Under-the-Table Pay Is Unacceptable
Pro: Everyone Has to Contribute Taxes
by Floyd Prozanski , Oregon State Senator, and Paul Holvey, Oregon State Representativ
Under-the-Table Pay Is Unacceptable
The federal government should crack down on businesses that pay employees under the table, because it needs the tax revenue. Pro or con?
The "underground economy" hurts government and private businesses. It directly affects governments ability to fund public services such as education, public safety, and human services. It also undercuts legitimate private businesses. It is imperativeespecially in hard economic timesfor state governments to take action by holding tax cheats accountable.
Employers who pay an employee under the table or misclassify an employee as an independent contractor, do not pay their allotted taxes and avoid other payroll obligations. This results in billions of dollars of lost revenue to state governments that would be used to provide essential public services.
The underground economy also puts law-abiding businesses at a disadvantage in the marketplace. Tax cheats gain an unfair advantage by not paying their share of taxes and fees. This can result in legitimate businesses shutting down.
Consumers are also affected by an underground economy. In many cases, consumer services such as home repairs and improvements are performed without proper licensing, bonding, insurance, safety, or qualityleaving little or no enforceable remedy for disputes.
In Oregon, the Department of Revenue has determined that unreported income amounts to an $18.3 billion underground economy. That represents 11.5% of Oregons total gross domestic product . The $1.25 billion in lost revenue to the state results in higher taxes for law-abiding citizens.
It is time for state government to be accountable to taxpayers and law-abiding businesses by enforcing our tax and employment laws.
Con: Show Compassion for Low-Paid Workers
In our haste to prevent employers from making under-the-table payments, we forget about the unintended consequences of such a crackdown on low-wage workers and the self-employed. Worldwide, 1.8 billion people are part of the "informal workforce," according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation & Development.
U.S. workers who may be paid under the table include our nations 7.4 million food and beverage workers, whose median wage is $7.14 per hour including tips, and maintenance workers, whose median annual income in 2006 was $19,930. In the U.S., 10.7% of full-time service workers were classified as the working poor, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The reality for all of these people, and those they work hard to support, is that every penny counts.
Opportunity@Work recently released the Family Bottom Line , a study charting how much it takes without government assistance for families to get by, relative to where they live. The study found that a family with two adults and one preschooler in Omaha needed $33,191 a year. And we know from experience that many families fall well below this line (even as some point to Nebraskas high employment in the face of this recession).
While we would never advocate tax evasion, we know a growing array of families that dont make enough despite their hard work. Punishing low-income and low-wage Americans trying to support their families, by asking them to carve out even a percentage of $20,000, could send them over the edge into homelessness, a cycle of poverty, or worse.
http://www.businessweek.com/debateroom/archives/2009/07/under-the-table_pay_is_unacceptable.html
Tags
Who is online
120 visitors

I am against paying people to work under the table, I am not aware of been involved in such activity, I prefer to call a licensed person for the simple reason, if something goes wrong, I have a complaint dept. to speak with and have the problem rectified...
This kind of under the table activity where people are been paid sometimes less than minimum wage is not good for anyone, with so much talk to increase the minimum wage I guess there will be more, not less people been paid off the books..
Sometimes it is less but most the time it is more and in many cases this is how illegal immigrants are paid.
CM
Well then it looks like the young fellow that mows my mother-in-law's lawn is either going to have to incorporate and start paying taxes or we will need to get another lawn service.
good point
The guy who does my heavy duty yard work gets paid in cash. He's not an immigrant, he's a local fellow. He is poor, not well educated, has a wife and 4 kids and struggles to live day to day. I consider him a gem - he works hard, does a good job, is honest as the day is long. I make him a sandwich and bring him ice water. You will have to travel many miles to find a man more appreciative. Maybe he should have been born 200 years ago when the world was a different place.
I personally think we should be paying taxes on what we consume, not what we earn.
But then that would reduce that 75,000 page IRS regulation manual and reduce the power of the government to control us, wouldn't it? What a refreshing thought!
We do. It's called sales tax.
We do. It's called sales tax.
I'm talking Federal, not state sales tax, although I would include that as well.
This way everyone would get to participate in the process, even those being paid under the table when they buy that new BMW from the sale of that big bag of cocaine.
RIO, I think your lawn mower service should be paying some sort of taxes..I have to pay on every penny I earn so should the other guy, don't you think?? It may seem, well I am not paying him that much, but it does add up when you consider yearly costs...and all the other clients yards he is mowing...
All money belongs to the federal government. We just get to borrow it for a while.
I'm not sure I agree with you on that RL. Like to see how it is any more unfair than it is today.
But I would have to say, no matter what way we are taxed Congress would get in on it with the IRS and tell people we're going to lower your sales tax if you purchase this product or have an income less that a certain amount.
Hard thing to deal with, but at least it would get some of that illegal money into the system as a tax, whereas now there is no income tax on income under the table and no income tax on the sale of illegal drugs. There are many other situations where there is no money going to the government from income as well.
There are a lot of nice amenities being bought with untaxed income and at the same time these same people are receiving entitlements from the government because their reported income is less than what it really is.
There are ways to balance the unfairness out, such as a refund to individuals who make below certain incomes or other family cost.
So RL, here we are.....right back into a 75,000 page IRS manual full of regulations. Crap.
Well, I'd like to have on my tombstone, I left this world owing the government $1 million dollars. Think I'll apply for the loan now. Think this comment will have any bearing on me getting the loan?
I'm sitting here wondering just how much money is earned under the table and untaxed. Then a horrible thought occurred to me: What will the do nothing Congress do with that little bit of extra money they would have access to? Ah, crap !! They are already flushing money down the toilet every chance they get.
It's like when I see people driving really really fast on the streets. They are in a huge rush to get somewhere. I always have to wonder what they think they are going to do with that 2 minutes they saved by driving that way. Probably nothin'.
That is what the credit for lower incomes would be for. It probably wouldn't work as I don't believe anything is going to work anymore, actually. We have become a nation of takers and putting the responsibility on others to provide for us as a right and when that idea is promoted long enough, we have more taking and less providing until the cart gets too heavy to pull.
I say who gives anyone the right to have even 1% more of my money than yours? As long as the mentality of what is yours is mine continues we're heading downhill.
CM
He is ten years old and spends the money on video games and ice cream
He gets $10 per week for mom's yard and another $10 from her neighbor
Itis not a lawn service (see comment above re young fellow) it is a little boy
Ha Ha ha, RIO, you got your point across, good, he is starting to know the value of money, when I was 10 -12 years old, I started a finance business, that is, I would loan money to my brother who is 9years older than me, He worked and was always broke before his next paycheck, my dad gave me $1.00/day lunch money, I would save $0.50 and use the other $0.50 for lunch while taking a sandwich to school, that's before this thing about having to eat the school lunch, so I would loan my brother money to help him out until payday, I also charged interest maybe an additional $0.25, when I was repaid, I reinvested that money while continuing to save that $0.50 each day and taking a sandwich, it was a good business, word got around and I got another client(my cousin) he was not as honest in repaying his loan and that ended my finance business LOL...
Illegals send over twenty billion dollars to Mexico annually. A good portion of it is under the table.
An interesting (false) correlation that only you would arrive at
Thanks for never disappointing
CM
Sounds like you were focused on getting ahead from an early age.
Good for you