Biggest Overhaul in Federal Drug Sentencing in Decades Clears Major Hurdle, Despite Opposition From Heartless Prosecutors
On March 11 the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee passed bipartisan sentencing reform legislation that reduces the federal prison population, decreases racial disparities, saves taxpayer money, and reunites nonviolent drug law offenders with their families sooner.
The reforms are supported by a strange bedfellows group of senators, including Senators Mike Lee (R-Utah), Rand Paul (R-Kentucky), Jeff Flake (R-Arizona), Ted Cruz (R-TX), Patrick Leahy (D-VT), Dick Durbin (D-IL), Carl Levin (D-MI) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI).
The legislation is opposed by some U.S. prosecutors who continue to defend a harsh, racially unjust system that has led to a greater percentage of black men being locked up in the U.S. than in South Africa at the height of Apartheid.
The bill, the Smarter Sentencing Act, is the biggest overhaul in federal drug sentencing in decades.
It would reduce federal mandatory minimum sentences for drug offenses and expand the ability of judges to use their own discretion when sentencing defendants, so that judges can consider the unique facts of each case and each individual before them. It would also make the reform to the crack/powder cocaine sentencing disparity that Congress passed in 2010 retroactive, so that thousands of people sentenced under the old draconian and racially unjust disparity can leave prison early.
Even though U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder urged the committee to reform mandatory minimum sentencing yesterday, the National Association of Assistant U.S. Attorneys took the somewhat rare step of opposing the Attorney General by releasing a letter in opposition to reform. "We do not join with those who regard our federal system of justice as 'broken' or in need of major reconstruction," the organization said. "Instead, we consider the current federal mandatory minimum sentence framework as well-constructed and well worth preserving."
According to the U.S. Sentencing Commission and a recent report by the Congressional Research Service, mandatory minimums have significantly contributed to overcrowding and racial disparities in the Bureau of Prisons (BOP). The BOP operates at nearly 140 percent capacity -- and is on track to use one-third of the Justice Department's budget. More than half of the prisoners in the BOP are serving time for a drug law violation. Even though African-Americans are no more likely than Whites to use or sell drugs, evidence shows they are far more likely to be prosecuted for drug law offenses and far more likely to receive longer sentences than Whites.
With less than 5 percent of the world's population -- but nearly 25 percent of the world's prison population -- the U.S. leads the world in the incarceration of its own citizens. With the vote today it is clear that both liberal stalwarts and Tea Party favorites recognize that our country incarcerates too many people, for too much time, at too much expense to taxpayers. Yet federal prosecutors are defending the current system with its enormous racial disparities, mass incarceration, and unjust penalties.
Apparently they are still living in the dark ages. Federal prosecutors are so entitled by decades of unfettered discretion they don't feel the need to acknowledge the consensus emerging around them that the system of mass incarceration is profoundly unfair and unsustainable. Their statement typifies the singular barrier prosecutors represent to reforming the deeply flawed criminal justice system.
[ LINK ]
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

Monday, Attorney General Eric Holder addressed the annual convention of the American Bar Association. In that speech, Holder said the American criminal justice system is broken and its time for some new policies. Unfortunately, Holder missed the chance to make some real improvements.
The main point of Holders speech was that the United States is locking up too many people. As has been widely reported, America has about 5 percent of the worlds population, but about 25 percent of the worlds prisoners. We have a lot of people behind bars about 2.5 million.
It took us 200 years to incarcerate the first million, but weve managed to lock up the second million in only the last 30 years. During the 1990s and early 2000s we were building one prison a week on average. And those prisons were quickly filled up. Many prisons are now operating beyond their design capacity.
Holder says it is time we face this reality. Facing reality is always sound advice, but its painfully obvious. Maybe next month he can go to Detroit and tell us about the potential risk of bankruptcy there.
Read the entire article ;
While I agree that non-violent drug offenders should not be facing the penalties they often do, this is where it gets tricky....
Breaking the Mexican Cartels: A Key Homeland
Security Challenge for the Next Four Years
Carrie F. Cordero
Georgetown University Law Center
, cfc34@law.georgetown.edu
Not disagreeing with ya; but,I do believe that there are victims because of drug use, besides just the user (or even their families.
LOL, we wouldend-up with 90% of DC arrested if that was the case so...
:~)
Imho making drugs legal would probably do little to the Cartells, thoughI also believ that addicts shouldn't be arrested or jailed.
Minimum sentencing should have also been negated. If we aren't going to allow judges to judge, and sentence on that judgment, we can save a lot of money throughout the US by dismissing all judges and placing that money in law enforcement apprehension.
Then, we can install computers in courtrooms to do sentencing based upon past deeds.
There have been several deaths of LEOs because they were sent to serve warrants on two-time offenders who did nothing more for their third offense than get a traffic ticket; but when the LEOs arrived there were ambushes and shootouts because, as the offenders who were not killed in the altercations stated, "I already had two strikes.. a third one meant a mandatory life sentence."
The main case that comes to mind is the one last year of the man who was caught with alcohol in the his vehicle by a Forest Ranger. He begged the FR to let it go, explained he had been out of prison for some time, had a job and family, and had just brought a couple of beers to celebrate the holiday.
The FR insisted on arresting him, so the man fought with him, took his gun, and shot him.
When you back an animal into a corner with no escape they become aggressively vicious.. and there is no animal more vicious than a trapped human.
I don't know so much about the strange bedfellows comment. The only name on that list that surprises me is Ted Cruz. Makes me wonder what he's up to.
The problem is the federalmandatorysentencing guidelines. Juries don't get to see most cases,becausethe defendant pleads out to a lesser charge to avoid long sentences, and the Judges are lockedin tomandatorysentences.
When cases go to trial and the prosecutors present evidence that proves their case, juries have to convict, and again the judges are locked in to 'mandatory guidelines'.
It's not illegal to be a drug addict, it's illegal to possess the drugs that causes the addiction.
We don't arrest people for being addicts, we arrest them for possession of drugs.
The spirit of the law has been forgoten by the letter.
The unintendedconsequences of the belief that harsh sentences deter crime.
Most criminals don't think about the consequences of their actions, in partbecausethey don't think they'regoing to get caught.
I also was taken aback when I saw his name on the list of sponsors. I would imagine Bill Piper , HuffPo author of the article, was as surprise as we are, hence the 'strange bedfellows' comment
He probably thinks the bill isn't going to pass, and he signed on to make points with the moderates. The SJC has a record of only 23% of it'srecommendationspassing into law. (GovTrack.org gives this billa 39% chance of passing)
I don't know why you always give me a hard time BF, we agree on a lot of issues.
We're not going to break the Mexican Cartels whether we legalize Pot and Coke or not.
".....breaking the Mexican cartels is no easy feat. But it is a necessary one to secure
our southern border, eliminate the presence of dangerous cartels in our cities,
reduce Americans contribution to the drug trade and resulting violence, and
play our role in restoring the Mexican citizenry to a society free from daily
terror."
IMO, the key to solving our drug problem lies in our education system. We have to not just teach our children about the evils of drug use, we have to convince them drugs will ruin their lives.
Harsh drug laws are obviously not the way to accomplish that goal.
The solution to that problem is to bring our drug laws into the 21st century.
Absolutely. It's unfathomable how many prisoners we have because of drug use/possesion. And it's doing not one iota of good.
It's doing a lot of good for the people in the lawenforcementand corrections industry.
Police departmentsareconfiscatingmillions of dollars incash and property from drug suspects.
Also, acc ording to the Bureau of LaborStatistics ;
As of May 2013 there were 432,630 COs and Jailers in this country, earning a mean hourly wage of $21.32 and a mean annual income of $44,356.
Do the math; that's just short of $2 billion a year just in salaries, and it doesn't even begin to address the cost of the facilities and their support systems.
Law Enforcement and Corrections is a big industry in America, and a strong lobby to maintain the status quo.
The factors you mention have little if any effect on the numbers mentioned. They have zero effect on the 5% of the world population, although that's a little high, it's actually closer to 4.5%, and the fact that some countries kill or maim people has little effect when your talking about theapproximately 9 million prisoners worldwide.
From Wikipedia;
We're talking about millions of people here Dennis, the factors you want to introduce to the discussion would have little or zero effect on the studies done to arrive at the 25% quoted.
Which is exactly why we need to start reforming our entire criminal law system.
We are comparing apples to apples, there aren't enough of your 'oranges' to effect the numbers.
Many people argue the position that there are no victims in the drug trade. They argue that drug users are victims.
Actually they are when they become addicts, but we can't blame that on the drug dealer any more than we can blame alcoholism on the liquor dealers.
Alcoholics and drug addicts are victims to alcohol and drugs, the same as people become victimsto various other illnesses.
Jerry - If the defendant pleads to a lessor charge there seems to be no need to have a jury trial.
That's what 'plea out' means. To plea out of a trial, and accept a lesser charge. And that's what I said; "Juries don't get to see most cases,becausethe defendant pleads out to a lesser charge...."
The judge sets the sentence in any case, the problem is under the present system the judges are locked into preset mandatory guidelines that eliminates judicialdiscretion inimposingthe sentences.