╌>

Let's Blame the Jews

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  12 years ago  •  12 comments

Let's Blame the Jews


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

Presbyterian Church (USA) Makes Controversial Divestment Move Against Israel

CATERPILLAR WESTBANK

The largest U.S. Presbyterian church narrowly voted Friday to divest from three multinational corporations that it said supply Israel with products that promote violence in occupied Palestinian territories.

The divestment, vehemently opposed by many of the nation's prominent Jewish organizations, and hailed by many pro-Palestinian activists, passed by seven votes after hours of tense and complex debate. It means the Presbyterian Church (USA) will sell its shares of Motorola Solutions, Caterpillar and Hewlett Packard, worth about $21 million.

The vote at the church's biennial General Assembly, meeting this week in Detroit, was 310 to 303. It makes the 1.76-million member church the largest religious group to vote for divestment, an issue that has been fiercely debated in recent years among mainline Protestants. The Episcopal Church and Evangelical Lutheran Church in America both have rejected divestment. Presbyterians have discussed divestment for a decade, and a similar vote was defeated by a slim margin two years ago at the last church assembly.

There was an audible gasp on the floor in at the COBO Center in downtown Detroit after the motion passed. "In no way is this a reflection of our lack of love for our Jewish brothers and sisters," Heath Rada, the church assembly's moderator, told the assembly afterwards.

But opponents described it as exactly that.

"This decision will undoubtedly have a devastating impact on relations between mainstream Jewish groups and the national Presbyterian Church (USA)," said Rabbi Steve Gutow, president of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, whose organization was one of several major Jewish groups that had flown rabbis to Detroit to plead against divestment. Gutow, in a statement, described the vote as stemming from a "deep animus" in church leadership against "both the Jewish people and the State of Israel."

Supporters of the wider Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, or BDS, described Presbyterian divestment as a victory, though the measure the church passed Friday evening separated itself from the movement.

Divesting from the three companies is "not to be construed or represented by any organization of the PC(USA) as divestment from the State of Israel, or an alignment with or endorsement of the global BDS (Boycott, Divest and Sanctions) movement," said the text of the Presbyterian's overture.

The vote, amended several times on the assembly floor, also supported interfaith cooperation, the right of Israel to exist, and a two-state solution. In addition, it said the church should strive for "positive investment" in nonviolent efforts that help everyday Israelis and Palestinians. An effort supporting "positive investment" was passed at the church assembly in 2012, and the church has since invested close to a $1 million in education, renewable energy and microfinance in the Palestinian territories, according to Elizabeth Dunning, moderator of the church Mission Responsibility Through Investment committee.

Dunning said the church singled out Caterpillar because its bulldozers have been used to demolish Palestinian homes. Motorola Solutions, she said, was selected because the Israeli Defense Force buys the company's communication technologies. She said the church targeted Hewlett-Packard because the Israeli Navy has used its products to coordinate the blockade of the Gaza Strip and because its biometric scanners are in place at checkpoints.

In a prior interviews and statements, Motorola and Hewlett-Packard representatives have defended their products and cited their safety and human rights protection measures. A Motorola Solutions spokeswoman said the company's checkpoint equipment helps "people to get to their place of work or to carry out their business in a faster and safer way." Caterpillar has said it doesn't sell its equipment directly to Israel, but to the U.S. government.

Pro-divestment speakers at the convention on Friday said the church has tried over the years to discuss its concerns with the companies, to no avail.

"These companies have failed to modify their behavior and continue to profit from Israeli human rights abuses and non-peaceful pursuits," said the Rev. Walt Davis, a professor emeritus of San Francisco Theological Seminary and member of the Israel/Palestine Mission Network.

The network, a strong divestment supporter made up of Presbyterians, came under intense criticism this week by Jewish and pro-Israel activists, who had attacked not only its position on divestment, but also "Zionism Unsettled," a booklet it published that was sold in the church's online store. It called Zionism a "false theology."

More than 1,700 rabbis signed a letter to the church asking it to oppose divestment and criticizing it for selling the network's literature. Major Jewish groups, including the Union for Reform Judaism and the Anti-Defamation League, came out against the pamphlet and divestment. Abraham H. Foxman, ADL national director, said Friday that church leaders have "fomented an atmosphere of open hostility to Israel" and that the vote sent a "painful message" about Jewish-Presbyterian relations.

Rabbi Rick Jacobs, the president of the Union for Reform Judaism, twice addressed Presbyterians on the assembly floor to plead against divesting -- including offering to set up a meeting for church leaders with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if they voted it down. He said the church was not only choosing divestment, but "separation" from Israel and Jewish allies. "So be it," he added.

In one move that did align with pro-Israel groups' goals, but was largely overshadowed by divestment, the church voted down a proposal to boycott all Hewlett-Packard products.

The church is not the first religious group to divest, though it's the biggest and most influential. The Friends Fiduciary Corp., which coordinates investments for 250 Quaker groups, divested from Caterpillar, Motorola Solutions and Veolia Environment in 2012. Last year, the Mennonite Central Committee decided to not "knowingly invest in companies that benefit from products or services used to perpetrate acts of violence against Palestinians [and] Israelis." Although the United Methodists voted against churchwide divestment in 2012, its General Board of Pension and Health Benefits decided last week to sell its stock in G4S, a prison and security services company, after members asked questions about its work in Israel and the Palestinian territories.

Not all Jews came out against the Presbyterian vote. Jewish Voice for Peace, a pro-divestment group based in Oakland, California, and Washington, D.C., sent several rabbis, many of the Reconstructionist denomination, to lobby in Detroit.

"We are grateful the church voted not to profit from the suffering of Palestinians under Israel's 47-year-old occupation," said Cecilie Surasky, the organization's deputy director. "Now that U.S.-backed peace talks have proven to be ineffective, we hope that others, including Jewish institutions, will follow suit. Divestment has become one of our best hopes for change."

~Link~

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Wanna read a fantastic work about European conspiracy theories concerning Jews, and their use by entities, look no further...

Umberto Eco and the Elders of Zion

The truth that directs the plot of The Prague Cemetery concerns a famous fiction created in the late 19th century, a fiction plagiarized from earlier fiction, including works by the French novelists Eugne Sue and Alexandre Dumas pre . Despite such disreputable beginnings, this famous fiction went on to assume the imprimatur of a truth so galvanizing it played a role in some of the more momentous events of the last hundred years. Fiction and truth thus penetrate each other with a creative abandon suggestive of inspired pornography. What we have here is a situation ready-made for a novelist with a Borgesian fascination with realitys perverse permeability by falsehoods. What we have here, in other words, is that famous fiction known as The Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

The Protocols are a forgery represented as the genuine minutes from a secret meeting of Jewish leaders conspiring for world domination, motivated by an unnatural will to power and an unappeasable hatred of Gentiles. They are dangerously indefinite on specifics dangerous because the vagueness allows a great range of events to be thereby explained but in general, tendencies like secularism, internationalism, communism, universal suffrage and universal education are all presented as tools dreamed up by international Jewry to subvert the morals, politics and finances of the Gentile world and deliver it into Semitic clutches. The Protocols in their finished form were published in Russia at a time when Nicholas II had his hands full with assorted dissidents, and the dissemination of the forgery was meant to discredit any and all reformers. But the Protocols have had an active life far beyond imperial Russia. Henry Ford excerpted them in his Dearborn Independent newspaper, and had 500,000 copies printed between 1920 and 1922. Adolf Hitler, of course, gave the fiction a rave review, but then so had Kaiser Wilhelm II, who entertained dinner guests with readings from the Protocols. And of course the Protocols continue to sell briskly as nonfiction in many Arab countries.

The story of the Protocols is rendered even stranger by the labyrinthine history of plagiarisms and hoaxes that went into its making, and it is this astounding back story that Eco fictionalizes. One of the plagiarized sources is an 1864 French political pamphlet, satirizing Napoleon III, entitled Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu. The author, Maurice Joly, who spent 15 months in jail for his efforts, attacks the legitimacy of the emperor by showing plotters in hell undermining a rightful regime. Roughly two-fifths of the Protocols so closely parrots Jolys wording that there is little doubt of the borrowing. Joly, in turn, had plagiarized a popular novel by Eugne Sue, The Mysteries of a People, which presented the schemers as Jesuits. These sources are predated by a late-18th-century best seller, Memoirs Illustrating the History of Jacobinism, by the French cleric Augustin Barruel, who charged that behind the French Revolution lurked a conspiracy of Freemasons.

Napoleonic imperialists, Jesuits, Freemasons: where are the nefarious Jews? It was Barruel who first introduced them into the mix, a few years after his anti-Masonic book, when he received a letter from a retired army officer named J. B. Simonini warning of a Judaic sect that was the worlds most formidable and demonic power. This irresistible Semitic gloss to the theory of a conspiracy behind all despised social trends was expanded upon by, among others, a novelist named Hermann Goedsche, who was also a Prussian agent provocateur specializing in the forging of documents to incriminate democratic leaders. Goedsches 1868 novel Biarritz had a chapter called In the Jewish Cemetery of Prague, which, detached from the novel, was widely circulated, especially after its translation into Russian, and became a source for the Protocols. (The chief of the Russian secret service helped advance the fraud.)

It is this farrago of fiction, plagiarism and hoax that The Prague Cemetery dramatizes. All the historical players in this deadly farce are portrayed, interacting with the novels invented protagonist, Simone Simonini, a professional forger who is the grandson of the original letter writer. Simonini is like a Forrest Gump of evil, always present where the action is. Or, to change the metaphor, he is a conspiratorial cross-pollinating bee, all sting and no honey, spreading any lie that he can sell for hard cash. Simonini, cynic though he is, is not devoid of all genuine feeling: he genuinely hates Jews. The threatening bedtime stories his grandfather tells him feature a Jewish boogeyman, Mordechai, who will drag me off to his infernal den, to feed me unleavened bread made with the blood of infant martyrs. Yet another formative fiction.

A great deal of the action of The Prague Cemetery consists of clandestine meetings where people lie to and blackmail one another, the shady dealings punctuated now and then by rants against a hated group, usually the Jews. A reader unaware of the underpinning in hard historical facts might begin to languish beneath the tedium of the scheming and ranting, though Eco has tried to relieve the monotony by superimposing a plot concerning his protagonist. Simonini suffers from a split personality and is writing his life story on the advice of a certain doctor he chanced to meet in a Parisian cafe. He thinks the man, either German or Austrian, is named Frode. I had rather hoped that the inclusion of Freud, otherwise gratuitous, was Eco intimating the Nabokovian claim that psychoanalysis, too, is a species of hoax, but no such luck.

Indeed, the plot concerning Simonini seemed flimsily unsatisfying compared with the fantastic plot handed over to Eco by the facts of history. Still, if the creation of Simone Simonini is meant to suggest that behind the credibility-straining history lurks a sick spirit compounded of equal parts self-serving cynicism and irrational malice, who can argue? And even if the best parts of The Prague Cemetery are those he did not invent, Eco is to be applauded for bringing this stranger-than-fiction truth vividly to life.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

Larry, it looks like you are correct, it would be a very interesting read. I think that is why we are where we are today, too much fiction permeating into this world as reality and then becoming the reason for the realities of today. Hope I got that right.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Yes, exactly right.

Eco is one of my very favorites and this book here is a must read for anybody that would like to explore how fiction and reality can become one in the same. An interesting thing about Eco is that he is a world renowned semiotician, essayist, philosopher, literary critic, and novelist . The dude is a freakin' genius. He is the real-life Robert Langdon ofThe Da Vinci Code minus all the James Bond action. I've NEVER read anybody like him, or even close to him.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

When the Presbyterian church divest themselves of all companies that provide anything to Israel, I don't really think it matters who told you the antisemitism of Jews is a fact!

Let's deal with facts here and not messengers.

Are you saying Hal's comments don't hold water because he has some of the same beliefs? I don't think so!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

This was perhaps the most meaningless decision ever taken in recent memory . Since it has no effect on Israel [sales from Israel] it is a less than useless decision . It's effects on the stocks of those 3 mega-corporations will not even be felt ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

It still sends a message and that message is antisemitic. A lot of Presbyterians don't agree with it them doing it either.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I'm not sure that using a bigot (Pat Condell) as the one to attack bigotry by others is the way to go.

The guy in the video is an anti-Muslim , anti-Catholic, bigot, and aggressive atheist, who goes overboard in every single video he makes. It is kind of his thing, although I have to say he is entertaining if you are in the right mood.

I agree that he may be less convincing for some people becauseof the way he expresses his views.

I don't know ifhe really a bigot. He's not prejudiced against any particular racial or ethnic group-- rather, as an Atheist, he's attacking a philosophy (belief in religion)

Mostly he attacks Islam, as currently (it was different during the Middle Ages) most of the violence in the world caused in the name of religion is caused by religious fanatics who happen to be Muslim. Syria/Iraq. Yemen. Libya. Nigeria, Chechnya. Dagestan/Boston Marathon. Russia. Even Western China. Gaza/Egypt. Sudan/Southern Sudan. Afghanistan. And I've probably forgotten a few....

I've listened to most (all?) of his videos. He also criticized Christianity & Judaism. But he's attacking a belief system (religion). (If he attacked a political belief system instead of a religious one-- bashing, say, Communism or Capitalism-- would it really be any different?)

P.S: Bill Maher does similar things, only he has a somewhat different sense of humour....and is somewht "gentler" in his style...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

I really like this guy and I'm not an atheist. He's not a bigot John. He is in the UK and is just trying to let us know what we are in for if we don't recognize what these Islamist Fascist agenda is. I'm not saying all Muslims are bad people. I deal with them daily. I only have one who I suspect would blow us up if he could, but he is making too much money to kill his goose right now.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

As mentioned, Bill Maher holds similar views, although his presentations are a bit gentler:

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

This was perhaps the most meaningless decision ever taken in recent memory . Since it has no effect on Israel [sales from Israel] it is a less than useless decision . It's effects on the stocks of those 3 mega-corporations will not even be felt ...

Of the 3 companies, the only stock I follow is Caterpillar. (I almost bought some of their stock a few years ago as a "protest" against BDS, although currently IMO, there are better buys).

The bigots of BDS have been pushing boycotts for years-- but this action won't even move the needle as far as Caterpillar is concerned. Here's the chart of the stock price:

z?s=CAT&t=1y&q=&l=&z=l&a=v&p=s&lang=en-US&region=US

Incidentally they pay a nice dividend (2.6%).

It closed up almost 2% on the day-- a nice move for one day, and in after hours it was up an additional .1%):

Caterpillar Inc. (CAT)

NYSE
109.38 Up 2.13 (1.99%) Jun 20, 4:07PM EDT
After Hours : 109.49 Up 0.11 (0.10%) Jun 20, 6:56PM EDT
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

She pretty much tells it like it is, but a little more gentler, doesn't she?

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot
Ozzwald


90 visitors