╌>

The Political Ginsburg -- The Justice's dissent in Hobby Lobby isn't a judicial opinion.WSJ Editorial 7/2/2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  5 comments

The Political Ginsburg -- The Justice's dissent in Hobby Lobby isn't a judicial opinion.WSJ Editorial 7/2/2014

As Democrats denounce the Supreme Court majority in Hobby Lobby as closet mullahs (see above), we shouldn't let pass the contribution from Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Her hyperbolic dissent is a political call to arms unworthy of a junior judge, much less the nation's highest Court.

The excess begins with her first sentence: "In a decision of startling breadth, the Court holds that commercial enterprises, including corporations . . . can opt out of any law (saving only tax laws) they judge incompatible with their sincerely held religious beliefs." She goes on to say that the Court's "radical purpose" may unleash "havoc," among other flourishes that distort the opinion to the point of intellectual dishonesty.

As Harvard liberal Laurence Tribe said on MSNBC, the majority's opinion is "not as radical" as many are claiming. It applies only to "closely held" companies with owners who have clear religious beliefs, and it explicitly says that companies cannot use the opinion as an excuse to opt out of other legal requirements. The majority merely said Hobby Lobby could refuse to pay for four kinds of contraception because the Administration's mandate violated the standard of religious conscience that Congress wrote into the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

Justice Ginsburg's dissent is so far removed from the legal reality that it doesn't qualify as a judicial opinion. It is a political opinion whose purpose seems to be to mobilize opposition to the Court and perhaps even motivate Democrats to turn out at the polls. Justice Antonin Scalia sometimes unleashes his rhetorical ferocity on decisions he dislikes, but his dissents are rooted in the law. Justice Ginsburg's is a flight from the law.

Not too long ago, the Court's ranking liberal suggested in a public forum that a "future, wiser Court" might reconsider the 5-4 Heller decision affirming the Second Amendment as an individual right to bear arms. That too was inappropriate for a sitting Justice, but then politics is increasingly her judicial sideline.

http://online.wsj.com/articles/the-political-ginsburg-1404342819


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
She's always been a zealot, but her dissent is pure demagoguery unhinged from both the facts of the case and the law at issue.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Anything noteworthy that three of the four dissenters were women?

I suppose they could not be expected to recuse themselves.

I wish you were on the court.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Excellent point.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
If a conservative claims a woman acts in a certain way, simply because she is a woman, they would be attacked as sexist. Yet, the commentary from the left on the case assumes thst their womanhood required them to oppose the religious freedom act. Very strange.The whole point of being a judge is too put your personal biases aside and apply the law fairly regardless of your own views. Not anymore apparently.Thanks for the endorsement!, being a justice seems lie a deem job, but being a lawyer seems like it would be then worst.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

"In a decision of startling breadth, the Court holds that commercial enterprises, including corporations . . . can opt out of any law (saving only tax laws) they judge incompatible with their sincerely held religious beliefs."

Factually incorrect, but an excellent bumper sticker or campaign sound bite.!

(the decision) explicitly says that companies cannot use the opinion as an excuse to opt out of other legal requirements.

Funny Justice Ginsburg didn't mention this fact!

Justice Antonin Scalia sometimes unleashes his rhetorical ferocity on decisions he dislikes, but his dissents are rooted in the law. Justice Ginsburg's is a flight from the law.

Neither is desirable from the SCOTUS, but I prefer the former over the latter

 
 

Who is online






56 visitors