Common Core Mathematics: Reasons to think
Category: News & Politics
Via: broliver-thesquirrel-stagnasty • 12 years ago • 22 commentsLink to The Common Core makes simple math more complicated. Here's why.
I have been coming across little teasers such as this article linked here :
Now, this seems so far fetched that I had to dig a little deeper (not much, because this article showed up as a related article) So, after following my nose, reading a whole bunch of crap, and discussing this with actual teachers, I have come to the conclusion that there are some definitions that need to be discussed in order to understand what our educators are trying to achieve and why there is a perception that the Common Core standards are somehow to blame.
Firstly, let me ask the question: How does an idea make it from the idea stage Hey, we had aught to teach this , to the actual process teaching and of learning so the light comes on in the students mind? There must be some processes in place to control what material is being taught in our schools, right?
Well, there are. That is what school boards, school board meetings, and departments of education are for. Now, would it not seem extreme that these same, apparently intelligent, people would allow and adopt a set of standards that would lead to the teachers confusing our children instead of teaching them?
This is where those pesky (and helpful) definitions come in.
Standards: A standard is a set, known quantity that other things are judged against. Or, in the words of an actual dictionary : a level of quality, achievement, etc., that is considered acceptable or desirable
A set of standards is what Common Core is . So, we have standards, how do we get to the teaching part? This is where the Curriculum comes into play. A curriculum is the set of courses that a school teaches. These curricula can extend down to the lesson plans and actual teaching materials.
In the video above, the interviewer is talking aboutactual teaching materials, but not understanding the concepts of the curricular model that are being taught or maybe the curricular materials are incorrect. I suppose I could go into the specifics, but I am only going to bore you for a little while, not a long while, longer.
From The Common Core makes simple math more complicated. Here's why.:
Can you teach number sense?
The Common Core standards aim to impart number sense. Although the standards don't tell teachers how to to teach or what materials to use, they say that students need to understand how to solve problems and why those methods work.
'NUMBERS AREN'T THESE BRITTLE, FRAGILE THINGS THAT BREAK'
The underlying lesson: "Numbers aren't these brittle, fragile things that break," Meyer says. "They can play with them in fun, flexible ways."
Students will still learn what's known as the standard algorithm, the way that their parents learned to multiply, divide, add, and subtract. But they'll also learn other methods that try to make the underpinnings of the standard method more obvious.
One example is subtraction with a number line. This went viral after a father posted his child's confusing homework assignment with his critique:
![]()
The idea behind using a number line for subtraction is that students get a visual representation of what subtraction is: figuring out the "distance" between two numbers.
Here's what a clearer version of the problem above would look like: Students put the two numbers at opposite ends of the number line.
Then they travel from one number to the next to figure out the distance. It's 4 steps from 316 to 320, 100 steps from 320 to 420, 7 steps from 420 to 427.
If I had been that engineers boss, I would have fired him . Well, actually, I probably would have laughed at him but not fired him (there are several ways to complete the problem using the number line, which to me are intuitively obvious, but, as I have learned from my ex-wife and others, that which is intuitive to one person is not always intuitive to another).
I know that when I learn something, it is far easier if I have an underlying framework to hang the things that I am learning on, rather than just use rote memorization. This is what the common core standards are trying to achieve, an understanding of why, not just do this and you will get the answer .
Personally, I think that the Common Core standards are a good thing and should, once we get the kinks worked out regarding the implementation of the curricula, raise our children's test scores and make the US more competitive on the world stage.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

These people who are dead set against the Common Core as a standard either accept the propaganda from opponents without looking to see what actually is occurring or they just don't want anybody telling them what to teach their children.
Although I am not all that familiar with these new standards I have some skepticism about them . There are concepts in higher math which can't be reduced to simple visuals like the number line . This teaching method might end up producing "dead end" students who can't progress to the next level in math ...
One more thing : common core appears to reject digital computations with numbers for an attempt to make the process an analog one . We haven't used analog computers for many decades ...
As I understand it, this is to build a firmer grasp of why things work, for mathematics, anyway. The Fundamental Theory of Calculus can be produced using this method... I see the showing of why math works to be a great leap forward (no pun intended) for children who will have their understandings buttressed by more than one way of looking at things. I know that I would have benefitted from going into the why instead of Do it like this.
I don't agree . In math & science we work with vast systems of methods . People who expect to learn something need , at some point , to have accepted some amount of "that's the method we use ." OTW they don't progress if only because there is too much to learn . Learning how to do multi-digit arithmetic requires certain assumptions about "borrowing" from higher digits etc . The number line approach makes a simple operation like borrowing into an unnecessarily complicated mess .
If people really want to understand what is behind the methods of mult-digit arithmetic they need to learn the fundamental properties of algebra :
additivity , commutivity , associativity
Does common core help to understand those ? Doesn't look like it :
Did you miss the part where the it was stated that the Common Core does not dictate how it is taught? It is just a standard, as in By the second grade children should know....
She does the same thing as all of the other detractors that I saw and takes the question out of context. If, as she claims, the students which she is representing went from the 80th percentile to C's D's and F's (little bit o' hyperbole there, I am willing to bet) it is more the misapplication or misunderstanding of the curricula or maybe the curriculum needs to be examined. This is obviously at the programs inception and the teachers as well as the students needed to learn a new way of doing things.
Look at her pushing rote memorization. Know what? I could never remember my multiplication and other tables. I had to work them out every time I took them because my brain does not remember things the same way as other peoples do. You want to know something else? I am a scientist, a geologist. I passed calculus with a 4.0. It took me two to four times as long to work out the problems, but I did it. I think that I have quite an understanding of what a scientist has to do with mathematics.
For some reason you want to say the number line approach is the only way they are learning, when they quite patently are not:
And that is where her (and your) argument falls apart. Somewhere between the standards body and the students, someone is falling down on the implementation of these standards, the design and implementation of the curricula, and that is not the standards fault. That is human fallibility of some sort.
I keep seeing reports that students are marked down for not writing down all the steps in the common core approach [which are usually quite a large number of steps ] . Are you saying those reports are fallacious ?
How would I know if they are fallacious or not? The students should be able to show competency in... whatever they are taught. So, if they are told that they are going to need to know the background on how multiplying two,two digit numbers works, then they should know how to do that. If you are shown this video, for example, it would be fairly easy to replicate on a test.
I find numbers and the graphical representation thereof fascinating, if incredibly frustrating at times.
These reports that you see may indeed be true, but if a student misses a question on a test, then where does the fault lie? With the student? With the teacher? With the curriculum?
Here is what I think is happening with regards to the tests: Sally comes home and her dad asks how her math test went. She tells him it went bad (because she doesn't pay attention in ELA [that's english to us folk over 40]
). Her dad asks to see the test and becomes enraged when he can't make heads or tails out of the question because he wasn't taught that way, and the spewing starts there. Then, it becomes some sort of witch hunt where people are portraying the explanation as the only way that math is being taught and railing against the standards because they are what promulgated the whole change.
People are too quick to assume things. They, we need to approach some of the issues of today with a little less rage and a bit more analysis. What I am most definitely not saying is that the common core standards have been implemented in a cohesive and structured manner. From what I have seen and heard, they have been plagued with miscommunication on a systemic level. The standards are fine. Implementation of the various curricula has been fraught with difficulties and missteps.
Here is what you quoted above :
BTW :
I am inclined to agree that in the age of digital calculators it is near useless to stress rote memorization of multiplication tables .
I am sorry,but I fail to see the connectivity between my two statements. Mayhaps I am too tired.
If someone is marked down on a test, it is either because they did not show that they knew the information or the question was misunderstood by the teacher or the student. That is pretty straightforward. So it seems moot to the question of whether or not the Common Core standards are good or evil incarnate or somewheres in between.
This whole issue is a red herring. The people who are against these standards are misinformed as to the standards role in shaping the education. They should be more concerned with the application of these standards to the curricula and to how they are taught on the local level.
I think a lot of fear arises from the thought that some voodoo slash witchdoctor is not going to be able to tell young children that the world is six thousand years old and that the universe took a little bit longer than six days to create.
Nature is analog Petey, and for centuries we measured it and calculated it using analog methods. Pretty well too! Nature hasn't changed, but our number crunching has with the introduction of binary computation. But where the rubber meets the road, there is still the AtoD/DtoA interface into the real world.
Pressure, flow, temperature, light, voltage, amperage, velocity, frequency..... all are analog. In short, study and application of physics is all analog.
No..... teach and learn analog first then digital. Without those basics, too much gets overlooked when one only understands ones and zeros. Ar you forgetting that the foundation of the internet is still analog?
The other errant statement you made about rote memorization of basic multiplication tables stands for itself. You must of just been having a bad night.
I haven't seen you in quite a while Fly . Watch'ya been up to ?
All I have to say about this is that they have lost their pea-picking minds!!!
I started with Arithmetic, in 1961. It was easy and I could do it. Now, they are nuts. Absolutely nuts. Arithmetic made sense and I could do it. Math makes some sense and I can do most of it. But NEW MATH? I'm on my 4th or 5th NEW MATH, depending on which base you're in, and frankly, I'm giving up.
I was a school teacher when they diagnosed me as having dyscalculia, and it finally dawned on me that I do math by putting the numbers into words. No wonder I have trouble counting spaces around a decimal... Try multiplying sev, (seven), by to. I know it's for teen.
This Common Core would be great for kids who move around a lot, as when I was a kid, no matter where I moved, I was behind in some things and ahead in others. However, these educators have no clue how kids really learn-- nor do they care. I'm sick of homework for my son that requires my husband and I to teach him. Dammit, YOU teach him, that is what you're hired to do!
This year, my son read Romeo and Juliet-- in modern English. Come on, folks, the whole point of reading Romeo and Juliet in Shakespeare's English is to understand the times AND the story, in a poetic language. So, we read Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet in the original language, together.
Not to mention, but his history teacher told him that in WWI, poor Germany's attitude that they were so put down and wished to pillage as much as everyone else had. Tell that to my family that fought in it! I wanted to go to the school and shake his teeth out. Did that guy ever see WWI veterans selling pencils on the street, their stumps sticking out of their sleeves and pant legs? I did.
At any rate, I went to a public school in a small town, and I got a decent education. For all its crowing and bluster, my son will NOT get the quality of education I got, in our giant school system that thinks its so special. Piffle!
Moved to Munich, Germany from Finland to salvage a plant expansion that had too many accountants involved from the get go. I was all ready to come back to the states in February, but executives had different thoughts.
Also got a little burned out on the "trench warfare/bunker mentality" that NT has evolved into. I don't mind a good debate, but I always thought it was absurd to think you could break a sidewalk by bouncing marbles off of it.
Been reading and watching though. You been good?
Have to agree with you Dowser. We have to teach the basics in all areas especially math and science.
What is a bit more alarming to me is that I think we have lost our ability to nurture and develop curiosity in our kids. We are working just to get an answer rather than understanding the process. I wonder if this has anything to do with the fact that we are now "mining" natures secrets for corporate profit rather than out of curiosity.
Hope you're well.
You are the "go-to guy " !
Well ... yes and no . Eg:
Dearest Flynavy, I am alive, and grateful to be so. My mother passed away recently, and I'm, naturally, grieving. My mind is still sort of wandering about, lost in space... I'm very much like the dog that is so busy and then sees a "Squirrel!"
I agree. I am worried that they are only concerned about getting answers, not understanding the depth of those answers. I hope that my kid has a bit of curiosity about him-- I made Romeo and Juliet something fun-- it was like translation. At least he knows the significance of the Lark and the Nightingale. He's thinking of writing it out in Japanese for his Culture Club class. Thank God.
Please take care of yourself-- you are very dear to me!
So are you against the standards, the curricula the teaching methods of the Common Core?
Fly Navy said:
You said:
I am sorry, but I don't understand your piffle reference as it relates to this subject, so I am asking for my own clarity.
Be well, Dowser!
I'm so sorry! I said Piffle over the fact that I worry that my son is not getting the same quality education that I had.
I think Common Core would be good, but it is too rigid, and the teaching method for mathematics that is used, frankly sucks. I grew up with a hodge-podge of math teaching methods, and barely survived it.
So, yes I am for it, but against it as it is currently being promulgated to the masses. Reading Shakespeare in modern English may make it great for the masses, but misses the point of Shakespeare in its poetic beauty. Why is the lark and the nightingale important?
Romeo argues that the bird singing is the lark, (1st bird to sing in the morning). Juliet insists that no, it is the nightingale, (a bird that sings when the sun sets). She wanted to be with him longer, and he knew he had to get out of there. That part is left out of the modernized version. My argument is that Common Core does not allow for the depth of understanding-- there is no time to discuss in depth, nor to appreciate the poetic beauty of the story.
So yeah, it would be great to be able to move anywhere in the country and have a similar curriculum-- but it isn't happening. There is no depth to the discussions, it is based on pablum fed to the masses.
I'm not saying this well, but I am trying...
Dowser, Thank you for responding to my question.
The curriculum will be different depending on the school district and the state.
In New York, it is the Board of Regents that sets/accepts the standards and devises the tests to make sure that they are being met. (That is my understanding of how the process works.) The Districts are responsible for the curricula, I believe. So, if you move from one state to another, you won't necessarily be being taught the same material, but the end result should be that you understand the concepts and can utilize those concepts proficiently.
Now, in NY, the Board of Regents has been tripping over itself in the implementation of these standards, the result of which has been a putting of the cart before the horse, so to speak, with the directives to teach to the standards without an actual knowledge of precisely how they are going to do that and what the requirements will be. So you get the teachers in some state of confusion because you are telling them your students need to know X, when X is really an unknown quantity.
Not such a great idea...
When I moved from KY to Arkansas, I was way ahead. But the school system was inundated with millitary children-- there weren't enough text books, not enough paper, not enough pencils. I fell behind my classmates in Owensboro. Then, when we moved back to Owensboro, and I spent about 6 weeks catching up-- working through recess and art time.
Then we moved to St. Louis. KY didn't teach math as in adding two digit numbers together, carrying over whatever was greater than 10. I was very small, (35 pounds), and they wanted to put me back into 1st grade. Daddy had a fit, so I stayed after school for about 4 weeks to learn how to add double digit numbers.
Then, we moved to Kansas, and the new math. Again, since I had never seen their way of teaching, I was confused, and again, they wanted to put me back in 1st grade. Again, Daddy wouldn't let them.
Then, we moved back to Owensboro, and they wanted to put me back in second grade, rather than being in 3rd grade, because I hadn't learned to write in cursive in Kansas. Again, I stayed after school every day for a couple of months to learn how to write cursive.
Then, we bought a house in Owensboro, and out house was located in the county school system, not the city school system, so they wanted to put me back, again. Fortunately, Daddy served in the National Guard with the principle of the school, and he put me in a split level class, an "upper" class where we studied with 5th graders. I loved it!
The next year, they moved the city/county system lines and I changed schools again. But this time, I was stuck in the "lower" class for 5th graders. The next year, I was tracked back to the "upper" class for 6th graders.
I can see where a core curriculum could be very helpful to those kids that move a lot-- but perhaps it should be general guidelines. Specific goals to be met, i.e., cursive is learned in 2nd grade...
These days, my son spends about 3 weeks every year in testing-- time wasted that could be used in classroom instruction. By pushing kids to be able to spout stuff for a test, they miss out on the whys and wherefores. They have no depth, and often forget the 'human' interest that makes the subjects come alive to the students.
It's hopeless. The more they study it, the worse it gets.
Dowser said:
ummmmmmm That is what I have been Saying...
The Common Core is a set of standards that lays out objectives for the child to meet. So at the completion of a grade level, they should be able to complete these general and specific tasks.
What common core does not do is tell you how to implement the standards. That is where the varying curricula come in... It is my understanding that it is not about teaching to the test, but promoting understanding of the underlying concepts, developing the critical thinking skills so as to make the subsequent education that much more interesting and fulfilling.
I feel that we are not communicating well, and I am not sure of the reason why. Maybe we are not understanding what the other is saying, or maybe I am just being thick.
Mike said:
I understand both. In the subtraction problem, the attempt was to demonstrate that there are are more ways to get the answer. The person doing the interview then said that that was the way to do it using the standards, which is false. It was a blatant attempt to discredit the standards, for whatever reason.
In the letter, you can use the number line to subtract, all you need to do is take the digits and start with the larger number and count down by the hundreds, then the tens, then the ones. It was clouded by the fact that the person in the example did it wrong. The fact that the father couldn't do it either was a testament to limited thinking, and another blatant and perhaps even untrue attempt as discretization.
As for the parents, if they know how to run the standard algorithms, they can know if the answer is correct or not. I think that most adults could stand a brushup anyway, and it never hurts to think a little bit.
Rote memorization never worked for me because my brain did and does not work that way. I didn't get to use a calculator, it just took me a severely long time to do the problems.
When I multiply 8*9 I have to square eight and add 8, or add a zero and subtract eight. My brain is fine with that....