It seems as if Native Americans are getting screwed again
$3.4 billion Native American land-trust settlement causing anger
HELENA, Mont. - Laura Juarez is supposed to receive close to $1,200 as her share of a $3.4 billion settlement among hundreds of thousands of Native Americans whose land-trust royalties were mismanaged by the government for more than a century.
The Bakersfield, California, notary public was going to pool that money with her husband's share, along with a portion of what was coming to her father's estate, to send her 17-year-old daughter to a student-ambassador program in Australia.
But the money, which she expected in December, still hasn't come and her daughter isn't going on next month's trip.
The payments have been held up by more than 2,400 appeals by people who were ruled ineligible to participate in the settlement. As the special master appointed to the case goes through those appeals, Juarez and other American Indians are growing increasingly frustrated over what they see as justice delayed.
"It seems as if the Native Americans are being screwed again," said Juarez, a 39-year-old member of the Comanche nation. "I know several others who have given up on it. It's created a sour taste in their mouths. We get our hopes up just to have it knocked down."
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/3-4-billion-native-american-land-trust-settlement-causing-anger/
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

And, how many times are we going to see this happen to the Indian tribes - soverieign nations within the United States as confirmed by the Constitution and by Congress and by SCOTUS?
"The lawsuit claimed the Interior Department mismanaged and squandered billions of dollars that were supposed to go to the landowners since the 1880s, but incomplete and missing records prevented them from determining how much was lost.
It took about 14 years to reach a settlement with the government, then another year for Congress to approve the deal in December 2010. It wasn't until December 2012 that all the appeals over the settlement were dismissed and the first monetary distributions were mailed."
163 years of trust-fund mismanagement to the tune of $86B owed the Indian people (low estimate based on "existing" BIA records)- and Congress authorizes payment of $3.4B - 3% of what is LEGALLY owed - by law - to the Indian people.
I, personally, prefer a kiss, some hugging and some oil before being told to bend over and enjoy it.
"We're from the government - and we're here to help you."
The accounting process for these claims is a mess because of the ways the laws are written. If a person had an "allotment" and received royalties from mineral extraction, etc., and the person passed away, the Feds don't allow for the individual's will to designate who the beneficary will/can be. The Feds state that all "dependents" of the deceased split the property for receipt of royalties.
Joseph A has six total dependents when he passes - the single royalty then gets split six ways. Each of the dependents has four dependents, so when that dependent passes, their share is split four ways. So, in just two generations, one royalty receipt now becomes 96 receipts - and that is just for 40 years.
The trust annuities began in 1848 and not all individual Indians received royalty income. In most cases, the tribal lands received the income which was to have been deposited into the tribal trust account - but wasn't.
That's just sad. I'm so sorry!
It is going to happen to all of us-- when it comes down to collecting Social Security as we retire. The money that we have put in for all these years, just won't be there.
Our Congressional representatives truthfully don't give a rats-ass about their constituents nor about the laws passed to protect those constituents.
You're right-- they don't. They have forgotten that they are Public Servants.
They do what is right for themselves, not the common good.
I say again... time for Indians to come together and head for Washington. Or, choose a prominent location and swarm all over it, setting up tipis and camper trailers. If Washington won't honor the treaties made in return for the land, take back the land.
Bundy is being allowed to take land he never had title to; Indians should be able to take back land that hasn't been paid for. Repossess it.
I'm doing a lot of research to see if there is anyway the Feds can be sued for non-compliance. 'Course, there are plenty of Indian Attorneys way ahead of me on this one.
If it has to come down to a standoff or a sit-in, I'll be there. This crap has gone on without any repercussion for the liars and cheats long enough.
I do not agree with Bundy's situation but he has started a trend and if it can make Washington sit up and take notice I will try it.
Have Tomahawk, Will Travel
Well, remember, we had the cowboys and Indians pour into DC 'bout two months ago for the XL Pipeline - didn't evenbudge them.
The delay is not the result of trying to screw anyone but rather to ensure that people aren't screwed. This is a settlement with a cap of $3.4 billion. Pursuant to the settlement, no payments can be made until all members are identified and it's not clear exactly who all the members are. Thousands of people who were determined ineligible to participate have appealed. Ifthe fund is depleted before their appealshave concluded, then they will be screwed. If they prevail, and are added to the class, then the payoutper person will be reduced because thenumber of participants went up. That's true with every class settlement.Those who expect to be paid prematurely are creating their own problems by trying to count chickens before they hatch.
However, under the circumstances, maybe the settlement can be modified such that it pays out with the assumption that all who appealed will be successful (even though current class members will get less than expected). Then do a true-up after the appeals have concluded and issue a supplemental check that pays participants any difference they are due based on the number of people who are ultimately excluded from the class.
Ah ... we have someone here who can think in legalese . Thanks for your explanation .
That's because they were peaceful and orderly, 1st, not too loud, and were not unruly.
A protest is not a protest and can produce no results unless there is a PRESENCE. The Blacks and Hispanics aren't quiet and orderly when they protest, they are so unruly the law doesn't bother trying to contain THEM, it contains the law abiding spectators who are there to see the show.
The cap is the major reason to protest. It's an insult.
You can't settle something for a fixed amount and then protest that the amount is fixed. If they think the amount is an insult, then they shouldn't have agreed to it. They may be able to amend the settlement term governing payout as I suggested but I don't see another alternative.
I see your point. And there are so many things Indians have a right to protest about any way....
The amount was settled for 349,000 or thereabouts. Appeals were made and denied. Congress authorized payment to the 349,000 but an additional 100,000 filed appeals for either not being on the lists or not getting as much as they thought they should get or, in some cases, wishing to receive double/triple payment due to the "Head of household" rule (occurs in the event of minors).
The anger is from the settlement being closed, appeals all denied and closed, and Congress submitting the funding to the Special Trustee and now, "someone" is attempting to add a new twist of adding new "recipients" after the listings have been closed.
mimi - if the Indians "protested" about all that they should, then we'd get the wrong kind of attention. We need to, sure, "protest", but we need to do it as people that we are - non-confrontational - in the courts.
Part of the anger I guess is from having waited almost 20 years (1996) after being told that you will receive your $750 bucks that is 180 years past due and now being told that you may not receive that for another 20 years - possibly.
Don't think the judge can made modifications without congressional approval 'cause the ruling was from SCOTUS - initially.
I'll do more checking also. Thanks 1ofmany.
I appreciate your effort to keep us all informed. The settlement was the outcome of a judicial proceeding. The government agreed to pay $3.4 billion. Since no agency has that kind of money laying around, I assume they had to get Congress to appropriate it. Once Congress appropriated the money, it's role ended.In order for the settlement to be effective, it had to be accepted by a federal judge. I think a federal judge can modify a payment term in the settlement if both parties agree and there's no injustice created by the modification. However, if you uncover information to the contrary, let me know.
Went to the NCAI and NARF websites and read the TONS of documents on this settlement. Technically, it's divided into three - scholarship for Indians; individual Indian money accounts and Land buy-back.
The IIM accounts have all been identified - but, over 30K have unknown addresses and another group is "dissatisfied" over levels of disbursement and have filed appeals - didn't say how many. The Special Trustee has stated he "would" authorize distribution of funds to the already identified and authorized IIM account holders. The frustration the people are feeling is that they "thought" the $3.4B was to be paid whereas only $1.9B will be paid to the IIM - $1.2B will go to the land buy-back plan and the balance will be used for the scholarships.
What a mess - as usual, nothing is easy when you're dealing with courts, eh?