The Pop-eyed Sisters and the Welfare State
My little Grandma was born in 1891, in Henry County, KY. The county seat of Henry County is New Castle, which is where Grandma lived during the school year. They moved to their farm on the Drennon Springs Road in the summer.
Every Sunday, Grandma and her family drove out the Drennon Springs Road to the little church built in 1812 by my 4 greats grandfather, named Mt. Gilead Methodist Church. He built the church before he built his house, and then prospered on his 10,000 acres, (about 1/8 th of the county), leaving many landless descendants, of which my branch has just about died out.
When Grandma was a child, in the late 1890s, a family attended the church that had two severely deformed girls, known as The Popeyed Sisters. I dont know if there were any other children in the family or not, but Grandma said the two girls were about her age. Besides their obvious birth defect, there was something wrong with them. Their eyes were on the side of their heads, like cow eyes, and they werent too bright.
Curious, Ive researched what this could have been and came up with a list of about 400 things that could have been wrong with them. Never having seen them, or met them, and not being a doctor, I really have no idea. It could have been one of the named birth defects that I foundor it could have been just a spontaneous malfunction caused by something environmentalor it could have been two people with the same unfortunate recessive gene got together and produced these poor girls.
Looking at the pictures of known, listed birth defects is more than enough to make me skip dinner, and, I am very grateful that I never looked them up before my son was born. As it was, the doctors had me so scared of birth defects that I had nightmares that my son would be born a gargoyle, based upon the quality of the ultrasounds. Thank God, he was born normal. (He couldnt be my son and not be weird.)
Anyway, back to the 1890s, the circus came to town, which seems to have been exceptionally startling to all involved, as New Castle is stuck in the middle of a county with little population, (still), and isnt on the beaten path, (also still). The Sunday after the circus left, the Popeyed Sisters did not come to church with their parents.
Hue and cry was raised: Where are the girls? Why are they not at church?
Their father finally grudgingly admitted that he had sold them to the circus . They were like cows anyway, he said, as reported to me by Grandma. The church was in an uproar! How could this be?
All the church elders got together; my great-great Grandfather included, and decided that the father of the Popeyed Sisters was an abomination to the Lord and should not be in church. In the first, and as far as I know only case, he was drummed out of the church and he and his wife prevented from ever attending again.
We now get to my questions. Grandma, what happened to the girls? Did they get to come home? Did anyone go after them?
No, she said. She never saw them again. No one knows what happened to them, or if they adjusted to life in the circus, or if they even survived life in the circus.
Grandma would then look me in the eye, and say, nodding her head wisely, That is why we have social services. Things like that couldnt happen today. This was in the mid 1960s.
No one, including the church, bothered to see about these two girlsif they were cared for, had food and could even eat it on their own, or if they were warm, etc. It is likely human nature to take care of ones own, but not extend the hand of charity when it costs too much time, money, and/or energy. While the father was universally condemned for his actions, the mother wasnt, (but what say did she have in the matter?). How could it really have affected the father that much? All he had to do was sell his farm and leave town, leaving the cloud of universal condemnation behind
Say what you will, when it comes to children, they need to be adequately fed and housed, and looked after, so as to have every opportunity for a decent life. And the welfare state works at doing just that.
What we need is jobs and jobs that pay something. That way, families can stay together and work their way out of poverty.
If any of us have anything to do with the public, we all know people who arent interested at all in working, and never will, especially if the government will support them. All right, Franklin Roosevelt started the Civilian Conservation Corps, which gave people an opportunity to work, for the government, at a wage that was enough for them to send some money home to their families. Their meals and barracks were paid forand the remainder of their paychecks went home to support those who needed it. It wasn't required or forced-- it answered a need.
I have long enjoyed the fruits of the labor of the CCC, in campgrounds, state parks, national parks, etc. The CCC was a good idea for people to work for the greater good of the country.
Could it work today? Likely not as it was set up then. We are in a different age, an age where taking welfare is not considered to be a social stigma, like it was in the 1930s. CCC removed the stigma for many people of getting help out of the grinding poverty of the Depression, and it didnt last forever. The men were working, and sending money home to their families. People were more honest back then. Few wanted to live on the government dole for long, and those that wanted to work, were able to do so.
So, what do you suggest? Dont forget the Popeyed Sisters, who had no one to care for them, or care about them. Is every case an individual case? How do you feed children and not their parents? How do you provide a place for children to live and not their parents? Is it best to keep families together in poverty, or does that just perpetuate the cycle?
I am very interested in hearing about your solutionsNOT complaints. Please keep the conversation civil, and rants down. While I know this will involve partisan politics, well have none of that finger-pointing here. We are working together for solutions.
Thank you for coming by!

There is no known picture of the Pop-eyed Sisters, nor could I find any kind of picture that really showed what Grandma described. There is this one, too:
Apparently, their heads were wedge-shaped, sort of, with their eyes on the sides of their heads. This is a picture of dysosteosclerosis. There are all kinds of awful pictures, but a lot of birth defects are caused by something that couldn't have been around back in the 1890s, like nuclear fallout, farm chemicals, etc. The other genetic things included Rieger Syndrome, Turner Syndrome, Noonan Syndrome, Apert Syndrome, and DiGeorge Syndrome, and a list of about 425 other things.
It got to be too hard to view. Anyway, I am open to suggestions to improving the 'welfare system'.
All I ask is that everyone try their best to keep the nasty down, and discuss this with a minimum of finger-pointing and partisan politics.
Thanks!
Note: I am getting ready to leave work to go home, so will not be back for a bit. Please be nice while I'm gone.
John, you have some good points. I'd like to offer an "Indian" point of view.
It was up to the tribe to take care of its people - not just one particular group. The individual was a member of the family or whole and each deserved equal treatment. With the tribe jointly caring for the individuals, there were no pressures on just one clan because it was an equal contribution.
That is what is wrong, to an extent, with today's society. Today, it is "me, me, me" and to hell with our neighbors or others within our community.
John, I'm all for everyone paying taxes! All of us need to pay our fair share. Would it be fair to get rid of the tax loopholes, for everyone, so that we all pay at basically pay the same rate? Back when the capital gains tax was modified, it surely didn't help poor people who had no capital to gain.
Everyone participates in the capitalist system, don't they? Just at different levels.
Thank you for your contribution!!
Yes, 1st, that is a fabulous idea. But it didn't work in the late 1890's did it? Humans are humans-- and after they had kicked the father out of the church, no one went to get those girls or to see about them. I don't see human nature getting any better, only staying about the same.
Isn't this what Hillary Clinton meant when she said, "It takes a village"?
I have no solution, but thank you for your contribution!
Yes, I didn't mean that-- I didn't say it right. I mean do away with the special interest tax loopholes so that we all pay in. That is more accurate! My fingers got ahead of my brain...
Well, if those are the only types of articles here-- 24/7 (!!!) --- why don't you stop posting them, and post something else?
John, it is probably my request to play nicely and discuss that got everyone shy. Most people enjoy fussing. I don't!!!
I like everyone, which is likely a terrible fault, but I do.
Dowser,
You asked if every case is individual. I would say definitely, especially when you consider things from the point of view of the person in need. When it comes right down to it, though, we treat the symptoms of our problems with more of a common denominator approach because, to our societies view, it would be too expensive to take the particulars of each case individually and tailor a plan to try.
I think that in order to address these issues of not only the sick or afflicted but the economically disadvantaged will necessarily take a paradigm shift away from some of our sacred cows and towards a new relationship with money and theh way that we think of utilizing it.
Tired. I should get back to this sometime this week.
Krishna, I think John also enjoys traffic on his articles. Like he said, a lot of what he posts that isn't politics gets little notice. Same here. Even a joke, if it is political, gets a lot of notice. Few people really want to try to find solutions.
Maybe if we paid more attention to his articles that aren't political, he would write more.
1st, I forgot to add something that's been bothering me for a couple of hours.
The tribal viewpoint, where the whole tribe cares for one another, is one that I admire greatly. It is also the way that things should be, but we have all lost our feelings of community. I think that many of us want the feeling of community, or concern for the greater good, but don't know how to go about it.
I've volunteered my time and $$ many times, toward the greater good, searching for a sense of community. I wish I felt it here in Louisville, but I don't. I don't feel it in my hometown, either. Grandma managed to accept the hypocrisy of a church who would "excommunicate" a member, but not care for the member's victims. Please forgive me, but that is what I see as typical "church". Grandma was born in a different time than I. Yet, she was a good woman and fed the hobos who hitched rides on the trains that my Grandpa telegraphed in and out of town. I think that my questions surprised her.
I think most people would agree with that.
But the real question is-- how to make it happen? Usually in discussions, both liberals and conservatives seem to be mostly looking for where to place blame-- rather than looking for solutions. (Well, actually, they don't have to look too far-- they just blame those on the opposite side of the spectrum
)
One of the favourite liberal vs conservative arguments is whether the government or private efforts should do it. But there is another factor that no one seems to talk about much. And IMO its one of the min causes of increasing unemployment-- and there seems to be no solution.
I'm not sure of the current term for it-- it used to be called "technological unemployment". One machine can replace many workers...
Just googled , here's but one example I just found.
You're right. But there have to be jobs out there that a person could do, not a robot.
Private versus Government is a good question... Private hasn't worked lately, has it? Not pointing fingers at any one political party, but of late, it seems that the private sector isn't doing it's share to create jobs. Even the government has gotten in on that-- hiring only part-time workers they don't have to provide health care for.
We all know that private sector employees have made little headway against expenses. Our combined salaries, (my husband and I), have had wage increases that have, in no way, made up for the extra expenses in health care, energy, or food. In the year 2000, we could afford to buy a couch if we wanted one. Now, we get the old one cleaned and save money to have it reupholstered if needed. (Which by the way, is long overdue!!)
Perhaps there could be incentives for Private sectors to create jobs. Breaks on health care costs for workers. Remove the tax breaks, but reinstate a few of them for those company that create jobs. And get the government to hire people-- full time people with benefits.
BTW, I work for the water company, a quasi-government entity, part time, and get no benefits. Luckily, my husband gets health care at work, so we're not personally responsible for all of our health insurance costs.
Personally, I think it is ridiculous to offer tax breaks for the oil and gas companies, when they make 35 billion dollars in profits every year. But that's just me, likely...
So, my answer would be BOTH.
I know you're tired and I'm sorry you have to work so hard!!!
I think every case is individual, as I'm not a one-size-fits-all person in a one-size-fits-all world. They have stopped making my shoe size, because only 3% of the population wears my size shoe. I now have to shop in the children's department!!! GRRRRR. I'm kind of worn out with little bows on all my shoes...
Anecdotal as that is, it is representative of the problems we face. Not one program will cover all contingencies, or one idea. We seem to simplify problems until they become understandable, then develop a solution to the simplified problem. The trouble is that humans are not simple...
Take care and I hope you feel better soon!