╌>

Justice Alito: The Most Partisan Supreme Court Justice Of All

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  cm  •  12 years ago  •  19 comments

Justice Alito:     The Most Partisan Supreme Court Justice Of All

The Most Partisan Supreme Court Justice Of All

By Ian Millhiser :

The Most Partisan Supreme Court Justice Of All

In mid-November of 2012, hundreds of tuxedo-clad Republican lawyers gathered at a hotel ballroom in Washington, DC. They were a mix of heads hung in dejection and chests puffed out in compensatory bluster. Less than two weeks earlier, theyd seen President Obama vanquish his opponent at the polls. Their last chance to knock a hated president out of office and their last real chance to halt thats presidents even more hated health reforms ended in failure. They and their allies had made their best case that liberalism was a path to economic ruin, and the American people had lined up at their polling places to pull the lever for liberalism.

And yet, at this annual gathering of the Federalist Society for Law and Public Policy Studies, arguably the most powerful legal organization in the country , Justice Samuel Alito was defiant. Not long after rising to give his keynote address to the room full of conservative senators, judges, and attorneys gathered before him, Alito launched into a story of a particularly uninspiring law professor whose course he took in law school. The professor, Alito recalled, authored a book in 1970 warning of a decaying society trapped in a moment of utmost sterility, darkest night, most extreme peril.

At this point in his speech, Alito paused, and looked over the roomful of lawyers still licking their wounds from Mitt Romneys very recent defeat. Our current situation, he told them, is nothing new.

ustice Alitos speech came during a brief moment of respite between two great constitutional battles. Just a few months earlier, the Court had rejected a request that it repeal the Affordable Care Act in its entirety, based on a tenuous reading of the Tenth Amendment that one prominent conservative judge dismissed as having no basis in either the text of the Constitution or Supreme Court precedent. Justice Alito dissented in the Courts health care decision. He wanted Obamacare gone.

Almost exactly one month after his speech, a gunman named Adam Lanza walked into an elementary school in Sandy Hook, Connecticut and murdered 26 people, 20 of whom were children . What followed was a nationwide debate over the proper way to solve gun violence and over the scope and the wisdom of the Second Amendment. Many of the lawyers and lawmakers who attended Justice Alitos speech would fight hard and, ultimately, successfully to defeat President Obamas proposals to prevent future Sandy Hooks.

In the moment of calm between these two storms, Justice Alito let the audience know where he stood on both questions. Referring to the text of the Constitution, Alito quipped that [i]ts hard not to notice that Congress powers are limited, and you will see there is an amendment that comes right after the First Amendment, and theres another that comes after the Ninth Amendment . He spent much of the rest of the speech criticizing legal arguments the Obama Administration had made in his Court .

So, when Chief Justice Roberts opened the final session of the Supreme Courts term on Monday by announcing that Justice Alito would deliver both of the Courts remaining opinions, liberals immediately knew that they were about to hear some very bad news. In quick succession, Alito dealt sharp blows to public sector unions and to women whose employers object to birth control .

A Straight Face

If Alitos Hobby Lobby opinion the second of the two decisions he handed down on Monday proves anything, it is that Alito has mastered the art of reading legal authorities that cut sharply against his position, and then authoring a legal opinion that passes them off as if they actually bolster his argument. In Hobby Lobby , Alito was confronted by decades of legal precedents establishing that religious liberty claims could not be used to diminish the rights of third parties, especially in the employment context. Worse, at least for Alitos belief that employers with religious objections to birth control could deny legally mandated coverage to their employees, Hobby Lobby turned upon how the Court interpreted a 1993 law a law known as the Religious Freedom Restoration Act or RFRA that explicitly stated that its purpose was to restore the compelling interest test set out by these earlier precedents after that test was overruled by an unpopular Supreme Court decision. This was the same legal test that was in place when the Court held that [w]hen followers of a particular sect enter into commercial activity as a matter of choice, the limits they accept on their own conduct as a matter of conscience and faith are not to be superimposed on the statutory schemes which are binding on others in that activity .

Yet Alito ignored Congresss clearly stated purpose, he offered little explanation for why he was justified in doing do, and what little justification he did offer falls apart upon a very cursory inquiry. At one point in his opinion, for example, Alito points to a 2000 amendment to a largely irrelevant provision of RFRA, claiming that the amendment was an obvious effort to effect a complete separation from First Amendment case law. Elsewhere, Alito argues that RFRA strengthened the legal protections available to religious objectors prior to 1990. Both claims, however, are difficult to square with RFRAs statement that its entire purpose is to restore prior precedents and there is nothing in the 2000 amendment which alters this statement of purpose.

Hobby Lobby is also the latest in a series of decisions Alito has handed down diminishing the rights of women in the workplace. Prior to Hobby Lobby , his most famous decision was undoubtedly Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire , the pay discrimination case that Congress overturned in the very first bill President Obama signed into law .

Alito, however, does not appear at all humbled by the experience of having a successful presidential candidate campaign against his most well-known opinion and then eradicate that opinion just over a week after moving into the White House. Last year, in an opinion with potentially much further reaching consequences than Ledbetter , Alito gutted a core protection helping prevent workers from being racially

or sexually harassed by their boss. Harassment suits of this kind are notoriously difficult to win, especially when a worker is harassed by colleagues without direct authority over them. When a worker is sexually or racially harassed by their supervisor, however, the law recognizes that employers should have a special incentive to halt this kind of exploitation immediately. In many cases, when a worker is the victim of harassment by their boss, their employer is automatically liable for this harassment.

CONTINUE READING:

http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/07/02/3455366/the-most-partisan-justice/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

The most partisan justice of all!!!! what else is new???

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Activist Judges...GWB's activist Justice, didn't GWB say he did not want activist Judges? did this appointee slip through his fingers or was he already aware of whom Alito was...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
This is a joke. Compare Ginsburg's record of partisanship with that of Alito's. You'd think the author would do a little bit of research before making such an easily debunked claim.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Ed whelan saved me the research:


ThinkProgresss Ian Millhiser has a tiresomely tendentious essay lambasting Justice Alito as The Most Partisan Justice. Millhiser draws a sensible distinction between someone whose decisions are driven by a fairly coherent judicial philosophy (though he attaches the pejorative label ideologue to Justice Thomas in crediting him with this approach) and someone who simply reaches partisan results. But rather than try to give an example or two (beyond his wildly mistaken account of Hobby Lobby) of instances in which Alito has supposedly been unfaithful to his judicial philosophy in order to reach partisan results, Millhiser resorts to statistical flim-flam.

For Millhiser, Justice Ginsburg cant be labeled a partisan because on one occasion in her 22 years on the Court, she broke with her fellow liberals in a case brought by unions seeking to make it easier for them to collect funds. Never mind that virtually no one has ever heard of the case, that her vote was unnecessary for the outcome, and that she concurred only in part and in the judgment.

By contrast, Millhiser wont count to Alitos credit the handful of cases where Alito joined a 5 justice majority [sic] that included one other conservative and three liberals. What Millhisers confusing phrasing (joined a 5 justice majority) seems designed to obscure is that Alito provided the decisive fifth vote in those cases. Further, in the one case that I quickly found that evidently is supposed to fit Millhisers description, the so-called other conservative was Justice Kennedy (who is no conservative).

For a vastly more intelligent account of Justice Alitos decisionmakingone that emphasizes how distinctive his judicial approach is from that of the three other conservative justices with whom he is generally lumped and how that approach has led him to stand apart from them in major First Amendment casessee Adam Whites 2011 Weekly Standard essay, The Burkean Justice. www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Alito has always had issues/concerns over the Establishment Clause, so his ruling/decision should come as no surprise.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Background and passage

The Religious Freedom Restoration Act applies to all religions, but is most pertinent to Native American religions that are burdened by increasing expansion of government projects onto sacred land. In Native American religion the land they worship on is very important. Often the particular ceremonies can only take place in certain locations because these locations have special significance. [5] This, along with peyote use are the main parts of Native American religions that are often left unprotected.

The Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment states that Congress shall not pass laws prohibiting the free exercise of religion. In the 1960s, the Supreme Court interpreted this as banning laws that burdened a person's exercise of religion (e.g. Sherbert v. Verner , 374 U.S. 398 (1963); Wisconsin v. Yoder , 406 U.S. 205 (1972)). But in the 1980s the Court began to allow legislation that incidentally prohibited religiously mandatory activities as long as the ban was "generally applicable" to all citizens. Also, the American Indian Religious Freedom Act , intended to protect the freedoms of tribal religions, was lacking enforcement. This led to the key cases leading up to the RFRA, which were Lyng v.

Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association (1988) and Employment Division v. Smith , 494 U.S. 872 (1990). In Lyng, the Court was unfavorable to sacred land rights. Members of the Yurok , Tolowa and Karok tribes tried to use the First Amendment to prevent a road from being built by the U.S. Forest Service through sacred land. The land that the road would go through consisted of gathering sites for natural resources used in ceremonies and praying sites. The Supreme Court ruled that this was not an adequate legal burden because the government was not coercing or punishing them for their religious beliefs. [ 6 ] In Smith the Court upheld the state of Oregon 's refusal to give unemployment benefits to two Native Americans fired from their jobs at a rehab clinic after testing positive for mescaline , the main psychoactive compound in the peyote cactus, which they used in a religious ceremony. Peyote use has been a common practice in Native American tribes for centuries. It was integrated with Christianity into what is now known as the Native American Church . [ 7 ]

The Smith decision outraged the public. Many groups came together. Both liberal (like the American Civil Liberties Union ) and conservative groups (like the Traditional Values Coalition ) as well as other groups such as the Christian Legal Society , the American Jewish Congress , the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty , and the National Association of Evangelicals joined forces to support RFRA, which would reinstate the Sherbert Test , overturning laws if they burden a religion. [ 8 ] The act, which was Congress's reaction to the Lyng and Smith cases, passed the House unanimously and the Senate 97 to 3 and was signed into law by U.S. President Bill Clinton .

Applicability

The RFRA applies "to all Federal law, and the implementation of that law, whether statutory or otherwise", including any Federal statutory law adopted after the RFRA's date of signing "unless such law explicitly excludes such application." [ 9 ]

Challenges and weaknesses

n 1997, part of this act was overturned by the United States Supreme Court . The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of San Antonio wanted to enlarge a church in Boerne, Texas . But a Boerne ordinance protected the building as a historic landmark and did not permit it to be torn down. The church sued, citing RFRA, and in the resulting case, City of Boerne v. Flores , 521 U.S. 507 (1997), the Supreme Court struck down the RFRA with respect to its applicability to States (but not Federally), stating that Congress had stepped beyond their power of enforcement provided in the Fourteenth Amendment . [ 8 ] In response to the Boerne ruling, Congress passed the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) in 2000, which grants special privileges to religious land owners. [ 10 ]

The Act was amended in 2003 to only include the federal government and its entities, such as Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia. [ 11 ] A number of states have passed state RFRAs , applying the rule to the laws of their own state, but the Smith case remains the authority in these matters in many states. [ 12 ]

The constitutionality of RFRA as applied to the federal government was confirmed on February 21, 2006, as the Supreme Court ruled against the government in Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente Uniao do Vegetal , 546 U.S. 418 (2006), which involved the use of an otherwise illegal substance in a religious ceremony, stating that the federal government must show a compelling state interest in restricting religious conduct.

CONTINUE READING:

The Link below is : Public Law 103-141 November 16, 1993

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

I am not a legal scholar, so I need some help from the Lawyers on this NT, how did Alito make the connection from protecting sacred land to protecting a for profit company who does not want to include into their benefits package, a product that was previously included in that benefits package from an insurance company, how does SACRED LAND, translates to contraceptives???

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

My point, I have linked the law from the Dept of Justice, I understand the constitution, what personal rights, how was the owners of hobby lobby rights, violated, when they had previously offered the very same product they are now objecting to, based on Obamacare, it is obvious and common sense that this had nothing to do with the product itself, but it had to do with the Objection of the Health Care Law which all of you RIGHT WINGERS believe should not exists, I would humbly ask, give up GOVT. Medicare and VA medical benefits, then we can have a chat...Another thing, Hobby Lobby could not have objected to Abortion Drugs when they had invested $73,000,000 million in Pharmaceutical Companies, Manufacturers of the very drugs they are objecting to, its all about Obamacare...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Well said.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

how does SACRED LAND, translates to contraceptives???

Because they were "screwed" out of it? Sorry, I couldn't resist. Smile.gif

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

LMAO!!!! Thank you my first Laugh in three days...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I discard anything that comes from the White House and since Think Progress is owned by Center for American Progress who provided office space to start Media Matters and John Podesta is the founder of Center for American Progress and also is part of the White House under Obama. Tony, his brother and Tony's wife, Heather, a lobbyist have been making a fortune during the last 5 years. Check it out. You will find out if you do. Don't use Think Progress to do it though.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

It would take a liberal who enjoys the freedoms this country has to offer to suggest Veterans who have served this country to insure those freedoms give up VA benefits. After all Liberals don't like the military. Many liberal colleges have in the past kicked the ROTC off their campuses.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Remember - key point - RFRA - 1993 and amended in 1996. Smith, Sherbert and Yoder were prior hence cause for RFRA. Don't consider cases prior to attendant laws.

Lyng - Justice O'Connor made the ruling based on "history" vice law - also before RFRA. Her contention was the government wasn't preventing the Indians from practicing their religion by forcing them to engage in any practice and because the government has a right to use, what is, after all, its land.

Gonzales - wrong example - Alito was not on the bench for that case. However, the court ruled 8-0 in favor of Gonzales - The Supreme Court ruled that the government failed to demonstrate a compelling interest in applying the Controlled Substances Act to the UDV's sacramental use of the tea.

Little point of information - when you are trying to cite a legal opinion, make sure all the threads go back to the same string. None of the cases you referenced, all dealing with Indian religious behavior, are/were applicable to the Hobby Lobby case. It is because of those Indian cases that RFRA came about - which the justices used in their decision.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Six, You are trouble, you know I am not asking Vets to give up there VA benefits, those benefits along with all other Govt. insurance programs are enjoyed by millions of people, Everyone, has done their part, the Vets have served the Country with honor and distinction and the Taxpayers have served the country with honor and distinction by continuing to pay their taxes in order to continue offering Vets and the elderly their medical care, EVERYONE is doing their DUTY...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

Confucius Says: Fox News has Opened shop in the Republican wing of the Halls of Congress, so Has the Wall Street Journal and the National Review Journal and all other news entities that Rupert Murdoch owns...Smile.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

CM, are any of those you mentioned working out of the White House? Do any of those have 501(c)s such as John Podesta? Read up on Tony and Heather Podesta. Life has been a boom for them during the last 5 years.

So this is off topic to the article, but only shows where you get your information is what their opinion or propaganda will be. As Obama would say, "It's the Law of the Land." Put a sock in it. Oh, he didn't say that part. LOL

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

1stwarrior, Thanks, this is where I see a disconnect:

Little point of information - when you are trying to cite a legal opinion, make sure all the threads go back to the same string. None of the cases you referenced, all dealing with Indian religious behavior, are/were applicable to the Hobby Lobby case. It is because of those Indian cases that RFRA came about - which the justices used in their decision.

But for the religious, I get the connection, no matter how hypocritical hobby lobby owners are...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    12 years ago

"It's the Law of the Land." Put a sock in it. Oh, he didn't say that part. LOL

OK..I'll just do that...

 
 

Who is online






56 visitors