╌>

Maureen Dowd's Vivisection of Hillary -- NY Times, JUNE 14, 2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  12 comments

Maureen Dowd's Vivisection of Hillary -- NY Times, JUNE 14, 2014

Excerpts:

Hillary still obsesses about money, a narrative thread that has existed since she was thwarted in her desire to build a pool at the governors mansion in poor Arkansas and left the White House with a doggie bag full of sofas, rugs, lamps, TVs and china, some of which the Clintons later had to pay for or return. Even Chelsea was cashing in, getting a ridiculous, $600,000-a-year scion salary from NBC, far greater than that of many of the networks correspondents.

As a Clinton White House aide once explained to me, "Hillary, though a Methodist, thinks of herself like an Episcopal bishop who deserves to live at the level of her wealthy parishioners, in return for devoting her life to God and good works."

Hillary had a similar cri de coeur in her interview with Diane Sawyer. When Sawyer asked her about the focus on her appearance that once kept her so "scripted, cautious, safe," Hillary replied: "When youre in the spotlight as a woman, you know youre being judged constantly. I mean, it is just never-ending. And you get a little worried about, O.K., you know, people over on this side are loving what I am wearing, looking like, saying. People over on this side arent.

It would make a great Idina Menzel anthem, but its not believable that Hillary Rodham Clinton will suddenly throw caution and calculation to the wind. Having market-tested the gender-neutral model in 2008, this time Hillary is presenting herself as a woman who has suffered the slings and arrows of sexism.

Her apology for being "wrong" about voting to authorize W. to invade Iraq took 11 years to spit out, and she told the Council on Foreign Relations on Thursday that she "could not have predicted" the success of Al Qaeda-inspired insurgents in seizing control of Iraqi cities. If some bold voices had fought going into a patently unnecessary war against a country that had nothing to do with 9/11 a war, waged ignorantly for silly, macho reasons, that was never properly debated or planned in the White House America would not be in a global crouch now, and Iraq would not be a killing field.

Hillarys new memoir, like her last one, is a testament to caution and calculation. It doesnt feel written so much as assembled by a "Hillary for President" algorithm. All this excitement is being ginned up, but nothing exciting is happening. There isnt one surprising or scintillating or provocative word in the whole book. "Hard Choices" is inert, a big yawn.

In her "If theyd listened to me" mode, she is distancing herself from the president on Syria, Russia and the Bergdahl trade because she does not, as the former Republican strategist Matthew Dowd puts it, want to be defeated by Obama twice.

The opening of her book tour/presidential campaign has featured some stumbles, causing some commentators to wonder if she has grown rusty and tone-deaf, isolated in the ice palace she erected to keep out the loathed press.

No one doubts that Hillary is tough and knowledgeable. But the question of how scarred and defensive she is, given all the fights and rough times she has gone through, and how that affects her judgment now, is a legitimate one.

Has she given up the my-way-or-the-highway imperiousness that doomed her health care efforts? Has she toned down the defensiveness that exacerbated the Whitewater affair? Has she modified the ends-justify-the-means mind-set that allowed her to participate in the vivisection of young women she knew Bill had been involved with? Has she tempered the focus on political viability that led her to vote to allow W. to scamper into a vanity war? Has she learned not to surround herself with high-priced mercenaries like Mark Penn and Dick Morris?

In the last few days, two women interrogators have rattled Hillarys ice palace gates with questions that were obvious and reasonable. With Sawyer, Clinton said she hadnt known enough to know the Benghazi outpost was unprotected, despite what Ambassador Chris Stevens had called "never-ending security threats." On NPRs "Fresh Air," Clinton grew testy when Terry Gross pressed her on whether the decision to finally publicly embrace gay marriage was a personal evolution or a political "calculus" now that its not as much of a political liability and now that the court has dismantled the dreadful Defense of Marriage Act, which her husband cravenly signed into law in 1996. Clinton said she couldnt do it as secretary of state. But the vice president was not constrained from saying what was in his heart and pushing the president in the right direction.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Intresting.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Missed the point by a mile.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Right! Here is Tony Blair on this:

Tony Blair last night accused critics of the war in Iraq of trying to "wilfully" claim the current crisis in the country is a result of the original invasion.

In a 3,000-word essay, Mr Blair rejected claims that he was to blame, saying that if the West had not rid Iraq of Saddam Hussein, the crisis in the Middle East would be worse.

"We have to liberate ourselves from the notion that 'we' have caused this. We haven't. We can argue as to whether our policies at points have helped or not; and whether action or inaction is the best policy and there is a lot to be said on both sides. But the fundamental cause of the crisis lies within the region not outside it," he wrote. Mr Blair added that it is a "bizarre reading of the cauldron that is the Middle East today, to claim that but for the removal of Saddam, we would not have a crisis".

Read more: Tony Blair Iraq essay full text

He wrote: "Because some of the commentary has gone immediately to claim that but for that decision, Iraq would not be facing this challenge; or even more extraordinary, implying that but for the decision, the Middle East would be at peace right now; it is necessary that certain points are made forcefully before putting forward a solution to what is happening now.

"Is it seriously being said that the revolution sweeping the Arab world would have hit Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Yemen, Bahrain, Syria, to say nothing of the smaller upheavals all over the region, but miraculously Iraq, under the most brutal and tyrannical of all the regimes, would have been an oasis of calm?

"Easily the most likely scenario is that Iraq would have been engulfed by precisely the same convulsion The risk would have been of a full blown sectarian war across the region, with states not fighting by proxy, but with national armies."

Mr Blair, who said he was not calling for allied troops to return to Iraq but all measures short of that, including air strikes, said the major cause of the current conflict was the civil war in Syria, together with the "sectarianism of the Maliki Government" which had "led to the alienation of the Sunni community".

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

John Russell is the most ridiculed evaluator of columnists.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

There is very little point to this article

John, you have a habit of passing judgment on articles to determine whether they are "relevant," based on your own political convictions. It might surprise you to know some people don't agree with you....

No one doubts that Hillary is tough and knowledgeable.

Knowledgeable about what, exactly? Clinton said she hadnt known enough to know the Benghazi outpost was unprotected, despite what Ambassador Chris Stevens had called "never-ending security threats."

She also claimed to be "surprised" that al-Qaeda had made the progress they have in taking back Iraq.

So what is it that she is "knowledgeable" about? She appears clueless to me.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

You know, it's 2014, and the election isn't for another 2 years. Hilary Clinton has not decided whether or not to even run. Yet, all of you chortle with glee to dig up dirt and spew even more hatred.

DISGUSTING. Jumping the gun a bit aren't we?

Frankly, the more articles I read about Obama and Hilary Clinton that aren't even the least bit fair and/or factual, the more I'm going to campaign for her. This article is just stoking up the hate another notch, and has little or no merit in my point of view. You can make your point without resorting to such derogatory innuendo. And, gee, I don't even really like her all that much. Yet, I am fed up to the gills with all the hateful crap on the front page.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
The least bit fair and/or factual,

I'd love to know what part of the article written by a liberal like Maureen Dowd in the New York Times that you don't find factual... Should be easy of you to do if it's as disgusting as you claim.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Dowser; you forget that this is a "man bites dog" article.

You are not even a bit surprised and curious that it is by an uberliberal who should rightly be standing where you are -- in Hillary's corner.

THAT is what is so shocking.

It shows vividly how mind-numbing and impervious to facts extremeliberals are.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Dowser,

I made two statements about her where she says out of her own mouth that she was caught "flat-footed" as we say in the South. As Secretary of State, she should have been aware of Benghazi.

And as an intelligent and worldly individual, to say she was surprised at the progress al-Qaida had made in Iraq, shows a lack of comprehension about the enemy we have been fighting for over a decade.

She also made the comment on The View a few years ago that common people should not have the power of recall because they have no idea how government works.

She also wrote up a report and submitted it to the UN in which she said some of our states were in violation of human rights. If she felt that was the case it was something she should have addressed here at home, not taken it on herself to run to the UN, who can't do anything about it in any case. That shows her interest is not wholly vested in this country, but how she could make headlines and make herself look good.

For these reasons, I would not vote for the woman, and calling what I said "hate" is a bit much. I don't hate her, but I do detest the woman for her condescending attitude toward those of us she considers in need of being ruled, not governed.

I suppose on the subject of Hillary, we should agree to disagree.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I understand, mimi. Those are her own words, and they should be publicized. I'm not for her, by any means. I hope they can come up with someone better. YOUR comments were right on-- not filled with hatred, not just nasty, but intelligent and worthy of discussion. But, for those that are constantly spreading lies and innuendo, (and your comment did not!), and constantly attacking her character, before she is even in the running, is stupid. That's just spreading hate.

Do you see the difference? I do.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

It shows vividly how mind-numbing and impervious to facts extremeliberalsconsevratives are.

There, fixed it for you. Len, can you even write a fair and balanced article about anything? I'd love to read it! Otherwise, you're just another Rush Limbaugh.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Sean, as I said above, even I'm not that thrilled with her-- but she is not even in the running. Can she win the nomination? Frankly, I doubt it.

However, until the republicans can put forth a candidate that is more centrist, one that can serve ALL the people, not just his oil company friends and special rich friends, I will vote for anyone with a D beside their name.

My point is that there are a group of people here on NT that constantly spew forth lies, white lies, innuendo, and just plain nastiness. This is certainly one of those articles. It sounds like Rush Limbaugh wrote it. UGH. Get a grip, people!

 
 

Who is online


devangelical
Nerm_L


119 visitors