The Hugo Awards and the Nihilism of the Cultural Left
few months ago, I wrote about a notable victory in the culture wars: a group of science fiction writers had pushed back against the politicization of the Hugo awards, the most prominent literary awards in the sci-fi genre. The Sad Puppies campaign and its more radical offshoot, the Rabid Puppies, promoted their own slates of candidates for this years award nominations and achieved a spectacular success. So it was assumed that, having swept the nominations, the Sad Puppies would stack up a large number of wins in the voting for the final awards.
The response from the cultural left, such as Marxist Philip Sandifer , was to propose a slate of negation: to vote en bloc for the no award option rather than let any of the Sad Puppies or Rabid Puppies nominees win. This has been called the Puppy Kickers campaign. And it succeeded. In the final awards ceremony held on Saturday, there were five categories in which the final result was no award. For context, there have been a total of five no award results in the entire 60-year history of the awards.
In other words, the left would rather have no awards than let them go to the wrong people. This approach has been summed up as Burn the Hugo to Save It .
Yet there is something appropriate, almost poetic, in this result. It represents the modus operandi and end goal of the cultural left. Their counterculture is not about creating a new culture. Its about destroying the culture of their opponents.
Take, for example, the decision to remove Alexander Hamilton from the ten dollar bill. He is not being kicked off because we have found someone who is clearly more worthy. He was kicked off in favor a woman to be named laterwhich, when you think of it, is kind of condescending, as if nobody could actually think of a woman who had actually accomplished anything. But the negative form of the decision is typical of the cultural left. The dictate came down is that it is necessary to put a woman on a piece of paper money, but it doesnt seem to matter who the man is that they take offor who the woman is who goes on. Its about smashing the patriarchy, and who cares what takes its place.
Or consider the Democratic Partys purge of Thomas Jefferson and Andrew Jackson from their annual fundraising dinners (and from the partys history). Its not that they have better options to put in their place; Ive already run down all the problematic possibilities .
And thats the dead end of the cultural left. Everything is problematic, even the cultural lefts own creations. Drag queens are banned from gay pride parades for being insensitive to the transgendered. A movie about the gay rights movement is attacked for failing to give enough credit to people of color, hustlers, lesbians, drag queens, and transgender people.
This is what happens when art serves a political master, particularly such a fickle master.
I recently argued that if were going to have a culture war, it should be more of a culture competition: you put out your best, most appealing visions of your ideal, well put out ours, and well see who wins more converts. That, in essence, is the challenge the Sad Puppies posed to the cultural left, and now we see how they responded. The only way they can win a cultural competition is by suppressing the alternatives.
Or to be more accurate, the only way they can win is to make everyone else lose. Its the culture of no award.
http://thefederalist.com/2015/08/28/no-award-the-hugo-awards-and-the-nihilism-of-the-cultural-left/
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

When I read that I had a flashback to the 1968 Dem convention . There were shots of "protestors" complaining against the main Dem candidate with no alternative presented . Perhaps that's when all of this began in the US ...
The Sad puppies should probably consider this a victory. They wanted to expose what a sham these awards are and they succeeded. Just like the Academy awards they are a joke.