╌>

Interests, Ideology and Climate Change

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  8 comments

Interests, Ideology and Climate Change

Krugman_New-thumbLarge.jpg?width=100 Paul Krugman

There are three things we know about man-made global warming.

First, the consequences will be terrible if we dont take quick action to limit carbon emissions.

Second, in pure economic terms the required actionshouldn'tbe hard to take:emission controls, done right, would probably slow economic growth, but not by much.

Third, the politics of action are nonetheless very difficult.

But why is it so hard to act? Is it the power of vested interests?

Ive been looking into that issue and have come to the somewhat surprising conclusion that its not mainly about the vested interests. They do, of course, exist and play an important role; funding from fossil-fuel interests has played a crucial role in sustaining the illusion that climate science is less settled than it is. But the monetary stakes arent nearly as big as you might think. What makes rational action on climate so hard is something else a toxic mix of ideology and anti-intellectualism.

Before I get to that, however, an aside on the economics.

Ive noted in earlier columns [1] that every even halfway serious study of the economic impact of carbon reductions including the recent study paid for by the anti-environmental U.S. Chamber of Commerce finds at most modest costs. Practical experience points in the same direction. Back in the 1980s conservatives claimed that any attempt to limit acid rain would have devastating economic effects; in reality, the cap-and-trade system for sulfur dioxide was highly successful at minimal cost. The Northeastern states have had a cap-and-trade arrangement for carbon since 2009, and so far have seen emissions drop sharply [2] while their economies grew faster than the rest of the country. Environmentalism is not the enemy of economic growth.

But wouldn't protecting the environment nonetheless impose costs on some sectors and regions? Yes, it would but not as much as you think.

Consider, in particular, the much-hyped war on coal. Its true that getting serious about global warming means, above all, cutting back on (and eventually eliminating) coal-fired power, which would hurt regions of the country that depend on coal-mining jobs. Whats rarely pointed out is how few such jobs still exist.

Once upon a time King Coal was indeed a major employer: At the end of the 1970s there were more than 250,000 coal miners in America. Since then, however, coal employment [3] has fallen by two-thirds, not because output is down its up, substantially but because most coal now comes from strip mines that require very few workers. At this point, coal mining accounts for only one-sixteenth of 1 percent of overall U.S. employment; shutting down the whole industry would eliminate fewer jobs than America lost in an average week during the Great Recession of 2007-9.

Or put it this way: The real war on coal, or at least on coal workers, took place a generation ago, waged not by liberal environmentalists but by the coal industry itself. And coal workers lost.

The owners of coal mines and coal-fired power plants do have a financial interest in blocking environmental policy, but even there the special interests dont look all that big. So why is the opposition to climate policy so intense?

Well, think about global warming from the point of view of someone who grew up taking Ayn Rand seriously, believing that the untrammeled pursuit of self-interest is always good and that government is always the problem, never the solution. Along come some scientists declaring that unrestricted pursuit of self-interest will destroy the world, and that government intervention is the only answer. It doesnt matter how market-friendly you make the proposed intervention; this is a direct challenge to the libertarian worldview.

And the natural reaction is denial angry denial. Read or watch any extended debate over climate policy and youll be struck by the venom, the sheer rage, of the denialists.

The fact that climate concerns rest on scientific consensus makes things even worse, because it plays into the anti-intellectualism that has always been a powerful force in American life, mainly on the right. Its not really surprising that so many right-wing politicians and pundits quickly turned to conspiracy theories, to accusations that thousands of researchers around the world were colluding in a gigantic hoax whose real purpose was to justify a big-government power grab. After all, right-wingers never liked or trusted scientists in the first place.

So the real obstacle, as we try to confront global warming, is economic ideology reinforced by hostility to science. In some ways this makes the task easier: we do not, in fact, have to force people to accept large monetary losses. But we do have to overcome pride and willful ignorance, which is hard indeed.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Did NASA/NOAA Dramatically Alter U.S. Temperatures After 2000?

It is my view that while NOAA/NCDC is not purposely fabricating data, their lack of attention to detail in the process has contributed to a false warming signal in the USA, and they dont much care about it because it is in line with their expectations of warming. The surface temperature record thus becomes a product of bureaucracy and not of hard science...Never ascribe malice to what can be explained by simple incompetence.

Ideologies from both sides seem to simply reinforce each other.

Deniers deny because it will hurt their pocketbook and most likely lead to more government intervention. Believers believe because the science says so and government is the only entity large enough to force you to live the way we want you to live.

right-wingers never liked or trusted scientists in the first place.

I beg to differ.

A provocative new study claims that conservative climate skeptics actually know plenty of science. But they're blinded by politics.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

From that study :

Kahan threw in a number of trick questions, including one that almost everybody got wrong: "Climate scientists believe that if the North Pole icecap melted as a result of human-caused global warming, global sea levels would rise." That's true of the South Pole, because the vast Antarctic Ice Sheet sits atop a landmass. It's also true of Greenland. But it's not true of the North Pole, where the ice cap is comprised of floating sea ice

This would actually make a good test question for "climate scientists" whatever those are . If they get it wrong they are not climate scientists , just posers with a political bent .

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

I'm sure they don't. Perhaps we should just use the word arrogance.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

AHA!!! Petey on a climate article!!! I've been dying to tell you this!

I found a letter from my Great-great Uncle Fred, who lived in St. Louis, in 1929. He wrote, "I'd have never believed it, but here in St. Louis, on the 25th day of March, 1929, the temperature reached 85o."

Sheer anecdotal, but I thought it was funny and have been dying to share it with you! Grin.gif

He also wrote one page about how he was well, he was glad that Grandpa and Grandma was well, and he hoped that they would still be well when his letter reached them, AND, it may be too hot to come on the train for a visit that summer. (Meaning, I have to say you're welcome, but I wish you wouldn't come...)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

So you're suggesting a possible link between climate cycles and economic cycles ? Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

No! I remembered you saying that temperatures in the 1930s were higher than normal, and then, Boom, there was Uncle Fred's letter! I thought you would enjoy the anecdotal proof that you were right! Grin.gif At least on that one day in 1929!

I meant this to be good, Petey, not argumentative or nasty...

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Ooooo. I see grant money in the future. The Effect of Climate Change on the Economic Well Being of Populations.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

That sounds like a plan [combined with "Take the grant money & run." ] .

 
 

Who is online








65 visitors