╌>

Federal Court Rules Cops Can Seize Guns Without Charges Or Warrant

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  12 years ago  •  24 comments

Federal Court Rules Cops Can Seize Guns Without Charges Or Warrant

A panel of federal court judges have ruled that it is not a violation of your constitutional rights for police to break down the door to your home, search the entire place, and take your guns if they believe it to be in your best interest.

The 7 th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on a case that dated back to May 22, 2011, where a womans psychiatrist phoned police to let them know that she thought she might be suicidal after receiving some bad news and expressing grief during a visit. Shortly after, police were dispatched to find 42-year-old Krysta Sutterfield in Milwaukee, Wisconsin so they could forcibly detain her and give her a mandatory medical evaluation.

Police went to her home with a description of her vehicle but were unable to locate it in her garage. Hours went by without them finding her, however Dr. Bentle called and told the police that she had called her some minutes earlier stating that she was not in need of assistance and that the doctor should call off the police search for her, court documents stated.

Police Officer Warrantlessly Enters House And Arrest Man

The police didnt call of the search, in spite of the doctors recommendation, and at 8:30 p.m. they found Sutterfield at her home. She answered the door for the officers but wouldnt allow them in her house because she didnt need assistance and had already called off the search, but that wasnt good enough.

After about a 30-minute standoff, police called for backup while Sutterfield called 911 to try to get them to back off. While she was on the phone the police kicked her door in and accosted her, and she could be heard on the 911 recording telling the officers to let go of her and that they leave her home.

Sutterfield was shackled and detained while the police, without a warrant, conducted a proactive sweep of her home. They found her pistol in an opaque case and a BB gun in the residence and seized both along with her CCW permit. She was then taken into custody and brought to the countys Mental Health Complex where she underwent a mandatory mental evaluation.

Sutterfield almost immediately filed suit against the Milwaukee Police Department for violating her Second and Fourth Amendment rights, contending that the search of her home without a warrant was illegal and so was the seizure of her firearms.

After her first case being dismissed, Sutterfield had her appeal heard by the 7 th Circuit, who ultimately ruled against her.

Judge Illana Rovner wrote that Although the court had found it likely that Sutterfields Fourth Amendment rights had been violated, the court discerned no basis to hold Milwaukee liable for the violation. She also said that the intrusions upon Sutterfields privacy were profound, and noted, at the core of the privacy protected by the Fourth Amendment is the right to be let alone in ones home.

The three judge panel found that Even if the officers did exceed constitutional boundaries, they are protected by qualified immunity.

The court found that There is no suggestion that (police) acted for any reason other than to protect Sutterfield from harm, which means that the violation of her Fourth Amendment rights was allowable since they were acting on her behalf.

So basically if the police have reason to believe that youre a danger to yourself they can kick your door in, take your guns, and take you into custody even if you have done nothing wrong. Such a precedent is dangerous and will undoubtedly lead to abuses, especially with doctors questioning people about having firearms in their homes.

http://www.mrconservative.com/2014/05/41377-federal-court-rules-cops-can-seize-guns-without-charges-or-warrant/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Oh I am sure someone will be here soon to attack the source and deny it ever happens.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This certainly puts a new perspective on how the government could take your guns away; for, if it is on record that the police had to intervene in this woman's personal life because they were acting to keep her from harming herself, she could be denied the return of her firearm and be barred from obtaining another one... at least legally.

The Black Market is always open, however.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

I never mention to anyone I have guns unless it is someone I know pretty well or have hunted or went target shooting with.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

The way I read the story the court thought the cops did violate her Fourth Amendment protection but their hands were tied because the cops were acting under the impression that the women could be a danger to herself and perhaps others, per her Doctor, and though they did overreact they had a qualified immunity protecting them from lawsuits for what they did wrong.

As someone that once spent a long night cleaning my fathers blood, brains and bone off of every surface in his bedroom after he put a riffle under his chin and pulled the trigger, Im not as opposed to having a doctor ask a depressed patient if they have easy access to weapons as some are. But hey, that's just me.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

The problem is, every time a proverbial can of worms like this is opened it leaves WAY too much room for abuse. I think we both know there will be instances where the police simply claim they are acting in the persons 'best interest" to get what they want.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    12 years ago

I think we both know there will be instances where the police simply claim they are acting in the persons 'best interest" to get what they want.

Perhaps 96WS6, but in this instance the ladies Doctor did tell the police there was a risk involved. The ambiguity comes in after the Doc tried to call them off and they didn't fall back.

Of course if they had backed off and then the lady started shooting up her workplace, looking for a suicide by cop situation, their collective ass's would have been left hanging out in the wind.

Maybe the qualified immunity rules are more of a true worry than any fear of some Gestapo type cops kicking down doors to collect legal weapons. Without the qualified immunity protection these cops would have had some legal problems for what they did, at least that's what I took from what the court wrote.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Here's what I don't get - gun rights advocates are quick to act like they support the kinds of restrictions that keep guns out of the hands of mentally unstable people, yet when people become mentally unstable after they are already in possession of guns, any attempt to remove the guns is seen as an attack on their fourth amendment rights.
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

That immunity argument is wrong. She can sue each and every member of the police force for over-reaching, as an individual, their job requirements - and I'd say go for it.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Maybe the qualified immunity rules are more of a true worry than any fear of some Gestapo type cops kicking down doors to collect legal weapons. Without the qualified immunity protection these cops would have had some legal problems for what they did, at least that's what I took from what the court wrote.

I agree.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

The problem is, once you skirt a law like this it will happen again. What will stop police in the future from saying well no, we didn't have a warrant but we were acting in the suspects "best interest".

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

I would think so too.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

The problem is HOW they confiscated the weapons. What is wrong with getting a warrant, you know, the way it is supposed to be handled in this country?

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

John said;

America is a country of law and due process. The court justified the police action. Why is this a discussion topic?

Because it is a fishing license for the police to use before the due process kicks in. The court basically said the police did violate her rights, but they were found by the court to be protected by qualified immunity:

Qualified immunity, when applicable, shields government officials from liability for the violation of an individual's federal constitutional rights . ( Wikipedia )

Further, from the same Wiki article:

As outlined by the Supreme Court in Harlow v. Fitzgerald , 457 U.S. 800 (1982), [1] qualified immunity is designed to shield government officials from actions "insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known." (Emphasis mine.)

So at least without digging too far into it, the contention of 1stWarrior (Below) that this is amisapplicationof thedoctrine appears to be correct.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
And if, in the meantime, that person shoots their family members? My guess is that the gun rights proponents would be first in line to criticize the system in any manner possible for "allowing it to happen."

Here's a thought - if you want to own guns, while you are under the care of a psychiatrist, and you make statements that that healthcare professional deems to be indicative of someone in mental distress, then accept the fact that you shouldn't be in the possession of guns for your own sake, and the sake of those around you. The fact that the doctor took back her statement later is not justification for this person to act the way she did. Her actions only further indicated that she is mentally unstable.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

America is a country of law and due process. The court justified the police action. Why is this a discussion topic?

Because it is a fishing license for the police to use before the due process kicks in. The court basically said the police did violate her rights, but they were found by the court to be protected by qualified immunity:

Qualified immunity, when applicable, shields government officials from liability for the violation of an individual's federal constitutional rights . ( Wikipedia )

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

Good comment Broliver, a pity it is wasted on John, according to John the government can do no wrong. At least while the Obama admin is holding the reigns that is.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Not a good enough reason to bypass due process and give police qualified immunity on it. That is like saying cars should be outlawed because some asshat killed someone else with their car. Sad that when it comes to government and guns you seem A-OK with that logic.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Don't you get it John? One isolated case is not sufficient reason to throw due process out the window. This case will be used to perpetuate this kind of right infringement in the future. We will be seeing cases in which they will be trying to determine if the situation warranted peoples basic constitutional rights to be violated. THAT IS NOT OK!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Rulings/laws like this one are too easily abused. Is that a simple enough explanation? Isn't is obvious to you how easily this power could be abused, and how impossible it would be to disprove without video footage and/or many witnesses? It is obvious you have never been unfortunate enough to have an officer of the law intentionally try to screw you. Not everyone is as lucky as you are.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

It is not the specific case, John, it is the precedent and the misapplication of statute. To requote:

As outlined by the Supreme Court in Harlow v. Fitzgerald , 457 U.S. 800 (1982), [1] qualified immunity is designed to shield government officials from actions "insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known." (Emphasis mine.)

From her conduct, it would appear that she knew of her rights and the police forced the issue anyway. The fact that the whole thing turned out all right (at least for the police) is beside the point. This is an expansion of the doctrine and will be seen by police as granting them greater room to infringe upon peoples constitutionally guaranteed rights and only to be questioned after the fact. You seemed to ignore the fact that due process is not just a mere convenience or technicality and totally brushed over the fact that it was ignored in this case.

Paranoid? Probably a little. But there is a reason that those rights, especially the Fourth Amendment in it's clear and unambiguous terms requiring due process, were added into the constitution. It is not a plot to take away freedom, it is the general trend of governments if not checked to gradually accumulate more power unto themselves, whatever the justification.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
The purpose of a car is to get people from here to there, not to mow people down. A gun's purpose is to end lives, plain and simple. Your comparison is totally irrelevant.
 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

" A gun's purpose is to end lives, plain and simple ..."....Really? So let me ask you this Hal,...I own several guns that have not killed or even wounded one single person,...are you telling me they are broken or maybe defective because I haven't used them for the purpose they were made for.....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

People kill People.....they just use weapons to do it with and guns are weapons just like a car can and has been used as a weapon......a baseball bat can be used as a weapon.....rope can be used as a weapon.....knives can be used as a weapon.....

weapons is for Hals benifit......

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Do you use them to hunt? That is ending a life. Do you keep them in case you need to confront a home invader? That is ending a life. Do you have guns just for target shooting? That is preparation for increasing your accuracy in a scenario where a life is going to be taken. A gun's purpose is to end life, that's it. It doesn't compare to a knife, because a knife can be useful for purposes other than killing. It doesn't compare to anything that has more purpose than to simply kill. Gun nuts like to try and force this false equivalency in an attempt to make guns look as innocent as butter knives, but nothing can change the fact that guns are unique in that their ultimate purpose is exclusively to end life.
 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

" A gun's purpose is to end life, that's it ."....really??? guns are used for protection,...to protect yourself you need not kill,.....guns are used in Olimpic events,..as a sport,...are you telling us these atheletes are secretly practicing or honing their killing skills disgused as a sport....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

" ...but nothing can change the fact that guns are unique in that their ultimate purpose is exclusively to end life ."...again I ask you are my guns broken because they will never be used exclusively to end any lives......

olimpic is for Hals benifit....

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Lol - guns are for Olympics, that's a new one. Congratulations on finding the most abstract justification for America's gun obsession imaginable! Officer, I didn't mean for my 2 year old to shoot the neighbor, I only had my gun out to practice for the Olympics.I ask you - except for your Olympic intentions, are your guns coming in handy for anything else? Does a rifle make a handy replacement for a table leg? Does shooting bullets at an ice cube work well for making chipped ice? I hope your shotgun isn't loaded when you use it to bat baseballs.
 
 

Who is online




100 visitors