The ACA passed the Senate on a party-line vote , and without a Democratic vote to spare, after a series of unsavory transactions that purchased the assent of several shrewdly extortionate Democrats. What will be argued on Thursday is that what was voted on the ACA was indisputably a revenue measure and unquestionably did not originate in the House, which later passed the ACA on another party-line vote.
This case comes from Matt Sissel , an Iowa artist and small-business owner who is represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation , which litigates for limited government. Sissel neither has nor wants health insurance, preferring to invest his limited resources in his business. Hence he objects to the ACAs mandate that requires him to purchase it or pay the penalty that the ACA daintily calls the shared responsibility payment .
In June 2012, a Supreme Court majority accepted a, shall we say, creative reading of the ACA by Chief Justice John Roberts. The court held that the penalty, which the ACA repeatedly calls a penalty, is really just a tax on the activity actually, the nonactivity of not purchasing insurance. The individual mandate is not, the court held, a command but merely the definition of a condition that can be taxed. The tax is mild enough to be semi-voluntary; individuals are free to choose whether or not to commit the inactivity that triggers the tax.
The exaction Robertss word looks, he laconically said, like a tax in many respects. It is collected by the IRS, and the proceeds go to the Treasury for the general operations of the federal government, not to fund a particular program. This surely makes the ACA a revenue measure.
Did it, however, originate in the House? Of course not .
In October 2009, the House passed a bill that would have modified a tax credit for members of the armed forces and some other federal employees who were first-time home buyers a bill that had nothing to do with health care. Two months later the Senate amended this bill by obliterating it. The Senate renamed it and completely erased its contents, replacing them with the ACAs contents .
Case law establishes that for a Senate action to qualify as a genuine amendment to a House-passed revenue bill, it must be germane to the subject matter of the [House] bill. The Senates shell game gutting and replacing the House bill created the ACA from scratch. The ACA obviously flunks the germaneness test, without which the Houses constitutional power of originating revenue bills would be nullified.
Case law establishes that the origination clause does not apply to two kinds of bills. One creates a particular governmental program and...raises revenue to support only that program. The second creates taxes that are analogous to fines in that they are designed to enforce compliance with a statute passed under one of the Constitutions enumerated powers of Congress other than the taxing power. The ACAs tax, which the Supreme Court repeatedly said is not an enforcement penalty, and hence is not analogous to a fine, fits neither exception to the origination clause.
The ACAs defenders say its tax is somehow not quite a tax because it is not primarily for raising revenue but for encouraging certain behavior (buying insurance). But the origination clause, a judicially enforceable limit on the taxing power, would be effectively erased from the Constitution if any tax with any regulatory behavior-changing purpose or effect were exempt from the clause.
The Court of Appeals sits six blocks from the Senate, which committed the legislative legerdemain of pretending to merely amend a House bill while originating a new one. Across the street from the Senate sits the Supreme Court, where this case may be headed.
Two years ago, the Supreme Court saved the ACA by declaring its penalty to be a tax. It thereby doomed
That's funny, the right wing propaganda machine said that very same same thing when it first went before Justice Roberts conservative court; in-fact I remember Michel Bachman and a whole bunch of right wing haters dancing and celebrating pre-maturely when they thought that the ACA was repealed by the supreme court.
But it was not.
So here we are again .... and you're absolutely sure that it will be repealed this time after the failure of 50 plus votes to repeal and the supreme deciding it was the law of the land.
Hmm..... good luck with that.
If SCOTUS refuses to recognize the constitutional legal problems of O'surance then the constitution itself is in more jeopardy than it was when the Patriot Act was passed and repassed . That had the motive of being a reaction to terrorism . But O'surance is nothing but shoveling dirt on the constitution's grave .
Didn't you see the smiley in her comment ? That was her version of logical discourse ...
0'may get Hillary to argue the case.
Robert G, regarding question:
Yeah, I don't think it will be repealed.
That's what I meant when I said ~ "Hmm ..... good luck with that"
You can see how that works can't you Rob?
An interesting exercise for constitutional lawyers, a few of which are probably becoming wealthy as this case would through the court system
The origination clause language does not seem to be satisfied by the PPACA, since the revenue from the PPACA tax {SCOTUS ruled that it was not a fine} goes into the general fund rather than a PPACA pool of money.
And the PPACA itself does not seem germane to the veteran's homeownership tax credit bill, which it was inserted in place of by the Senate and then passed.
All that being said, it would seem that a ruling based solely on case law would go against the PPACA in the DC Court of Appeals, but I am skeptical that this will happen and expect that the politics of the situation will play a significant role in a decision or more likely a non-decision as this is punted to the SCOTUS
Though it has no place in the decision on whether the validity of theprovision of the PPACA meets to requirements of the constitution and settled case law regarding revenue bills, the effect of taking such a key provision )the individual mandate) out of the PPACA and its effect on the program's ability to adequately meet its purpose will play into the decision process.
The court is supposed to be a "sterile environment" devoid of political, economicand emotional contamination during the decision process, but it is seldom so.
Yes and if the SCOTUS can toss the constitution in the trash as Harry Reid did the House bill, then we are doomed
There's another problem... Note: Existing Law
A Budget Reconciliation Bill (such as HR 4862) contains changes to EXISTING LAW that are recommended pursuant to reconciliation bill instructions which are provisions directing committees to submit legislation making changes to EXISTING LAW in order to bring spending and revenue in line with an existing budget resolution.
Budget reconciliation maneuvers only need to be passed by a majority in the US Senate and are protected from being filibustered. The Democrats are incorrectly using a budget reconciliation bill in order to avoid having their desired changes blocked by a Republican filibuster in the US Senate.
The HR 4872 budget reconciliation bill was passed by the House of Representatives on March 21, 2010 by a recorded vote of 220-211.
Theres only one slight problem. The House voted to make changes to the EXISTING LAW of HR 3590 when the President of the United States hadnt even signed HR 3590 INTO LAW yet. The House of Representatives voted to make changes to something that didnt even exist at the time of the vote!
Not that it seems to matter these days. The constitution is just a piece of trash as far as Congress and the President are concerned and they don't let it get in the way of ruling the people. The law has been unconstitutional long before the mandate was passed by the SCOTUS.
Also. good luck in trying to take it away from more than 12,000,000 twelve million people....
and a whole lot more!!!!!