Supreme Court Rules Police Need Warrant To Collect Your Cell Phone Data
With few exceptions, police may not look at the contents of a persons cellphone during an arrest, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Wednesday in an important privacy rights decision.
The police generally may not, without a warrant, search digital information on a cell phone seized from an individual who has been arrested, it unanimously held in Riley v. California , where the Court consolidated two suits involving California police who pulled over drivers and used their cellphone data to later charge them with crimes.
The ruling is a powerful affirmation of the constitutional right to privacy and requirement that police obtain search warrants in our modern digital communication era. Cellphones contain too much private data accumulated over years, which is not the same as police asking someone to empty their pockets, the Court explained:
Before cell phones, a search of a person was limited by physical realities and generally constituted only a narrow intrusion on privacy. But cell phones can store millions of pages of text, thousands of pictures, or hundreds of videos. This has several interrelated privacy consequences. First, a cell phone collects in one place many distinct types of information that reveal much more in combination than any isolated record. Second, the phones capacity allows even just one type of information to convey far more than previously possible. Third, data on the phone can date back for years. In addition, an element of pervasiveness characterizes cell phones but not physical records. A decade ago officers might have occasionally stumbled across a highly personal item such as a diary, but today many of the more than 90% of American adults who own cell phones keep on their person a digital record of nearly every aspect of their lives.
The Court concluded that personal privacy rights trump police fishing expeditionsor finding something else to charge an arrested person with. It pointed to previous Supreme Court rulings on whether a search warrant was needed and affirmed that privacy rights outweigh police expediency.
The Court generally determines whether to exempt a given type of search from the warrant requirement by assessing, on the one hand, the degree to which it intrudes upon an individuals privacy and, on the other, the degree to which it is needed for the promotion of legitimate governmental interests, it said, citing an earlier ruling.
California had argued that police needed to look at cellphones and suggested that the Court create rules for doing so. But the Court rejected most of those with a few exceptions. For example, it said cellphones could be examined by police to see if they can be used as a weapon. But it emphasized that did not mean that police could look at the data.
Digital data stored on a cell phone cannot itself be used as a weapon to harm an arresting officer or to effectuate the arrestees escape, it wrote. Officers may examine the phones physical aspects to ensure that it will not be used as a weapon, but the data on the phone can endanger no one.
The Court also said that police fears that people who were arrested would erase their phones were not justified, because police can still recover cellphone datasuggesting that broadband companies can asked to turn over all kinds of datafrom who have been called to whatever is backed up on the cloud.
As to remote wiping, law enforcement currently has some technologies of its own for combating the loss of evidence, the Court said.
Californias contention that police would only look at information relevant to the possible crime was also was rejected by the Court.
Tags
Who is online
79 visitors

Join the new Supreme Court Watch group;
The Supreme Court Watch was created to compile and discuss the latest SCOTUS rulings that affect our lives in very real ways. Please join us in our effort to evaluate the often controversial decisions of the "The Nine"
It seems to me it was a 'no brainer'. The cops should have known they couldn't look at your cell phone data w/o a warrant. Actually they probably did know, but who was going to stop them?
My question at this point is, can they confiscate your phone until they get a warrant?
Actually some police don't need to have physical possession of your phone to collect its data, here is device used by the Michigan State Police, called CelleBrite , that only needs to be in the proximity of your phone to do a remote scan.
This is good news ... mostly . But it will ruin the plot line of several cop shows on TV .
Yeah it's good news, although I kinda expected they were gong to rule this way. Funny how the NSA and other secret snoopers don't need a warrant for the same thing.
Btw, are you and Petey going to join the new SCOTUS watch group on NT? There should be some interesting ruling coming out in the next few days.
I didn't figure you for cop show watcher Petey, I thought you spent all your time busting chops on NewsTalkers.