╌>

Federal Court: Warrantless Cell Phone Tracking Is Unconstitutional

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  12 years ago  •  8 comments

Federal Court: Warrantless Cell Phone Tracking Is Unconstitutional

Yesterday, the 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals made a landmark decision regarding police access to cell phone tower tracking data. The Guardian is reporting by way of the Associated Press that, while ruling on the Miami armed robbery case of Quartavious Davis, a panel of three judges from the court decided that law enforcement officers must attain a judges warrant before seizing cell phone tower data that could be used to track a suspects movements. The ruling however was not used to overturn Davis conviction, as judges allowed a good faith exemption, since the ruling happened afterward, and law enforcement officers would not have been able to rely on it during the investigation.

Attorneys at various levels of government have long argued that individuals surrender their privacy rights by using a cell phone provided by a third-party company. However, consumer cell phone agreements respect users privacy in terms of the personal data stored through such services. The 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that warrantless cell phone tracking violates the Fourth Amendment, arguing that individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy with regard to the details of their movements from place to place.

Cell phone tower data can be used to determine a significant amount of information about an individual. Details about ones movements could be used to identify a persons social relationships, business arrangements, religious beliefs, and other interests which are within the expectation of privacy. According to the ruling, law enforcement officers can attain such data during the course of an investigation, but only with a judges warrant after demonstrating probable cause.

This is the first time that a federal-level court has ruled on warrantless cell phone tracking in the context of a criminal case. The decision only applies to the 11th Circuit at the present time, which covers Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. A nationwide policy change would likely require a decision by the Supreme Court.

http://benswann.com/federal-court-warrantless-cell-phone-tracking-is-unconstitutional/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I'm amazed that the court showed enough integrity to make this ruling in the face of everything else that has been made legal to invade the privacy of citizens.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

All of the top cop shows (NCIS/NCIS LA/CSI all cities) have been showing using cell tower data for 'bout six years now so I guess the attorneys figure that if Jethro can do it, it's gotta be legal, eh?Grin.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Yes, score one for the people for a change!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Police will use anything that hasn't been outlawed, and sometimes things that have been.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Police will use anything that hasn't been outlawed, and sometimes things that have been.

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 113.gif 113.gif 113.gif 113.gif 113.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

NSA reform falters as House passes gutted USA Freedom Act

he House passed legislation Thursdayironically called the USA Freedom Actthat continues to allow the National Security Agency the ability to sift through the phone metadata of every phone call made to and from the United States.

The so-called "reform" measure comes a year after the Guardian revealed the snooping program with documents supplied by NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden. Civil rights advocates withdrew their support for the package, H.R.3361 , after the Obama administration pressured the Republican leadership to water it down.

"The ban on bulk collection was deliberately watered down to be ambiguous and exploitable," said Harley Geiger, an attorney with the Center for Democracy & Technology. "We withdrew support for USA Freedom when the bill morphed into a codification of large-scale, untargeted collection of data about Americans with no connection to a crime or terrorism."

The White House doesn't see it that way. "The bill ensures our intelligence and law enforcement professionals have the authorities they need to protect the Nation, while further ensuring that individuals privacy is appropriately protected when these authorities are employed," the White House said.

The measure passed 303 to 121 in the House.The administration urged the Senate to follow suit. Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy, a Democrat from Vermont, suggested that the legislation faces a tougher sell in the Senate.

"I was disappointed that the legislation passed today does not include some of the meaningful reforms contained in the original USA Freedom Act," he said. "I will continue to push for these important reforms when the Senate Judiciary Committee considers the USA Freedom Act next month."

Under the legislation passed Thursday, instead of the NSA collecting and housing the metadata from every phone call made to and from the United States, that data will remain in the hands of the telecoms. Previously, there were no laws barring the NSA from searching the data carte blanche , although the agency promised it would only do so if it had a "reasonable,articulable suspicion" against a terrorism target.

The USA Freedom Act, however, demands that the NSA get approval for a search from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court before demanding that the telecoms hand over metadata. However, no "probable-cause" Fourth Amendment standard is required to access the database.

"The result is a bill that will actually not end bulk collection, regrettably," said Rep. Zoe Lofgren, a Democrat from California who voted against the bill.

Under the act, a database search inquiry is allowed if it is "a discrete term, such as a term specifically identifying a person, entity, account, address, or device." Until Tuesday, an allowable search under the USA Freedom Act was defined as "a term used to uniquely describe a person, entity, or account."

That nuanced change, lobbied for by the Obama administration at the 11th hour, was among the biggest reasons civil rights groups and scholars objected to the measure. They said the new language was vague and perhaps would allow the NSA to ensnare the metadata of broad swaths of innocent people in violation of their constitutional rights.

In particular, while the previous bill would have required any request for records to be tied to a clearly defined set of specific selection terms, the bill that just passed leaves the definition of 'specific selection terms' open. This could allow for an overly broad and creative interpretation, which is something we've certainly seen from the executive branch and the FISA Court before," said Elizabeth Goitein, a co-director of the Brennan Center's Liberty and National Security Program.

It was pretty good when it went in, but when it came out it had been gutted and Nancy Pelosi lobbied hard to pass it and obviously most of the Republicans went along with the gutted act that still doesn't protect our privacy.

This is an ever increasingly powerful government no matter who is in power.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

My cousin told me she received a phone call from one of her grandsons. My cousin and her daughter had left the two boys at home and they had to go into town to take care of some business. They had planned on stopping at the grocery store, but decided to do so on the way home.

While in the grocery store she received a phone call from one of her grandsons. He asked her while she was in the grocery store to pick up this and that. She asked him how he knew she was in the grocery store. He said he could tell where she was on his phone. So for all you cheating husbands and wives out there......

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Do you really believe anything they say fool?

 
 

Who is online





104 visitors