Morning Joe: If a GOP Prez Lost IRS Emails, It Would Be NYT Lead Story Every Day
"I think with a different administration, one that was a Republican administration, this story would be a national obsession..."
ccording to most of the Morning Joe panel on Monday, the media is not doing its job covering the IRS scandal. As Mark Halperin opined, " I think with a different administration, one that was a Republican administration, this story would be a national obsession, and, instead, it's getting coverage here and a few other places. But it deserves a lot more questions. "
Halperin began the discussion but fellow panelist BobbyGhosh and host Joe Scarborough quickly joined him in calling out the hypocrisy of the mainstream media.
The segment began with Halperin telling Scarborough that the IRS scandal was a test for the media. Joe asked the Bloomberg columnistto explain.
Halperin : Because when any government agency, particularly one as powerful as the IRS, engages in something that even people sympathetic to the admission says looks weird and suspicious, it's incumbent on all of the national media to aggressively ask more questions. The Republicans in Congress are asking questions. I think with a different administration, one that was a Republican administration, this story would be a national obsession, and, instead, it's getting coverage here and a few other places. But it deserves a lot more questions.
Bobby Ghosh agreed, but Bloomberg's Al Hunt, who usually goes out of his way to protect the Obama administration, said there has been plenty of coverage of the scandal.
Ghosh : Absolutely. If they were targeting Democratic groups and had been a Republican president, I think it would be in the front pages of every newspaper for weeks.
Hunt: Yeah. I actually think there's been reasonably aggressive coverage, mark. I'll send you a bunch of The New York Times pieces. I don't think it's covered up by the press. I think it's confusing, however. There is no evidence yet that there was any political interference. There is clear evidence that there was absolutely outrageous behavior by bureaucrats. There was clearly some targeting that went on. Some of it grows out of the Citizens United case. There are people who ought to be punished, perhaps even prosecuted. The critical question remains whether there was political interference from the top, either the treasury or the White House, and everything we have seen so far suggests not. But more is to be investigated.
Halperin: I just don't think we can presume a presumption of innocence just because the White House says the Treasury wasn't involved.
Joe Scarborough ended the conversation by implying the mainstream media is not passing the test Halperin outlined:
Scarboroug h: ...But you have a situation, again, where somebody was, again, where the chairman of Ways and Means-- I find it hard to believe that if the Democratic chairman of the Ways and Means sent a Republican administration a letter saying we are going to begin an inquiry about you targeting individual Americans and political groups that don't like Republicans -- and then a week or so later, e-mails from the top leaders at the IRS disappear...? [Holding up the "NY Times" he added] I find that hard to believe that would not be on the front page of this newspaper every day. Who knows?

This is his presidency - you can't accuse him/them or you are racist.
What occurred with the electronic storage drives/systems is BS. The files are there and they can be retrieved with little to no trouble by capable IT folks. They just need access.
The IRS is not and has never been sorry for its actions. Its just sorry it got caught.
And they will keep on keeping on.
Didn't mean to go over your head - I'll try to get simplier for you in the future.
Why imagine?
The Bush White House email controversy surfaced in 2007, during the controversy involving the dismissal of eight U.S. attorneys.
Congressional requests for administration documents while investigating the dismissals of the U.S. attorneys required the Bush administration to reveal that not all internal White House emails were available, because they were sent via a non-government domain hosted on an email server not controlled by the federal government. Conducting governmental business in this manner is apossible violation of the Presidential Records Act of 1978, and the Hatch Act.
Over 5 million emails may have been lost or deleted. Greg Palast claims to have come up with 500 of the Karl Rove lost emails, leading to damaging allegations. In 2009, it was announced that as many as22 million emails may have been deleted.
What was that IRS number again?
Those of you trying to imagine, I hope this has been helpful.
Do express your outrage, please.
The irs, acting as a partisan enforcer, broke the law. The emails are, accordingly, important.
But when they have done so, all were fired by an incoming President; Bush fired those who would not arbitrarily prosecute democrats for so-called "election fraud." The fraud was in alleging that there was such fraud. Bush's firing of the attorneys was just as partisan.
So, get hysterical.
I'm not defending the IRS; until such time if ever the IRS publishes a list of all of the nearly 300 targeted groups, it deserves the suspicion.
I have been searching for the names of those groups to no avail.
But my comment in in regard to the hysteria you were imagining. Selective indignation is my issue.
No, he's not - but - he's got 2 1/2 years of job security if he says the right thing
Judging by the number of articles I can still find on the Bush attorney dismissal in comparison to articles on the IRS scandal, I would have to say you just proven Sean's point.
Of course you'd say that but you'd be wrong.
Presidents coming into office fire all Federal Attorneys and replace them ALL AT ONCE; they do not selectively do what Bush did nor for the reason he did it, namely to toss out Federal Attorneys (9 of them) because they would not go along with partisan, fraudulent prosecutions.
Fired U.S. Attorneys: Bush Administration 'Turned The Justice Department Into The Laughingstock Of The Country'...
I am talking about the amount of media coverage, which you have demonstrated again, seems very abundant on Bush. Both of these scandals are equally offensive and are a slap in the face to the American people and the justice system.
"I am talking about the amount of media coverage, which you have demonstrated again, seems very abundant on Bush."
I understand that as well; if you Google the current IRS issue you'll find abundant coverage, probably even more than on the Bush e-mails -- try it and see for yourself.
The difference is that while the current IRS issue has not been proven -- there are articles indicating that liberal groups were also investigated -- the partisan Bush firings were verified by some of the attorneys themselves.
And Sean was talking specifically about the "hysteria." Bush/Gonzalez were trying to steal local elections which the fired attorneys would not accommodate! That was verified and yet, not that much hysteria from the same righties that are ranting currently about lost e-mails today.
Selective indignation = hypocrisy.
I don't know dennis; it could certainly answer some questions -- either way; I don't know if it's a privacy/protocol thing -- I keep looking.
I have not even read of Issa asking for the list -- wouldn't you think he'd do that at the top of the investigation?
In all honesty, Six, every news organization that I've seen lately, this is the hot poop of the week. It's on CNN, NBC, CBS, TWC News, etc.
I don't think anyone is handling this with kid gloves, but I could easily be wrong. I don't get my news from the newspaper, these days. They have a tendency to pile up around the house.
I've been searching for days for a list of the organizations "targeted" by the IRS regarding the 501 (c) (4) "investigation" -- the so-called "IRS Scandal."
I can't find such a list of the almost 300 organizations.
Wouldn't one expect that Issa and other Republicans insisting that liberal groups were not targeted, WOULD HAVE FIRST THING, ASKED THE IRS TO PROVIDE SUCH A LIST, AND, UPON RECEIVING THAT LIST, DISPLAYED FAR AND WIDE, THE EVIDENCE?
Instead, we have an on-going "investigation" -- one that keeps the headline in everyone's face -- while the Elephant in the Room, THE LIST OF ALLEGEDLY TARGETED GROUPS, IS NOT MENTIONED NOR EVEN ASKED FOR (to my knowledge).
Rule-of-thumb for trial lawyers: "NEVER ASK A QUESTION (during a trial) TO WHICH YOU DON'T ALREADY KNOW THE ANSWER."
There's plenty of media coverage on this story, but no one is asking the obvious question!
Thanks, Mike,
I can barely read the names on the list as the print is quite small.
I do see the word "party" in a number of groups and that in-and-of-itself is a red flag as it implies "political" rather than "social welfare" activity which under 501 (c)(4) exemption, disqualifies.
If in fact extra scrutiny was placed on Conservative groups then indeed, the "whys" might be obvious although I'd still like to see a complete and readable list. And of course, who directed such a targeting is key.
I found this interesting from the article
So then, what's the list at the link?
I'd expect Sekulow to put himself in the picture
Sekulow is a frequent guest commentator on the Christian Broadcasting Network and the Fox News Channel . He's had other issues (from my liberal perspective) as well.
And till, NO FULL LIST = SUSPICION all the way around. I can see how either side of the issue might not want full disclosure.
And ultimately, the 501 (c)(4) language must be restored and enforced at its 1959 and true status. No politically-involved activity, right or left, should have tax-exempt status.
Open a Congressional hearing on reforming the tax code, televise the entire process right down to posting the language of the revised code on screen and the internet, ban any/all lobbyists/special interests from the procedure, forever disallow such entities to write any code provisions --
How's that for starters?