amac,
I don't believe you get it. The bill you are talking about is a pacifier. The bill I am talking about would have stopped the collection of private phone data without a warrant. The bill I am talking about would have given us our freedom of privacy back. At least for phone data, we still have a ways to go.
Give you specifics on the first two? Come on, AMac!. We spent pages and pages of comments on the subject of the California school that would not allow the child to wear a T-shirt with the American flag on it because the principal said it would upset the Hispanic students. It went all the way to the Supreme Court.
As for the kids not being allowed to sing American patriotic songs... that happened in New York when the black principal refused to allow the (fifth grade?) graduating class to sing Lee Greenwood's song, saying at first it was "too adult" a song for the young students. When the teachers had the class sing it for her, perfectly, she then said it would upset the non-Americans and "new" Americans in the class. This was in the news, front pages, for about a week.
As for the other, just because some people are so stupid and bigoted doesn't mean that everyone who expresses displeasure with the current president is a racist. The word has lost its bite and meaning, it has been tossed about so much.
There will always be isolated incidents perpetrated by stupid people.
It is not pervasive.
As for the bigotry/racism associated with Obama haters, I can offer "pervasive."
I dont.
I actually dont mind opening the borders.
Please stop projecting your conversation with other people on me.
Not very much like that . Auto insurance exists because cars are inherently dangerous . There is no equivalency to health insurance .
Thank God for no diseases, no auto accidents involving those inherently dangerous things, falls
not to mention having to pay $1100/year in extra premiums for those who go to the ER uninsured
All insurance is purchased with the hope it's never needed.
But, LIFE IS INHERENTLY DANGEROUS.
Better to have it and not need it than to need it and not have it.
Really? Give me a break. We still have the Patriot act under his rule. Yes I know he didn't start it but he always continues the worst Bush policies doesn't he? Have you heard of NDAA? You don't think losing the right to due process is a big deal? How about HR347? I could go on, but I know it's a waste of time so TTFN.
Shit happens all the time . But far more of it happens in cars . Speed kills quickly and easily . Car accidents are the #1 cause of death and dismemberment in the US .
If the elderly could get reduced health insurance for wearing fall protection there might be some sense in forcing them to buy insurance . But that is not a provision ...
Not in the US . Any country that suffers an invasion on its space tends to have a lot of communicable disease .
So ... I'm guessing you expect people to live forever . Eventually we all succumb to something . And modern medicine can't stop that from happening .