╌>

The Right To Be Forgotten - A Stopwatch On Free Expression

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  larry-hampton  •  12 years ago  •  11 comments

The Right To Be Forgotten - A Stopwatch On Free Expression

Google Starts Scrubbing News Articles From Search After Court Ruling

Raising concerns about censorship and the freedom of the press, articles from major British news outlets are beginning to be removed from some Google search results after a European court ruling began allowing citizens to request their personal histories to be scrubbed from search engines.

The Guardian and the BBC have both received takedown notices from Google, informing them that articles they have written about certain public figures will no longer appear in search results when users search for certain names because of the so-called right to be forgotten.

~LINK~

For Google, the Right to Be Forgotten Is an Unforgettable Fiasco

Since the beginning, Google has cultivated the idea that its results arelike good journalismunbiased, complete, and compelling. Nowhere is that message more clearly telegraphed than in the design of Googles search interface itself. Google isnt a person. Its just this little box. Put your search here and the smartest computers in the world will tell you what you need to knowno messy human judgment involved.

In reality, however, teams of living, breathing people are constantly at work behind the scenes at Google tweaking algorithms to juice search results according to subjective standards like quality. This is often a good thing. Concerted efforts to cut down on the proliferation of link spam and content-farmed drivel have kept search results truly useful, which is good for users and Google both. But as Facebook has experienced even more strongly in the backlash to its emotional contagion study , users prefer not to be reminded that human-crafted filters unavoidably come into play in the dissemination of digital content.

~LINK~

Is Google trying to sabotage the right to be forgotten?

British journalists are in a tizzythis morning.It startedyesterday, when James Ball of the Guardian wrote a gently seething comment piece about notices his paper received from Google, warning itthat six articleswould no longer be listed on the search engines European sites.This was followed by apost from the BBCseconomics editor, Robert Peston, whocomplained that Google had removed this example of my journalism.

The message from both pieces wasclear: As the result of a rulingin Mayby the European Court of Justice, Google has been forced to becomeclearly a reluctant participant in what effectively amounts to censorship, in Balls words. The Court ruled last month (pdf) that Google must remove search results from individuals when asked, if the results are irrelevant, outdated, or otherwise inappropriate.

Yetread through both pieces and you findthat things are more complicated than it mayat first appear. Peston updated his piece later to say itseemed the subject of his originalarticle had not requested a take-down,while others speculated thatperhaps a reader who commented on the piece had asked to be forgotten. Ball for his part notes that whether for commercial or free speech reasons (or both), [Google is]informing sites when their content is blocked perhaps in the hope that they will write about it.

That is a common thread this morning. On Twitter, the Financial Timess Robert Shrimsley, a columnist and the editor of the FTs website, pointed out that:

Paul Bernal, a media law lecturerat the University of East Anglia, articulatedsimilar thoughts in a blogpost titled Are Google intentionally overreacting to the Right to be Forgotten?

Theyre trying to say, I think, you know, we were right! This ruling means censorship! This is dangerous! Theyre also trying to get journalists like James Ball and Robert Peston to be on their side, not on the side of the CJEU and in Balls case, at least, they seem to be succeeding to an extent.

The Guardians Chris Moran, who runs search-engine optimization for the paper, has similar thoughts :

Its worth stating again that all of the obvious idiocy in the implementation suggests at the least that Google is far from whole-heartedly embracing the ECJ ruling.

And as Quartz reportedlast week, Google is certainly not being shy about the changes it ismaking to search results in the European Union, adding adisclaimer that results may have been removed even if they havent been.Andrew Orlowski at The Register called it two weeks ago: The ads giant has launched a broad-based PR campaign pushing to change the law, creating a false impression that its being asked to make difficult decisions in vast numbers (in fact courts ultimately decide, not Google), and that the situation is burdensome for it (when in fact it can bounce all the complaints to the data protection registrar, and wait for the legal system to do all the work).

~LINK~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Ah the EU, so progressive, so liberal.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Most European countries do not support the right to free speech the way we do here. (most-- Denmark is an exception, perhaps there are others)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

It is an interesting clash, in that Google sees their profit margin, as well as possible ideology, being challenged by the EU ruling. I wonder just how far Google can push, and I wonder if it will do any good?

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

It will be interesting to see where this goes. I'm not about to make any guesses yet.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

I agree Grump. This should be a very interesting situation.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I'm guessing that in the US you are still gonna have problems using Google ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

More security leak news : Bad news ...
Your Android phone could be leaking your Wi-Fi history


but also good news : instructions on how to fix the leak in the linked article .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Thanks Petey!

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Thanks Petey! I changed mine. How's that NoScript working out for you?

I have started in the last 6 months using other search engines other than Google and in most cases getting much better results. It started with me when I found searches with Goggle seemed to be leading me. My brother, who is into this much more than I am suggested a couple of other search engines and I've found they are much more inclusive than Google.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I wonder-- how long will it take 'till Europe becomes part of the Caliphate?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago
 
 

Who is online






56 visitors