Deceptive Numbers
AT THE start of this year the Mayor of Chicago, Rahm Emanuel, had good news on crime and violence. The murder rate was lower than it had been for decades. 2013 saw 415 murders, 88 fewer than in 2012, according to the Chicago Police Department (CPD). Overall crime was down too.
The news was a relief. The previous year had been nasty and bloody, with a resurgence of gang warfare fuelled by a long, hot summer. Yet 2013s figures are now coming under scrutiny. Last month Chicago Magazine reported that it knew of ten people who were beaten, burned, suffocated or shot to death in 2013 who were not included in the official count for at best, unclear reasons. The article raised similar concerns over the numbers reported for other crimes. Moreover a recent audit of crime figures from Chicago's Office of the Inspector General, and a sudden rise in reports of murders this year, have driven speculation that Chicagos crime numbers are faked.
Some of this is silly. The recent surge in murders reflects the known fact that most killing in Chicago takes place when the weather gets warmer. Moreover the audit by the inspector general has been widely misinterpreted. It is true that the IG found that police were failing to count crimes with multiple victims as separate offences. It is also correct that this resulted in a 24% underestimation in sample of incidents in 2012. However, Chicago's police have been massaging their crime figures this way for years, so this wouldn't explain a sudden downward trend.
The question, then, is whether there has been a recent change in the way that crime figures are reported that might account for the better numbers.
Eli Silverman, a professor emeritus at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York and an expert on crime statistics, says Chicagos remarkable drop in crime is very difficult to believe. Indeed, he has spoken to people within the CPD who have shared their own concerns over the accuracy of the figures. He has seen similar drops in crime at other police departments after they introduce centralised data-driven performance targets, which put individual officers under pressure to keep their numbers down. He calls this the New York model as it got its start in the Big Apple in 1994, and has since spread to Atlanta, Baltimore, Dallas and New Orleans as well as to Australia, Britain and France.
Surveys of police retirees in New York found that the introduction of this CompStat system brought pressure to downgrade crimes to less serious offences. For example, the NYPD undervalued property losses so that an incident was not listed as a felony, and a series of crimes in one place might be listed as a single event.
Tellingly the NYPD reported a 50% drop in assaults between 1999 and 2006 even though hospital records showed a 90% increase in assault-related visits to the emergency room. Another sign of a problem can be seen in the 41% decrease in New York's felony burglaries during this period. Felony burglaries are a serious crime that is counted in national statistics. A similar offense, known as misdemeanor criminal trespass, is not. If police were reporting crimes consistently one would expect these two crimes to follow pretty similar trajectories. But they did not. In fact there was a 71% increase in misdemeanor criminal trespass. It looks very much like more serious crime was being downgraded.
A spokesperson for the CPD alleged that the Chicago Magazine article was based on factual errors and misleading statements. One of the cases cited inthe article involved Michelle Manalansan, a 29-year old student from Harold Washington College, who was found dead in her apartment wrapped in blanket on March 17th 2013. Though her death certificate says she died by homicide, from a blunt head and neck trauma, she was not counted as a murder by the CPD. On April 8th 2014, however, the CPD said Manalansan's case had been reclassified as a murder on March 23rdjust before the Chicago Magazine article went to press. Beth Fenner, the magazine's editor-in-chief, disputes this, alleging that neither the internal CPD victims database nor the citys online data portal showed the Manalansan case as a homicide until their article brought this case to light.
This week Chicago Magazine published a follow-up to their story, which reports that sources in the police department feel they are indeed under pressure both explicitly and implicitly to under-report crime.
The row is awkward for Mr Emanuel, who faces an election next year. Unhelpfully, he is seen in a new documentary called "Chicagoland" putting a great deal of pressure on his chief of police over crime numbers. Both the mayor's office and the CPD are saddled with grim budget problems and weak controls on the resale of guns.
In April James Comey, the new director of the FBI, said he planned to direct more federal resources to help Chicago manage its seemingly intractable gun violence. The US Attorneys Office, part of the federal Department of Justice, recently said it will create a specialised unit in the city to deal with violent crime. Regardless of the numbers, it hardly looks like Chicago's police department has its crime problem under control.
http://news360.com/article/240115495

Mayor Emmanuel, the police department and the city administration as whole is under high scrutiny as the crime statistics which have shown a falling violent crime rate over recent years are called into question for their validity and for the accuracy and straightforwardness of the reporting process.
This is nothing new as it has happened in other large cities, such as New York in the past.
One expert notes
Sean
I am sure that this public relations and political practice is present in many cities / countries around the world
There is too much importance placed on the "numbers." Focusing on them and the reports that need to reflect progress takes away the important work of actually DOING something about them.
That's why they manipulate them, Gunny. I worked for a company once where a couple of the managers on the production floor spent more time figuring out how to make the reports to management look good instead of trying to fix any of the problem areas that were slowing production and shipping.
The company now has its production operations in Malaysia.
Or in other words...
the wrath of Allah fell upon her head for displeasing her man.
mimi
Great point
Sad but in some cases true
And that is the bottom line . There is the motivation for distorting the stats .
Indeed
Sad but true
Oh look, another Chicago crime article.
And no doubt every municipality does as well, which brings us right back to the idea that not being truthful about the numbers ensures that the problem will never be solved since there is no evidence of a problem in the first place.
pat
The article is about crime stat manipulation and actually mentions other cities that are guilty of it as well as Chicago where the latest appearance of the phenomena manifest itself
Again the central point
Exactly, Gunny!
Well said Gunny