╌>

Tea Party phonies: Doing the conservative zigzag and right-wing flip-flop, based on who’s president

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  0 comments

Tea Party phonies: Doing the conservative zigzag and right-wing flip-flop, based on who’s president

250px-Salon_website_logo.png?width=100 By Paul Rosenberg

The Democratic Party is not as liberal as it was. The GOP is further right. Why do Republicans live in fantasyland?

tumblr_m8tteehgnS1qg0oiyo1_1280.jpg?width=500 Tea Party Fantasyland

Fifty years after its underlying polling was done, The Political Beliefs of Americans by Lloyd Free and Hadley Cantril remains the starting point for anyone who wants to understand the big picture of American political opinion. But a new report on political polarization from Pew adds important new information, even as it leaves some questions tantalizingly unanswered and/or underanalyzed. Most notably, the twin issues of whats driving polarization and how symmetric or asymmetric it is remain to be fully explored, while the greatest locus of continued agreement is overlooked.

In a section titled Is Polarization Asymmetrical? the study first suggests that Democrats are driving the process, before introducing two caveats. This finding is simply not credible in the America described by Norm Ornstein and Thomas Mann in Its Even Worse Than It Looks: How the American Constitutional System Collided With the New Politics of Extremism ,or, more basically, in the system thats produced the sharp rightward trend in roll call voting among congressional Republicans since 1980 (as mapped by the DW-Nominate scores of Keith Poole and colleagues) compared to a relatively modest leftward drift among Democrats. [ House mean , Senate mean .] Moreover, Pews report itself contains a variety of contradictory information not least the fact that the most consistent liberals are the people who most want political leaders willing to compromise.

While others have written extensively about Pews new report, Id like to focus more on questions raised, on whats not resolved, and that requires an initial discussion of why Free and Cantril remain relevant to this day. Their most innovative approach was the use of three different frameworks an ideological spectrum based on questions about government intrusion vs. individual self-reliance and the free market, an operational spectrum based on support for specific government spending programs, and self-identification as liberal, conservative or middle of the road. A key finding was that 50 percent of Americans were ideological conservatives, while 65 percent of Americans were operational liberals an overwhelming supermajority. More particularly, this psychological split manifested within the ranks of ideological conservatives: 46 percent of them were operational liberals, compared to just 26 percent who were operational conservatives. Thus, when you hear Tea Party Republicans say, Keep the governments hands off my Medicare! what youre actually hearing is just the tip of an iceberg that Free and Cantril were the first to discover and begin exploring.

The ideological and operational spectrums paint starkly different pictures of America with the self-identification scale falling in between, with a 38 percent plurality calling themselves middle of the road. One consequence of these two pictures was a suggested difference in how to identify core liberals and conservatives. Since so many people supported spending more money on the operational questions, the relatively small fraction who dont are prime candidates for the conservative label. Similarly, since so many people opposed government intervention on principle, those who dont are prime candidates for the liberal label. It makes sense to define these ideologies in different terms, because thats what produces relatively compact groups with coherent policy views on both sides.

Compared to Free and Cantril, Pews handling of the ideological spectrum represents a dramatic improvement in two fundamental ways: First, theyve created an ideological consistency scale that includes a broader range of issues, including questions on race, immigration, foreign policy, homosexuality and the environment several of which werent even salient political issues in 1964. Second, their questions are framed by presenting two contrasting positions and ask people to choose between them, whereas Free and Cantril presented one statement, and asked people to agree or disagree a practice now widely understood as biased toward agreement. Whats more, Pew uses its ideological consistency scale in a gradiated manner consistent or mostly liberal or conservative, with a mixed category in the middle which mirrors Free and Cantrils scale of complete or predominant ideologues, with a middle-of-the-road category between them, and Pew uses this scale consistently and creatively throughout its study.

Despite Pews excellent use of its ideological consistency scale, its important to understand whats not being captured in its analysis: the operational level, which is where much higher levels of agreement still reside. As an example of how ideological value statement questions differ from operational spending questions, consider what Pew has to say regarding spending on the poor, after noting that partisan divides have deepened on nearly every measure in the ideological consistency scale:

For instance, while Democrats have always been more supportive than Republicans of the social safety net, the partisan divide on these questions has increased substantially over the last 20 years. Two-thirds of Republicans (66%) believe that poor people today have it easy because they can get government benefits without doing anything in return; just 25% say poor people have hard lives because government benefits dont go far enough to help them live decently. Among Democrats, just 28% believe the poor have it easy. The partisan gap on this measure is now 38 points, up from 19 points in 1994 and 26 points in 2004.

Things look dramatically different, however, if we look at specific spending questions.

Read more


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc

Who is online





87 visitors