California: “Land of Opportunity” or “Land of Poverty”?
For decades, Californias housing costs have been racing ahead of incomes, as counties and local governments have imposed restrictive land-use regulations that drove up the price of land and dwellings. This has been documented by both Dartmouth economist William A Fischel and the state Legislative Analysts Office.Middle income households have been forced to accept lower standards of living while less fortunate have been driven into poverty by the high cost of housing. Housing costs have risen in some markets compared to others that the federal government now publishes alternative poverty estimates (the Supplemental Poverty Measure), because the official poverty measure used for decades does not capture the resulting differentials. The latest figures, for 2013, show Californias housing cost adjusted poverty rate to be 23.4 percent, nearly half again as high as the national average of 15.9 percent.Back in the years when the nation had a California Dream, it would have been inconceivable for things to have gotten so bad particularly amidst what is widely hailed as a spectacular recovery. The 2013 data shows California to have the worst housing cost adjusted poverty rate among the 50 states and the District of Columbia. But it gets worse. Californias poverty rate is now more than 50 percent higher than Mississippi, which long has set the standard for extreme poverty in the United States (Figure 1).cox1The size of the geographic samples used to estimate the housing adjusted poverty rates are not sufficient for the Supplemental Poverty Measure to produce local, county level or metropolitan area estimates. However, a new similar measure makes that possible.The California Poverty MeasureThe Public Policy Institute of California and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality have collaborated to establish the California Poverty Measure, which is similar to the Supplemental Poverty Measure adjusted for housing costs.The press release announcing release of the first edition (for 2011) said that: California, often thought of as the land of plenty in the words Center on Poverty and Inequality director Professor David Grusky, is in fact the land of poverty.The latest California Poverty Measure estimate, for 2012, shows a statewide poverty rate of 21.8 percent, somewhat below the Supplemental Poverty Measure and well above the Official Poverty Measure that does not adjust for housing costs (16.5 percent).The California Poverty Measure also provides data for most of Californias 58 counties, with some smaller counties combined due to statistical limitations. This makes it possible to estimate the California Poverty Measure for metropolitan areas, using American Community Survey data.Metropolitan Area EstimatesBy far the worst metropolitan area poverty rate was in Los Angeles, at 25.3 percent. The Los Angeles County poverty rate was the highest in the state at 26.1 percent, well above that of Orange County (22.4 percent), which constitutes the balance of the Los Angeles metropolitan area. However, the Orange County rate was higher than that of any other metropolitan area or region in the state (Figure 2). San Diegos poverty rate was 21.7 percent. Perhaps surprisingly, Riverside-San Bernardcox2ino (the Inland Empire), which is generally perceived to have greater poverty, but with lower housing costs, had a rate of 20.9 percent. The two counties, Riverside and San Bernardino had lower poverty rates than all Southern California counties except for Ventura (Oxnard) and Imperial.The San Francisco metropolitan area had a poverty rate of 19.4 percent, more than one-fifth below that of Los Angeles. San Jose has a somewhat lower poverty rated 18.3 percent (Note 1). The metropolitan areas making constituting the exurbs of the San Francisco Bay Area had a poverty rate of 18.7 percent. This includes Santa Cruz, Santa Rosa, Stockton and Vallejo. Sacramento had the lowest poverty rate of any major metropolitan area, at 18.2 percent.The San Joaquin Valley, stretching from Bakersfield through Fresno to Modesto (Stockton is excluded because it is now a San Francisco Bay Area exurb) had a poverty rate of 21.3 percent, slightly below the state wide average of 21.8 percent. The balance of the state, not included in the metropolitan areas and regions described above had a poverty rate of 21.2 percent.County Poverty RatesAs was noted above, Los Angeles County had the highest 2012 poverty rate in the state (Note 2), according to the California Poverty Measure (26.1 percent). Tulare County, in the San Joaquin Valley had the second-highest rate at 25.2 percent. Somewhat surprisingly, San Francisco County with its reputation for high income had the third worst poverty rate in the state at 23.4 percent. This is driven, at least in part, by San Franciscos extraordinarily high median house price to household income ratio (median multiple). In this grisly statistic, it trails only Hong Kong, Vancouver and Sydney in the latest Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey. Wealthy Santa Barbara County has the fourth worst poverty rate in the state, at 23.8 percent. The fifth highest poverty rate is in Stanislaus County, in the San Joaquin Valley (county seat Modesto), which is already receiving housing refugees from the San Francisco Bay Area, unable to pay the high prices (Figure 3).cox3The two lowest poverty rates were in suburban Sacramento counties (Note 2). Placer Countys rate was 13.2 percent and El Dorado Countys rate was 13.3 percent. Another surprise is Imperial County, which borders Mexico and has generally lower income. Nonetheless, Imperial County has the third lowest poverty rate at 13.4 percent. Shasta County (county seat Redding), located at the north end of the Sacramento Valley is ranked fourth at 14.8 percent. Two counties are tied for the fifth lowest poverty rate (16.0 percent), Marin County in suburban San Francisco and Napa County, in the exurban San Francisco Bay Area (Figure 4). https://shastalantern.net/2015/08/california-land-of-opportunity-or-land-of-poverty/
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

I Love California and especially Los Angeles. My wife and I often take day bus trips back there to visit. We lived there for 13 years, but couldn't afford to retire there. Still, it was GREAT while it lasted and it's so nice to go back and visit. One of these days we'll have to go visit my son at his place North of the San Fernando Valley, but his husband's band is on tour so much it's difficult to work out a good time for all. They'll be in Japan starting next week and then China and then off to Europe for a few weeks. I'm glad his band is doing so good, but my son does miss him while he's gone.
Maybe, but it's much more exciting to live in Los Angeles and, despite a higher poverty rate and supposedly crime rate, I never once, not a single time, ever felt unsafe during my time living there. Always something great going on and you can never be bored living there. There was always the shopping, restaurants, theaters, concerts, beach towns, etc. The variety of the dozens of different kinds of ethnic stores, bakeries and restaurants made it worth it just because of that. The great neighborhoods made it nice too. Hollywood, West Hollywood, Santa Monica, Venice, Koreatown, downtown, the South side and on and on and on. You could enjoy a day at the beach and an evening in the snow on the same day. Wonderful!
AG.... I would highly recommend a vacation to WA state for the "weed". Legal, reasonably cheap, and available anywhere! Stay high, my friend!
We always knew that when we moved to Los Angeles that we would not be able to by a home to retire there. However we now live less then a 2 hour drive from all of the good things we loved (and still do) about Los Angeles and have a home that is certainly a wonderful one in a quiet neighborhood on a quiet cul de sac in the Coachella Valley. Since we don't have to commute to jobs any longer, it's a perfect location.
Many people from Los Angeles (and all over America and Canadian) have retired here and most visit the city (or San Diego) a few times per year. We love to go to Santa Monica and the Farmer's Market there or to The Grove for shopping or great restaurants. We knew when we moved to Los Angeles that we would not be able to afford to retire there, that's why we bought this home years before we retired when the housing market had bottomed out and it has gone up in value more the 150% since we bought it five years ago, so we were not "priced out" as much as we had a great investment opportunity to buy a fine home and still be close to the city we love. We may live in the Coachella Valley, but we still, partly at least, consider ourselves to be residents of Los Angeles since it's so close.
Besides, all of the things you mentioned as a reason to live up there, are down here in or near Coachella also. That's one of the wonderful things about California. You can live in a quiet, peaceful, safe community (as we certainly do now) and still have fairly easy access to everything the state has to offer. From mountains to deserts to seashores, to state and Federal parks and everything in between is down in this part of the state also.
Hell, even our weed is as good or better then Humboldt too.
Yep.
Actually I was replying to this comment "Mole hill into a mountain."
But then again you knew that didn't you. Cheap on your part very cheap.
Bullshit strawman comment.
However, it depends on what you are looking for wherever you go.
California is what you want it to be. Just about whatever you're looking for, it's here.