╌>

NYT: Bergdahl Just A "Free-Spirit;" Capture Was His Lying Platoon's Fault

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  12 years ago  •  45 comments

NYT: Bergdahl Just A "Free-Spirit;" Capture Was His Lying Platoon's Fault

The leftist media smear of Bergdahl's platoon is gaining momentum. Now the New York Times has jumped on the band wagon (emphasis mine):

This duck-and-cover response is the result of the outrageous demonization of Sergeant Bergdahl in the absence of actual facts. Republican operatives have arranged for soldiers in his unit to tell reporters that he was a deserter who cost the lives of several soldiers searching for him. In fact, a review of casualty reports by Charlie Savage and Andrew Lehren of The Times showed there is no clear link between any military deaths and the search.

And a classified military report shows that Sergeant Bergdahl had walked away from assigned areas at least twice before and had returned, according to a report in The Times on Thursday. It describes him as a free-spirited young man who asked many questions but gave no indication of being a deserter , let alone the turncoat that Mr. Obamas opponents are now trying to create.

If anything, the report suggests that the army unit's lack of security and discipline was as much to blame for the disappearance , given the sergeant's history.

Taking their cue from President Obama, The New York Times is comparing soldiers to children who need constant guidance and supervision. At the same time, the NYT blames Bergdahl's actions on fellow soldiers, who apparently are responsible for controlling Bergdahl's "free-spirited" inquisitiveness.

But all of that is really irrelevant, according to the NYT, as the whole ugly incident is just a product of "Republican operatives" who managed to convince Bergdahl's platoon to lie to make "President Obama look weak."

It's all just a conspiracy.

UPDATE: Another jumps on board. Think Progress is blaming the Army .

Link


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Yeah it's all the Army's fault, all the Platoon's fault. This young man has no responsibility in walking off his post-in violation of the UCMJ and various Army regulations. Some people spend their life polishing turds. They try, butlike this guy Bergdahl, its still a turd.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Well if he is simply a "free spirit" then it all makes sense now!!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
The Obama administration is taking the same tack, smearing the members of his platoon as psychos.

The men who have spoken up about bergdahl are brave, brave men. While putting their lives on the line in Afghanistan speaks for itself, speaking out against the administrations lies carries a lot of risk as well. You know audits are coming via the IRS and their lives will be under a high powered microscope by every relevant agency in the administration. If one of these guys pissed outside when they were 16, Obama administration will begin calling them a sex offender to every news organization in the country. For their sakes, I hope all of their tax returns were perfordf by outstanding accountants and all of their skeletons are buried deep.
 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

NYT: Bergdahl Just A "Free-Spirit;" Capture Was His Lying Platoon's Fault

It is interesting that the concept of innocent until proven guilty is absent from the freakishly partisan Obama Hate machine. It is now at full throttle, using the release of an American POW, that had been a prisoner of the Taliban for five years and who tried to escape his captors on more then one occasion.

His health after five years of captivity had deteriorated to the point of near death and he isnow receiving medical treatment for those issues. So after putting his life and health on the line toserve his country and being harmed from providing service to his country, he is now being character assassinated by the Obama Hate Machine because he was released on Obama's watch and the haters can't stand to acknowledge anything good about President Obama. Their excessive over the top hatred for the man is freakishly out of all proportion.

So the Obama Hate Machine has stooped to attacking a wounded American soldier with out any concern for his side of the story which has not been heard or to at least give him the benefit of the doubt, "innocent until proven guilty". That is a basic democratic Constitutional right that he himself was defending in a combat zone in a far awayland that his country had sent him to.

The only crime that soldier committed is in the minds of the Obama Haters who want to shit on anything good that President Obama accomplishes. Even if it means unfairly attacking an American soldier in the press with out real evidence and before the investigation is complete and all evidence has been heard.

I can't help but wonder if the situation were exactly the same with the exception of the President, imagine instead of President Obama that it was Saint Regan, those same rabid Obama haters who are now attacking that soldier would be singing his praises and congratulating Saint Regan for liberating an American Soldier from captivity, and attacking anyone who disagreed with them as unpatriotic haters of American Freedom.

No in the Obama Hate Obsessed right wing mind; that American soldier is guilty for serving his country under President Obama.

They are a bunch of partisan hypocrite's that is what is obvious about their sorry behavior.

I'm glad President Obama got our soldier back. I thank him for his service and I hope that he makes a full recovery.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Still haven't read or seen anything from Bergdahl himself...

Rumor mill keep on spinning...

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"So after putting his life and health on the line to serve his country...." in what worlddo you live in where leaving your post (going AWOL) is serving your Country????

"...and being harmed from providing service to his country, ..." Again in what country do you live in where going AWOL is providing service to his country,..are you telling us he was well trained in the art of AWOL by his country????24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

"...he is now being character assassinated by the Obama Hate Machine because he was released on Obama's watch...." and this person who left his post and got captured is now being defended by the Obama Love Machine,.....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

More nonsense from the Obama kids table. Now Bergdahl is supposed to be viewed as just a free spirit who comes and goes as he pleases. Maybe he'll be back; maybe he won't. Total crap. A free spirit wouldn't be tolerated in any civilian job (including the NYT), let alone in a military unit that depends entirely on cohesion and discipline. Desertion is not like cutting class. It is a serious criminal offense and, in the past, has been punishable by death.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

Lon eRanger01, regarding reply:

in what worlddo you live in where leaving your post (going AWOL) is serving your Country????

Yeah... so your repeating the same partisan talking points against Bergdahl, how original and clever,or do you have credible non-partisan evidence that proves Private Bergdahl went "AWOL" If so then please provide the source or link, if it is a partisan right wing source then don't waste my time.

Again in what country do you live in where going AWOL is providing service to his country,..

Again, do you have clear credible non-partisan evidence that proves he went "AWOL"? or are you just regurgitating the same bullshit talking points from the freakish Obama Hate Machine?

...are you telling us he was well trained in the art of AWOL by his country????

Your clever wit is devastatingly lame. You are a powerful advocate, good job.101.gif

and this person who left his post and got captured is now being defended by the Obama Love Machine,.....

Again what is your credible non-partisan source for those accusations, do you have any or were you there personallyin the combat zone with Private Bergdahl himself?

Or are you just repeating what you heard from Fox Propaganda and the rest of the Obama Hate Machine. If it is the latter then I would humbly suggest that you try once in a while to form a coherent original thought based on objective evidence and fairness.Grin.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Bergdahl was supposed to be on the base. However, according toavailable information, he slipped off the base without going through the checkpoint. That's AWOL by definition. He apparently left a note saying that he was disillusioned with the army and was leaving to start a new life. If true, that's desertion (so far, the military won't confirm or deny the existence of the note). I really don't see a lot of facts in play here. All Bergdahl has to do is answer twoquestions: Did you write this note? Did you leave voluntarily with the intent not to return? If he answers yes to both (or just yes to the last question), then he's guilty of desertion and he can save any extenuating circumstances for an argument regarding his sentence.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

Oh my brightstarone betawhan grasshopper,....you proceed from a false assumtion in thinking you know what my political views are.......

"...evidence that proves Private Bergdahl went "AWOL" ..." a FACT that has never be in question,....desertion is the charge that is in question.......

"Or are you just repeating what you heard from Fox Propaganda and the rest of the Obama Hate Machine...." listening to this dribble sounds like you are trying to make lemonade from a hand full of oranges......24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif and while the thought maybe impressive to you....it just never works......24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

June 27, 2009, Bergdhal sent this email to his parents, right before he disappeared:

The future is too good to waste on lies. And life is way too short to care for the damnation of others, as well as to spend it helping fools with their ideas that are wrong. I have seen their ideas and I am ashamed to even be american. The horror of the self-righteous arrogance that they thrive in. It is all revolting. [...] one of the biggest shit bags is being put in charge of the team [...] [Bergdahl's battalion commander is a] conceited old fool [...] In the US army you are cut down for being honest [...] but if you are a conceited brown nosing shit bag you will be allowed to do what ever you want, and you will be handed your higher rank. [...] The system is wrong. I am ashamed to be an american. And the title of US soldier is just the lie of fools [...] The US army is the biggest joke the world has to laugh at. It is the army of liars, backstabbers, fools, and bullies. [...] The few good SGTs are getting out as soon as they can, and they are telling us privates to do the same. [...] I am sorry for everything here. These people need help, yet what they get is the most conceited country in the world telling them that they are nothing and that they are stupid, that they have nfo idea how to live. We don't even care when we hear each other talk about running their children down in the dirt streets with our armored trucks [...] We make fun of them in front of their faces, and laugh at them for not understanding we are insulting them [...] I am sorry for everything. The horror that is america is disgusting [...] There are a few more boxes coming to you guys. Feel free to open them, and use them.

He is ashamed of being American. America is disgusting.

I'm not giving the bastard the benefit of the doubt any more; as an American, I don't feel he deserves it. A friend said on the news this morning she heard that Bergdahl said people should leave his parents alone and leave him alone.. that he was going back as soon as he could to Afghanistan.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The Afghan people have been complaining for years about how the soldiers treat them so there may be some truth to what Bergdahl says in this statement and I can understand why he didn't want to be associated with it.However, he can't just walk away from a commitment he chose to make. If other soldiersacted improperly, then he should have set an appropriate example as best he was able under the circumstances. There are many Americans (including his own parents) who do not endorse the things that apparently appalled him. Flipping Americathe finger and then walking away (if that's what he did) is irresponsible.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

@ GySgt USMC (ret):

Knowing that desertion in a combat zone is punishable by firing squad, the question is whether the Obama administration will allow it to be said he was a deserter.

After all, Obama has had a photo op with Bergdahl's father where it was implying that the deserter was a hero of some sort for being a prisoner for five years... if he was. There are more questions than answers to this story.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
All groups have some dysfunction.That's not an excuse for the administration to label the non deserters psychopaths.Where's their due process???? Funny how the amdinstration will attached judgments to them without any process.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
And that, in a nutshell, is the biggest problem in this country. Lack of personal responsibility...it is always someone else's fault.
 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

1ofmany, regarding post:

Bergdahl was supposed to be on the base. However, according toavailable information, he slipped off the base without going through the checkpoint.

"...according toavailable information..."

Yeah ... available information, so what is the source of this available information; could it be : Bill O'riley or Sean Hannity perhaps,or maybe some other source with the same journalistic integrity and credibility that Bill and Sean have.

"That's AWOL by definition".

Yeah you speak with such absolute authority and sure-ness of fact, almost as though you were there in the war zone right next to Bergdahl himself. So were you there to see for yourself how it happened or are you just repeating the same partisan talking points from the comfort of your computer Keyboard.

He apparently left a note saying that he was disillusioned with the army and was leaving to start a new life.

Uh huh, that sounds speculative. Not factual. In-fact it sounds very much like partisan speculation for a particular political purpose that has nothing to do with understanding the truth, but instead to advance a politically driven narrative using the horrible experience of an American soldier who suffered as a POW for five years for cheap political gamesmen-ship.

If true, that's desertion....

"if true..."

More speculation that skews in favor of Obama Hating narrative, but no statement ofreal fact.

(so far, the military won't confirm or deny the existence of the note).

So if the claim that he left a note did not come from the military, then where did this note story come from? ... Fox Propaganda.... World Nut Daily... Alex Jones ... what credible source did this information come from if not the military?

I really don't see a lot of facts in play here.

Yeah I know the Obama Haters media complex is not known to be factual, they tend more towards gossipy bullshit.

All Bergdahl has to do is answer twoquestions: Did you write this note? Did you leave voluntarily with the intent not to return? If he answers yes to both (or just yes to the last question), then he's guilty of desertion and he can save any extenuating circumstances for an argument regarding his sentence.

Your compassion for an American soldier who was a POW for five years and who tried to escape more then once and who ended up near death; is touching and heart warming, especially since he is recovering from his captivity in a medical facility from experiences that he suffered as a captive of the Taliban for the last five years.

Experiences that you nor I could possibly understand or know about because we did not go through it, he did. I for one presume that he is innocent until proven guilty and I also recognize that he is recovering from his ordeal and understand that he should be taken care of before subjecting him to character assassination and trial by media and false partisan accusations based on partisan political gossip.

But then again when I say I appreciate and am thankful for Americans that serve our country in far away lands I actually mean it.39.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago
And that, in a nutshell, is the biggest problem in this country. Lack of personal responsibility...it is always someone else's fault.
AMEN!!
 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

Oh my brightstarone betawhan grasshopper,....you proceed from a false assumtion in thinking you know what my political views are.......

It is not hard to understand what your saying it is the same partisan talking points from the right wing media complex's latest manufactured Obama Haters scandal, nothing new nothing original, SOS.

"...evidence that proves Private Bergdahl went "AWOL"..." a FACT that has never be in question,....desertion is the charge that is in question.......

No.

We don't know how or why Private Bergdahl disappeared because we weren't there and we don't know his intent. We are getting all this information second hand after the fact from the partisan right wing media complex.The investigation has not been completed or even started because he just got back from captivity after five years as a POW of the Taliban, and he is recovering from nearly dying while serving his country as a POW of the Taliban in a dangerous war zone while you were safely here in America busy posting right wing talking points on the Internet.

"Or are you just repeating what you heard from Fox Propaganda and the rest of the Obama Hate Machine....

" listening to this dribble sounds like you are trying to make lemonade from a hand full of oranges.....and while the thought maybe impressive to you....it just never works......

Oh you nailed me good there LR, that was a powerful point you made ...

" it just never works"

I'm devastated.

"Lemonade from oranges" ....

Classic projection from an advocate of right wing media talking points.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

" We don't know how or why Private Bergdahl disappeared because we weren't there and we don't know his intent ..." NEWS FLASH,..the email from this person released by his father says it all..........

"...and the rest of the Obama Hate Machine...."....still crying....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif if I were to vote on a leader for the dreaded "Obama Hate Machine" today I would have to say the person to whom you are so desperatly defending would qualify as the leader based on his own words in his own email......24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

If you are going to cry and whine Obama Hate Machine maybe you should get on the same page as the one you are defending.....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

" We don't know how or why Private Bergdahl disappeared because we weren't there and we don't know his intent...

No we don't knowand no we were not there I stand by what I said.

"..NEWS FLASH,..the email from this person released by his father says it all..........

Yeah I read some of that email and it looks as though he had volunteered to serve his country in a war zone far away from home and when he got there his experiences showed him that it was not exactly the way he had heard it would be, that their were some shameful things happening to the native peoples whose country we had invaded and his conscience bothered him about it.

That tells me that he was a man of good moral conscience, there is an indication here that maybe terrible things are being done to people of the countries that we invade and the soldiers of good moral fiber are bothered by it. Perhaps that may be oneof the factors that can explain the high rate of suicideamong combat veterans that come from that war zone. Of course I would not presume to judgePrivate Bergdahl cause I have not walked in his shoes, but I know he volunteered to serve his country and hewentwhere they sent him; to find that it was not a perfect idealizedJohn Wayne Movie but a nightmare of death and destruction to innocent people for the sake of war profiteering.

"...and the rest of the Obama Hate Machine...."....still crying....

No.

Calling outthe phony partisan political propaganda hate machine that is the right wing media complex is not the same as crying, it is pointing out the truth about political bullshit.

You can see the difference can't you LR?

if I were to vote on a leader for the dreaded "Obama Hate Machine" today I would have to say the person to whom you are so desperatly defending would qualify as the leader based on his own words in his own email......

I don't see it the same way you see it, from what I've read of those e-mails it looks as though Private Bergdahl is a good man of conscience who was disturbed by what was being done to innocent people in our name. And I believe that his experiences are credible because unlike you or I he was actually in harms way and has first hand intimate knowledge and understanding of what is going onover there in ways we could not since we are safe here in these United States posting away our time on the Internet.

So I am interested and curious to learn what happened to this soldier, what made him disillusioned with what we were doing to the innocent civilians ofa country that we've occupied for over ten years. What terrible things have been done that drive such a high number of suicides of veterans from that war zone.

If you are going to cry and whine Obama Hate Machine maybe you should get on the same page as the one you are defending...

I don't know what you mean, as for the Obama Hate machine well that is an obvious fact and you can pretend that it is not I don't care but it does not change the truth of the matter and I will call it out every time I see it.

And you can cry about it every time I do.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Free spirits are not supposed to join the marines ... the Air Force maybe but not the army & definitely not the marines .

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

America and Americans are so disgusting we are deluged with millions of freaking bodies from all over the world and they keep on coming; for the love of G_d someone please get the word out how evil and disgusting we are!

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"And I believe that his experiences are credible because unlike you or I he was actually in harms way..." speak for yourself....I am a highly decorated combat Soldier who was in real life in actual harms way...so I DO know what it is to walk in what you are calling his shoes.....I don't believe you know what is nor was he ever in actual "Harms Way" That I say as a Professional Soldier who in fact served in Combat Honorably.....

just so you know,..I was at An Coung2 Aug 18 1965,...in Vietnam,..I was the Lance corpral who went all "Rambo" on the VC before rambo was cool......24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

"And I believe that his experiences are credible because unlike you or I he was actually in harms way..."

speak for yourself....I am a highly decorated combat Soldier who was in real life in actual harms way...so I DO know what it is to walk in what you are calling his shoes....."

If you say so... I guess.

But as far as private Bergdahl is concerned I was speaking to his specific experiences in that theater of war which affected his personal out look about what his country was doing to the people of that specificcountry in these times afterwe invaded and occupied them for over ten years.

I don't believe you know what is nor was he ever in actual "Harms Way"

He was a soldier in the U.S. military and part of an occupying army that was not invited into the country ina combat zone where soldiers were getting killed and wounded every week, it is easy to discern from those facts that he was not having a day at the beach while he was there; and that he was in-fact in harms way.

That I say as a Professional Soldier who in fact served in Combat Honorably.....

That makes no sense at all, you're telling me that because you say you served in Vietnam that Bergdahl was not in a combat zone and in harms way and you know this for sure because you say you served in Vietnam over 40 years ago?

That is utter non-sense.

just so you know,..I was at An Coung2 Aug 18 1965,...in Vietnam,..I was the Lance corpral who went all "Rambo" on the VC before rambo was cool....

I don't think there is anything cool or funny about war.

War is a disgraceful failure of civilization.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"it is easy to discern from those facts that he was not having a day at the beach while he was there; and that he was in-fact in harms way."...This is where your personal lack of military knowlege shows through....you can be in a combat zone and never be in "Harms way"

"That makes no sense at all, you're telling me that because you say you served in Vietnam that Bergdahl was not in a combat zone and in harms way and you know this for sure because you say you served in Vietnam over 40 years ago?".....NO, I'm saying as a Professional Soldier who served Honorably I do not believe he was ever in Harms way.....

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

This is where your personal lack of military knowlege shows through....you can be in a combat zone and never be in "Harms way"

So if a massive force of armed men invade and occupy another mans country and operate in combat zones then they may never be in harms way.

Well I guess that could be true if the army invaded Disney World.

But they didn't invade Disney World did they, they invaded Afghanastan. And soldiers operating in that combat zone were killed and Bergdahl was captured and imprisoned for five years.

I think that if you invade another mans country and occupy it, then don't be surprise if they take up arms and shoot at you or plant IED's all over the country. I don't think it would be safe anywhere for an occupying force of invaders.

"No, I'm saying as a Professional Soldier who served Honorably I do not believe he was ever in Harms way.....

So they were never in harms way in Afghanastan, and you know this for sure, not because you were there yourself; but because you claim to have been a professional soldier.

Hey I have another theory here it is:

you said what you said because you're advocating for an anti Obama talkingpoint narrative thatyou heard from theright wing media complex and you must regurgitate it.

OK, fair enough you can post anything on the Internet. But no one has to buy it do they, I don't buy into talking point bullshit from Obama Haters.

SorryGrin.gif

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

its clear you have no combat experience and have no idea what its like in a combat zone or even in an occupied country....so I'm done with your crap.....as for your Oh you must be an Obama hate Machine,...you sound like a broken record,...try to at least get some new material......

BTW why don't you show me one, just one quote from me where I have ever said anything that can be considered as Hating Obama.....

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    12 years ago

I don't buy into talking point bullshit from Obama Haters.

Fair enough brightstarone. Do you buy into talking points from Obama lovers? Grin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

its clear you have no combat experience and have no idea what its like in a combat zone or even in an occupied country....

That was never in dispute LR, I never claimed to have combat experience or to have been in an occupied territory, so why are you responding to me as though I did?

Is that a feeble attempt to come up with a straw-man argument because your Obama Haters propaganda is exposed for what it is?

Partisan Political bullshit rhetoric.

so I'm done with your crap.....

Gee you disagree with what I said and so you call it "crap"

I find that very surprising, never saw that coming.Grin.gif

as for your Oh you must be an Obama hate Machine,...you sound like a broken record,...try to at least get some new material......

Well the fact that you use the same unoriginal Obama haters talking points from the right wing media complex was an easy giveaway.

Perhaps you coulduse some new materialLR.

Just calling 'em as I see 'emGrin.gif

BTW why don't you show me one, just one quote from me where I have ever said anything that can be considered as Hating Obama.....

I can't know with absolute certainty that you yourself have hatred in your heart for President Obama and I never said that. What I mean when I say Obama Haters is to point out the excessive partisan hyperbolic word spewfrom the extreme right wing media complex which has a significant and unsavory racist component driving it.

And so within the Obama haters nation there area lot of dupes who may not actually hate President Obama but that blindly believe everything they hear from the right wing media complex when anything negative is said about the President.

The entire character and nature of the Obama Haters Nation is easily spotted by there over the top rhetoric and personal animosity against the President and even his family and anyone that supports him.

Their rhetoric is not about serious political discourse or legitimate policy disagreements it has been filled with a lot of personal insults fear-mongering, negative what if speculation and trivial gossip about the president being a Muslim, a communist, a Nazi, a Kenyan, secretly Gay.... etc The haters have been putting out their bullshitfor all of his Presidency and I expect that they will attack him after he leaves office, and even decades from now after the President dies of old age their will still be a few soon to be extinct Obama haters railing against the president holding on to their precious hate, while the rest of the world moved on.

The thing of it is LR the majority of the American people are not with the Haters, that is why he won the elections to office with the popular vote each time. The Obama Haters Nation is a minority of malcontents who have failed to win the support of the American People in their hysterical mania to bring President Obama down; in-fact the President has been largely successful despite their nefarious efforts.

It's so sad to see people surrender to the dead end wasteland of the Obama hate ideologyand not be able to see reason or decency.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"I can't know with absolute certainty....." and to the end of your rant,...I say nothing but pure unadultrated bullshit......24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

GySgt USMC (ret), regarding comments:

LR pacifists, anti military people. How can they be so blind to the real world.

I don't know who you think is anti military but I know who is anti military. The civilian leaders that put our military in harms way for the purposes of serving their corporate interest of war profiteering instead of thesecurity of the nation.

Over spending on a vast military that is spread out all over the world like an imperialarmy;a military industrial complex that supreme allied commander of WW2and president of the United States Eisenhower warned us about when he left the Presidency in the late 50's

Maybe and I think we shouldnt have gone there or at least left when Bin Laden was taken out, which really ended the mission there. When the president extends the stay more will die. Staying in a country that does not want us more will die. so the Onus is on this president.

Agreed.

Interesting that those statements express an anti war sentiment, and yet you derisively call anti war people "pacifists" and "anti military"

I can't help but wonder if the President had pulled out as I think he should have would the Obama hate machine have accused him of being weak and pulling out to soon.

Yeah I have a feeling they would have, dam if you do and dam if you don't.

But combat as you and I know is not invading Disney Land.

You're using my words in a manner that changes what I meant out of context. So to set the record straight this is what I said in context when I referenced the Disney name.

"So if a massive force of armed men invade and occupy another mans country and operate in combat zones then they may never be in harms way."

"Well I guess that could be true if the army invaded Disney World."

"But they didn't invade Disney World did they, they invaded Afghanastan. And soldiers operating in that combat zone were killed and Bergdahl was captured and imprisoned for five years."

This of course was our training in boot camp, people die in war, our job is to make sure its the enemy who dies for his cause.

The fact that people die in war and that a soldier is suppose to kill the enemy soldiers whose land was invaded and occupied for the purposes of corporate profiteering, is obvious and pretty much well understood and was never in dispute.

But thanks for stating the obvious GySgt.

That was very helpful ...... I think.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Bergdahl was supposed to be on the base. However, according to available information, he slipped off the base without going through the checkpoint.

Yeah ... available information, so what is the source of this available information; could it be:Bill O'riley or Sean Hannity perhaps, or maybe some other source with the same journalistic integrity and credibility that Bill and Sean have

Pick any source you like because they all have the same information and none of it supports the view that Bergdahl was supposed to be anywhere but on base.

That's AWOL by definition".

Yeah you speak with such absolute authority and sure-ness of fact, almost as though you were there in the war zone right next to Bergdahl himself. So were you there to see for yourself how it happened or are you just repeating the same partisan talking points from the comfort of your computer Keyboard.

My source is Article 86 of the UCMJ. If Berdahl failed to report or left his post, then he's AWOL without permission. Show me a single shred of information from any source whatsoever that says Bergdahl had permission to be off base.

He apparently left a note saying that he was disillusioned with the army and was leaving to start a new life.

Uh huh, that sounds speculative. Not factual. In-fact it sounds very much like partisan speculation for a particular political purpose that has nothing to do with understanding the truth, but instead to advance a politically driven narrative using the horrible experience of an American soldier who suffered as a POW for five years for cheap political gamesmen-ship.

Facts are non partisan. The issueof the note could be quickly resolved if the military would confirm or deny its the existence.Butkeeping silent allows people like you to deflect the discussion to his captivityandaway from the circumstances that led to his captivity.

If true, that's desertion....

"if true..."More speculation that skews in favor of Obama Hating narrative, but no statement of real fact.

No, it simply states the circumstances that would support desertion. If you think they would not support desertion, then explain why rather than trying to dismiss everthing as Obama hating narrative.

(so far, the military won't confirm or deny the existence of the note).

So if the claim that he left a note did not come from the military, then where did this note story come from? ... Fox Propaganda.... World Nut Daily... Alex Jones ... what credible source did this information come from if not the military?

No, it's source is the military but it's unofficial. Again, it could be quickly resolved if the military officially confirmed or denied the existence of the note.

I really don't see a lot of facts in play here.

Yeah I know the Obama Haters media complex is not known to be factual, they tend more towards gossipy bullshit.

If you see a lot of facts in play, then identify them . . . if you can.

Your compassion for an American soldier who was a POW for five years and who tried to escape more then once and who ended up near death; is touching and heart warming, especially since he is recovering from his captivity in a medical facility from experiences that he suffered as a captive of the Taliban for the last five years.

Your turning a blind eye to the circumstances that led to his capture is an insult to all who serve.

Experiences that you nor I could possibly understand or know about because we did not go through it, he did. I for one presume that he is innocent until proven guilty and I also recognize that he is recovering from his ordeal and understand that he should be taken care of before subjecting him to character assassination and trial by media and false partisan accusations based on partisan political gossip.

You're confused. I'm not sitting on a jury but rather discussing the available information. It's not my fault if Bergdahl is silent in his defense (if he has one). In any event, the elements of AWOL are spelled out in the UCMJ. His state of mind is not included, nor should it be. He can reserve the excuses in a plea for lenient sentencing (if found guilty).

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

We don't know how or why Private Bergdahl disappeared because we weren't there and we don't know his intent . . .

That's really the crux of your misunderstanding. His intent is relevant only to the extent that he knew where he was supposed to be. There is not one single allegation from anyone that Bergdahl had permission to leave the base and no one has suggested that he is too stupid to know when he is on and off base. Under the UCMJ, Article 86, he's subject to court martial for AWOL (i.e. he absented himself and remained absent from his unit, organization, or place of duty at which he was required to be at the time prescribed).

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

But all of that is really irrelevant, according to the NYT, as the whole ugly incident is just a product of "Republican operatives" who managed to convince Bergdahl's platoon to lie to make "President Obama look weak."

It's all just a conspiracy.

Thanks for the extra info, Six. I've followed some of the reports of this story and believe there's a strong possibility that the highlight is true, although, I think President Obama also knows what needs to happen for him to meet his goals of military strength and presence. Lying to destroy people is so wrong and disheartening, but it does happen. Thank you for the report.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The Army has already explained. Bowe Bergdahl CANNOT be a deserter prior to an investigation into his disappearance that includes an interrogation /interview with him. Period.

It is self-evident that one cannot be convicted before being charged. I was discussing evidence that "could" support desertion.

Had he been whereabouts unknown for 30 days after he left his base camp, then he could have been categorized a deserter. That did not happen.

There is no timeperiod in the UCMJ, 30 days or any other number.

The Army said, a day or two ago that Bergdahl is not a deserter, at this time. That is all there is to it, which begs the question as to why some people can't get that through their thick skulls.

The operative phrase is "at this time." Another self-evident statement since he has not yet been charged let alone convicted. Perhaps you can get it through your thick skull that the issue is still open.

Obama did not bring back a deserter.

You couldn't know that since, as you point out, there's been no investigation, charges, or trial.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

His intent is relevant to whether or not he could ever be charged with desertion.

I was talking about AWOL, not desertion.

The fact that Bergdahl went for "a walk" once before and came back actually helps him because it would tend to show that he may not have intended this last time to stay away permanently. It's not 'proof', but could be one factor considered. I'm sure he will have a good lawyer.

That will help if charged with desertion but would probably reinforce a charge of AWOL. As for desertion, his correspondence may be used to establish an intent to be absent permanently. Plus, desertion can also be based on an intent to "shirk important service." Article 85 (a)(2), UCMJ.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

1ofmany, regarding reply:

Bergdahl was supposed to be on the base. However, according to available information, he slipped off the base without going through the checkpoint.

Yeah ... available information, so what is the source of this available information; could it be : Bill O'riley or Sean Hannity perhaps, or maybe some other source with the same journalistic integrity and credibility that Bill and Sean have

Pick any source you like because they all have the same information and none of it supports the view that Bergdahl was supposed to be anywhere but on base.

No 1ofm that is not how it works, you made the statement and so you are the one who is suppose to reveal the source that the statement is based on.

Your suggestion that I pick a source is ass backwards.

You can comprehend that can't you 1ofmGrin.gif

That's AWOL by definition".

So what does that have to do with Bergdahl?

No investigation has been completed and no determination has been made by the relevant authorities that are suppose to regulate the Bergdahl matter.

All we have heard are the character assassination and gossip from the right wing propaganda machine.

Yeah you speak with such absolute authority and sure-ness of fact, almost as though you were there in the war zone right next to Bergdahl himself. So were you there to see for yourself how it happened or are you just repeating the same partisan talking points from the comfort of your computer Keyboard.

My source is Article 86 of the UCMJ. If Berdahl failed to report or left his post, then he's AWOL without permission.

Your quotation of Article 86 is not proof of what Berdahl did or did not do.

Show me a single shred of information from any source whatsoever that says Bergdahl had permission to be off base.

I don't have to show you anything because I was not there and so I don't know and I don't jump to conclusions with out hearing all of the evidence from the investigation that will be made, instead of the politically driven gossip from the right wing noise machine.

He apparently left a note saying that he was disillusioned with the army and was leaving to start a new life.

Uh huh, that sounds speculative. Not factual. In-fact it sounds very much like partisan speculation for a particular political purpose that has nothing to do with understanding the truth, but instead to advance a politically driven narrative using the horrible experience of an American soldier who suffered as a POW for five years for cheap political gamesmen-ship.

Facts are non partisan.

Do tell.... I didn't know that.

But then again there is a tendency in such partisan political matters where people spin their own facts to suit there political narrative now don't they 1ofmGrin.gif

The issueof the note could be quickly resolved if the military would confirm or deny its the existence.

If the military did not confirm its existence then whey would you spin it as though there was a note? Are you looking for the truth or are you trying to lead the discussion to a preferred politically driven narrative conclusion?

Butkeeping silent allows people like you to deflect the discussion to his captivityandaway from the circumstances that led to his captivity.

And no proof of a note allows people like you to make propagandistic speculations that have not been proven as fact or even investigated.

If true, that's desertion....

"if true..." More speculation that skews in favor of Obama Hating narrative, but no statement of real fact.

No, it simply states the circumstances that would support desertion. If you think they would not support desertion, then explain why rather than trying to dismiss everthing as Obama hating narrative.

It is a speculative statement, meaning that it is not a certain and established fact. And the speculation is slanted by the right wing OBAMA HATEING RIGHT WING MEDIA COMPLEX.

Hence the reason I call it an "Obama hating narrative"

(so far, the military won't confirm or deny the existence of the note).

So if the claim that he left a note did not come from the military, then where did this note story come from? ... Fox Propaganda.... World Nut Daily... Alex Jones ... what credible source did this information come from if not the military?

No, it's source is the military but it's unofficial. Again, it could be quickly resolved if the military officially confirmed or denied the existence of the note.

I really don't see a lot of facts in play here.

Yeah I know the Obama Haters media complex is not known to be factual, they tend more towards gossipy bullshit.

If you see a lot of facts in play, then identify them . . . if you can.

Again I was not there and I don't jump to speculative conclusions about things when I get second hand information like secret sources and right wing partisan media talking points.

Of course you can continue to do that it is obvious andtransparent.

Your compassion for an American soldier who was a POW for five years and who tried to escape more then once and who ended up near death; is touching and heart warming, especially since he is recovering from his captivity in a medical facility from experiences that he suffered as a captive of the Taliban for the last five years.

Your turning a blind eye to the circumstances that led to his capture is an insult to all who serve.

Your spewing speculative right wing Obama hating talking points to support a political narrative at the expense of a soldier who suffered while serving his country and not even respecting his right of innocent until proven guilty is an insult to all who serve and who would be under the same unfair character assassination before all the facts have been investigated and revealed, all for the crass reason of advancing a phonypolitical narrative, just to attack the President of the United States.

Experiences that you nor I could possibly understand or know about because we did not go through it, he did. I for one presume that he is innocent until proven guilty and I also recognize that he is recovering from his ordeal and understand that he should be taken care of before subjecting him to character assassination and trial by media and false partisan accusations based on partisan political gossip.

You're confused. I'm not sitting on a jury but rather discussing the available information.

I'm with out doubt not confused at all. I see exactly what you are doing your advancing the latest manufactured anti Obama right wing scandal with the same talking points that the right wing media complex is putting out to gin up the Republicans right wing extremist base.

It's not my fault if Bergdahl is silent in his defense (if he has one).

Bergdahl is recovering from near death in a medical facility after five years of captivity as a POW of the Taliban. Your compassion for this American soldier is heart warming.......41.gif (sarc)

In any event, the elements of AWOL are spelled out in the UCMJ.

hey you know what else : one is suppose to STOP when one is driving towards a STOP sign. That is a fact.... so I guess that proves .....?39.gif

His state of mind is not included, nor should it be. He can reserve the excuses in a plea for lenient sentencing (if found guilty).

As I've said and as I will continue to say :

INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY

All the noise from the right wing hate machine will not change that.Grin.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I'll venture a guess here. Bergdahl will plead guilty to AWOL and ask for a lenient sentence based on mitigating circumstances. Either at his request or on the Court's own motion, the Court will consider that his five year incarceration with the Taliban is punishment enough. The question is then whether he gets discharged.

If he is also charged with desertion, Bergdahl can claim that he had no intentto be absent permanently but rather he just left "to get his head together" and was captured before he could decide what he was going to do. The military will probably just let it go especially since the charge would be difficult to prove and, if convicted, would be embarrasing to the military and the president to have exchanged 5 high ranking Taliban for a deserter, only to have the deserter later shot or imprisoned for desertion.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

LoneRanger01, regarding reply:

I can't know with absolute certainty....." and to the end of your rant,...I say nothing but pure unadultrated bullshit.... ..

Hey LR, you said that you were not going to respond to.... what was that?... oh yeah "my crap"... but you then responded.

But having read your response I can see why, taking my words out of context and then putting a self-serving answer to it was a brilliant response that you had to post I understand.

That was an impressive display of your formidable intellect.

That is your best.

How sad.Frown.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

No 1ofm that is not how it works, you made the statement and so you are the one who is suppose to reveal the source that the statement is based on. Your suggestion that I pick a source is ass backwards.You can comprehend that can't you 1ofm . . .

What I comprehend is that you spend a lot of time not actually saying anything. To your limited way of thinking, any discussion of available information is part of a right wing partisan conspiracy against Obama or is slander or attempts to prove facts (when others are simply discussing allegations) or is contrary to innocent until proven guilty. I'll leave it at we can just agree to disagree.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Obama did not bring back a deserter.

You couldn't know that since, as you point out, there's been no investigation, charges, or trial.

Oh, I do know. He was not a deserter on the day he was released. The Army said so. He may become a deserter after the investigation, but he has not been one up until now.

You're playing semantics. Obviously, he can't be an adjudicated deserter before trial. However, if he is later found guilty of desertion, then Obama brought back a deserter.

Soldiers who are awol for 30 days with whereabouts unknown become deserters. Army spokespeople have already discussed this.

Soldires are guilty of desertion if they are absent with intent to remain away permanently.There is no 30-day time period. My source is the UCMJ itself. The military may decline to prosecute if the absence is less than 30 days but that's not in the UCMJ.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"(hint: He served his country)"....and just which country are you calling HIS????

Afghanistan or the US.....remember inhis email hesaid "...I am ashamed to even be american..." and "And the title of US soldier is just the lie of fools"

but you know I think you maybe right,...heaven forbid I should think that leaving a guard post unguarded and leaving the post without permission would not be considered "serving your country"......

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

What would you call what he did between "So help me God" and his departure?

Irrelevant.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

but you know I think you maybe right,...heaven forbid I should think that leaving a guard post unguarded and leaving the post without permission would not be considered "serving your country"......

They don't realize how serious this is. What if everybody decided to come and go as they please? Everybody's life would be at risk. Try this on your job and see how long it takes to fold the joint up.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

You are right by that statement 1ofmany. But his action as to premeditation to leave his post in a combat zone. ( emails). prove the intent to desert.

I think it's more accurately described as evidence of intent to desert. His attorney could try and spin the letters arguing that they simply illustrate the degree of his mental confusion and that, although hewasAWOL during his looooog walk to clear his head, he would have returned if he had not been captured by the enemy and prevented from returning. Of course, the prosecution can counterspin and argue that Bergdahl never intended to return and would still be running away if the Taliban hadn't captured him.

 
 

Who is online




120 visitors