By ROBERT EVERETT-GREEN
The small childs leather tunic has fringe along the arms and torso, and the neck is embroidered with beads in purple, pink and turquoise. But what really grabs the eye is the jagged bullet hole in the centre of the chest, and the large stain of dried blood on the back.
Till Monday noon, this gruesome Plains Indian artifact was on show at the galleries of Waddingtons, the Toronto auction house, which planned to sell it during a decorative arts auction on Tuesday evening.
It was abruptly pulled from the sale after social media began to heat up with complaints about a bloody remnant of violence against a First Nations child being hawked as decorative art. The tunics full provenance is unknown, as are the exact circumstances of the shooting.
We dont want to upset anybody, so are withdrawing the item and returning it to the consignor, said Waddingtons president Duncan McLean, minutes after the sale preview ended.
But two other indigenous objects of historical importance are still headed for the auction block: a pair of heavily beaded moccasins that belonged to the Lakota chief Sitting Bull, and a 19th century mask of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) False Face curing societies that are still active around the Great Lakes. The Haudenosaunee Council forbids the sale or even the exhibition of medicine masks.
Those auction lots are part of a much larger market of important native artifacts that many indigenous people see as an affront that demands action. Who, if anyone, they say, has a right to buy, sell or display objects that have functional significance to indigenous communities?
These are important items to people who live today, said Hayden King, a member of Beausoleil First Nation who teaches history and native politics at Ryerson University. Im generally of the belief that they should be returned. Some government agencies and museums agree, but the market includes many players who do not.
The items at Waddingtons came from the estate of William Jamieson, a collector and dealer of often macabre artifacts who at one time owned the Niagara Falls Museum. The tunic was displayed in a cabinet next to a number of executioners blades, with an electric chair at the rooms opposite end.
It was very, very difficult for me to catalogue [the tunic], because of its relation to a terrible period of history, said Sean Quinn, the Waddingtons decorative arts specialist who reviewed the item and decided it was worth $2,000 to $3,000. The death of any child is horrific.
Yet until social media took notice, no alarms went off at Waddingtons, where Mr. Quinn and his colleagues spent months preparing items for the Jamieson sale. What if it were Trayvon Martins hoodie? someone asked on Twitter.
It all reflects this apparently endemic belief that native people are extinct, so we can do whatever we want with their stuff, said Mr. King. The same mentality, he said, was at work when the Seattle Art Museum bet the loan of a 135-year-old Nuxalk mask on the outcome of the Superbowl in January (the mask was withdrawn from the bet after complaint from the Nuxalk Nation of Bella Coola, B.C.).
My job is to liquidate objects of the estate, said Jessica Lindsay Phillips, Mr. Jamiesons fiance at the time of his death in 2011. She said that Mr. Jamieson had returned sensitive objects in the past, including mummified remains that are not legally saleable.
We believe the fairest thing for the estate and for any institution interested is for us to auction things to the highest bidder, Ms. Phillips said.
Items of indigenous cultures entered the money economy as soon as Europeans arrived in the Americas. Major objects were sometimes simply taken, including the Gpsgolox totem pole chopped down and sold by a federal Indian agent in 1929. It was returned by a Stockholm museum in 2006, after decades of lobbying by West Coast native groups. Items from the long-outlawed potlatch ceremony were returned in 1979 to indigenous peoples on Quadra Island, where they are housed at the native-run Nuyumbalees Cultural Centre.
Those articles are critical to keep the potlatch going, said Mr. King. As for the Plains Indian tunic in the Jamieson collection, he said, the best option would be to send it to a research institution such as the National Museum of the American Indian, where its specific origin could probably be gleaned from details of beadwork and stitching. Then it could be returned to the descendant community.
Ms. Phillips agrees that the tunic is a piece of history. But she said it will be up to the executors to decide how to dispose of it.

It all reflects this apparently endemic belief that native people are extinct, so we can do whatever we want with their stuff, said Mr. King. The same mentality, he said, was at work when the Seattle Art Museum bet the loan of a 135-year-old Nuxalk mask on the outcome of the Superbowl in January (the mask was withdrawn from the bet after complaint from the Nuxalk Nation of Bella Coola, B.C.).
I have just begun to read The Earth Shall Weep by James Wilson.
I expect there will be many such indignities and injustices described within.
This is beyond atrocious. To even consider auctioning such an item shows the venality of the executor of this estate, as well as a lack of even a single shred of decency.
Good that they pulled the tunic. I can't imagine anything more horrible!!! How would they feel if it were their child's?
The rest, chalk it up to ignorance. I feel the way you do. And it's awful. I'm so sorry.
PS, I hope that they keep it, (the tunic), and use it in an exhibit to discuss the horribleness of the fate of the Plains Indians. Sort of like those slavery exhibits. They need to be shown far and wide as to the utter horror.
It's a fairly typical response Swamijim. It's all about money, not morality when it comes to our sacred or important items. Most were taken illegally. There is a huge illegal trade in Indian artifacts through out the world.
It's just one more ''Red Privilege'' that we enjoy. /s
And it will only scratch the surface Mac. Sadly it's on going.
It's all about the money, not morality mimi.
It's not only the Plains Indians Dowser, it's every tribe from California to Maine.
And yes, an exhibit for everyone to see, what really happened. Not the BS you read in our history books.
How could anybody put a price on something such as that?? Tzia shakes head!
''It all reflects this apparently endemic belief that native people are extinct, so we can do whatever we want with their stuff,
I think that answer your question Tzia. That and the money involved in it.
I don't see it any differently than Lincoln's assignation chair that is displayed in Dearborn, Mi. I suspect the chair would sell at auction for more than the tunic and hiding either one in a closet out of public view doesn't change history.
The small childs leather tunic has fringe along the arms and torso, and the neck is embroidered with beads in purple, pink and turquoise. But what really grabs the eye is the jagged bullet hole in the centre of the chest, and the large stain of dried blood on the back.
Waddingtons, the Toronto auction house, which planned to sell it during a decorative arts auction
The death of a child is celebrated as Decorative Art that is just sick and wrong I don't care what anyone says.
Larry, I agree!
@Dean It isn't decorative art , and if you think it is then YOU are still part of the over 500 year old problem.
Dean, the violent death of a child isn't art. Sad that you can't grasp that concept.
Morality isn't part of the of the auction Larry. It's all about money, no matter how disgraceful it is.
Somehow this seems particularly atrocious to me because it was obviously looted off the body of a murdered child, K. I can "understand" the looting of religious/cultural artifacts-- conquerors have stolen those things everywhere once the rightful owners were overwhelmed. But stripping the shirt off a dead kid for a souvenier is just fucking vicious... and rationalizing putting it up for auction is too callous and arrogant for words.
Ummm-- tell me again who the 'savages' are???
And I'd almost guarantee that the tunic will be sold privately & without fanfare to some wealthy ghoul once the uproar dies down...
Ummm-- tell me again who the 'savages' are???
Seems evident doesn't it Swamijim.
No doubt in my mind about that Swamijim.
Hey, why not Lincoln's blood-stained coat, maybe with a little gray-matter still adhering? That would certainly fetch a prettypenny...
I don't find it to be disturbing and I can see why people would want to collect it and display it as art. Same goes for Hitlers's desk valued at one million dollars.
I repeat then YOU are part of the problem and I feel sorry for you and your narrow mindedness.
Is it not true that theIroquois decorated their villages with scalp art?
Ignorance is no excuse try reading a bit more, try this for starters:
You just might learn something.
Is it not true, that the Dutch and British put Indian heads on stakes in their villages.
Stick with the topic of the article Dean.
It's like putting a price on the death of an innocent child. It's just not right.
I was trying to educate myself and I got the information about Indian scalp art here.
Written by a white man based on questionable verbal reports from other white people at best take a look at him he's a wanna be:
Yep. Not the BS, but the truth!!!
It's one thing to acquire the property of a perpetrator -- morbid curiosity and no respect earned. But to acquire the clothing of a victim of violence is insensitive to say the least.
While taking a scalp is barbaric, to take revenge on those who stole your home(land) is VICTIM-PROVOKED-AGGRESSION.
What would you do if someone took all you owned and, after claiming to have "discovered" it, murdered your family, etc. to keep what he/they stole?
I'll bet your a capital punishment fan.
Just reading the first few words describing the article of clothing brought tears to my eyes...I can see either one of my children in that tunic. Rest in peace little one.
:^(
Plus scalping was the invention of the Dutch and British.
It is a verypainful reminder of the past Larry.
It is utterly HORRIBLE!
That it is Dowser..
I felt the same way, Larry. It immediately brought to mind my great granddaughter, Gabby, who is so interested in Native Americans now... it's about her size.
It looks Sioux, but I am no expert on the clothing of different Tribes. Sometimes I can immediately tell by looking at a picture of the subject wearing the clothing which Tribe it is, but I'm not always correct.
It's macabre whether it's the child's tunic or the chair with Lincoln's blood stains.