Woman faces life in prison for stopping car to help ducks and causing crash that kills two
Woman faces life in prison for stopping car to help ducks and causing crash that kills two
FILE 2014: Emma Czornobaj is pictured at the Montreal Courthouse in Montreal. Czornobaj. She who stopped to help a group of ducklings on the side of the road. AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Graham Hughes
A Montreal jury ruled Friday against a 25-year-old Quebec woman who was on trial for stopping her car on a busy highway to rescue some ducklings and causing a crash that killed a motorcyclist and his teenage daughter.
Emma Czornobaj faces a maximum sentence of life in prison after she was found guilty on two counts of criminal negligence causing death and two counts of dangerous driving causing death.
Defense attorney Marc Labelle said Czornobaj was shocked by the verdict. He wondered how she could be found guilty of criminal negligence in the absence of other contributing factors.
"This was not a race. This was not a person who took a chance and drove drunk," Labelle told the Montreal Gazette after the verdict. "This is not about someone who was speeding and took a risky maneuver."
Andre Roy, 50, and his daughter Jessie, 16, were killed when Roys Harley-Davidson chopper slammed into the rear of Czornobaj's Honda Civic on June 27, 2010.
Seconds earlier Czornobaj, a financial analyst, had stopped her car in the left lane of a provincial highway in Candiac, south of Montreal, after she spotted a group of ducklings on the median, CTV News reported. She got out of her car and tired to herd the ducks into her car.
Roys wife Pauline Volikakis was injured when her Yamaha motorcycle also slammed into Czornobajs car.
Volikakis said Friday she did not blame Czornobaj. My feelings are that its time that we go on, she said, according to CTV. I have no expectations but I dont wish any ill will to anyone.
Prosecutors wondered what Czornobaj was thinking when she stopped her car in a traffic lane, saying that it was not normal.
Czornobaj testified in her own defense. She said if the same thing were to happen today I would not have stopped.

Wow, this is just awful. A person tries to do a good deed, and 2 people unfortunately die.
This IS just awful, but I don't see the benefit in jailing her for life. She was trying to do something good... I'm very sorry for the deaths of the man and his daughter.
I would have stopped to capture the ducks . Duck L'orange is very tasty !
There might have been a safer way for her to park and rescue the ducklings. It sounds like she didn't think this through very well.
I think you're right Grump.
She tried to do something god, and the endresult was tragedy.
People need to maintain situational awareness while driving or riding. It is the norm, at least in the United States, to ascribe fault to the driver of the vehicle following for not maintaining sufficient distance. There is usually some ordinance banning non-emergency stopping on limited access highways.
What if it had been a car or truck that hit her instead of motorcycles? The results would no doubt be different, possibly even to the point of her being killed. Who would be at fault then?
Not well thought out? Yes. Criminally negligent, I don't really think so.