A Victory for and a Giant Leap Towards Theocracy for America
The SCOTUS decision regarding Hobby Lobby is an abomination. IMO for a number of reasons
BUT THIS DISCUSSION IS ABOUT ONE AND ONLY ONE OF THOSE REASONS AND I INSIST THAT ONLY THE REASON STATED BELOW BE THE SUBJECT OF COMMENTARY!
The SCOTUS decision sets a precedent by which "SINCERELY HELD RELIGIOUS BELIEFS"CAN JUSTIFY THE WILLFUL FAILURE TO ABIDE BY LAW!
THIS BY VIRTUE OF THE FACT THAT, IN SPITE OF TESTIMONY GIVING VERIFIABLE SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE THAT HOBBY LOBBY'S UNDERSTANDING OF THE EFFECTS OF THE MEDICATIONS AND DEVICES THEY OBJECTED TO COVERING, WAS COMPLETELY WRONG -- THAT IS, NOT ONE OF THOSE ITEMS WAS ABORTIFACIENT NOT ONE
Nevertheless,Justice Alito, having heard the testimony, indicated that the scientific evidence did not matter, and, that the "sincerely held religious beliefs" of Hobby Lobby (and other religionists) was sufficient (and thus as valid as the scientific information to the contrary) to justify their unwillingness to cover those medications and devices!
When religion trumps science and law, a de facto theocratic environment is in place.
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

My issue is clear and concisely stated. Address it specifically after which, your editorial comments are welcomed. But address the issue first.
I'm agnostic and believe in the right to religious freedom. We must prevent our big bloated intrusive government from trampling on our religious rights. Laws that infringe on our religious rights should be repealed.
YOU DID NOT RESPOND TO THE SPECIFICS I CITED.
Otherwise, your comment
Is a theocratic ideology.
Please do not leave further comments in this thread until you first address what I asked be addressed.
BF,
Read the sequence leading to the decision. It's not about pills, it's about science and law being subjugated to "sincerely held religious beliefs."
The so-called "baby Drano" pills are NOT abortifacient NOT!
Your comment indicates that you either didn't read the article and/or are under the same erroneous conclusions as Hobby Lobby.
____________________________
If you're keeping score folks, the three comments (other than my own) FAILED TO ADDRESS THE ARTICLE'S CONTENT.
And of course, they are on the Hobby Lobby/SCOTUS side of the decision.
Which is consistent with the failure to make a case based on facts and going instead with anything but very much in concert with things like making important decisions based solely on "sincerely held religious beliefs."
Welcome to Salem, 2014. Burn a witch oh wait, better yet, start an inquisition.
When religion trumps law, people die -- that's the history.
More right-wing buzzwords -- you're off topic and Romney lost.
But I'll say this, if corporations are people, then FUCK THEM.
'Course, if they are, and you do, take personal responsibility and use a condom.
Also, if you can't discuss the content of the article
Don't comment further.
RFRA trumps "science"
Only if you think a corporation is actually a person.
That's four out of four. Oh, I see Robert has returned -- five out of five.
We're on a factless roll which works in a science-denier's world.
You boys can't address the specifics.
Objective readers will notice that.
BF,
I will rephrase/paraphrase the scenario sequence.
Attorney for the Defense
"Your Honor, the plaintiff's case is predicated on demonstrably incorrect conclusions as explained in testimony before the Court by expert witnesses in science and medicine."
Response by His Honor
" The facts are immaterial; as long as the plaintiff deems his contentions to be correct, those based upon his 'sincerely held religious beliefs', I award him a victory."
Calling me "melodramatic" does not change the reality that the very premise of Hobby Lobby's case was not based on facts. Its objections to the coverages were predicated on alleged abortifacient medications and devices -- citing that as being violative of their religious beliefs.
The very premise, even with regard to how those items violated their religious beliefs, was and is incorrect. And yet the court held that as long as Hobby Lobby believed it was correct (based on its religious beliefs), that it somehow put truth and reality on its side.
When religion calls the tune IN SPITE OF ITS SELF-SERVING INDIFFERENCE TO AND CONTRADICTION OF REALITY, THAT IS THE CHARACTER OF A THEOCRACY.
To your question
The Supreme Court and the new law of the land based on its decision is the de facto religious leader on this one. A titular head is not necessary; it is the action and its consequences that makes this a step towards theocracy.
Address what I've specified, not your opinions of me.
I think birth control should be part of health insurance but a company should be free to decide whether to offer it. No one is forced to work for Hobby Lobby. They can work for someone else or join obamacare.
Basically, from what I understand, the Creationist Museum can now break any law it wishes, because it is based on a sincerely held religious belief. They can now discriminate, based on whatever criteria they choose, fail to pay taxes, sell liquor without a license, (not that they would, but $$ talks), etc.
This is the most disgusting work of the Supreme Court in my lifetime.
Disagree; you have failed to apply the specifics to the premise, but, I respect your right to and assertion so
By laying out the specifics of the case and showing where the facts were disregarded and in deference to religious belief, I explained logically what my headline says, NOT that America is a theocracy, rather that by virtue of the court allowing religion to take precedent over science and law, a theocratic element has begun to emerge.
Whenever you care to stop pissing on the floor and denigrating conversation that would be outstanding.
Otherwise, you don't do the site any favors.
Your opinions are welcomed but your annoying and worthless interjections would, in a separate space, be fun.
Disregard the sexual orientation of Lord Stanhope and assume that profiling doesn't negate the validity of a comment advanced by the profiled.
I mean, some herein probably take you seriously.
Since you went there
If Barack Obama held a press conference reminding Americans that it was unwise to eat excrement
Conservatives across America would no longer flush.
RFRA doesn't address corporations nor does it consider them as people.
"RFRA applies "to all Federal law, and the implementation of that law, whether statutory or otherwise", including any Federal statutory law adopted after the RFRA's date of signing "unless such law explicitly excludes such application."' 42 U.S. Code 2000bb3 Applicability
Nothing in RFRA warrants a judgement made in the admitted disregard of the very inaccuracies/premises upon which a "religious freedom" case is predicated.
Further
"A PERSON'S" - the SCOTUS has fucked the American middle and poverty classes twice now -- first via CU and now, Hobby Lobby.
FYI ( and I know you already know)
When religiosity "justifies" its despicable, inhuman, criminal acts in the name of its i.e. "sincerely held religious beliefs," and "THE LAW" allows it (you fill in the blank) ________________________________________!
Don't remember reading of a "disregard of the law" in the opinion.
...
Anyone not aware of this yet still thinking the case was about a religionist objection to "paying for abortion," comes to the argument without understanding that FACTS AND LAW WERE TRUMPED BY "SINCERELY HELD RELIGIOUS BELIEF."
"SINCERE IN ITS MISTAKEN BELIEF!"
Try dealing with all of the people and issues in your life rolling with that "my way or the highway" bullshit.
You know, like, "Hey, my sincerely held religious beliefs tell me it's okay to steal your land, enslave your people, commit genocide and what the fuck if I'm mistaken -- I am sincere about my reasons to fuck you over."
Sincere!
1st,
For the record, I did not say "disregard of the law," I wrote
And you need to recognize that "proof" was neither provided by Hobby Lobby, nor of importance to Justice Alito.
The decision was made in favor of a plaintiff despite the fact that the plaintiff's basic argument was wholly inaccurate.
Perhaps one day you or a family member will be the defendant in a case in which the plaintiff's arguments against you are without factual basis. Your attorney will call expert witnesses to debunk the plaintiff's bogus "evidence."
But you will be convicted nevertheless because the prosecution will argue that, "while the plaintiff hasn't fact number fucking one, let alone a preponderance of evidence, nor evidence beyond a reasonable doubt (depending on the allegations you face), the plaintiff is sincere in his beliefs that you i.e. bombed his house and murdered his family " notwithstanding that you were three thousand miles away from the scene when he "saw you do it."
That's how Alito rolled with Hobby Lobby.
...
That was not the basis of Hobby Lobby's case. The religionist-right and the Obama haters don't seem to give a shit about that.
Would you like to discuss the actual case or just go with an argument against a different issue?
That goes for anyone else who expresses an opinion that is not germane to the issue at hand.
Focus:
Can religious belief trump the law solely because it is "sincerely held" albeit factually incorrect?
When so-called "evidence" is shown to be false, can the plaintiff's case based on that "evidence," still be deemed viable?
You'd like to see the Supreme Court become the American version of the inquisition, in which 9 unelected judges have the power to decide what a valid religious belief is. You realize the first amendment exists to keep the court from doing such things, right? The idea of the Supreme Court handing down religious dictates is terrifying, I'm surprised anyone would advocate that the court has the power to determine what a valid religious view is, I'd assumed that sort of thinking went out with the inquisition.
"Legitimate Religious Beliefs" based on a verifiably incorrect premise?
You mean that kind of precedent?
A decision by a Court or government body that sustains an argument based not on fact, rather on a "sincerely held (albeit factually wrong) religious belief, IS EXACTLY WHAT THE INQUISITION WAS ABOUT!
a religious tribunal, which you appear happy to turn it into.
Can you please spell out the demonstrably false belief? I haven't been able to find it.
No disagreement if the belief is purely philosophical or ideological and impossible to evaluate on empirical information.
But a "belief" that is presented as being fact-based, as was the case with Hobby Lobby, a belief, the stated basis of which can be and was medically and scientifically discredited in the courtroom -- MUST BE ACKNOWLEDGED BY THE COURT AS BEING "PURELY BELIEF," AND NO MATTER HOW SINCERELY HELD, NOT THUS VIABLE AS A LEGAL JUSTIFICATION TO ABROGATE PART OF OR THE ENTIRETY OF A LAW!
Indeed, that's what it became. Religious ideology verifiably shown to be OUTSIDE THE REALM OF REALITY, nevertheless was the basis of the decision (as I posted).
Sean, we clearly disagree, but I respect your presentation of counter-points.
We just disagree.
But they can't possibly agree that an incorrect, factually wrong "belief," has the same legal weight as does an actual fact.
IMO, the decision was ideological and partisan, not based on law, rather than on politics and religionist-politics. Ginsburg did not comment on the basis of, of Alito's discounting of the facts of the case only on the problems it will create and how it may create them.
And what happens when the next employer tells the court, "I have a strongly held religious belief that blood transfusions cause all sorts of disabling diseases and I shouldn't have to pay the insurance premiums to cover them for my employees."
Factually wrong but sincerely believed.
How was/is atheism so great?
More people have been murdered by atheists than by all the religions.
Mao, Stalin, Pol Pot, Kim Il Sungplus, arguably, Hitler, Tojo and Hirohito.
But atheists don't claim to be "God-fearing/loving" do they, Len?
So religious murderers are not only murderers, they're murderous hypocrites!
What else ya' got?
No, Alito hedges if you read his opinion. But beyond that, if your scenario is correct, it means that the facts supercede even a "sincerely held religious belief" when that religious belief is contrary to reality.
Damn, Sean, I think we agree!
But wait
Presumably women chose to work for HL before last week, knowing some birth control was not offered by insurance. Likely the ones who wanted it bought other insurance.
Why not force employers to offer auto insurance.??
How does a secular society determine "sincerely held religious beliefs"? When a belief system is at odds with our scientific system, upon entering your house of worship you can check the science at the door (if you wish). On the other hand, science and religion can co-exist IMO. The belief subscribed to by the owners, life begins at conception, is why they vehemently pursued this to the SCOTUS. The IUD and morning after RX prohibit implant of the "possibly" fertilized egg which is why H.L. considers it an abortifacient.
My take - any "for profit" corporation must never be allowed to use it's own take based on their religious beliefs. We've seen it in restaurants not wanting to serve the LGBT community, florists, bakeries, pharmacists, etc. The funny thing for me is, I subscribe to much of the belief system the owners of H.L. have and yet the decision IMO is wrong. Separation is there for a reason!
Christians would do well to remember, we are a nation of numerous faith systems; the battles seemingly won may be one day a war they cannot. When the oppressor becomes the oppressed, the view of "sincerely held religious beliefs" will take on a whole new meaning. Those pesky unintended consequences...only time will tell.
In the future I suggest you do like John Russell does . When he dislike a comment he just calls it nonsense ...
I don't agree . It only interferes with the govt's power to force the citizenry to its will .
In the future, as always, I will address every comment, even those that are nonsensical.
Now, how shall I address your comment?
Third man in?
As for Robert's "moving the goal post" misdiagnosis, I never duck a comment or question; if the questions/comments in a thread total "x" and "x" consists of "y" different topics/issues, I'll answer all "y" of them addressing their individual subjects.
Translation of Robert's "moving the goalpost" comment = Robert's inability to respond to any question anywhere on the field so he pisses on it.
Your myopic answer is already behind the fallout of groups and businesses jumping at their perceived opportunities to circumvent a number of laws by virtue of their religiously-based objections.
It has already begun; I'm headed for bed but I'll provide specifics in the near future.
My insight is 20/20 . Yours , not so much .
Incomplete sentence, Robert.
The non-truncated version
Walk; Time and time again, you offered nothing to rebut that I am able to rebut in a specific, intelligent, cogent manner, so instead I post off-handed, summary dismissals, quips and personal smack downs.
Translation:I will not join you in your masochistic fetishes which aren't really that but since I haven't the factual nor intellectual wherewithal to mount viable rebuttals, I'll demagogue and insult.
Your eyesight might be that but your insight is often more like an attempt to incite.
Good night all.
You called my comment "myopic" without explanation . So thanks much for the :
off-handed, summary dismissals, quips and personal smack downs.
It only seems that way because you don't seem to understand how and why your 20/20 comment was and still is yup
Myopic/myopia
myopia |mp|
noun
nearsightedness.
lack of imagination, foresight, or intellectual insight
Check back to your comment and simply apply the definition.
And now, for real good night Petey.
Got it . My perceptions are myopic . Yours are all seeing and all knowing ... at least in your own mind . And you are still in attack mode , not even trying to make a cogent point . Your futile attempts at dialogue are should be a satire on fairness and reason ...
Which religion opposes capital punishment?
Genesis / Chapter 9
6 Whoever sheds the blood of man through man shall his blood be shed, for in the image of God He made man.
Sad how atheists quickly forgive murder but hate measure-for-measurepunishment for murder.
Simply not true!
Many scientists, even Nobel laureates, are religious. I am a religious electronics engineer.
Maimonides wrote: "Study astronomy and physics if you wish to comprehend the relation between the world and God's management of it."
But religion is at least as much, even more so,about behavior as about theology.
"wars aren't fought in the name of atheism, mustaches, or math."
I doubt they'll get around the tax code although I say that with a bit of reserve since corporate lobbies already write portions of the code to give them advantage over individuals.
But I will wager right now, $25.00 for the American Cancer Society that we will see cases involving attempts at firing, hiring wage differential, and various other discriminatory practices (i.e. based on sexual orientation, religion, et al) citing the Alito language as precedent and "justification." Let's say the filing(s) will begin before the end of this year. Like today perhaps.
First taker is on.
Did you miss my next sentence, which is how I view science and religion? They can co-exist. The check it at the door statement was for those religious zealots too ignorant to think for themselves and who are so close minded they're not open to the possibility God didn't tell us everything in His word
The inquiries have already begun. Let's see how long the (first) filing takes to register in court.
Can religious belief trump the law solely because it is "sincerely held" albeit factually incorrect?
When so-called "evidence" is shown to be false, can the plaintiff's case based on that "evidence," still be deemed viable?
-------------------------
My understanding is HL objects to providing coverage for some forms of birth control they view as immoral. they also close on Sundays on moral grounds.
HOW CAN WE PROVE EITHER OF THESE IS NOT IMMORAL.??
What those forms of birth control do or don't do is irrelevant.
Many people sincerely hold false beliefs.
Your understanding is incorrect.
Hobby Lobby wasn't making a specific objection to "contraceptives." The medications and devices they were objecting to paying for, it claimed wereabortifacient.
THEY ARE NOT!I've been explaining this since the decision and also explaining that Alito acknowledged that HL's beliefs were inaccurate but he still found in favor of the company, NOT BECAUSE THEIR BELIFS WERE VALID BUT BECAUSE OF THEIR RELIGIOUS BELIEFS WERE "SINCERELY HELD!"
Good thing their "sincerely held religious beliefs" don't including eating their young.
And until this past Monday, you couldn't make a winnable legal case based on such beliefs. Before Monday, a plaintiff had to satisfy a "burden of proof" by presenting a "preponderance" of evidence regarding its allegation(s).
I wonder if HL believes that God did not intend women to be promoted to executive positions because that could reduce their child-birthing time.
Aside from which, "morality" is relative. Demonstrable Truth is absolute.
If/when you are accused of some infraction and brought to trial, I'm guessing that your accuser doesn't play the Hobby Lobby card before a conservative-minded jury.
Just a guess.
The precedent is only tangentially about "religious freedom," "birth control," the ACA the dangerous precedent is in the failure to apply the "burden of proof" standard.
my understanding is correct, taken from several stories.
There was only one burden of proof, the RFRA standard of was there a less restrictive way to enforce the law. The court said there was. The end. Nothing else mattered.
At one time you could not make a winnable legal argument for gay marriage.
That's because such an argument would be based on ideology, philosophy, theology and interpretation; HL argued its position on the basis of the effects of the medications and those effects are not a question of ideology, rather medicine and science.
Alito acknowledged that HL had not satisfied the burden of proof then went on to say it didn't matter as long as the HL's religious beliefs were sincerely held.
You may be OK with an abrogation of jurisprudence protocol; but it's not OK in my world.
HL argued its position on the basis of the effects of the medications and those effects are not a question of ideology, rather medicine and science.HL argued its position on the basis of the effects of the medications and those effects are not a question of ideology, rather medicine and science.
_______________
WRONG
They said providing those were against their religious beliefs, which don't have to pass a scientific test. AGAIN, the court only said there was a less restrictive way the govt could handle this. It did not consider science an issue.
-------------
I prefer all laws to be made by the legislative process rather than a court or an executive order, whether I agree with it or not.,
There are exceptions but they should be few.
Forget passing a Scientific test, a plaintiff needs to pass the accuracy test of its allegation.It can't simply make up the science to validate its case.
The point you missed is that atheists have no moral compass. When they murder you cannot accuse them of hypocrisy.
Science has NOTHING to do with this. It's about a belief on morality based on religion.
===========
The Green and Hahn families object to their closely-held for-profit corporations providing health insurance coverage to their female employees of four FDA -approved contraceptives that the Green and Hahn families believe may prevent implantation of a fertilized egg (many scientists disagree), which the Green and Hahn families believe constitute an abortion ================
This seems to be a trend-- those on the extreme right wanting to "restore the Caliphate" so to speak.
But the crazier they get, the more of a backlash is developping.
RELEVANT. pertaining to the case.
Science is irrelevant to this case.
Apparently this is one of these cases where SCOTUS had to act because congress did not create a needed law to deal with new circumstances . The SCOTUS default is not ideal and never will be . The same thing happened with the Citizens United decision .
" FDA-approved contraceptives that the Green and Hahn families believe may prevent implantation of a fertilized egg (many scientists disagree), which the Green and Hahn families believe constitute an abortion==== "
And that belief is INCORRECT -- medically, physiologically, anatomically, scientifically INCORRECT. Alito specifically noted that the belief was incorrect -- then went on to say it did not matter, that because HL had a sincerely held religious belief, in essence, THE FACTS, SCIENCE, MEDICINE, REALITY DIDN'T MATTER.
The SCOTUS awarded a decision albeit acknowledging that the facts did not support that decision!
Why TF does this have to be explained over and over as a major sell out of the judicial system on behalf of "religious belief?"
Petey,
Agreed for the most part.
I don't care what they say about you ... You're OK !
You stated
"The SCOTUS decision sets a precedent by which "SINCERELY HELD RELIGIOUS BELIEFS"CAN JUSTIFY THE WILLFUL FAILURE TO ABIDE BY LAW!"
Which is clearly wrong, as there is nothing in the decision that states what you posted. You just wanted the decision to say it allows this so you can attack it.
So when you start with an incorrect premise, you did further damage by going into a rambling rant against Alito. And again, absent of any facts, you just rely on misguided opinion to dictate your position
But Atheists do claim to be caring loving people, yet look at the millions they have exterminated in just the last 100 years.
True point, secular humanists have no moral compass, these progressives are the ones who have exterminated millions
But this case was not about religious belief trumping the law. This case was about the feds forcing their beliefs on private people/companies and forcing them to do things they did not want to do. This was a case about religious and individual liberty, something those on the left oppose
"True point, secular humanists have no moral compass, these progressives are the ones who have exterminated millions"
Do provide us with the specifics.
I insist."But Atheists do claim to be caring loving people, yet look at the millions they have exterminated in just the last 100 years."
Please show the actual claims, the claimants with whom they're associated and the events.
Any modern day leftist from leftist politicians, to their supporters, they all support an ideology that seeks to enslave and destroy, yet they say they care
Leftist ideology from fascism to Communism The secular humanists are on the left, and they are pure evil. Look at the millions killed by the leftists in WW2, during the cold war, and from left leaning governments worldwide in the 80's 90's and today
"But this case was not about religious belief trumping the law. This case was about the feds forcing their beliefs on private people/companies and forcing them to do things they did not want to do. This was a case about religious and individual liberty, something those on the left oppose"
This case was about Hobby Lobby objecting to paying for several specific medications and devices that allegedly violated its religious beliefs. And it failed to make its case in that it claimed the medications were "abortifacient." Not only are they NOT abortifacient, Justice Alito actually stated in the decision that HL was mistaken!
He then went ahead and said "it didn't matter that it was mistaken" because (even though it was wrong) it had a "sincerely held religious belief" (that it was correct)!
Stop with the pronouncements and declarations; they don't ring true simply because you declare them.
A justice/jury/court is charged with making decisions based on the evidence presented, or, the failure of that "evidence" to meet the standard of the level of viability. To grant a win while simultaneously stating in essence that the claim was not a win, is a frightening precedent.Every time someone misrepresents in this thread, what the case was about and/or the significance of allowing "religious belief" to trump reality, I will respond.The Court ruled that the law is Unconstitutional in the issue that HL bought forward. And indeed it is unconstitutional in that aspect, as well as many others. Would like for anyone to point out where the Constitution enumerates that the feds were given the power to force individuals and companies to have or provide health insurance.
I am not Religious. Nor do I hate Obama, I just do not agree with his leftist political ideology
You are in essence calling me a liar. I posted the very language in Alito's decision that you claim I'm contriving. You're off to a bad start here.
As follows:
Hobby Lobby's contention that the medications and devices for which they did not want to pay, are abortifacients, was and still is INCORRECT! And Alito's majority paper not only acknowledges that, it states that it doesn't matter because Hobby Lobby's "sincerely held religious beliefs" essentially made what was false, somehow true!
If you imply or state I make things up/lie again, you can stay off of my discussions.
"Any modern day leftist from leftist politicians, to their supporters, they all support an ideology that seeks to enslave and destroy, yet they say they care"
Another pronouncement with no specifics.
Really, look at modern day leftist ideology. The new masters of the slaves are the elites and the politicians in their pockets. It is these politicians who enslave the people to government dependency, which is slavery. In the past 8 years, look at how the number on some kind of government assistance has sky rocketed. So instead of making an environment where jobs can be created and sustained, the leftist politicians are forcing jobs to flee the country, hence driving people towards government dependence
So show how leftist ideology actually lifts people up instead of enslaving them
"Theocracy"-- OK. But what happened to "Plutocracy" -- some people really liked that part!
No, I am not calling you a liar. I am saying you are misrepresenting what Alito wrote. You are looking at the decision from a very narrow viewpoint that you already had established before the decision even came out. In other words you want to frame this as a war against Women, and it is not working.
HL has insurance coverage for their employees that covers 16 of the 20 pills that the FDA approved. HHS mandated that the employers has to cover all of them, even though the 4 in question are used to abort an already fertilized egg. That to some people is an abortion. And yes for those who are opposed to abortion, they should not be forced to pay for another to have an abortion. Heck no one should be forced to pay for another person to have an abortion, religious or not. What obamacare was trying to do, which the court found unconstitutional was force their beliefs onto someone else
Republicans have killed every jobs bill and minimum wage bills and a bill to give tax advantages to corporations that have outsourced American jobs if they bring them back. They fought equal pay for women
Again, just pronouncements no specific.
FYI, Red states are the most welfare-dependent.
And you're non-specific declaration is merely an allusion to the Romney campaign lies that have been debunked.
"So show how leftist ideology actually lifts people up instead of enslaving them"
Not the way it works; you make the allegations, the burden of proof is on you.
The Koch Brothers and the Danger of American Plutocracy March 27, 2014
Charles and David Koch should not be blamed for having more wealth than the bottom 40 percent of Americans put together. Nor should they be condemned for their petrochemical empire. As far as I know, theyve played by the rules and obeyed the laws.
Theyre also entitled to their own right-wing political views. Its a free country.
But in using their vast wealth to change those rules and laws in order to fit their political views, the Koch brothers are undermining our democracy. Thats a betrayal of the most precious thing Americans share.
"Republicans have killed every jobs bill and minimum wage bills and a bill to give tax advantages to corporations that have outsourced American jobs if they bring them back. They fought equal pay for women
Again, just pronouncements no specific."
So typical, just throw out inaccurate leftist talking points and think you won. It is Democrats that are opposed to creating Jobs here, it is democrats destroying Jobs with their regulations. Face reality, the democrats are the problem, as well as the Rinos
Oh, the Koch Brothers, the ones who give more to charity than any leftist.
Barking up the wrong tree here
I quoted what he wrote!
I never mentioned that; stop putting words in my mouth.
NO. THEY ARE NOT!
You are reaching a conclusion that does not come from what he wrote.
Those on the left are trying to claim this is a war against women, you are continuing that false argument
But they are.
Besides HHS has other ways of providing them
You're done here! Again making me out to be a liar.
Stay out of my articles.
...
...
...
And I just remembered where we "met" before! One of the reasons the other place went to hell was the trolling and relentless bashing that got to interfere with actual dialogue and discussion and motivated many to leave.
And again, you cannot throw out bogus leftist talking points. Face it, the democrats are the ones against jobs in America, and it is leftist democrats destroying our jobs. I do not care what left leaning sites want to lie about, or socialist Senators like Sanders. You cannot throw out claims that are inaccurate. Like your claim that the USSC wants to make a religious Theocracy in America. Who is it that is opposing the Keystone Pipeline that would make 10's of thousands of jobs here in America. Who is it that is causing Electrical generation plants and mines to shut down, it is not the Republicans
And I am not making you out to be a liar, I am only refuting what you are posting.
Who did not make their case was team Obama's HHS
Alito nor any Judge can say if a persons belief is incorrect, that is not for the court to decide. What the court decided was that HHS did not prove their claims, and that people would not be harmed if HL was allowed to continue not to provide those 4 abortion pills. Being that those pills are available to everyone, no one is harmed by HL or others from not paying for someone's else abortion
BURWELL, SECRETARY OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, ET AL. v. HOBBY LOBBY STORES, INC.,
Not having read anything yet concerning the scientific evidence presented in a court I cannot say anything towards that part of your statement; however, the sincerely held belief did not trump law, at least according to the majority opinion, but rather, the HHS mandate is unlawful.
Splitting of hairs, probably.
What the court said was that Obamacare violated RFRA - period.
Yeah, I know - and if a bull-frog had wings, he wouldn't bump his ass everytime he jumped - or if a rabbit had a back pocket, he'd carry a gun.
IF - IF - IF- IF. Stick to the facts. The case was decided based on RFRA - as required. Various "personal" thoughts and opinions "mentioned" by the justices are just that - "in dicta" - JMHO - not binding.
The Court held that Congress intended for the RFRA to be read as applying to corporations since they are composed of individuals who use them to achieve desired ends. Because the contraception requirement forces religious corporations to fund what they consider abortion, which goes against their stated religious principles, or face significant fines, it creates a substantial burden that is not the least restrictive method of satisfying the governments interests.
In his concurrence, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wrote that the government had not met its burden to show that there was a meaningful difference between non-profit religious institutions and for-profit religious corporations under the RFRA. Because the contraception requirement accommodates the former while imposing a more restrictive requirement on the later without showing proper cause, the requirement violates the RFRA.
Now, what is going to be interesting is - "Justice Breyer and Justice Kagan wrote that the Court need not decide whether for-profit corporations or their owners may sue under the RFRA."
I read it as "we do not hold" in this case. That, to me, left room for a different decision in a different case. I can understand your reading of it. I've spent enough time in law libraries doing research for attorneys to know that a court decision is not always as straight forward as it would seem, at least not in the eyes of the legal beagles.
The Citizens United case left the court open to a barrage of business that I believe they will be unwilling and unable to handle.
The ball is now in the court of an inept and unwilling Congress.
This reflects back to the mistaken belief that the Puritans came to the "New World" for religious freedom. The truth is that they HAD been in power in England during which time they outlawed Christmas. The Puritans came here to enforce their religion. Elders went from home to home looking for people that were not in church.
The constant referral to the United States as a "Christian Nation" is totally false. The founding fathers wanted to make sure no single religious view would control the government. The Church of England became the Episcopal Church to avoid direct connection to the state religion of England.
Individuals employed at HL are FORCED TO FOREGO CERTAIN HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS NOT DENIED TO EMPLOYEES WORKING FOR OTHER FOR-PROFIT COMPANIES.
The issue is not whether they can obtain those benefit items elsewhere by other means, rather that their employer's religious beliefs discriminate against them.
Actually it was; but Alito said in the majority report that "it doesn't matter."
And by the way
The ACA does not require employers to provide any health insurance coverage for their employees. Instead, the law requires those employers thatdoprovide health insurance coverage offer that coverage equally for both men and women.
HL could, but then they'd not be as competitive in hiring with regard to similar companies providing coverage.
And Congress doesn't usually pass laws with the objective being that no one abide by them.
But it voted to uphold the Constitutionality of the ACA, another reason why the HL decision seems to be contrary/conflicted and deferential to one particular religion over others.
Logical fallacy.
One religion has been favored over another. Conversion is a red herring.
It has been for female employees at HL. Their religious beliefs don't preclude them from what HL refuses to cover.
Leave my grandchildren out of it; the embarrassment will be in the fact that I bother to respond to you.