Repeal RFRA? One corporation is making that argument -- WSJ Best of the Web --James Taranto 7/3/2014
We feel obliged to give the Freedom From Religion Foundation some credit for forthrightness--though not in their self-description as "the nation's largest association of freethinkers." That's a euphemism for "atheists," but while some atheists think freely, the FFRF guys are doctrinaire as hell.
But FFRF's response to Burwell v. Hobby Lobby , while histrionic, is a good deal more honest, or at least better-informed, than much of the idiotic commentary we rounded up yesterday. Which isn't to say it's likely to be persuasive to anyone but true unbeliever.
Our faint praise is not unqualified. The response, a full-page ad in today's New York Times, includes a certain amount of blather. It approvingly quotes Justice John Paul Stevens: "Corporations have no consciences, no beliefs, no feelings, no thoughts, no desires."
To which we reply: Then shut up . Normally that wouldn't be much of an argument, but in this case the logic is impeccable. According to its Internal Revenue Service Form 990 , the Freedom From Religion Foundation Inc. is a corporation organized under Section 501(c)(3) of the U.S. tax code.
The ad from the Madison, Wis.-based group also includes a quote from its home city's namesake: "Liberty may be endangered by the abuses of liberty as well as by the abuses of power." That's from Federalist No.63 , and its applicability to the case at hand is dubious. Madison was arguing for "the utility of a senate," by which he meant a legislative body whose members would not be popularly elected. There's no word on whether the FFRF favors repeal of the 17th Amendment.
Still, the Madison quote amounts to an implicit acknowledgment of a truth many Hobby Lobby haters vehemently deny: that religious liberty was at stake in this case. The FFRF--if you'll pardon us for saying such a thing about a corporation--just doesn't like religious liberty.
The ad correctly notes: "The Hobby Lobby ruling is based not on the Constitution, but on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act." And it draws the logical conclusion from which most opponents have shrunk: "Congress must repeal RFRA." That is another implicit concession--that Hobby Lobby was, if not correctly decided, at least a reasonable interpretation of the law. If you don't like a law, try to change it.
So far so good, but the FFRF's rhetorical approach does not seem finely tuned for the purpose of winning political allies. The ad is more in the spirit of James Blaine than James Madison. It begins with a quote from birth-control (and eugenics) crusader Margaret Sanger, then, in large capital letters, declares: "Dogma Should Not Trump Our Civil Liberties. All-Male, All-Roman Catholic Majority on Supreme Court Puts Religious Wrongs Over Women's Rights."
Disparagement of males is commonplace in today's culture, but anti-Catholic bigotry still has a bad odor. It must be said, however, that the FFRF ad is not the first, or even the worst, example of it in the context of the ObamaCare mandate. A candidate for those superlatives is Jamie Stiehm , a syndicated columnist who in January denounced one of the Hobby Lobby dissenters as a papist for issuing a stay to a Catholic convent (or "nunnery," as Stiehm put it) seeking an exemption. An excerpt:
Et tu, Justice Sonia Sotomayor? Really, we can't trust you on women's health and human rights? The lady from the Bronx just dropped the ball on American women and girls as surely as she did the sparkling ball at midnight on New Year's Eve in Times Square. Or maybe she's just a good Catholic girl.
The Supreme Court is now best understood as the Extreme Court. One big reason why is that six out of nine Justices are Catholic.
We wish we'd remembered Stiehm's reference to the "Extreme Court" when we wrote about "Idiocracy" yesterday.
At the Puffington Host this week, Ronald Lindsay of the cryptically named Center for Inquiry (another atheist outfit, as best we can tell) puts forth a slightly higher-toned version of the same argument, if one can call it that. "The question needs to be asked," he claims: "Is it appropriate to have six Catholic justices on the Supreme Court?"
Well, there were six Protestants on the court as recently as 1993, the year the Religious Freedom Restoration Act became law. Did anyone ask if that was appropriate? Lindsay's claim is that the majority decision in Hobby Lobby "relies squarely on Catholic teaching about 'complicity' to explain the supposed burden" that the mandate imposes on the plaintiffs' religious liberty.
Lindsay thinks he's caught the majority bowing to Rome by rejecting the government's slippery-slope argument:
Presumably, employers who object to blood transfusions could refuse to provide such services to employees, Scientologist employers could refuse to provide for psychiatric care, and so forth, all on the grounds that doing so would facilitate immoral acts by others
But wait! Here the Court drew a line. As the majority emphasized, Hobby Lobby deals with contraception only. Other possible objections to health care coverage would present different considerations.
You're damn right they would. They would present considerations important to Jehovah's Witnesses, Scientologists, Christian Scientists, and the whole host of small minority religions that don't have the benefit of having six justices on the Supreme Court.
But the line the court drew wasn't between which mandates are subject to challenge under RFRA and which are not, only between the mandate at issue in this case and those that are not. It made a decision about the former and left the latter to be decided later if (and only if) someone raises such claims.
The claim that Catholic justices are hostile to the religious freedom of minority religions is bunk, and we've got two cases to debunk it. The first is Gonzales v. O Centro Esprita Beneficente Unio do Vegetal , a 2006 ruling in which the court sustained a RFRA claim brought by "a Christian spiritist sect based in Brazil." The vote was 8-0; four of the justices were Catholic, including the unanimous opinion's author, Chief Justice John Roberts. To this day not a single adherent of O Centro Esprita Beneficente Unio do Vegetal sits on the high court.
The other case is Hobby Lobby. The owners of the companies that brought that suit are a family of evangelical Christians. In the companion case, Conestoga Wood Specialties v. Burwell, the company seeking to vindicate its religious liberty is owned by Mennonites. The court may have six Catholic justices, but at least five of them take a small-c catholic approach to religious liberty.

Posted in honor of "free-thinking" contributor Hal.
Wheatons Burden
Editorial of The New York Sun | July 4, 2014
Those words from Justice Sotomayor will, we predict, go down as among the most notorious ever to issue from the high bench. She is dissenting from a temporary injunction issued by the Supreme Court to protect the rights of Wheaton College under the First Amendment. What the justice is saying is that she or the government knows better than Wheaton what constitutes a burden on Wheatons religious beliefs.
Continue Reading
More from Sun editorial:
What Wheaton objects to is not just that it has to fill out a government form. Its Christian principles dont object to government forms. It fills out all sorts of government forms. What Wheaton objects to is the substance of the form at issue here.
The form would inform its insurance company that the company must on its own underwrite the contraceptive coverage that Wheaton wont provide. Why should a religious institution be required to fill out such a form? If the government wants to make sure an insurance company knows something, let the government tell the confounded company. Otherwise it seems that government just wants to humiliate religion, force it to bow to the government rather than God.
That is a bad business. It is shocking that Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Ginsburg dont appreciate it.
It seems that there are more SCOTUS cases happening which require Congress to write new laws instead of relying on the SCOTUS default . But that does not seem likely to happen in the current political environment .
If Congress can't agree on a writing a new law, it's certainly not the Supreme Court's place act for them.
Agreed . The Citizens United decision was about the failure of congress to act . SCOTUS can't write laws . That is the job of congress .
Courts, not even SCOTUS, are making law all over the place.
Where have you and Peteybeen?
Give examples Len ...
Give examples Sean ...