Midterm Election Turnout Isn’t So Different From Presidential Year Turnout
Spend enough time around pundits and youll hear somebody say, Its all about turnout. Who shows up to vote, and those votersdemographics, is the great mystery of any election. The conventional wisdom is that the demographics of the voting poolare friendlier to Democrats in presidential yearsthan they are in midterm years, and that its the other way around for Republicans. Sasha Issenberg had a recent piece in The New Republic arguing that the Democrats may be doomed in this years midterm elections because they cant find a way to bring midterm turnout closer to what it is in presidential years. Peter Wehner, meanwhile, wrote in Commentary in February that Republicans are doomed in presidential years because of the change in the electorates racial demographics.
But turnout isnt nearly as important as D.C. wags make it out to be. The demographics of who voted in 2012 vs. 2010 were different, 1 but that difference didnt make much of a difference. The reason Republicans won more votes in 2010 and likely will in 2014 is thatvoters wanted Republicans in office, not thatminorities and young people didntturn out to vote.
First, lets sort out the differences between people who voted in 2010 and 2012, according to the governments Current Population Survey .
![]()
Note how all minority groups but others made up a larger shareof voters in 2012 than in 2010. Notice, too, how young voters decreased as a percentage of all voters, regardless of race. The share of voters who were whites over the age of 30, the most Republican group, was6 points higherin 2010 than in 2012.
But if the two voting pools somehow magically switched places, 2012s demographicswouldnt have swung control of the House in the 2010 election.I transposed the 2012 demographics onto the 2010 vote tallies 2 and Republicans still wonthenational vote by about 3.3 percentage points in the midterms.
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/midterm-election-turnout-isnt-so-different-from-presidential-year-turnout/

It seems that the demographics of turnout are not as radical in mid-term elections as some talking heads would have us believe.
Could results in non-presidential election years simply have to do with public dissatisfaction with issues and how they are being handled?
The demographics may be of little difference, but what really matters is the percentage of the population who voted. The figures all equal 100% of the voters, but the real question is what is the percentage of Americans who voted in 2010 and 2012? Or even what is the percentage of registered voted 2010 and 2012?
SIxpick
Excellent question
census.gov shows that for the 2010 election the participation was 37% of eligible voters in the U.S. in the election of members of the House of Representatives
And the bipartisan policy center shows that there were 126 million voters who participated in the 2012 elections or 57.5%
Big difference
Appreciate the feedback and perspective
Thanks
I a little surprised at those figures, but the primaries come in way below the general election I would imagine.
Thanks for your time in obtaining that information Robert.
Six
The midterm numbers seems wicked low to me as well which is why I added the link in case I was misreading what was being said.