╌>

Federal judge tells Supreme Court to 'STFU' after Hobby Lobby ruling

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  cm  •  12 years ago  •  49 comments

Federal judge tells Supreme Court to 'STFU' after Hobby Lobby ruling

Federal judge tells Supreme Court to 'STFU' after Hobby Lobbyruling

There are a good amount of people upset with the Supreme Court over its Hobby Lobby decision , and you can count federal judgeRichard Kopf among them. Kopf, an H.W. Bush appointee to the Nebraska District Court, has the unusual habit (for a federal judge) of maintaining a blog about his thoughts on the court system and often unfiltered thoughts at that. On Saturday, Kopf took to his blog to argue that perhaps the Supreme Court shouldn't have taken on the Hobby Lobby case at all, thus not setting a wide precedent and allowing the executive or legislative branches of government work out a solution. "As the kids says," Kopf writes, "it is time for the court to STFU."

Kopf doesn't touch on the legal elements of the decision, but he breaks down how it appears from the outside: partisan, sexist, religiously motivated. "To the average person, the result looks stupid and smells worse," Kopf writes.

In part, this is why Kopf argues that the court should start taking a lighter touch when dealing with major issues. He cites legal philosopher Alexander Bickel in arguing that the Supreme Court should generally avoid highly controversial cases unless the fate of the nation is at hand. "What would have happened if the Supreme Court simply decided not to take the Hobby Lobby cases?" Kopf asks. "Had the court sat on the sidelines, I dont think any significant harm would have occurred. The most likely result is that one or more of the political branches of government would have worked something out. Or not."

In closing, Kopf argues that the court has been causing more harm than good by taking on such controversial cases recently. While the Supreme Court has the power to decide those, Kopf quite bluntly suggests that the court recognize that it has the power to avoid cases as well.

http://www.theverge.com/2014/7/7/5877273/federal-judge-tells-scotus-to-stfu-after-hobby-lobby


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Well, I think he may be right...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

He thinks that the court should only decide easy and popular cases

Kopf is suggesting using the Obama approach to politics ? Maybe he is planning on running for office ...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Are you two, Robert G and Petey children??? The Judge suggests the SC not get involved in controversial matters, SC are now voting according to their political affiliations and their friends affiliations, you know, the Koch Brothers and other Billionaires...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Childish ? How about suggesting that a judge appointed for life needs wealthy friends...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

the Supreme Court should generally avoid highly controversial cases

The dumbest damn thing I have ever heard!

That logic would mean that we would not have had decisions cases such as Roe v Wade, Brown vs Board, Miranda vs Arizona

Perhaps this judge should take his own advice and STFU!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

That logic would mean that we would not have had decisions cases such as Roe v Wade, Brown vs Board, Miranda vs Arizona

Actually there's another interesting aspect to this. Cases that, by their nature, not highly controversial, more often than not do not make it to the Supreme Court. Relatively non-controversial cases are much easier to settle in the lower courts-- and so they usually are.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Cases that, by their nature, not highly controversial, more often than not do not make it to the Supreme Court

Excellent point!

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

"As the kids says," Kopf writes, "it is time for the court to STFU." Kopf doesn't touch on the legal elements of the decision, but he breaks down how it appears from the outside: partisan, sexist, religiously motivated. "To the average person, the result looks stupid and smells worse," Kopf writes.

I think it would be more useful if Kopf explained the decision for those who don't understand it rather than urge the court to avoid making decisions that are hard for people to understand. Kopf's view that the political branches would have worked this out is at best naive and at worst just plain stupid. The Obama administration was steamrolling corporations like Hobby Lobby, in spite of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and a fractured Congress wasn't going to do anything to stop it. The Supreme Court took the case and decided it as the Constitution intended for them to do. The reason the Justices have life-time appointments is so they can do what's right, not just what's easy.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Nothing about the topic ? Thanks much for your shitty commentary ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I wasn't talking to you !

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

The Obama administration was steamrolling corporations like Hobby Lobby, in spite of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and a fractured Congress wasn't going to do anything to stop it.

So I take it you're not entirely in agreement with the view some have expressed here: that this single decision has totally turned America into a Theocracy? And/or a

heck-- maybe even worse than a Theocratic Plutocracy!115.gif

(or is it a Plutocratic Theocracy?)

And so it begins:

hangin-with-pluto.jpg

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

He sounds like a sensible gentleman. Let's run him for president!

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

So, the court should only take on simple and transparent items that the average Joe can fully understand and comprehend? That's one of the stupidest ideas I've ever heard. The Supreme Court is there to decide highly complex issues that can't be resolved at lower levels (like where this guy lives), and many of these are not understood by the 'Average joe'. It's not the court's job to make the average Joe or anyone else happy. Maybe the court should help naming the next Kim and Kanye baby-that way everyone can understand in simple single syllable words.

BTW, who is H.W. Bush? I understand whohe is referring to, but is that just laziness on the part of the author or just failure to proofread?

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

The Judge suggests the SC not get involved in controversial matters, SC are now voting according to their political affiliations and their friends affiliations, you know, the Koch Brothers and other Billionaires...

Nothing but assumption on your part, CM. So the other side of the court is voting according to their political affiliation, in other words, however Soros tells them to vote? Oh wait, becuase they are on your side of the fence they are good and altruistic jurists?

Someone said Childish about 2 others? The kids inRomper Room complaining about the other kids in Romper Room? Yup.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I think he's right. The Supreme Court should never have heard the case to begin with.

However, it does highlight the great divide between, not only political boundaries, but among men and women. As a woman, I don't feel that we're making any headway, at all, toward equality. I notice that none of these decisions, discussions, etc., revolve around the use of Viagra or Viagra-like medications. I also notice that most of those who support the Hobby Lobby decision, have no idea about the female physiology-- it's obvious, based on the statements they make.

Are they uneducated, or just can't be bothered with insignificant trivia?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

No, I don't think that at all. But I don't think their latest decision has served them well. They are supposed to be unbiased, but they are not. Once again, the paternalistic society is dictating what one half of the population can do or not do-- this time, they are using the excuse of "religious freedom", but what it seems to be is "corporate funds".

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

As a woman, I don't feel that we're making any headway, at all, toward equality. I notice that none of these decisions, discussions, etc., revolve around the use of Viagra or Viagra-like medications. I also notice that most of those who support the Hobby Lobby decision, have no idea about the female physiology-- it's obvious, based on the statements they make.

Thank you Dowser, you have said it so elegantly, that is why I commented on this topic last week that "MEN" who are not in the Medical Field especially Gynecology, should not comment on the subject, they will "NEVER" understand what is going on in a female's body physiologically, "NEVER" so since they do not know or care to know, as the good Judge said STFU!!!!!! If I were to visit my Primary Care Physician with a female issue, him being a doctor for more than 40years, I would be given a referral to a GYN and told "I do not know ENOUGH about female issues, although I am a doctor, you need a specialist"......

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Spike: As far as I know, I could be wrong, "NONE" of those Justices have a Medical Degree, or perhaps knows anything about Female Health, I wanna bet, not one Gynecologist gave testimony as an expert witness, THEY DO NOT KNOW...SHITE!!!! about women, I can understand why the Female Justices were so angry at the decision, MEN making decisions for Women, Women are going to take over the Leadership of this Country, slowly but surely....

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
All court cases involving woman should be decided by women. And only blacks can understand blacks. And only white men can sit Im judgment on white men..etc etc...

Progressives turning the clock back by centuries...

Charles Cooke on the lefts inability to even grasp the role of the Supreme Court:

"One cannot help but wonder whether (progressives)are aware of what the Supreme Court actually does which, as anybody who has even a fleeting grasp of American civics knows, is not to set American policy, on health or anything else, but to interpret and uphold the law. In this particular case, the justices were called to judge whether a mandate that was pushed out by the Obama administration in 2012 was in conflict with another law, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, that was added to the books in 1992. This being so, the degree to which those who decided the case are experts on womens health is wholly immaterial. The justices are jurists not doctors they are nine appointed attorneys whose role in the American settlement is to provide legal answers to legal questions. Man or woman; straight or gay; handsome or ugly; Jew, Catholic, or protestant the law must remain the law, regardless of in whose name its intricacies are decided. The alternative would be disastrous. Does Harry Reid aspire to see Roe v. Wade, which was decided by nine men, overturned?"
 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

All court cases involving woman should be decided by women. And only blacks can understand blacks. And only white men can sit Im judgment on white men..etc etc...

Simplistic response, My comment mentioned Expert Testimony, and BTW, this case was decided only on religious issues there was nothing about the constitution in there decisions...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

You can spin it any any direction you like, Friends doing favors for friends in high places, give me a break, is that concept new to you????

Advocacy Group Says Justices May Have Conflict in Campaign Finance Cases

WASHINGTON When the conservative financier Charles Koch sent out invitations for a political retreat in Palm Springs later this month, he highlighted past appearances at the gathering of notable leaders like Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas of the Supreme Court .

A leading liberal group is now trying to use that connection to argue that Mr. Scalia and Mr. Thomas should disqualify themselves from hearing campaign finance cases because they may be biased toward Mr. Koch, a billionaire who has been a major player in financing conservative causes.

I TRY NOT TO POST ANYTHING THAT IS NOT DOCUMENTED, I UNDERSTAND ABOUT LIBEL OR DEFAMATION OF CHARACTER:

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

"One cannot help but wonder whether (progressives)are aware of what the Supreme Court actually does which, as anybody who has even a fleeting grasp of American civics knows, is not to set American policy, on health or anything else, but to interpret and uphold the law. In this particular case, the justices were called to judge whether a mandate that was pushed out by the Obama administration in 2012 was in conflict with another law, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, that was added to the books in 1992.

They ruled based on religion, but they knew the Law was about Health Care and they knew the Four Items Hobby Lobby did not want to Cover in the health package was about contraception, therefore there ruling affects women directly, this ruling is a back door erosion of the Abortion Law...Roe vs Wade...

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

It's not limiting what choice a woman makes, it's limiting the company's liability to pay for those choices a woman (and sometimes a man makes)-and in this particular case, something that is very optional. And at that, only in a very limited manner.

I've seen the endometriosis argument, but I do not believe the court found anything wrong with regular birth control-only the 'regrets on monday morning' type birth control.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

As to women taking over the country? We'll all probably be better off for it. Were the cases that were heard before making it to the SCOTUS level involving Gynecologists? As a matter of course, the court (and the young folks that do the lion's share of research for the justices) looks at case history and testimony as part of their decision making process. Addiitonally, look at the narrowness of the ruling........

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

I also don't think Viagara or any of those similar drugs should be paid for through this either. But again, look at the narrowness of this ruling. Are the typical birth control pills addressed or is it more the morning after type pills?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

From what I have read it is the typical birth control pills, IUDs, and the morning after pills. It is state law in KY that any health insurance company that covers Viagra-type meds must also cover birth control pills, etc. I look forward to KY dingdonging about that...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

CM

You are 100% correct and their ruling does not in any way say what type of contraception a woman can, should, can't, or shouldn't use so no medical background is needed to adjudicate the case.

The court ruled that the company did not have to provide insurance that covered contraception not that the women could not use or have contraception.

Facts screw up the rant for sure, but those are the facts.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Once again, the paternalistic society is dictating what one half of the population can do or not do-- this time, they are using the excuse of "religious freedom", but what it seems to be is "corporate funds".

I take it that you find the dissent unbiased rather than a maternalistic society dictating what one half of the population can or cannot do.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

You are reading meanings into my words that are not there. I hope for an egalitarian society. That three dissenters were women should have given the court a preview of how women, in general, feel about the ruling.

How are the women of the world telling the men what to do? I am mystified. Seeking justice, from a non-political entity, should be egalitarian.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Thank you Dowser, you have said it so elegantly, that is why I commented on this topic last week that "MEN" who are not in the Medical Field especially Gynecology, should not comment on the subject, they will "NEVER" understand what is going on in a female's body physiologically, "NEVER" so since they do not know or care to know, as the good Judge said STFU!!!!!!

Those women who think you need to know the female body in order to apply the law to a particular set of facts are not suited to be judges.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Exactly; SCOTUS and all the rest of our courts should be about the business of protecting feelings, not Rights. Kopf seems to want a Supreme Court that even the dullest and dumbest of society can love and appreciate. What a crack-head.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Hobby Lobby was opposed to the "HEALTH CARE LAW" Period!!!!!!!!the ruling removed protection from WOMEN Period!!!!!!!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Hobby Lobby Invests in manufacturers of abortion drugs, what you are saying its ok to reap the profits of abortion drugs but not ok to pay for the purchase in their health plan..those drugs help women in certain health situations where other drugs do not work, that's what they removed...women who has health issues needs those drugs..

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Hobby Lobby was opposed to the "HEALTH CARE LAW" Period!!!!!!!!the ruling removed protection from WOMEN Period!!!!!!!

The court properly applied the law to the facts PERIOD!!

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Are the typical birth control pills addressed or is it more the morning after type pills?

It only covers 4 out of 16 contraceptive methods . . . the 4 being those that "may have the effect of preventing an already fertilized egg from developing any further by inhibiting its attachment totheuterus."

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Hobby Lobby Invests in manufacturers of abortion drugs, what you are saying its ok to reap the profits of abortion drugs but not ok to pay for the purchase in their health plan..those drugs help women in certain health situations where other drugs do not work, that's what they removed...women who has health issues needs those drugs..

I don't know or care how Hobby Lobby invests its own money and that wasn't at issue in this case. What I'm saying is that, BY LAW, the government cannot force Hobby Lobby to spend its own money on certain kinds of contraceptives over the company's religious objection unless the government; 1) has a compelling interest to do so; and 2) accomplishes that objective through the least restrictive means. If women need the drugs and can't pay for them, then nothing's stopping theObamaadministration from absorbing the cost the same way that it does with the non-profit organizations that it exempted fromtherequirement.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Irrelevant to the point of law adjudicated in this case.

HL (and certain other companies) will not be required to offer contraceptive coverage in their employee insurance plans, but the employees will still be able to use contraceptives if they so choose with the matter of who pays for those contraceptives to be worked out at this point.

And the women who have health issues and need those drugs for other than contraception will also still be able to get those drugs with the same caveat of who pays

I support a woman's right to use contraception just as I support a man's right to use Viagra but do not think that employer provided insurance need pay for either.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

How are the women of the world telling the men what to do? I am mystified. Seeking justice, from a non-political entity, should be egalitarian.

They got justice but, for some reason, you don't think so because the majority was comprised of men.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

I can understand why the Female Justices were so angry at the decision

Were the Female Justices upset at the ruling based on law or feelings? You seem to be saying that the Male judges just made a decision based on being men.....

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

A "BACK DOOR" way of eroding Roe vs Wade and you know it!!!!!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Not in the least

No restriction on abortion or access to contraceptives

Merely adjudication that certain employers are not required to provide contraceptive coverage in the employer provided medical insurance plans.

Read the decision, no prohibition whatsoever on a woman's right to use contraceptives or have an abortion.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

The court properly applied the law to the facts PERIOD!!

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

Dam I can't fix or delete my post. I'll try again.

The court properly applied the law to the facts PERIOD!!

Well to be exact, 5 old, white, Catholic men decided one way while all 3 women and the one old Jewish guy decided that the majority decision was was a real "dogs breakfast" of a mess.

Oh well these are the rules our Nation has agreed on so for now our country will just have to live with such a stupid decision but if history is any kind of guide this slap at women will eventually get corrected.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Hobby Lobby did offer those drugs in their health care plan prior to Obamacare made law, they then decided contraceptives of the kind was against their religious beliefs...hypocrites, is all I can say about HL...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Hypocrites perhaps but immaterial to the ruling

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

A "BACK DOOR" way of eroding Roe vs Wade and you know it!!!!!

It doesn't erode Roe vs Wade simply by recognizing that a woman does not have the unequivocal right to demand that her employer pay for her contraceptives over the employer's religious objection. By the shit yourself!

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Viagra treats a disorder, birth control pills do not (except in certain cases). There is no valid comparison.
 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

I will allow another female to respond to your statement, my response will, I am sure, be considered insensitive towards the use of Viagra....

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Judges at all levels, just like regular people, fight among themselves. They generally don't do it on the internet though.

 
 

Who is online





55 visitors